It's Not Gay If...

by TittySparkles

Rating: mature
Tags: Trixie, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Fetish, Starlight Glimmer, Sunburst, Porn, Sex, Slice of Life
Length: 3320

Starlight and Trixie convince Sunburst to get pegged in the butt.

For a while now, Trixie, Starlight, and Sunburst have been growingly intimate with each other in the bedroom. Despite the enjoyment both mares get out of it, they would constantly try to rope Sunburst into trying out… kinkier alternatives.
One evening he finally gives into the idea of one such alternative, and he’s about to learn that getting pegged in the ass is a very enjoyable experience.

Kinks: M/F/F Threesome, Pegging, Blowjobs, and Mares Magically Massaging Pony Prostates.
Edited and pre-read by: Shakespearicles, and AndwhatIseeisme
Cover art by: Kejifox
Flash Request: 3

Published 2020-08-14 16:40:03 UTC
Last updated 2020-08-14 16:40:03 UTC

It’s not gay if mares rut you in the ass

Another late night, another successful day of running the School of Friendship in Ponyville. The school week had come and gone, and now a nice relaxing weekend was all that greeted a lot of creatures. Most had gone to bed, but a certain trio was still running the midnight oil…

Sunburst sat at his desk as he continued to look over what felt like endless paperwork for the school. The dull hum of magic filled the air as his quill marked down important notes for the upcoming week. Across his desk shone a dying candlestick, minutes from flickering it’s last flame as it cast long shadows over the room.

A loud yawn filled the air, breaking Sunburst from his mindset momentarily, but quickly realizing it was just one of his partners, he continued to take down notes.

“Sunnnnburrrrrrst,” Trixie whined as she shifted in the bed she was laying on. “It’s the weekend finally. Put down the paperwork and come have some fun with me and Starlight for a bit.”

“In a minute,” Sunburst shallowly replied as he continued to read over notes while ignoring her.

“Don’t ‘in a minute' us,” Starlight spoke up from the same bed as she snuggled herself close to Trixie. “We all had a long day and we already agreed on having some fun.”

“Give me five minutes,” Sunburst replied in the same tone again, before he flipped to a new page of notes.

“We gave you five minutes, twenty-five minutes ago,” Trixie groaned in protest.

“I just need five more,” Sunburst replied, pushing the quill into the page, only for the tip to snap off.

“You know, if you drown yourself in the paperwork, you’ll be tired and miserable in the morning,” Starlight said as she flared up her horn.

“The work needs to get done before we can have fun,” Sunburst noted as he put the quill down and turned his attention to a nearby drawer. “Just let me mark this…”

Sunburst stopped talking as he noticed a field of magic covering the drawer that held all the extra quills. He quickly recognized the mint green field as Starlight’s and turning around in his swivel chair, he gave her an unamused glare. Both mares said nothing in return, only to smugly smirk back at him.

“Starlight, come on, I really ne-”

“Plllllllleeeaaassseee!?” both mares said in unison as they cupped their hooves together and bowed their heads into the sheets. “Tonight was the night you said you would try the strap,” Trixie spoke up, before she lit up her own horn. “You promised that if we didn’t bother you all last week, you would try it out.”

Sunburst said nothing as he pushed his glasses back to his face and his eyes darted to a small box of sex toys that Trixie was pulling out from the corner of the room. Looking at her with a dark glower, he let out a deep sigh.

“I know, I know, but that was before we got that invitation from Queen Novo that we were allowed to take all the students to visit her kingdom for a full week in the upcoming month.” Sunburst’s sigh deepened as he looked back and took note of all the parental forms he made up for all the parents of the students.

“But that isn’t until next-next month!” Trixie whined as she pulled out a jet black strap-on.

Sunburst’s eyes scanned the object and inadvertently clenched his butt at the thought of it going in his ass. Thankfully it was smaller than the usual size the girls loved to play with, and they even bought it to be used on him exclusively. At first he wasn’t interested in taking a silicone dick up his ass, but Trixie and Starlight were smart and slowly edged him towards getting enjoyment out of it. Mostly all sessions had one of the girls at his rear, poking and prodding his anus to find his comfort levels and eventually they found it. Now they just wanted to take it to the next step.

“Just come have some fun with us and unwind,” Starlight said with a big smile, before she snuggled even closer against Trixie. “I’ll even suck your dick if you let Trixie go first.”

Sunburst took a deep breath and attempted to pull on the drawer one last time. He didn’t bother as Starlight's magic was still covering it. As much as he wanted to continue to do work, the mere thought of Starlight sucking him off while Trixie worked his ass sent a pang into his loins. He felt a small stiffening feeling building up and he knew if he tried to protest further, it would only delay the final result. Finally he let out a defeated sigh and rose from his seat.

“Fiiiine,” he whined melodramatically at Starlight as he trotted for the bed. “I’m only agreeing right now because you’re better at it then Trixie.”

“Oh please, Starlight has nothing on Trixie’s skillful tongue,” Trixie butted in with an annoyed tone before sticking her nose up in the air. “Trixie could suck you dry and you’ll still beg for more. Ask Starlight about how great and powerful Trixie’stongue is.”

“I won’t deny you got better carpet munching skills, Trix,” Starlight replied as she playfully shoved the arrogant mare. “Buuuut… don’t let that get to your head… after all, you can barely deepthroat Sunburst.”

“Well it’s not my fault that he’s gifted in the sack!” Trixie spoke back, her annoyed tone quickly turning into sharp irritation. “Honestly I don’t even know how you can take him to the hilt. I can’t even take him to the med-ring.” she ended as she brought a hoof up to rub her throat.

Sunburst couldn’t help but smile at the compliment.

“Practice makes perfect,” Starlight spoke with a growing grin as she turned back to Sunburst. “Now how about we put that saying to work?”

Trixie just huffed at her, but Sunburst was quick to notice a small grin starting to form on Trixie’s face.

“Alright,” Sunburst sighed as he removed his cape and neatly folded it, before putting it off to the side. “Just… make sure you use plenty of lube okay, Trixie.”

“Awww, but I wanted to go in dryyyy,” Trixie whined as she rolled her eyes at him.

Sunburst couldn’t help but clench his ass in response and cringe.

“Oh calm down, I’m kidding,” Trixie’s tone turned into a casual nonchalant one as she focused on the nearby box again. “We got plenty of lube for you.”

Floating up a large black bottle, Sunburst instantly relaxed as Trixie popped the top.

Staying quiet for a few seconds, Sunburst watched as she poured a moderate amount of lube out of the bottle and used her magic to spread it out evenly on the rubber phallus. The light from the candle made the black texture shine in the dim light, subconsciously telling Sunburst it wasn't going to hurt his ass. Despite still not being fully comfortable with the prospect, Sunburst recalled a few previous sessions where either of the girls massaged his prostate to a hooves-free orgasm, and with that memory in his mind, he was quick to hop on the bed.

“So how are we going to do this so everyone is cozy?” Sunburst asked as he laid on his stomach.

“Simple actually,” Trixie started as she attached the strap-on to her hips and buckled it in place. “You lay on your back while me and Starlight get into position.”

Starlight said nothing, instead she just shot a quick grin as Sunburst as he started to roll over, Once he rolled over and his back hit the bed, both girls' smiles widened as they quickly latched their eyes on his sheath. He was already starting to harden and the tip of his pink penis had already made its way out.

“You know for somepony who didn’t want to have sex,” Trixie noted as she slathered a bit more lube onto the shaft. “You sure get excited quickly.”

“Oh come on, Trix,” Starlight spoke out as she lit up her horn and crawled to Sunburst’s side so her face was facing his growing erection. “You know he likes playing hard to get.”

Trixie just huffed and rolled her eyes, before she floated the bottle towards Starlight. Quickly taking hold of it, Sunburst leaned upward in time to watch as Starlight squirted a small amount of lube onto a small magical blanket, before she turned her attention to his waiting asshole. As the cold liquid greeted his rim, Sunburst tensed and felt a chill run through his spine for a brief moment, before he relaxed as Starlight began to massage and loosen him up.

As Starlight did that, Trixie was quick to position herself on the bed so she could rut him as he was. Her eyes stayed downward as she fidgeted with the strap-on and quickly lined herself up. Quickly discarding the bottle off to the side, Starlight brought her magic against his puckered butthole and began to massage it. While both girls were focused on Sunbursts rear, he simply took a deep breath and did his best to relax himself further and put his tired mind at ease.

Sunbursts’ state of mind was quickly broken as Trixie shuffled forward and pressed the head of her erection against his asshole. He tensed up for a brief second, and stifled a small whine as Trixie began to gently push the tip against him. Despite the uneasiness, Starlight took over his attention as she lowered her face into his crotch.

Suddenly without warning, Starlight shifted her body. In one swift motion, she laid on Sunburst's body with her rear facing him, while his cock stayed rigid in front of her face. Thanks to her lithe frame, Sunburst was able to breathe easily as his eyes latched onto Starlight's puffy pussy. Arousal was already present, thanks to a thin line running down her thigh, and giving her butt a shake, Sunburst couldn't help but smile and relax more.

Starlight was quick to gently nuzzle his growing erection and eagerly lapped hard at the tip. Enjoying the feeling, Sunburst let out a deep rumble of approval as he leaned his head forward and brushed his muzzle against her wetness. A strong scent filled his nostrils, urging him to stick out his tongue just to get a taste of it. Before he could, he felt a surge of life course through his erection as the feeling of a hoof brushed gingerly against his nuts.

As Starlight gently rubbed Sunbursts' balls and meekly played with the tip of his erection with her muzzle, Trixie was starting to get impatient on her end. Suddenly the feeling of the rubbery strap-on started to edge it’s way into his ass. He got ready to tense back up, until Starlight wrapped her lips around the flare of his growing erection. He let out a deep sigh as Starlight loosen her lips so she could blow hot air down his shaft. He felt her breath beat against his nuts for a mere moment and as it did, Starlight put her effort into her magic.

Not wanting her to feel neglected, Sunburst pressed his muzzle more into Starlight's wet folds. As the wet tip of his nose made contact, Starlight moaned eagerly into his cock, whilst shimmying her hips for him to go deeper. Before he could, the feeling of Starlight playing with his butthole became noticeable again.

Shutting down his own feeling of cringing, Sunburst felt Starlight edge his butt open before the sudden push of the strap-on became a dominant feeling. Quickly stuffing the first few inches of it inside of him, Trixie smiled as he let out a small whine and pulled his face away from Starlight's rear.

“Still got another few inches to go,” she snarked as she slowly rocked her faux-erection into him.

Sunburst said nothing, and instead of feeling pain, he instead found the hard flare of the erection rubbing against his prostate. Letting out a groan of approval as Trixie edged herself back and forth against his sweet spot, Sunburst could only let out a stuttered gasp as Starlight started to take more of his cock inside her mouth. Feeling the hot, wetness of her throat enveloping his cock, Sunburst could only bask in the feeling as Starlight’s tongue greeted his erection.

He attempted to lean back into Starlight's folds, but found Starlight herself working his cock too well. He felt her velvety muscle swirl about, eagerly licking at the side of his shaft as more and more of it went inside of her. When the head of his erection finally hit the back of her throat, Sunburst felt her throat contract slightly before she was able to take even more of him in. She was quick to shoot past his medial ring, and for a few brief seconds she vibrated her lips against the small bump. He tensed and bucked his hips upward, sending more of himself inside of her, while at the same time, making the edge of the erection in his ass press harder against his prostate.

Sunburst gritted his teeth as the feeling of the erection in his ass became apparent again, and slowly but surely, Trixie had managed to work a fair amount of the faux-penis into him.

“You should do that thing that you always do,” Trixie spoke out suddenly.

Sunburst didn’t answer, knowing very well that Starlight was the receiver of the question. Almost instantly, a bit of magic managed to creep its way into Sunbursts’ ass. Though off put by the extra bit of girth, the feeling quickly subsided as Starlight’s magic was quick to press against his prostate.

Another stuttered gasp left his mouth. His eyes went wide as the feeling of magic gently rubbed against the sweet spot. To him it felt like a small wave of water, gently crashing and coasting along, causing his erection to buzz with life. The feeling was divine, yet it only got better as Starlight began to bob her head up and down.

His mouth went agape as both girls subconsciously synced up their movements. When Trixie gave him a thrust, Starlight would pull back so only the tip of his erection stayed nestled inside her mouth, and when Trixie pulled back, Starlight took him back down to his medial ring. He felt bad that he couldn't focus on pleasuring Starlight like he wanted, but with both girls working him so well, he hoped that Starlight wouldn't be annoyed at his lack of participation.

For seconds turning into minutes, they ran with that motion and quickly it became a well oiled machine that pleasured Sunburst to perfection. He wanted to speak, he wanted to tell them great it felt to get fucked in the ass, while getting his dick sucked at the same time. He wanted to compliment Starlight on how great she was massaging his insides and how it was quickly causing him to peak. He couldn’t speak no matter how hard he tried, but his body started to speak for him.

As they continued to work his body, Sunburst couldn’t help but gently rock his hips forward. A telltale sign that he was starting to hit that edge, Starlight only intensified her bobs and suckled harder on his erection as she went. Trixie increased her speed as well. Now able to stuff nearly all of the strap-on in Sunbursts’ ass without resistance, the intense rutting was almost enough to draw his attention away from Starlight’s mouth and magic.

Slowly and surely he found himself starting to peak. His erection swelled with life as his hips seemed to move on their own. He felt his pre flowing freely out of his cock, to which Starlight was quick to eagerly lap up the premature spunk, and it only got better as he was quick to shoot past his limit of no return. A deep grunt came from Sunburst as he brought his hooves up and placed them against Starlight’s sides. Feeling that, Starlight's head went faster and her magic at his prostate moved and vibrated so hard it was enough to make a large spurt of cum shoot out of his erection.

“Ahh, Sssssh-” Sunburst hissed as he gritted his teeth and fully tensed up.

As he came, Starlight moved her body off his, pulled her mouth off his erection, and was quick to bring the hoof up from his balls to stroke his shaft. On Trixie's end, she quickly hilted herself inside Sunburst, causing the stallion to groan hard as a volley of cum shot out and landed on his face. A bit of the slimy spunk hit his glasses in the process, but before he could even worry about it, another volley of cum came and landed on his chest. Weaker spurts came as well, but with dropping intensity in each spurt until they became mere dribbles of spunk riding down his shaft. As he came, Trixie suddenly unlatched the strap-on from her hips and left the appendage buried deep within him. Unable to do anything, Sunburst just owe’d and ah'd as the intense orgasm started to wind down.

“Think that was the biggest volume of cum I’ve ever seen from him,” Trixie spoke up as she crawled beside Starlight as she brought her head to Starlight’s chin to lick a bit of semen that managed to land on it.

“Told you we could make him cum lots,” Starlight spoke proudly as the feeling of magic against his prostate disappeared, quickly making him realize just how stuffed his ass really was.

“Oooohhhh, that felt so good,” was all Sunburst could moan out as he wiggled his rump, allowing the thick erection to prod deeper inside of him. “Both you girls were great.”

“Don’t forget... powerful,” Starlight added slyly as she brought up a hoof to flick her mane.

Trixie just huffed in annoyance as she rolled her eyes, but as Sunburst pulled his head up, he could see a small smile on her face.

“Come on, Trix, now that he’s spent for the next few minutes, how about we have some fun ourselves?” Starlight asked while she wrapped her foreleg around Trixie’s shoulder.

“Are you reading my mind again?” Trixie asked, giving Starlight a quick kiss on the nose.

“Would you like me too?” Starlight coyfully responded as she gave Trixie a lusty grin.

“Hey, before you girls get it on,” Sunburst cut in as he felt the erection still stuck in his ass becoming a nuisance. “Could you kindly remove the uhh… dick from my butt?”

“Nah. I think it looks good inside of you,” Starlight spoke up, her eyes looking up his body, while Trixie just snickered to herself. "Besides, think of it as punishment for getting me all riled up, but not delivering,” she ended, flicking her tail with an annoyed look on her face.

"Sorry." Sunburst couldn’t help but blush meekly, quickly realizing that he managed to annoy Starlight with the lack of participation on his end. "It's hard to concentrate when both of you are that good."

Both girls suddenly hopped off the bed and began to walk for the door.

“H-hey, where are you going!?” Sunburst asked frantically as he tried to shift his body, but found the erection inside of him restricting his movements.

“We’ll be back in a bit,” Starlight replied before she looked over her shoulder and gave the stallion a cheeky smirk. “Just stay there for a few minutes while I look for that mind reading spell.”

“Could you please pull this thing out of my butt first!?” Sunburst shouted as both mares walked into the hallway. “Girls!? Ugh… can you at least grab the wipes on your way back!?”