The Failed Conquest

by Violet Shade

Rating: mature
Tags: Violence, Princess Celestia, Anthro, Lyra, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Colgate, Dark, Original Character
Length: 4832

So far I have conquered four mares. One of them was easy, two were difficult and the fourth one was perfect, I married her! Now I can still continue to add to my collection so I decided to go for a tougher one.

So far I have conquered four mares. One of them was easy, two were difficult and the fourth one was perfect, I married her! Now I can still continue to add to my collection so I decided to go for a tougher one. I had a dental appointment so I began to think about trying to conquer the tough as nails Dr. Colgate.

Warning: Story includes cannibalism, age regression and memory eradication.

The gore in this fic is heavily inspired by StormLuna's "Colgate's Practice" series.

Published 2020-08-19 23:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2020-08-19 23:10:00 UTC

A Horrible Punishment

It had been a couple months since Velvet and I had hooked up and both of us had begun to show. Now we had been discussing going and destroying Cadence's marriage but given that we were both pregnant, we decided to put it off. Despite living in Canterlot, I convinced Velvet that she should see the dentist in Ponyville. She wasn't sure why at first but when I told her that we could try to seduce a strong willed mare and make her ours, she quickly agreed.

The train ride to Ponyville wasn't too bad. Some ponies were Canterlot natives and some were Ponyville natives and we received plenty of glares. I know that they were likely glaring at us because of everything that has happened recently, especially since the word of Princess Twilight's mother's scandalous breakup with her husband had reached all over Equestria.

When we got to Ponyville, the glares continued. With most ponies, it would make them nervous but the two of us? No way in hell was something so menial going to stress us out! It would take a whole lot more than that to cause us any kind of discomfort. What mattered to us was that we had each other and did plenty of wonderful things together.

When we got to Colgate's office, we headed in together and were immediately greeted by Dr. Colgate's younger sister, Lyra Heartstrings. She always has been a nice mare. I've thought about her some but she is kind of young and I know that if I tried anything with her, Colgate would likely do who knows what to me. I heard what happened one time when a stallion accidentally touched her flank. Even though it was accidental, she ripped his horn out with her teeth and broke a leg of his.

Now as long as I don't try anything with her, I'll be fine. With Colgate however, I'm going to spread powerful seduction magic, just like I did with Fluttershy. Yeah Colgate is anything but sweet and kind but it is definitely worth a shot. It wasn't any more than a few minutes after Lyra greeted us that Colgate came out to get me.

Now naturally Velvet and I were pretty much inseparable so after five minutes of begging Colgate to let Velvet come back with me, she finally allowed her to come back. Now I had also heard about how Colgate will get with ponies who do not take good care of their teeth and that kind of scared me. Ever since I moved up to Canterlot to live with my new wife, I hadn't been brushing.

I would face her wrath all too quickly as when she discovered that I had a cavity, she went into a rage. I saw nothing but pure fury and hatred in her eyes and I decided that I would fix that! I lit up my horn and began to spread my magic but even when I started looking into her eyes, nothing changed. I had the same furious dentist lecturing me over my bad teeth.

I had to quiet her down so I finally said something, "I'm sorry Dr. Colgate but once I moved up to Canterlot to be with Velvet, brushing kind of skipped my mind."

She smacked me and yelled, "That is a piss poor excuse Violet Shade! You used to be a good pony who brushed her teeth and did as I ordered but now you are pathetic! You are a pathetic slutty bitch who cares nothing about her teeth!"

I intensified my spell and looked deeper into her eyes but still, nothing. Finally it would affect her but not in the way I hoped. She slapped me and yelled, "Don't even try and use that seduction magic on me Violet Shade. You may have taken four mares with it but unlike them, I can't be taken like that." She slapped me again and continued, "You don't get successful like me by being vulnerable to spells based on emotion."

Velvet then lit up her horn too. I had a feeling that things would not bode well for her either and that was the case. Colgate slugged her and yelled, "Not you too." She then began to head towards the front and yelled, "Don't go anywhere or you'll wish you were never born!"

While she was gone Velvet asked, "How is this? How could she be immune to your magic? You took my daughter but your spell won't work on her? How?"

"I'm not sure how she did it. I just hope she doesn't do anything....." I replied.

Soon Colgate returned and gave us a sadistic smile. She let us know that she had closed up shop early with a beaming smile on her face. I had heard rumors about how she delights in the suffering of others and I began to regret ever trying this. I knew that whatever she had planned, it would not be good.

She grabbed us in her aura and began to drag us with her. She had a door in the back and I dreaded where it led. I began to wonder if she wasn't either going to violently horn rape us, cast some sort of spell to alter our personalities or worst of all, inflict severe pain upon us in one way or another.

When she finally got us downstairs, she had multiple gurneys down there and used her magic to restrain us. She secured us to where our arms and legs could not move. She did leave it to where we could still move our heads up. I'm pretty sure that was so that she could hold our heads in place so that we would be forced to watch her work whatever kind of horrible magic she had planned.

She then headed over to a cabinet and began digging through things. I would be horrified when she returned with a big, sharp knife. I began to worry that she was going to do something so horribly bad that it would make me horn raping many many mares throughout my life look like nothing.

Before she got to work she first addressed Velvet, "Velvet, you have done some bad things in your life. They aren't horrible but still, they shouldn't go unpunished. From what I understand, you bedded this Twilight re-color while you were still married and he caught the two of you on the kitchen table. Before you go asking about this, he was so distraught that he changed the dentist he sees since you are friends with the one in Canterlot. He broke down crying in here and while I normally wouldn't care about such things, I felt bad for the stallion. He didn't deserve this."

Velvet replied, "But Violet is so hot and I wanted to be with her instead! Her horn is so much better than his stallionhood!"

Colgate sighed, "Whatever." She then turned to me and continued, "And don't think I don't know about everything you have done Violet Shade. I know you have horn raped many mares. You horn raped a lot of them in Fillydelphia and you have done the same to several here in Ponyville. I will let you know this, giving horn sex while your partner is under a mind control spell counts as rape. I also know you have broken the entering of many mares' homes to horn rape them and don't think I don't know about the both of you swaying that judge by having sex with her either."

I gasped, "You're not going to kill us over this are you?"

Colgate laughed, "No, I am not. Killing you would be letting you off easy for all the crimes you have committed. I have a much better plan, a much more fun plan!" She then eyeballed Velvet and continued, "And Violet, I figure I will force you to watch me cut your lover over here open."

She grabbed my neck and forced me to look up and watch her. I was completely terrified when I saw her began to cut Velvet open. Velvet was screaming in pain and she was trying so hard to break free but could not. Her breathing became heavier and heavier the more Colgate cut into her. Soon Velvet's body began to spasm the shock was so hard on her. I would then cringe at what happened. She began to rip her open with her teeth, exposing her stomach and her reproductive organs.

She began to eyeball them and laughed, "Shall I Violet? Shall I stop this before you can raise another seductress?"

I began to cry, "No, please don't! That unborn foal has never done a thing to anypony!"

Colgate laughed, "Well too bad, I'm doing the world a favor!"

She then ripped Velvet's womb straight out of her with her teeth, causing another agonizing scream from her. She spit it on a table and then got to work on removing the rest of her reproductive organs. I continued to cry, "What are you going to do with her unborn foal? Why did you just spit it out on the table?"

Colgate cackled, "Lyra and I do need supper you know." Her cackling only became more manic, "I've done this before and fetuses are quite tasty. Now yeah those were of ponies who couldn't pay their bills but this time it is far more satisfying." She then began to eyeball me and added, "And this time, Lyra and I won't have to share!"

I began to cry knowing that our unborn foals were going to be nothing more than a meal for Colgate and her sister. After she removed all of Velvet's parts, she cast a spell to immediately heal her. She gave her a smile and laughed, "Now you see Velvet, I didn't kill you!"

Velvet snapped, "You may as well have! You took my foal from me!"

Colgate simply gave her a laugh before turning to me. She laughed harder, "Take two!"

She forced Velvet's head up to force her to watch her cut me open. The pain I felt was a hundred times worse than that one time when somepony bit on my horn while I was trying to make her mine. At least that pain only lasted for a few seconds. This lasted for what seemed to be forever. I couldn't see what was going on but I did hear Velvet begging her not to take my foal and reproductive parts too.

Colgate just gave Velvet a smile and cackled, "Now you should know that I can not allow you two to raise any deviants!" She then pounded her fist to where she began to cut me open and screamed, "It is ponies like you that are a cancer upon this world! It is your type that must be stopped from ever harming anypony else."

She then began to get to work on me much more quickly. Every single bit was a new experience in pain but I knew the worst was yet to some. Once she got me cut open, she actually pulled my womb out and began to laugh, "And to think, if this foal didn't have degenerate parents, it wouldn't be on the menu!"

She then ripped the womb out with her teeth and the pain was horrific. It was so horrible that my body began to spasm as the shock had become severe. At that moment I was really wishing I would just die but I knew that Colgate likely knew magic that would prevent that. As she continued to remove my reproductive organs, every single bite was a new experience in pain. Once she had removed them all, she cast a spell to heal me but she did not erase the pain for either one of us.

Once she was done, she started to head for the door and laughed, "Now don't go anywhere ladies, we're not done yet!"

As she left, the two of us were still in so much pain that we barely knew where we were. I knew that whatever she was doing upstairs was likely bad, very bad. Once her and her receptionist, Lyra returned I knew what was going to happen. I knew they were going to wipe it in our faces that they punished us for what we have done.

Colgate pointed to the two plates and asked, "So Lyra, do you want mama Twilight's or the Twilight re-color's?"

Lyra replied, "I'll take Velvet's!"

"Sounds good little sis!" replied Colgate.

The two then decided to do something truly sadistic. They grabbed our heads and turned them towards them as they ate our foals and the rest of our organs right in front of us. I truly began to wonder what we did to deserve this. Yes I have done a lot of bad things but I certainly didn't deserve this and Velvet never took a life nor did she horn rape anypony. I have a feeling she did this to her to punish me.

She ate the other organs first but when she bit into my womb and ripped my foal's head off, I began to wonder if perhaps Celestia had her do this to me. I know Celestia was angry over what I did to Twilight that one time and when she found out about what I did to her recently she was likely angrier. I was praying to Mother Faust that she and her sister would just go ahead and kill us but I have heard about Colgate's sadism and like she said earlier, killing us would be letting us off easy.

Once they had finished our meals, Colgate glared at us and continued, "Well ladies, we're almost done." She turned to Lyra and suggested, "You're way more pure than me. How about you wipe out their lust, especially little miss Violet's special talent and desire and then I'll take their memory."

Lyra was beyond ecstatic, "I'd love that big sis!"

I could hardly believe this. Not only did they take our foals but they were going to take away my special talent and wipe out our memories? Given what I heard, it sounded like they were going to make us asexual! I began to plead, "No, please no! Please don't take away from me what makes me who I am!"

Colgate smacked me and laughed, "Well too late! This MUST be done!"

First Lyra wiped out Velvet's desire and lust. It wasn't as hard on her since it wasn't her talent. With her it was more of her simply finding me hot that led to what she did but when she got to me, it was painful as hell. I began to struggle but to no avail. It took her a whole lot longer on me but she finally succeeded and once she was done, my cutie mark was gone. She stole my talent and took away my cutie mark.

I began to cry, "No, please no! I don't want to be a blank flank again!"

Lyra smacked me and laughed, "Too late Violet, once it is gone it can not be restored!" She then began to snicker, "There are a group of three fillies here who have yet to get their cutie marks and they run this little club where they try to find their special talent!"

Colgate added, "You could become their oldest member and since my sister has removed what made you a threat to everypony, you'd be harmless." She then smacked me and added, "Now for the final spell!"

She first moved over to Velvet and began the memory eradication spell. Lyra began to wonder how much she was going to erase. She asked, "So sis, how much are you taking?"

She pointed down to Velvet and said, "A year." She then pointed to me and yelled, "And I'm taking everything with her! She will know absolutely nothing! Hell she may not even know how the hell to walk!" Her laughing only became more manic as she continued, "Just think sis, we could raise this one right! We could raise her to have a good work ethic like us." Colgate continued to laugh, "An age regression spell too! She's going back to being a newborn!"

I was terrified when I heard this. I knew that she was sadistic but not only is she taking my whole memory but now she is going to age regress me to a newborn and raise me to be a boring workaholic like her? It was at that moment that I finally realized that everything I had ever done in my life was wrong. I always thought that I would get away with everything I had done in my life, I had always believed that I could horn rape anypony I desired but now, I'm about to become the daughter of a work first sadist.

I felt horribly bad as I watched her wipe out the past year of Velvet's memory but all I could think of was her basically resetting me and knowing my luck, she'd probably give me a different name just so nopony would ever remember me.

Finally she got to work on me and this final set of spells was even more painful than when she cut me open. I had a feeling that this was likely done on purpose as one final punishment. The pain was becoming more and more severe until my body was shaking and the shock was becoming more and more severe on me. I could hear Velvet begging and pleading for Colgate to stop. That was the final thing I remembered before blacking out.

A New Start

Author's Note

This story will be told in the third pony since Violet is a newborn.

A New Start

It was two hours after Colgate and Lyra had punished Twilight Velvet and Violet Shade for the things they had done, especially Violet. Colgate and Lyra had taken the newborn Violet home with them and they had absolutely no idea how to care for her. She was crying loudly and that was about to drive Colgate nuts. She yelled, "How do we shut her up Lyra? How do we shut a newborn up?"

Neither one of the two had ever raised foals but Lyra was more calm and composed when it came to things like this. She replied, "Well she's probably hungry. We're going to have to go to the store and get some baby food, some formula and a bottle for her." She paused for a minute before adding, "And she's going to need diapers too."

Colgate sighed, "Very well. After we get her fed though, we're going to have to go up to Canterlot, make up a world class lie and then see if we can adopt her so she can be raised right."

"Alright, sounds good." replied Lyra

Colgate headed out and she dreaded going to the store to buy such items. Everypony in town knew that she had never had any foals and had no plans on having any. They knew that her temper was way too short to handle even school foals, much less newborns.

When she got to Barnyard Bargains she headed in and at began to wander through the aisles, trying to find what she needed. When she finally got to the foal aisle, she began to wonder what to get. She grabbed some formula and figured, "Meh, formula is formula." She then grabbed a couple bottles and then went to the baby food. She figured that she should likely get a variety of flavors because she wouldn't want to eat the same flavor of things all the time. Then one more thing crossed her mind, a stroller. She knew that she couldn't just carry her in her aura.

Given that she was a newborn, getting diapers for her was much easier since there were ones specifically labeled that they were for newborns. Filthy Rich would be shocked when he saw what Colgate was buying, "Colgate? Why are you buying baby stuff? Did you hide a pregnancy or something?"

Colgate lied, "Actually yes, I did. I wanted a foal so I was artificially impregnated and given that I always wear oversized shirts, hiding the pregnancy was easy."

"Huh," he replied "you don't really remind me of the foal type but congratulations!"

Colgate said, "Thanks!"

Colgate left the store and then realized that she was going to have to lie to not only Lyra, but to Celestia when they go up to Canterlot so she can get a birth certificate and thus, citizenship. When she got home her and Lyra got a diaper put on her before beginning to feed her. Almost immediately Violet calmed down and Colgate decided to bring up her lie to Lyra.

"Lyra, I think I may have made some sort of mistake when I went to Barnyard Bargains."

"Oh, what was that?" Lyra asked

Colgate replied, "Well you see, Filthy Rich asked me why I was buying stuff for newborn foals and if I hid a pregnancy and I told him that I did."

Lyra gasped, "You what? You told that huge of a lie?"

Colgate replied, "Yes but I did it for a reason. I told Filthy that so that we can take her up to Canterlot, hopefully get a birth certificate for her and then she will be recognized as my foal."

Lyra wasn't real sure about this. She asked, "Colgate, are you even going to be able to handle raising her? I know how short your temper is and I don't know if I'll always be around to calm her down."

Colgate replied, "Well I'll have to sign up for parenting classes. I do want to raise a model citizen after all."

Lyra asked, "What are we going to do during the week? I don't think I can just keep her behind the receptionist's desk with me! That would be a violation of health codes!"

Colgate sighed, "I know. I'm probably going to have to close up shop for a couple weeks until we can get all this figured out. For now though, we need to get up to Canterlot."

Lyra replied, "Alright, let's get going." Lyra then remembered one more thing, "What are you going to name her? I doubt you can just use the name Violet Shade because ponies would wonder why you would name her after such a horrible pony."

"Hmmm...." Colgate stood there for several minutes before saying, "Violet Sky! How does that sound?"

Lyra replied, "Well the Violet part may sound fishy but she does have a violet coat, I think, so that should be good."

Lyra put everything in a bag and Colgate put Violet in her stroller and they took off. Colgate was really wishing that she could have just carried Violet in her aura but knew that doing that would likely lead to her being deemed an unfit parent and having her "new foal" taken away from her before she could even get herself classified as her mother.

During the train ride, Violet Sky began to cry and Colgate realized that she had better get used to playing the role of mother. When she checked on her, she discovered that she needed her diaper changed. Even though the process nearly made Colgate vomit, she managed to get her diaper changed and while she knew she likely shouldn't have, she simply put the dirty diaper under their seat when nopony was watching.

When they got to Canterlot, Colgate, Lyra and Violet immediately headed to the palace. Once they arrived, they immediately headed to the throne room. When Celestia saw Colgate with a baby stroller, she was in a state of shock. She asked, "Colgate, what are you doing with a baby stroller?"

Colgate replied, "Well it is an interesting story, one that you likely would never expect from me."

Celestia said, "I'm listening."

Colgate began her lie, "Well you see, last year I decided I wanted a foal and given that I am a lesbian, I wasn't about to do it the old fashioned way." Celestia nodded and Colgate continued, "Well I headed back east to the sperm bank in Manehattan and was artificially impregnated." Celestia again nodded and Colgate continued, "I did a very good job of hiding the pregnancy but this morning, I wound up giving birth in my home and I need to see what I need to do to get my daughter recognized as an Equestrian citizen."

This was a lot to take in because Celestia knew how Colgate was when she was in her school. She remembered how she was the only student that refused to take any kind of parenting class since she had no desire for children. She gave her a half smile and asked, "Really Colgate? What changed? What caused you to want to be a mother?"

Colgate continued her lie, "Well I just saw how happy the Cake Family was after their foals were born and I wanted to experience the same thing."

She motioned for her to approach her, She asked, "So what have you named her?"

"Violet Sky." replied Colgate.

Princess Celestia took a look at Violet and then at Colgate before taking another look at Violet. She said, "I must say, whoever it was that provided the seed for her must have been a dark violet in color and had purple eyes because it is obvious that she doesn't share much of any traits you have outside of being a unicorn."

Colgate replied, "Well the seed they provided was random for the most part. The only requirement I had of the sperm provided was that it came from a unicorn."

Celestia was having trouble believing her but then she remembered another pony who didn't look anything like her parents, Pinkie Pie. She gave Colgate a smile and replied, "Alright, we will get her a birth certificate and an Equestrian ID number since she was born of an Equestrian in Equestria." She motioned for her to follow her and continued, "Follow me."

Celestia led the three to Canterlot tower where she began to fill out a birth certificate.

Name: Violet Sky
Kind: Unicorn
Gender: Female
Coat Color: Violet
Mane/Tail Color: Black, Pink, Dark Violet (Tri-color stripes)
Eye Color: Purple
Mother: Dr. Minuette Colgate
Father: Unknown

She then took a picture of Violet to go along with the certificate for the birth records. She then made a copy of the certificate to give to Colgate. She gave Colgate a smile and continued, "Well you are the last pony in Equestria I ever expected to give birth to a foal but congratulations! I know you will do a good job raising her." She then gave her another smile, "Although I would advise you get her some clothes and get some blankets. She can't go around in nothing but her coat and diapers and she will get cold."

Colgate replied, "Will do princess, will do." She turned to Lyra and added, "Well sis, shall we go shopping? You're more into fashion than me so you'd know what would look best on her."

Lyra laughed, "Of course sis, you know I'll be here to help."

Celestia gave them one more smile before adding, "And Colgate, if you need any advice on being a new mother, I know Mrs. Cake can give you the best of anypony in Ponyville."

"I'll take that into account." replied Colgate.

Once they began to leave the palace, Colgate asked, "Well let's go find a good store with newborn clothes? After that we can go and get some lunch before heading home." Then one more thing crossed her mind, "When we get home, we need to get Violet a crib, pillows and some bedding."

Lyra replied, "You know, I think you're going to be a better mom than anypony would think."

Colgate gave her a smile, "Well I plan on it!"

As they headed towards the shopping district to get some good clothes for Violet, Colgate felt happier than she had in ages. For so much of her life she had always viewed foals as a burden and caring for them as a royal pain but now that she was in that situation, she felt good, she felt happy that she could make the life of a pony much better.

Lyra did have her concerns though. She had her concerns that eventually what the two of them did would be discovered and that not only would somepony find a way to restore the Violet Shade that had made the lives of so many mares miserable but then face criminal charges of their own. She knew that the spells they used were highly illegal and that even knowing them could land them in jail. One thing Lyra did know too though was that Colgate was good at thinking ahead and would be more than likely able to get away with this.