Basement Fluttershy

With her vision obscured, Fluttershy had no way to tell how much time was passing. The soft dripping sound of a leaky pipe echoed through the darkness every few moments, and above her head was the hoofsteps of her captors, a constant terror consuming Fluttershy’s mind anytime they sounded like they might be coming towards the stairs to the basement. Hours passed, or at least that’s how it felt. The mare’s eyes drifted closed under her blindfold, sleep slowly taking her.

“And you are certain that they won’t think to look here?” Column asked. “Don’t get me wrong, that slut is the best fuck I’ve had in a long time, but you know who her friends are. If they ever find us, we’d be lucky to survive long enough for them to lock us up.”

“Relax.” Snatch spoke dryly, pouring a bag of oats into a bowl. Setting the bag down, he shot a calm smile to his roommate. “We grabbed her on the road. They have no way of knowing what happened, only that she didn’t arrive at that little wildlife expedition she was supposed to, and that was not only miles away from where we grabbed her, but half a country away from where we are now. They have no way to track us and no way to predict where we went.”

“I suppose you’re right. So, the only thing we have to worry about is her trying to escape then, and well…,” he trailed off, gesturing dismissively, getting a laugh out of Snatch.

“Yeah, there’s no chance of that happening. She’s ours now, Column. Relax and enjoy having a little cumsock to play with.”

“Mm, speaking of…,” Column glanced down the hall to where the stairs to the basement were, “I may want to do that right now.”

“Of course.” Snatch lifted the bowl of oats with his magic. “Let’s give her the chance to eat a little and use the restroom first. Unless you want her pissing all over your dick when you inevitably lose your temper and terrify her.”

“Yeah, fine. Let’s make it fast though. I really need to cum, and it’s not like she has anything better to do.”

Fluttershy woke to the feeling of her body restrained and her fur covered in dried cum. Whatever she’d dreamed of was instantly gone from her mind, and the mare, still not fully awake, struggled to try and free her hooves. It was pointless, and the tape held up against her weak efforts without even loosening.

‘How long has it been? Why hasn’t anypony found me yet?’ The mare wondered to herself, unconsciously mumbling into her gag, her muffled voice echoing through the empty room. ‘They have to come for me. They have to. I just want this to be over.’ From up the stairs she could hear the stallions talking to each other, though she couldn’t hear about what. A wave of panic washed over her as she realized the voices were getting louder. They were coming towards the stairs.

“We brought you a present, slut. You feeling hungry?” Snatch called from the stairs as he made his way down. “It’s not the fancy stuff you are probably used to as one of the princess’ little toadies, but it’s food.” He walked in front of where she was chained, and she heard the sound of a bowl clattering to the ground. The mare tried to speak through her gag. The stallion hummed in recognition. “Yeah, the gag would make that hard. Everything else stays though. You only get to see and use your hooves when you behave. Do what you’re told for a few days, and we will untie you again. For now, eat up.” Fluttershy felt the same sensation she had the other day, as the stallion’s magic lifted the tape from her mouth painlessly.

Lacking the ability to see, the mare fumbled out in front of her with her bound hooves, feeling until she found the spilled bowl. She realized that she hadn’t eaten in at least a day, possibly far longer, given that she didn’t know how long she was unconscious before coming here. The last she could remember, she was heading to the Misty Vale’s Wildlife Expedition. That was miles from any town, and she’d heard Twilight talk about sleep spells enough that she was now fairly certain that was what was used on her. It was the only thing that explained her lack of memory of how she ended up in this situation. She might have been unconscious for more than a day. As horrible as she felt about the mere idea of eating off of the floor, since very little food was still in the bowl, the clawing hunger she felt was too much. Tears of humiliation soaking into her blindfold, she leaned down and lapped oats into her mouth. Without the ability to see, she tasted the floor more often than not, but it wasn’t like there was anything she could do.

“That’s a good girl.” Snatched praised her tauntingly. “Eat up.”

The two stallions watched the mare fumble about with amusement. Watching her miserably squirm as she tried to reach everything they had given her was starting to make them both hard. It was just about time to have their fun.

“I suppose we should let her relieve herself.” Column said dismissively, glaring at Snatch. The unicorn rolled his eyes in response. “Yeah yeah, I’ll take her. Give me a second.” His magic reached out and unlatched the collar around the slut’s neck. “Alright, that’s enough for now. Don’t worry, we’ll give you something else to eat in just a moment. Now, I’m going to take you for a short walk, and if you try to run…, well, I think you already have an idea.” Snatch magically released her hooves from their bonds. “You’ve been a bad filly, so we are tying you up the moment we get back. As I said before, start behaving and we won’t need to do that in the future. Ok?”

“O...Ok.” The mare weakly whispered. Snatch reached his magic out to grip the mare by the scruff of her neck, gently pulling her up the stairs. The mare fumbled and nearly tripped a few times on the way up. When she reached the top, the mare briefly stopped, sunlight glowing through a nearby window illuminating her bound form.

“Enjoying the feeling of sunlight? Well, don’t get used to it. Come on.” He lightly tugged her fur, and the whore reluctantly started walking again.

Column waited impatiently. There wasn’t really anything to do in the basement while he waited. Not that it mattered, he supposed. They only really needed a room to keep the dumb bitch in, it didn’t need to be nice. Still, it was pretty boring. The sound of the toilet flushing made the stallion audibly sigh with relief. He had never done well with boredom. Soon after, Snatch came down, escorting the miserable looking mare.

“Finally. Welcome back, bitch. Are you ready for the rest of your breakfast?” The mare lifted her head, some tears leaking through her blindfold.

“You are going to rape me again.” She whimpered, crying softly to herself.

“I’m going to put you to good use, yes. Stop being such a foal about it.” Column growled, truthfully delighting a bit in the mare’s fearful response as she started crying louder. Snatch came over and set a hoof on her shoulder.

“It’s time.”

The unicorn lifted the mare onto the table she had been tied to on her first day, then taped her hooves together again. The mare pitifully weeped as this happened, causing Column’s already hard cock to twitch. The slut curled up on the table, her wings shifting nervously.

“There,” Snatch patted her condescendingly on the head, “Now you are all secure. Remember, struggling will only make us tie you down more.” The mare nodded her understanding, tears soaking dark patches into her blindfold.

“I’m sorry I was...bad. I just want to be able to move my hooves. Being tied up is driving me crazy.” She said. Column rolled his eyes irritably. Did the stupid slut have to complain so much. It’s not like she would be going anywhere even if she was untied.

“So you’ll behave?” Snatched asked.

“I...I’ll do what you want me to. I p...promise.”

“Good.” Snatch looked up to see Column slowly walking over to stand in front of the mare. “Now, open up.” Fluttershy knew what that meant for her, and sobbed. However, she did what she was told, and opened her mouth. Column wasted no time, pushing past the mare’s quivering lips and savoring the feeling of her tongue against his shaft. He moaned loudly. Her mouth was drier than the other day, and Column realized that they had forgotten to give her water. Oh well. He’d give her something to drink.

The full feeling of the cock down her throat was making Fluttershy gag. She was still completely unused to this, and the head of the stallion’s penis was pressing against the back of her throat. Under her blindfold, the mare’s eyes rolled back as her mind blanked out everything but the sensation of her throat being violated. Then Column started moving. She knew it was coming, but her body was still unable to manage it. Choking violently, Fluttershy struggled as best she could to keep herself from unconsciously thrashing to get free. She felt hooves on her butt. Snatch spread her cheeks apart, then there was the feeling of a rough tongue against sensitive flesh. Fresh tears streamed down her cheeks, the blindfold too soaked to stop them anymore.

“You really do have the perfect body for this. Such a shame it went to waste for so many years. It’s ok, now that you’re with us, we’ll put that sexy body of yours to good use.” There was the same pressure as before, and Fluttershy squeezed her eyes shut, whining loudly around Column’s cock as she felt Snatch enter her again. The cold table rubbed against her body as she was roughly fucked from behind, her whole body swaying with the motion, the force regularly pressing her into Column’s dick more harshly than before, the thick member shoving its way further down her throat.

Fluttershy’s mind was on fire, synapses blaring panic as her throat and hips grew sore and the pure misery at her situation grew. She thought she could adjust, to get used to this. It wouldn’t be long before she was rescued, so she just needed to hold it together until that happened. However, no matter how much she steeled herself, no matter how ready she thought she was, when all control was taken away from her, when her own body was nothing but a toy for these two monsters, when the pain of what they were doing set in, any hint of composure left her. Fluttershy lay there on the table, her legs pulled straight as Snatch used them for leverage, her hair suddenly being roughly pulled as Column yanked her face into his hips, and she couldn’t take it. Loudly wailing, Fluttershy gave up any veil of misery. Her body shook with her violent sobbing.

Without realizing, her wings started flapping gently, an unintended response to her peril; some part of her brain was trying to get away, to escape. Snatch just laughed. Fluttershy was caught off guard as suddenly her mouth was filled with cum. She had been so lost in her suffering that she hadn’t even noticed Column getting close. Semen spattered out from between her lips, and the mare didn’t even think to do anything about it.

“Stupid bitch,” Column growled, though the mare could hear a hint of delight in his voice, “You are supposed to swallow. What a mess!” There was a sting in Fluttershy’s cheek as he slapped her, and Fluttershy’s mouth fell open, cum oozing out onto the table as she bawled her lungs out.

“Oh C...Celestia!” She screamed. It was all too much. “No...nononononono….”

“Damn, she whines a lot.” Column said. “Let me get some tape to shut her up.”

“Nah, let her scream.” Snatched replied, pure joy in his voice. “I like hearing her cry.” His hooves dug into her thick legs, his hips pounding into her, squishing her ass cheeks against his body. Her already tight walls were clenched tighter in fear, as the despairing mare knew that was only making things feel better for her rapist. Burying her head into her bound hooves, she gave the stallion what he wanted, and sobbed, covering her forehooves in tears and the semen that seeped out of her mouth.

“Yeah, whatever. Meet me upstairs when you are done.” Column said, then it was just Fluttershy and Snatch again. The pegasus didn’t know how long it lasted for, but eventually she felt the warmth of fresh cum fill her. Snatch pulled out of her, then wiped his cock down on her tail.

“That felt fantastic.” He ruffled her hair. “I don’t know about Column, but I am probably done for the day. I’ll be down to give you food and water later. That said, I saw what you did with your wings there.” He said, with mock disappointment. The mare refused to even move, and just cried into her hoofs more. “You tried to get away. I warned you, didn’t I? Oh well. Maybe another day.”

Fluttershy heard the tearing of tape, and felt herself lifted into the air with magic. The stallion tightly bound her wings to her body by wrapping tape around her wings and chest. The mare sniveled, already feeling herself going crazy at being unable to move even more of her body willingly. She was set down onto the floor, and from the feeling of loose oats against her fur, the pegasus realized it was where she had slept before. The collar was again fastened around her neck, tape slapped over her lips, and when the stallion left, she was once again left alone. The damp blindfold around her eyes only grew damper as the day passed.

‘Why is it taking so long?’ She asked herself, ‘My friends are going to rescue me, aren’t they?’ For the first time the mare had a terrible thought. ‘What if they can’t find me?! No! No no, I can’t stay here! My friends have to find me, or or or, these stallions can’t just hold on to me forever. They’ll let me go, they have to! I want to go home!’

The two stallions were celebrating. Snatch had bought a barrel of cider from the town down the road, and had poured them both some of it.

“This was the best decision either of us have ever made.” Column laughed, downing half of a jug in one go. “I’m probably too tired to go again today, but that’s the beauty of it. She’ll still be there tomorrow.” His face suddenly got dour, “That said, taking care of her is still your responsibility, you did agree to that.”

“I did.” Snatch agreed, “Granted, I only agreed to that to convince you to help me grab her. On the road home from visiting your Ma in Van Hoover, and we spotted a cute mare all alone, and you were going to just let her walk by.”

“She is an Element of Harmony! There would be consequences if we were caught!”

“Pfft. Well worth the risk. Besides, like I said before, there wasn’t even much danger. My sleep spell held, and those roads aren’t well traveled. Tie her up in case she somehow wakes up, toss her in the wagon, and boom. We have ourselves our own little sex slave. The fact she is…, sorry was an Element just means we have a particularly famous sex slave.” Snatch leaned back, and closed his eyes. He could actually hear the slut’s soft crying echoing up the stairs to where they sat. If he wasn’t so damn tired, he’d go give her something to cry about, but that would have to wait.

“Yeah yeah. We got lucky and that makes you right. Still, no matter what the reasons for it, you did agree to be the one to take care of her.” Column gave a teasing look. Snatch laughed.

“Alright fair. I’ll bring her some food and water in a bit. For now though…,” He reached his mug out and Column did as well. Cider sloshed as they cheered their success, their laughter drowning out the faint sounds of sobbing from below.