Pinkie Pie Chronicles

((This part may be a bit violant but nothing grimdark))

Pinkie, i mean Diane Pie looked up at him all sad and nodded.

“Yes mister Doctor, I'm the second dominant personality of us...”

The Doctor though a bit, the second so it mean that she have more personality then two then, it could get complicated for their task, anyway seeing by how this one was, he need to bring back Pinkie Pie and he just had the best idea.

“Pinkie... i mean Diane, i need Pinkie Pie back ok? For that i will do something to you that will help you whatever how many Pinkie there is in your head to be able to change from one personality to another but some may be harder to bring them up, is that ok with you?”

Diane nodded as she knew that she wasn't fit the task to help them against Evil Pie since she was afraid of her after all the bad thing she does to her. The Doctor lead her to a sit in another room of the Tardis. Diane Pie sat on the chair and then the Doctor moved a machine over her head while Derpy was hovering behind him looking carefully. Diane turned to the Doctor who was setting the machine.

“Is this machine safe mister Doctor?”

She asked on a sad tone. The doctor cheered happily turning back to her his configuration all set.

“Its all safe don't worry dear!

After he said those word Diane smiled slightly to him and he pressed a bottom knocking out Dian for a second. She slowly woke up after 5 second, both the Doctor and Derpy looking at her hoping she’s right. Diane slowly got to herself and suddenly her mane and tail inflated and pop in the old puffy style but soon, she picked up glasses out of nowhere and wear them.

“Hi Pinkie Pie Solution is here!”

The Doctor and Derpy raised an eyebrow. The Stallion moved closer to her.

“Are you ok?”

Pinkie giggles at him and get off the chair.

“Yes i am perfectly correct, i never felt that good in my whole life actually, its good to be free after so many years inside our host Pinkie Pie”

Doctor was surprised by how she was talking, the Pinkie he know is more happy and hyper then that, even if he know her only from some minute ago but she seem smart, maybe she could be a good help. Pinkie Solution smiled as she walk in the middle of the room.

“If you want me to tell you why i am here and not Pinkie Pie, its because she’s in our head telling to all the other Pinkie about what is happening. Sadly, for now only me Pinkie Pie and Diane Pie can take place even if there is more useful part of Pinkie inside.”

This whole Pinkie thing was really strange, even for the Doctor and Derpy was totally lost. Pinkie Solution trotted toward the main room speaking to the Doctor.

“I’m also here because Pinkie have hard time handling the sight of what happened to our world and don't want to risk and be forced to make Diane Pie come out again, how it work is a bit complicated but lets just say that if Pinkie get really sad Diane Pie take place.”

The Doctor could follow what she said, it was fairly simple. He followed her to the door and himself followed by Derpy. Pinkie Solution opened the door and trot outside. She gazed around to see how it looked like. The orange grass seems dead under her hooves, the castle was still Gothic like, the moon following the soon in a constant eclipse. The Doctor followed her out with Derpy who gasped to how horrible it was. The Doctor had seen worst but it still saddened him while Pinkie Solution remained calm.

“Doctor, we have to find Twilight Sparkle, she’s the best one to help us, after that we can find the other member of Harmony to help us in our quest to defeat Pinkamena Evil Pie.”

The Doctor and Derpy nodded and and they started their way to Ponyville. Pinkie Solution continued her speech while they walk.

“If Pinkamena Evil Pie has in fact prevented the Sonic Rainboom that Rainbow Dash was supposed to do 10 years ago, it mean that all of my friend didn't get their Cutie Mark or at least not the same one, by the look of Canterlot, i doubt that Twilight is there unless Pinkamena Evil Pie captured her but lets search in Ponyville first, i doubt that Pinkamena Evil Pie’s plan is that simple.

The Doctor nodded again in agreement's.

“You’re quite smart Pinkie Solution, you will really be a great help in this!”

Derpy was going to say something but the Doctor cut her knowing she was going to talk.

“I will explain you later Derpy.”

They continued their way heading to the half destroyed village... city. As they get there, Pinkie Solution and the Doctor were making a plan.

On her side, Pinkamena Evil Pie in the Canterlot Castle sit down on the throne in this nightmare looking castle was talking to her subordinate, laying her hooves on Celestia’s back, tied up on the floor by chain. Her leg, body, a metal cap on her horn made of metal that block magic and even piercing hole in her wings to pin her down with lockers to the floor, she could hardly move and used as a bench to held your hooves on.

“Dawn Shimmershine, How’s the thing in Ponyville’s going?”

A dark red coated unicorn mare with long yellow mane straight down and falling in her face, dark blue eyes and some gears as a cutie mark trots to her Master.

“Twilight Sparkle is a great student, she’s learning everything i know about science, the question of Ponyville go really well, they are all on our side after all those years trying to convince them to obey you or they are jailed and it finally worked. Back to Twilight, she will soon fulfill her destiny and will accomplish what she have to do in around 20 years if everything go according to the plan B.”

Dawn finished her report. Pinkamena Evil Pie nodded at her then Turned to a tall deep dark blue mare with long blue mist like mane and tail wearing a light blue armor and a moon for cutie mark.

“Nightmare Moon, Have you convinced the Dragon civilisation to be on our camp yet?”

The moon mare walked forward to her and bowed in-front of her master, by the same time, Celestia tied to the floor gave her the most angry glare she never did but she didnt said anything. The mare stand up again.

“The Dragon refuse to bow in-front of your power, nothing work to convince them, not even force I'm afraid”

Evil Pie was leaning her head in boredom on the them handle and yawned and looked at Nightmare Moon uninterested.

“You do realise that a sever punishment is waiting you right?

Nightmare Moon protested quickly at Pinkamena Evil Pie, she was already disgusted to get order from a Earth Pony and if also she have to punish her for something that is not her fault, it was enough.

“Who do you think you are pathetic little pony! Its not my fault if those Dragon are stubborn! You have no right to punish me for anything, you shouldn't even be the one commanding here! I’m the goddess of the night!”

She stomped on the floor causing a lightning storm just be this little action. Pinkamena laughed lightly, Dawn her right hand backed a bit, no one should ever go against what her master said. Even Celestia had given up knowing that she cant do anything against her. The Evil pink mare slowly get her hooves off Celestia’s back and stand up looking at Nightmare Moon.

“You’re gonna regret your word pathetic fake god. Your horn and wings mean nothing nor your height, you’re just a cry baby who is envious of her sister who can control the sun. But right now i am in control of that sun, because your dear old sister have enough of me torturing her so she’s simply obeying me and move it for me, and if you are not willingly moving the moon for me or OBEYING ME! YOU WILL BE AT THE SAME PLACE AS YOUR PATHETIC OLD SISTER UNDERSTOOD THAT? KNOW YOUR PLACE!!”

Fear moved all the way in Celestia and Nightmare Moon’s spine, as well as Chrysalis and Discord on the right of the throne room waiting there for any order from Pinkamena Evil Pie. but then Nightmare Moon got over herself and said reluctantly.

“I’m not afraid of you! You can’t even kill me, You never kill anyone and always ask to make no one death.”

Discord face-palmed at her stupidity while Chrysalis shook her head thinking that she shouldn't have said that. Tears flowed down Celestia’s eyes and Dawn wouldn't look at what will happen. Pinkamena Evil Pie started to laugh insanely and then look at the foolish moon mare.

“There is way worst then death little filly.”

Suddenly Nightmare Moon got her body pierced through by Pinkamena’s arm who mysteriously appeared on her back without anypony noticing. Nighmare Moon spit some blood and her legs was shaking as she started to lose her straight. She turned her head to look behind her, blood dripping off her mouth and saw the whole arm going through her body. She spit blood another time having hard time to breath and Celestia yelled in tears.

“NOOO!! Not her! Anything but torturing her!”

Celestia was desperate to save her from that, she had already goes by that herself and refused her sister to go through that too. She even struggled against her chain, something that she haven't done in the past 5 years.

“Punish me for her i beg you... please... not her.”

She cried for her sister who was slowly losing all her blood and couldn't stay on her legs and fell on the floor. Tears flowed down of her cheek as well as her older sister realising how bad all her choice was in her life and regretted to have become Nightmare Moon as she saw her sister crying for her, the one who caught her and chained her to the floor.

“I’m sorry sister”

Nightmare Moon said between two blood spit. Pinkamena Evil Pie soddenly removed her arm of her body having it all covered in blood and laughing at her.

“You’re pathetic, you cant even see me coming unlike your sister who actually was able to fight me even if i defeated her.”

Pinkamena shook her arm full of blood to get it off and leave Nightmare Moon laying there in her blood.

“When you will be dead, I'll revive you and then you will woke up in one of my torture room where you will be tortured to death and revived several time before jailing you until you choose to follow my order again or you simply beg me right now to pass over your insubordination and be under my order again.”

Nightmare Moon didn't know what to answer and was slowly loosing her mind from the blood lose. Celestia turned her head to her still in tears.

“Luna... please follow what she want”

The night mare was still confused but she decided to follow her sister and tried to speak even if it was hard for her right now.

“I... I will... follow you’re... order master...”

She spit some blood again. Pinkamena raised an eyebrow at her and then grinned.

“Well look at that pathetic pony who finally knew her place. But sorry i still have to kill you, its part of the process”

She walked to the mare and broke her neck then grabbed her with one hand and opened a hole in space time with the other one. She pulled her on the hole then took her out after closing it up and opening it again. When Nightmare Moon was out of the hole, it was like she never has been injured or killed but she remembered everything. Celestia knew this trick, She was herself been killed many time. Nightmare Moon stood there for a few second then bowed to her master.

Pinkamena Evil Pie grained and walked back to the throne on her hind leg, she never walk on for leg. Celestia was calling that a sign of her true evilness since just doing that was betraying their equine origin. It wasn't bad in general but its the fact that she was doing this constantly and only to show her superiority and nothing else.

“May this serve for example for every of you here, no one disobey me and failure is not an option.”

Every of them in the room nodded, Chrysalis walked to Pinkamena who was once again laying her hooves on Celestia’s back and holding her head in her hand. Chrysalis started her report in her double echoed voice.

“The Grifon country is still opposing resistance but my changeling army is slowly pushing them making them retreat, everything is going as planed on my side, soon we will be able to convince them to be under your command.”

Pinkamena smiled, she finally heard some good news.

“Good work Chrysalis. Keep it up”

Chrysalis bowed to her and return to her place. Discord then walked in front of her waving his arm happily and a usual smile on his face and bowed to her like a gentleman.

“I can inform you that all my chaos is perfect as always. I followed every of your instruction and even added my personal touch of anarchy to it”

He laughed happily. Between all of them, the one who Pinkamena liked the most was him, he was always making good decision on his own that was benefic for her and her plan and he was the only one who was totally following her lead without saying anything against that, He actually proposed himself willingly under her command. Pinkamena smiled at him and stand up moving her hand to him and he did the same they both gave themselves a high five.

“Great work Discord, i can always count on you.”

Discord put his other arm in his back and moved the other one upward.

“Well all your idea are genius and your chaos may be a bit darker then my own style but i actually really like it, i should reconsider my own style.”

Pinkamena get back on her sit and smiled.

“Good that you finally recognize my work Discord, you do know that you are kinda my idol, you may not be as evil as me but your chaos is totally pure and totally senseless unlike mine that make some sense.”

Discord laughed and nodded at her.

“Yes your chaos make some sense but not enough for me to unlike it and it do have a lot of charm But anyway, what is my next task my overlord?”

Pinkamena think a bit and finaly made a decision.

“Well i was gonna ask you to find Pinkie Pie in your spare time but since Nightmare Moon failed at convincing the Dragon, i think you are more suited for this task.”

Discord bowed at her accepting his task.

“As you wish my dear.”

And he vanished opening a trap on the floor that never existed before. Nightmare Moon walked to her master. Pinkamena looked up at her.

“This is the only task that i allow failure because i don't even know when she will appear, like always i don't want the gloomy Pinkie at the Mining career with the rock cutie mark but the happy one with balloon like i have as cutie mark. You can go now and come back in a week”

Nigntmare Moon nodded and flew off by the front door. Evil Pie moved her hand to Dawn telling her to come over there. Dawn followed her order.

“Yes madam?”

Evil Pie pointed at Celestia.

“Its the noon, bring something to eat for Celestia”

Then she looked at Chrysalis and moved her hand to tell her to go. Chrysalis followed her sign and trots off the room and closed all the door with her magic. Dawn trots away to the kitchen in the always on the left of the throne. Pinkamena got her hooves of Celestia’s back and started to speak to her.

“You did a good job today Celestia. It was the right thing to do to convince her to be under my order again.

Celestia answered her angrily taking that as an insult.

“I didn't do it for you monster! I did that to save my sister. You’re not getting away from this Pinkamena”

Pinkamena walked in front of her and bent to bed at her height.

“For your sister or me it doesn't matter, If my plan work no one will remember this, and if it fail... Then this world will probably be destroyed by me.”

Celestia yelled back at her non-sense.

“You always keep saying that like it make sens! But you are destroying this world, How can you plan not be destroying it, you’re just a psychopath.”

Pinkamena loose her patience at her and yelled back.

“YES I AM AND I CAN'T BE ANYTHING ELSE!! IF MY PLAN WORK I WILL FINALLY GAIN WHAT I WANT, AND ITS SANITY! I CAME TO YOU AND ASKED YOU TO DO SOMETHING FOR ME BUT YOU CANT GIVE ME BACK MY SANITY!! YOU CAN GAVE ME WHAT IS MISSING!! AND MY PLAN IS DOOMED TO FAILURE! IF IT WASN'T DAWN WOULDN'T BE HERE!!”

Celestia remained silent trying to sort this and see the sense in that.

“You never answered my question that i asked you years ago. Who is Pinkie Pie and why does this mare supposedly have the same cutie mark as you?”

Pinkamena looked around not sure if she should tell her but she finally did.

“If you say that to anyone you’re going deep in the dungeon in a place nopony would ever be able to go. I’m Pinkie Pie Evil self. I’m the Yin in her personality. Its why i need her but before she need to be stronger but the problem is it seems like she will fail or never come since Dawn is here. If she indeed never come its ok, i will just rule this land forever. If you’re wondering why i need her to be stronger and come here? Its because i want her to kill me before i do bad things. I know its sound weird coming from me but i don't actually want to do all these, i do them because I'm forced to. Its stronger then me, I'm the Yin of Pinkie Pie, i cant be anything but evil but since Pinkie is the happiest pony that can exist, my personality conflict with my nature, making me realise that what I'm doing is bad and its the worst part. Whenever i try to be good I'm forced to make ponies suffer and ITS DRIVING ME CRAZY!!! You would never understand my condition I’m not even a pony like you I'm a piece of mind the part that make the bad thing, that make a pony think in a bad way but i would be ok with that if i wasn't CORRUPTED BY THE ELEMENT OF LAUGHTER!! FROM YOUR DAMN ELEMENT OF HARMONY!! This pathetic thing that you no longer control had to go in the only pony that have her mind split in around 40 part me included. This is literally your biggest joke Celestia, Its why i hate you so much and i don't even want you to be under my command, If I'm here doing all this its because of you fault!!”

Celestia had more information then what she wanted, she didn't realised her error by choosing Pinkie Pie to be the element of Laughter. Its just another faith of destiny. She doesn't remember doing this though but she do know she come from an alternate reality so this must be true, she believed her, why would she be lying anyway.

“Whatever the Celestia from your reality did, i didn't do it here, you must have preventing me from doing it since you appeared 10 years ago. You changed everything. I’m not the Celestia who did that to you.”

Pinkamena grabbed her hand in her hand having another urge to spread pain on ponies.

“I DONT CARE!! SHUT UP!!!”

She kicked Celestia in the face who winced in pain leaving her bleeding with a wound on her left cheek. It calmed Pinkamena a bit and she got back to Celestia.

“You see, i just wounded you because i cant contain myself and if i try to heal you to be kind, i will just be forced to do worst to somepony else, you’re lucky that i could let your sister just get back under my command without losing myself and forced to torture her. Don't think i do this by choice because i don't, unlike you i don't have free will, I'm ruled by a force that prevent me from being good.”

Dawn came back in the room and saw Celestia having blood dripping on the floor from her cheek. The wound wasn't too bad though, it was small. She trotted to her with a rag to wash the blood of her cheek with her magic.

“Princess Celestia what happened?”

The red mare asked curious about what happened but Celestia moved her head away disgusted by this mare who was willingly under Pinkamena’s command even if she understand a bit more her goal. Dawn kept her head in place and washed the blood and gives her her food. Pinkamena Evil Pie Exited the room and goes to her bedroom.

“Princess, you should stop refusing my help”

Celestia still couldn't understand why the only one still calling her Princess was that mare she never saw before.

“Why do you still calm me princess? I left the statue of Princess behind me years ago. From all ponies under Pinkamena’s commands you’re maybe the worst. You’re too good to really be under her command. You prefer following somepony like her then going against her, why? The other one have a reason, Chrysalis always wanted our Kingdom, Discord is the god of Chaos, Nightmare Moon is eaten by jealousy, but you... you’re a regular Unicorn, and kind and always want good for others.”

Dawn looked down and sigh. Celestia mad her feel bad but not enough to discourage her from her personal goal.

“The reason why I'm her under her command is because I'm here to keep her away from doing bad thing as hard as i can. I can’t stop her wrath but i can slow it down. I came from the future to stop her but she defeated easily, i accepted my faith and followed her command against my will at first but then she explained me everything and I'm here to help her now... She need help...”

Celestia yelled at her, helping somepony like her even if she’s fundamentally evil isn't an excuse. She need to be stopped as soon as possible. It was ridiculous, its clear that after all it was all lies and she was just manipulating her.

“You’re insane, she doesn't need help, don't you see its only a game for her. She’s manipulating you! She’s just going to destroy and enslave anypony like half of the country already is and she fooled you!”

Dawn sighed and looked Celestia in the eyes.

“Maybe one day you will understand Princess.”

With that, she let the plate in front of her and put a band-aid on her cheek, then get up and leave Celestia alone in the throne, chained to the floor eating even if she didn't wanted to. She sigh and started to cry just having enough of this life.