The Tales of The Nightmare Night

by KingofNightmares

Rating: mature
Tags: Anthology, Profanity, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Death, Alternate Universe, Narcotics, Sweetie Belle, Other, Original Character, Apple Bloom, Mystery, Fetish, Rainbow Dash, Suicide / Self Harm, Horror, Non-consensual, Violence, Sex
Length: 1356

My Halloween themed MLP scary tales

My Halloween themed MLP scary tales

Published 2020-10-09 16:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2020-10-09 16:20:01 UTC

The Candymaker

The Candymaker

Cutie mark crusaders were very excited about Nightmare Night because lots of candy that they would get. They dressed up in their unique costumes. Apple Bloom was a witch that specialized in making potions. Sweetie Belle was a professional singer that was in a gorgeous blue dress. Scootaloo was a wonder bolt because of her adopted mother’s pride. They said goodbye to their families and went out to get their candy from the Ponyville residents. During the night, They filled their bags to the rim with varying kinds of sweets. Apple Bloom managed to carry her bag without any sweat due to her earth pony bloodline. However, her friends struggled with their like prisoners slowly dragged their balls and chains. Cutie mark crusaders decided that they would go to one more house before going back to their homes.

The mysterious fog suddenly appeared and engulfed them. A quick few moments passed by, it just faded like a rat’s eerily eyes in the darkness. Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle were confused about what’d happen. However, Scootaloo exactly knew what happened because her mother told her what was.

“Girls, it was just a fallen cloud passed through. I see our last candy stop for this Nightmare Night in front of us.” Scootaloo stated with a nonchalant expression before raising up her goggles onto her forehead. Her friends nodded their heads to her before they went in the direction of the house. At this point, they wanted to collect their candy from this house and ran back to their homes. The Nightmare Night fear finally and steadily crept into their skins. This house had a metal spike fence around it that was decorated with fake bloody pony body parts on it. They were amazed that the pony parts props were looked to be realistic than cheap plastic ones. The gate was opened with a hanging sign that said, welcome tricker and treaters, I have candy for you.

Cutie mark crusaders entered the front yard and went on the front porch. The yard had lots of unique Nightmare Night decorations that were scattered over it. Sweetie Belle had a growing fear in herself from feeling a mysterious magic aura around her horn. Since she came closer to this house, the feeling grew more robust with each step that she took. She didn’t know what it was. In the corner of her eye, Sweetie swore the scarecrows and jack-o'-lanterns on the porch gave her a grinning and scary expression. She hoped that her mind was imagining that due to she was a little terrified. Apple Bloom knocked a couple of times on the door.

“Trick or treat!” Apple Bloom, Scootaloo, and Sweetie Belle simultaneously shouted with a smile on their faces after a pink unicorn mare that wore an apron with multiple color stains on it.

“Hello there, I'm Sweetheart. I see a witch, singer, and Wonderbolt that are best friends and have a great future with each other. Here are filled bags of my fresh-made candy. Also, I'll give you fillies a sample of my new caramel apple chewy candy to try out.” Sweetheart sweety said with a smile, levitating three heavy bags out of her house and put one beside each filly. Then she brought out a plate that has small candy samples on it. Cutie mark crusaders were happy to try out her samples. Each of them took a candy sample and put it into their mouths. After a few moments of chewing it, their mouths were bombarded with the perfect mix of apple and caramel flavors that it immediately learned a delicious Mmmmm from the fillies. Cutie Mark Crusaders were about to thank Sweetheart for candy. But they were suddenly tired and collapsed onto the ground. The last thing that they heard and saw before passing out.

“Ah sweeties, you must be tired from your night of treat or tricks. I'll fix this, sweeties.” Sweetheart exclaimed with a sweet tone in her voice before moving them with her magic into her home and closed her door. Then her house disappeared out of the existence and didn’t leave anything that would be tale-tell signs that it was here.

An unknown amount of time passed by, Apple Bloom woke up and realized that she was tightly strapped down on a surgical table. Also, she wore a dog muzzle that wouldn't let to talk.

“My sweet Apple Bloom, you finally woke up from your nap. I know you are confused and terrified of your situation now. I need your flesh for my candy apples. But, you'll not die, and I'll give you a lot of candy. I promised, sweetie.” Sweetheart exclaimed sweety, coming closer to her. Apple Bloom’s reply was panicky and frightenedly mmmmmmmmmmmm as she attempted to broke free from straps that held her in place. With all of her earth pony strength, she wouldn’t break free from them. Her only option was to sob and cried until this nightmare over. Sweetheart didn’t show any emotions towards the crying filly and picked up a surgical knife off a mini table. Then she made incisions below Bloom’s neck and above her hind legs. Bloom cried in agony while her blood oozed out from her fresh cuts.

Sweetheart ignored the filly’s crying and continue to cut her hind to connect incisions with each other. After connecting them, she quickly tore Apple Bloom’s belly flesh off her body with her magic like a bandage. Apple Bloom unleashed the most painful moan ever in her life before passing out from shock and blood loss. Sweet laid down the filly’s flesh on a table beside her. Then she grabbed a potion on the mini table and splashed its liquid onto Apple Bloom’s body. Her body immediately absorbed the mysteriously liquid and grew scarred skin to heal her wound entirely. Sweetheart grabbed the filly’s fresh-cut skin before leaving the room with it.

Sweetie Belle was in the same situation as Apple Bloom was. However, there were two differences, which they were she was strapped down in a chair instead of a surgical table. Also, there was a contraption that forcedly kept her left eye open wide. Sweetheart promised the exact things to her. The unicorn filly gave the same reply to the mare as her earth pony friend did.

Heart grabbed a surgical knife with her magic and readied for cutting Belle’s left eye out from her head. During the progression of cutting the eye out, the contraption perfectly did its job of keeping her eye open. Unfortunately for Sweetie Belle, this Nightmare night would haunt her for the rest of her life. After Sweetheart removed her eye, Sweetie Belle passed out from the pain. Heart used a healing potion to grow Belle’s eye back. Then she repeated this progression until she got the whole tray of eyeballs. She grabbed it with her magic and left the room.

Unlucky for Scootaloo, she had the shortest straw in this situation because Sweetheart wanted both of her hind legs for some kind of candy. Unlike her friends, she didn’t lose consciousness due to her adrenaline training. Unfortunately for her. It was a con because it made her dealing every ounce of pain from her horrific surgical procedure. She felt every cut that Sweetheart made in her hide. The worst part was the insane mare broke off her hind legs’ bones with a hammer. After that part, Scootaloo slowly passed out from the blood loss. Sweetheart grabbed a healing potion and splashed its liquid onto the filly's wounds. Her body immediately formed fleshy bumps where her hind legs would be. Sweetheart grabbed Scootaloo’s legs with her magic and left the room.

Rainbow Dash heard a couple of knocks on her door and assumed that was Scootaloo.

“Sc………………” She exclaimed with a smile on her face as she opened the door. She didn’t inspect to see the grim sight of tortured looking cutie mark crusaders were surrounded with a lot of candy bags.

“What in Celestria, What happened to you guys!” She acquired terrify before calling for help on her home phone.

THE END