Brony T. Pony has always hated celebrating the holidays, due to having to hear his parents arguing and later being too broke to actually celebrate the holidays. In order to combat the feeling of holiday joy, Brony decides to repeat the infamous "Hearth's Warming Eve Goo Powder Prank Incident". After he is caught and punished, Gallus agrees to stay with him. Wanting to learn the reasoning behind Brony's hatred for the holidays, Gallus seeks the help of Princess Luna who shows him and the rest of his friends what Brony had to go through.