An Incorrect Use of Love Potions

by Rimmer

Rating: mature
Tags: Zecora, Rainbow Dash, Zephyr Breeze, Romance, Porn, Fetish, Fluttershy, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 4128

Tired of Zephyr Breeze’s advances, Rainbow Dash uses a love potion to make him fall in love with the first female that isn’t her. Unfortunately, the first female that Zephyr sees isn’t a pony.

Tired of Zephyr Breeze’s advances, and willing to do anything to make him stop, Rainbow Dash has Zecora make her a love potion that will make him fall in love with the first female that isn’t her. Unfortunately, the first female that Zephyr sees isn’t a pony.

TRIGGERS: Bestiality, Voyeurism, Masturbation, Big Cock → Small Hole, Size Difference, Excessive Cum, Hints of Incest (but not really)

This story is a commission for: superfun
Information about my commissions can be found on my profile page.

Published 2020-11-17 14:40:00 UTC
Last updated 2020-11-17 14:40:00 UTC

Zephyr's New "Marefriend"

The rolling fog danced around the wet, muddy ground of the Everfree forest. Even during midday, the underbrush was shrouded in a dark shadow that hid most of the forest’s secrets from view. The only beacon of light in the dark was from a small, ramshackle hut that belonged to a certain zebra alchemist.

“And you’re sure this will work?” Rainbow Dash asked, eyeing the bubbling purple sludge wearily. Zecora nodded in affirmation before dropping in the final ingredient. The concoction exploded in a poof of violet smoke, making Rainbow gag as the foul stench hit her lungs. She coughed, flapping her wings to waft the cloud away from her, and then gasped at what she saw.

The putrid purple liquid had been replaced with a crystal-clear one, and Zecora poured a few spoonfuls into a small vial. She handed it over to Dash. “Give this to the stallion who woes you so. Once he drinks it he will go.” Zecora waved her hoof in a fleeing motion.

Rainbow took the vial, eyeing it before slipping it into her saddlebag. “Thanks, Zecora,” she said. “How much should I give him?”

“Half a vial should be enough, to sway a stallion no matter how tough.” The pegasus nodded and thanked the zebra again before leaving.

Rainbow had the potion, and she had been assured that this specific brew would cause any stallion to fall in love with the first mare they saw besides her. Now, the only remaining question was who to make him fall in love with.

Multiple mares came to mind, but Dash was not cruel enough to try and hook him up with any old mare. She needed to find one who would effectively block his alchemically-induced advances. As she thought about it, a devious idea came to mind.

Fluttershy. She would bring him to see Fluttershy. Her face broke out into a conniving grin as she flew back towards Ponyville. Fluttershy would definitely reject her brother’s feelings. She was the perfect match! Plus, this was bound to be one of Rainbow’s best pranks yet! With her plan solidified in her mind, she picked up the pace, flapping her wings harder and soaring to the center of town.

It was not particularly hard to find Zephyr. After getting fired from the Canterlot Royal Guard, he had fallen into a predictable routine. As expected, he was sitting near the Ponyville smoothie bar. The remnants of a consumed strawberry banana smoothie sat in front of him as he lounged about. He noticed Rainbow Dash almost immediately, and perked up as soon as he saw her.

“Rainbow Dash!” he called out excitedly. “I knew you’d come to visit me eventually!”

The cyan pegasus had to resist the urge to roll her eyes. “Hey, Zephyr,” she said uncomfortably. “What’s up?”

Zephyr shrugged, and tried slurping more of his drink out of the empty cup. “Eh, not much,” he said. “Just chillin’ here, drinking my smoothie.” He wiggled his eyebrows at Dash. “Waiting for you.”

Rainbow shuddered, holding back the urge to gag. Without any more delay, she enacted her plan. “You want another smoothie?” she asked, gesturing his empty cup with a hoof. His eyes widened and he nodded eagerly in response. Rainbow turned away from him and headed over to the counter, painfully aware that Zephyr was staring at her ass the entire trip.

She ordered another smoothie, throwing the bits on the counter. As the glass was placed in front of her, she shifted her wing, carefully removing the potion from where it was hidden underneath her feathers. Checking to make sure her body was obstructing Zephyr’s view, she removed the stopper and poured about half into the drink. She stirred it in, mixing it into the smoothie thoroughly to try and obscure whatever taste it might have. Tucking the vial back underneath her wing, she turned and went back over to Zephyr, the altered beverage in hoof.

“Here you go,” Rainbow said, placing the drink in front of him. “Oh, and by the way, Shy wants to see you,” she added. “That’s kind of the real reason I’m here.”

Zephyr chugged the smoothie in a few short gulps before standing. “Ah, fine. Let’s go.” The two spread their wings and took off, flying towards Fluttershy’s cottage on the edge of the forest.

When the two of them landed, Rainbow bounced on her hooves a little before trotting up to her friend’s house. She was excited to get this whole ordeal done and over with. She would finally be free of Zephyr’s unwanted advances, and would get to pull off an epic prank in the process. It was quite literally the best of both worlds.

Rainbow pounded her hoof on the door in three loud knocks. “Flutters?” she called. “It’s me, Dash!” She tapped her hoof on Fluttershy’s welcome mat impatiently, waiting for her friend to open up the door. She was about to knock again when the door opened up slowly and Fluttershy peeked her head out.

“H-hello?” the yellow pegasus whispered. “Oh, Dash, it’s you.” The door opened fully and Rainbow practically pranced inside.

Giddily bouncing on her hooves, Dash turned to smile widely at Fluttershy. “Yeah, of course it's me. I said that when I knocked.” She gestured back at the doorway. “Zephyr here has something he wants to tell you,” she said smugly.

“Oh,” said Fluttershy softly. “Zephyr is here?”

Raising an eyebrow, Rainbow looked back towards the stallion who followed her here. “What? Yeah, he's right… there…” The cyan pegasus looked around, but Zephyr was nowhere to be seen. “Zephyr?” she called out looking around Fluttershy’s living room.

“Zephyr?” questioned Rainbow Dash again, this time stepping back outside. “Where’d you go?” She looked around, but there was no sign of the other pegasus anywhere. Confused, Dash walked around to the side of Fluttershy’s cottage and she spotted Zephyr over near the animal pens. “Oh, there you are,” Dash said, rolling her eyes. “What are you even doing back here.”

Suddenly, Zephyr sprung forward catching one of the many rabbits in his forehooves. The small animal let out a squeak as the other bunnies hopped away. Rainbow raised an eyebrow as he brought the small animal up to eye level and stared at it for a few moments.

“Uhhhh, buddy?” Dash asked, taking a few steps forward. “What… what are you doing there?” Zephyr only briefly glanced at the cyan pegasus before he brought the bunny up to his face and looked it in the eye. Then, without any warning, he brought it up to his lips and gave it a kiss. “Whoah, dude! What the fuck?”

Rainbow Dash cringed in disgust as she watched him start to make out with the small rabbit. His tongue was attempting to slip into the animal’s mouth as he locked lips with it. However, as the scene progressed in front of her, she finally put two and two together.

The potion that Dash had slipped him had caused him to fall in love with not just the first mare he saw, but the first female he saw. And that female just happened to be that bunny. She started snickering as she realized what had happened and soon Dash had erupted into all-out raucous laughter.

Hoofsteps approached the side of the house, but neither Rainbow nor Zephyr paid any attention to them. “Did you find Zephyr?” questioned Fluttershy as she rounded the corner. She noticed Rainbow laughing and followed her gaze. It took a few moments for her to register what she was seeing, but eventually reality caught up with her. “Bella!” gasped Fluttershy as she saw the small bunny in Zephyr’s grasp. “Oh my gosh! What is going on?!”

“No, you see,” Rainbow Dash began, trying to talk through her snickers. “This is totally fine! One-hundred percent A-OK.” The pegasus could not contain herself any longer, and burst out laughing again. She fell onto her back, clutching her stomach as she laughed and trying to stem the tears that were streaming down her face in glee.

Fluttershy, however, was not as amused. “Rainbow!” she scolded in the loudest voice she could manage. “This is not funny! He could hurt that poor bunny!” She shifted her hooves in worry, looking back and forth between her friend and her brother, who was still sloppily making out with the tiny lagomorph. “What is going on?!”

Rainbow tried to respond, but could not stop laughing long enough to explain. A few other bunnies had gathered around the pair now, watching in curiosity. They did not understand what was happening, but it nonetheless piqued their interest. Zephyr finally pulled himself away from the rabbit, taking a breath and glancing at Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy.

The two of them watched as he lifted Bella up and lined his muzzle up between her hind legs. Rainbow eyes widened in a sense of humorous surprise as his tongue slipped out and he lapped at the bunny’s tiny pussy, whilst Fluttershy let out another horrified gasp. Bella squirmed in Zephyr’s grip as he ate her out, tiny pleasure-filled squeaks escaping her mouth as he did so.

Seemingly without a care in the world, Zephyr leaned back and spread his hind legs. His hefty balls and sheath were on display for all to see. The view only contributed more to Rainbow’s chuckles, while Fluttershy blushed deeply and averted her gaze. However, she was quickly drawn back as her brother’s cock began to slip out of it’s wrinkled home.

Zephyr’s dick quickly grew to its full length and hardened, pulsing with lust as he licked up and down her wet slit one last time. A glob of precum drooled out of the tip of his penis, slowly dripping down the side. He lowered Bella down to give the bunny another deep kiss before lifting her up and positioning her over his length.

Zephyr lined the flat head of his horsecock up with Bella’s small rabbit pussy. The bunny’s eyes widened as she felt the massive rod press against her. It pushed forward, parting her lower lips and slowly sliding into her tiny cunt. Zephyr moaned loudly as he squeezed his way into her, his progress slow but steady. Soon, what appeared to be an impossible length was buried in the bunny’s tight snatch, and he could not go in any further.

For her part, Bella was doing an excellent job of taking Zephyr’s massive dick. Her entire lower body was stretched around his length, but she showed no signs of discomfort. If anything, her small face was twisted into a look of pleasure as the pegasus stallion used her as his cocksleeve.

Rainbow Dash actually looked on in awe at the sight. “Holy fuck,” she said. “She’s taking that meat like a champ!”

“Rainbow Dash!” Fluttershy scolded. “This isn’t funny! Tell me what’s going on right now!”

“Alright, alright! Calm down, yeesh!” Rainbow scratched the back of her head with her hoof. “Okay, so listen. Zephyr constantly hitting on me was kinda getting real old real fast. That and all the touching was really starting to piss me off. So I maybe asked Zecora to make me a potion that would make him fall in love with someone else?” Her statement was phrased as a question, and she shrunk back in fear as Fluttershy’s eyes widened into her signature stare.

“What. Did. You. Do?” Fluttershy emphasized the question by poking Rainbow firmly in the chest with each word, and the cyan mare tried to make herself even smaller.

Gulping, Rainbow replied, “Um, I gave it to him and he might have fallen in love with that rabbit.”

Fluttershly looked back to Bella and her brother and watched as he slowly dragged the small animal up and down his throbbing length. Each time he reached her maximum depth, she let out a quiet coo. The yellow pegasus could not deny that Bella looked like she was enjoying herself just as much as Zephyr was. She was trying not to pay attention to her brother and his impressive endowment, but she found her eyes drifting down to his hefty cock and balls.

The rod was slicked with Bella’s rabbit juices, which were practically gushing out. Wet spurts of bunny cum dripped down his shaft and over his round orbs, making them glisten in the afternoon sun. Fluttershy was finding that she could not pull herself away, and continued to watch as her brother fucked the small animal.

A wet schlicking sound beside her was what finally pulled her away from her staring. She looked to her right and saw Rainbow Dash leaning back in the grass, hind legs spread as she lightly rubbed at her pussy. Fluttershy’s blush deepend and she gasped at her friend’s flagrant display of exhibitionism. “R-rainbow!” she squeaked.

“What?” Dash asked, only briefly pausing her masturbating. “It’s kinda hot.” She resumed playing with herself, turning her attention back to the action in front of her.

Fluttershy found herself caught between the two lewd actions happening on either side of her. Her eyes shifted between watching her brother’s interspecies romp and her friend’s self pleasure. Moans and grunts of pleasure assaulted her from both sides until she just could not take it anymore. The sexual energy was overpowering, and she let out a cry of frustration as a drip of her own fluids leaked down her hind leg.

“Rainbow Dash!” she screamed, using a brief burst of flight to slam the ground in front of the rainbow pegasus. “Stop touching yourself and go get Zecora!” she ordered. Rainbow froze and looked up at her, hoof midway through circling her clit.

“Uh, do I have to do that right now?” she asked. “I’m kinda in the middle of something, in case you couldn’t tell, Shy.” Fluttershy’s breathing sped up in anger, and she glared down at the pegasus. “Oh no, yeah. I can do that. Right now, no problem!” Dash hurriedly corrected herself, quickly licking off her hoof and standing up. “Zecora. Go get Zecora. Getting right on that!”

Rainbow Dash quickly spread her wings and took off, speeding towards the edge of the forest. Fluttershy’s angry face fell as soon as her friend was out of sight, and she let out a nervous sigh as she turned back to look at Zephyr.

Bella was rapidly bouncing up and down on the horsecock, her small tongue lolling out in pure biss. Her tiny squeaks were quick and filled with pleasure with each bounce, her tiny front paws gripping onto Zephyr’s hooves as he lifted her up and down.

With everyone else gone, Fluttershy found that she could not deny the emotions brewing inside her any longer. Something about what she was watching was surprisingly attractive. The way that Bella’s small body slipped around her brother’s cock so perfectly, the way that she eagerly took as much of his length as she could. Fluttershy found herself growing more and more aroused the more she watched.

Suddenly, Zephyr slammed Bella down as hard as he could, burying his massive length as far it could go inside of her. Her grunted as his balls churned and his dick pulsed. The bunny let out a startled cry of pleasure as the pegasus came inside of her, blasting the inside of her tiny pussy with his thick seed.

Globules of his off-white cum squeezed out around the base of his cock, rolling down over his balls and dripping to the dirt below. Fluttershy’s mouth hung open as she watched him lift Bella off of his cock, the action accompanied by a vulgar squelch. A flood of semen spurted out of the rabbit’s stretched cunt, sloppily gushing onto the ground. The two panted in the afterglow of their orgasms, but it appeared that they were not quite done.

Zephyr fell backwards to that he was lying down in the dirt. His cock was still rock hard and it pointed straight upwards to the sky. It glisted with the combination of his jizz and Bella’s fluids, and pulsed steadily in time with his heart beat. Getting the idea, Bella shakily stood on her hind legs and wrapped herself around the dick, messing up her fur with their mixed sexual slime.

Her tongue flicked out and licked at his length as she rubbed her body against his cock. Watching them now, it was almost comical at how large his dick was compared to her small form, and Fluttershy wondered how they even managed to fit that in her.

The yellow pegasus sat down as she watched little Bella give it her all, eagerly rubbing herself up and down against Zephyr’s mighty cock, jerking it off with her entire body. Somehow, the small animal seemed like she wasn’t tired at all.

If Fluttershy was going honest with herself, it was not the bunny that was getting her going. Sure, being around animals day in and day out had made the general idea of zoophilia enter her steamy thoughts quite often, but what really did it for her was the size difference. A small, helpless animal wrapped around a massive cock that dwarfed its own body - doing everything in its power to pleasure its dominator.

Without Fluttershy noticing, one of her hooves began to sneak down towards her heated privates. The tip dragged slowly along her spread thigh, working its way up towards its goal. It lightly brushed against one of her outer lips, and the pegasus felt a desperate heat blossom up through her entire body. She wanted to feel the sweet relief her hoof could give her. She needed it.

Her labia parted, and clit blinked outwards as she watched Bella and her brother. She pictured herself as the small animal, being taken by a large beast with a massive cock. Her hoof circled the outer edges of her flower as her arousal leaked out and puddled on the ground. Perhaps a large dragon would come and claim her right then and there, and she would be helpless to stop it. She threw her head back as her hoof finally brushed against her clitoris, and she let out a whimpering moan.

Just as Fluttershy was about to fully give into her fantasy and temptation, she noticed two ponies rushing back towards her cottage. Rainbow Dash was flying overhead while Zecora was trotting up to her. She quickly stood back up, flipping her tail down and pressing it tight against her wet cunt. Her face was bright red, and she was thankful that she noticed them before she had started fully playing with herself.

“I’m back,” panted Rainbow as she landed. “Zecora’s here.” She glanced back at the duo, observing whatever progress had been made since she left. “Oh cool, they switched positions!”

Ignoring her friend, Fluttershy went over to Zecora, nervously tapping her hooves on the ground. “Are they going to be okay?” she asked. “Will they stop soon?”

“Have no fear my pegasus friend. Eventually the effect will end,” Zecora said as she inspected Zephyr. She poked around, lowering her head between his hind legs and eyeing the back of his ballsack and asshole.

“So, you mean it’s temporary?” asked Fluttershy in a small voice. “Oh thank goodness!”

The zebra shook her head, licking her lips and reluctantly drawing her gaze from Zephyr’s ass. “It appears that you might have misunderstood. Your brother here loves this bunny for good.”

Fluttershy’s pupils shrunk to pinpricks. “W-what?” she whispered. “But you said that the potion would wear off!”

Zecora nodded. “Yes indeed, the lust will fade. But in terms of love, the bond has been made.”

Rainbow Dash leaned in. “I think she means that eventually he will stop fucking…” the cyan mare paused for a moment. “What did you say her name was?”

“Bella,” Fluttershy said quietly, ears flattened back on her head as she watched Zephyr grunt as he came again. Spurts of thick spunk flew out of his tip, raining down against his belly and the bunny wrapped around his cock. A stray blob landed on one of Fluttershy’s hooves, and looking down at it, she fought the urge to lick it off

“It’s gonna be fine,” Rainbow said, laying a wing across her friend’s shoulders. “Look, they’re already tuckered out.”

Sure enough, Bella finally fell off of his cock. A deluge of stallion spunk drooled out of the rabbit’s gaping pussy, which was still full from before. Her fur was matted down with his cum, dripping down onto his coat below her. Zephyr’s dick was coated with a combination of their juices, and it flopped down over his stomach. It was no longer rock hard, but it did not seem ready to retreat back into its sheath yet, either. Instead it just lay there as their sexual slimes smeared into his fur.

“This is like... the best possible outcome,” Dash said after a moment, causing Fluttershy to look at her in shock. “Think about it. He’s not chasing my tail anymore, and he sure won’t be chasing any other poor mares!” Fluttershy just shook her head, not knowing what to say to that.

Zecora finished her visual examination of the couple and looked back up to address Fluttershy. “Leave them be and let them rest,” said the zebra as she turned and began to head back towards the Everfree Forest. “Given the circumstances I think that would be best.”

Despite her initial feelings of concern and disgust, Fluttershy now had to admit one important thing to herself. She had to agree with Rainbow Dash. Watching her brother fuck that bunny had definitely been pretty hot. As the other two walked away in their separate directions, she quickly gave into the urge and licked the glob of her brother’s cum off of her hoof. The more she thought about it, the less opposed she was to the idea of Zephyr being in love with Bella. After all, worse things could happen, right?

“I saw that.” Rainbow Dash’s voice startled Fluttershy and she turned around to see that the cyan pegasus had somehow doubled back to sneak up on her. “I knew you were getting all hot and bothered.”

Fluttershy’s face could not get any more red. Her muzzle was hot enough to cook an egg on and Rainbow Dash knew it. “I’m not- I didn’t…” the pegasus stammered, backing a few steps away from Dash. “It’s just that-”

“Oh, don’t even worry about it, Flutters!” laughed Rainbow as she came up alongside her and placed a wing over her back. “I’m sure you’ll tell me all about how much you wanna try it out while I fuck you silly tonight.”

The yellow pegasus just stammed even more as her friend guided her back towards the house. This was not how she saw this day going at all. “W-wait,” she stuttered, sliding out from under Dash’s wing. “I… I need to check on Bella!”

Rainbow Dash rolled her eyes as Fluttershy trotted over towards where her brother was passed out in the dirt. His dick was still out, draped across his stomach while the rest of his cum dried onto the hair coating his belly. The tiny rabbit was curled up against it, basking in the warmth of its pulsing presence.

“B-bella?” Fluttershy whispered, leaning in towards the animal. The scent of her brother’s cum wafted into her nose, and she did her best to suppress any urges that it roused inside her. “Are you o-okay?”

The bunny looked up at Fluttershy with tired eyes before letting out an exhausted series of squeaks. As the pegasus listened, her face only got redder and her tail idly swished behind her, fanning the scent of her arousal to whomever was nearby.

“Oh my,” said Fluttershy as Bella finished, and she pulled away. “Wow, um okay.” She took a few steps back, letting the bunny cuddle back up with Zephyr’s dick as she drifted back to sleep.

Dash walked up to her, a cocky grin on her face. “So, is she okay?” she asked, already knowing the answer.

Fluttershy could only nod in affirmation as she looked up into Rainbow’s magenta eyes. “I-I think I need to you f-fuck me, right now,” the yellow pegasus stammered. “I-if you don’t m-mind,” she added as an afterthought, shamefully hiding behind her pink mane.

Rainbow only chuckled in response. “That was the plan, Flutters,” she said as she guided Fluttershy back into her cottage. “That was the plan.”

Author's Note

This story was a commission! If you're interested in any of my commissions, send me a DM to get the conversation started! More information about my commissions can be found on my profile page.