Choose Wisely (Alternate ending)

by Mpony1

Rating: mature
Tags: Porn, Mystery, Princess Cadance, Comedy, Queen Chrysalis, Shining Armor, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 7970

What if Shining Armor figured out a way tell who's the real Cadence?

Just a short Alternate ending to the story "Choose Wisely" by, dirty little secret.

Click Here to read that story before reading this one.

Warning: SPOILER ALERT

Shining Armor was rope into a game where he had to figure out which of the two Cadance's is the real one and which was Chrysalis in disguise. The two mares didn't make it easy for him. Leaving no room for error and making it impossible for him figure out who was who.

In the end he chose wrong and per the rules he was punish. But what if Shining chose the real Cadance and how will he do it with the odds so stack against him.

Published 2020-11-26 18:10:00 UTC
Last updated 2020-12-19 14:53:30 UTC

You have chose wisely

“Cadance! Cadance, I'm ready to—” Shining groaned, but without Cadance One's mouth on him, the orgasm didn't quite come.

“Ready to pick which one?” They stood up and turned around, presenting themselves for him. “Great! Mount the real me! Do it!” Each of them had long trails of glistening wetness seeping down their inner thighs, and they held their tails high, arched all the way up over their backs.

The double-vision temptation in front of him combined with his near-miss orgasm slowed his thoughts to a crawl, but he pressed through the mental fog of arousal as well as he could. Oh Goddess, he just wanted both of them so badly! Why did this have to be so hard? An evil little part of his brain supplied him an idea: if he just guessed, there was a fifty/fifty shot of getting it right. Pretty good odds, and if he did get it right, everything would be perfect. A more cautious part of him worried about the fifty percent chance of getting it horribly wrong. But then his cock chimed in, telling him that either way, at least he'd get a warm, soft pussy to cum inside.

Given how supremely horny he was, that last little argument was more than enough to sway him.
He jumped off of the bed, rushed over, and chose Cadance A at random, sliding his chest up over her rump. He could already feel the heat of her wet pussy against the tip of his cock, and he couldn't wait to take her and—

“Are you sure, Honey?” Cadance One's words froze him for a moment.

Glancing over at Cadance One, he saw the raised eyebrows, the slight hint of disapproval ... and then he knew. Cadance One must be the real Cadance! He slid off of Cadance A and hefted himself on top of his wife, grateful that she would give him a little hint like that before he did something terrible. He lined his cock up to Cadance A wet pussy; ready to penetrate her but just before he did a thought struck his mind like a lightning bolt. "What if this isn't the real Cadance?" Shining thought. Stopping himself from plowing the mare under him. "What if this is actually Chrysalis and the warning, she gave was a trick to make me believe that the real Cadance was trying to help me?"

That had to be it. There's no way Cadance would go through all the trouble to make Chrysalis disguise perfect just to help him in the end. But that doesn't mean that Cadance 1 could be the real one or that the real Cadance is Cadance A and is trying to help him out. Their just no pure absolute way of telling and despite how horny he is right now and how much he just wants to give in, fuck one of them, and leave everything to chance. A part of him actually wants to win this game and prove to Cadance that he can tell his own wife apart from a fake. The only question is "How?"

"So, you figure it out?" Shining still mounted on Cadance A turned to look at Cadance 1 when she spoke. "She's trying to trick you Shining I'm the real Cadance!"

"No, I'm the real Cadance!" Cadance A spoke looking back at Shining getting his attention. "I know I made things difficult for you to choose. I know it was too unfair making sure Chrysalis disguise was perfect." Cadance A gave Shining an apologetic look. "But that is why I'm helping you now. Cadance A smiled lightly. "I'm sorry for putting you through this. So just fuck me with that big cock of yours and claim that reward I promise you."

"No Shining; you chose right the first time when you mounted me, and you still have a chance to do so again." Cadance 1 lowered her head and lift her flank up. Shaking her ass in a teasing manner. Her moist pussy on full display. With both hind legs spread apart Shining can clearly, she her mare fluids dripping from her pussy like a waterfall.

"You see this my husband?" Cadance 1 said in a lustful voice. "This is the pussy of the mare you married; this is the pussy you fuck a hundred times over."

Cadance A pull herself from shining grip as she walked forward. Giving the unicorn room to land his forehooves on the ground and stand properly again. She too took on the same pose as Cadance 1 and shook her hips as her pussy also leak like a waterfall. Just the same as Cadance A. Which only once again put the distraught unicorn right back to not being able to tell which is which. Then again, he never left that square in the first place.

Cadance A spoke, in the same lustful tone. "Look Shining. This is the pussy you came inside a hundred times. This is the pussy that gave birth to our daughter. This pussy is yours to do whatever you want to it."

Cadance 1 reach both her forehooves behind her. Each grabbing an ass cheek and spreading them apart. Showing Shining her tight plot hole along with her moist pussy.

"Come to me Shiny!" "SMACK" Cadance 1 slap one of her ass cheeks. "Come and fuck my asshole. Be as rough as you want. You know I can take it." Cadance 1 gave a wicked grin as she turned her head to look back at Shining the best she could in her position. "I can tell you're just as eager." Cadance 1 can clearly see Shining Cock. Still as hard as a rock. His length was bobbing and smacking his belly while leaking large amount of pre-cum on the floor. He was desperate for release. Desperate to fuck one of the Cadance's and cum inside. It was clear his resolve was weakening; and both Cadance's knew it.

"Yeah, so hurry and fuck the real me already." Said Cadance A. As she once again mimics the same pose as Cadance 1. Showing off her sexy assets to Shining Armor. "I need it just as bad as you do Shiny. 'Mmmph.' I can't wait any longer."

"Yes, hurry up and fuck me already!" Cried Cadance 1.

"No, me!" Argue Cadance A.

"Me!"

"Me!"

"Me!"

"Me!"

As both Cadance's argue over who's the real one. Shining stood their confuse at what to do. His head turning from one Cadance to the next and back again each time one of them spoke. It only seems to frustrate the prince further.

Grabbing his head in his fore hooves to stop it from turning. Shining tried to figure out what he should do. But his own arousal and desperate need for release were clouding his mind. But the thought of wanting to succeed in this game kept his head afloat in the sea of lust, that he more than anything wants to let himself drown in.

But which one was the real Cadance? As much as he wants to win, he can't figure it out. Shining was thinking about just throwing caution to the wind and take a leap of faith as he originally tried to do earlier. Just leave everything to chance. He might guess right, or he might guess wrong, but at least he could finally satisfy the aching need to cum inside a hot wet pussy. Shining Armor was goanna go through with his original plan but once again he stops himself.

Shining lowers his fore hooves to the floor and. Sits their quietly.

"NO!" Shining thought to himself; quickly dispelling the idea of randomly choosing. "I can't give in so easily. There must be a way to tell them apart." Shining stared at the two identical twins. Both their glistening wet pussies and tight assholes perfectly exposed to him; waiting for him to shove his big hard cock inside one of them. And as much as Shining wants to do just that he doesn't want to end up choosing Chrysalis and getting punish. But mostly because he's still doesn't trust the changeling queen like everyone else. Yes, Twilight reformed her and she's on good terms with Princess Celestia and Luna; but the thought about being with her all that time around his wedding day still haunts him a little. If he couldn't tell the difference when Chrysalis wasn't even trying to act like the real Cadance, what hope did he have now that she was imitating her so perfectly.

But Shining Armor wasn't going to let what happened in the past get to him any longer. Cadance sure isn't; if she was willing become friends and do all this with the one who kidnap her, imprison her in the canterlot caves, and stole her identity. It shows that his wife put the past behind her, and she now trust the former villain. And if she could do it so, can he. The pain was still there. He'll still need some time to adjust but he will try. Now all he needs to focus on is figuring who is the real Cadance.

"Are you ok Shining?"

Shining Armor snap out of his thoughts when he heard one of the Cadance's speak. Now back into the world of the living. Shining could see both Cadance's had turned their heads back to look at him. Both with concern looks on their faces.

"Haven't you made your choice? Said Cadance A.

"Or are you still unsure? Said Cadance 1.

Shining Armor took a deep breath before answering. "I'm...still unsure!" He said dejectedly. "You two clearly put a lot thought and planning into this." He watches as both Cadance's turned around to face him properly and sit down on their haunches before continuing. "It's obvious enough you two spent a lot of time together preparing and that today's secret royal summit was just to spend time making final preparations for tonight."

Both Cadance's chuckled lightly. "Very observant hubby." Said Cadance 1. With a sly grin.

"But Knowing that isn't going to help you figure out who's the real Cadance." Cadance A. said with her own equally as sly grin.

Shining Armor though still feeling sad that he can't tell who his wife is. Shining remains steadfast and unwavering as much as he could. "Neither were your tests!"

Both Cadance's tilted their heads and quirk an eyebrow before speaking at the same time. "How So?"

Shining knew they were faking ignorance, but he carried on any way. "Earlier you two said I know my wife better than anypony." He sighed. "But this game was rig from the start; Chrysalis disguise is just too perfect. From looks, feel, smell, taste, and knowledge." Shining was slowly losing his composer as he went on. "In the end I had no choice but to choose at random and pray I get lucky." (pun not intended) A new thought cross Shining mind and when it did it scared him. "Infact who's to say that neither one of you is the real Cadance?" Shining stood up and began pacing back and forth. "Sure, one of you could be Chrysalis. But the other could be one of her changelings? Heck maybe both of you are?" Shining stopped his pacing and glared at the two Cadance's suspiciously. "Which means if I chose the drone; they could probably just change into Chrysalis or at the least mimic her voice while still in Cadance form!"

Shining Armor walk away from the two Cadance's and began searching the bedroom. He didn't use magic, but he didn't need to. Twilight thought him how to sense magic when a spell is constantly active. Sadly, it doesn't work on changelings since their ability to shapeshift is natural. This way of sensing magic is used to anonymously detect and not alert if somepony is nearby and/or unseen but is constantly holding up a spell that could allow that pony to spy on others. Say for instance an invisibility spell perhaps?

"Which also means that the real Cadance is hiding somewhere in this room." Shining said as he continued his search. Making sure to check every square inch and leaving no stone unturned. "Cloak behind an invisibility or illusion spell."

Both Cadance's watch with great amusement as the prince check every corner, open every door that wasn't the main one. They almost burst into laughter when he even checks under the bed. But did their best to hold it in.

"COME ON OUT CADANCE; I'M ON TO YOU."

It was getting harder and harder for both Cadance's to stop themselves from laughing out loud. Trying to stifle their laughter with their hooves. It wasn't helping when Shining started checking drawers and other small place the Alicorn clearly couldn't fit into.

"Did you shrink yourself? He questions while looking inside Cadance's jewelry box; before closing it. He then looks up at the high ceiling hoping that she was up there in the air but saw nopony. But that doesn't stop him. "ARE YOU UP THEIR CADANCE. HIDING BEHIND SOME SPELL?" He looks for any signs of change but saw nothing, so he figured he just have to get up there and bring her down himself. He trots over to a big box containing many different things given to him by friends and family over the years. After a little search he took out a box that said "SUCTION CUP HOOVES" on the front. It was a wedding gift from an old friend of his back in Canterlot the two of them made it a tradition too get the other some comical gag gift after all the funny pranks they would pull on each other from time to time. And what can be more hilarious than getting something like this as a wedding present. His friend still got shining a meaningful gift as well; as an honor of their friendship and congratulating him and wishing him good luck with his marriage life.

Now after all this time. This gift will help serve Shining in his mission to find his real wife and "Fuck her silly!" This once useless gift has now become the tool to Shining winning this game. With strong determination he opened the box and took out one of comically large suction cups. He examined it, inspect it. It was self-explanatory on how to put them on. The prince looks up at the ceiling one last time and held up the key to his victory.

"YOU SEE THIS CADANCE. THIS IS THE KEY TO YOUR DOWNFALL AND TO MY RISE TO TRIUMPH. SO, PREPARE YOURSELF MY WIFE; CAUSE AFTER I CATCH YOU, I'M GONNA FUCK YOU SOOO HARD YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO WALK STRAIGHT FOR A MONTH." Shining declared putting on a cocky grin full of self-confidence. "AND WHEN I BEAT YOU AT YOUR OWN GAME. IT WILL BE I WHO WILL HAVE THE LAST LAUGH."

The prince was just about to put on the first suction cup until a large laughter caught his attention. He looks over at the two Cadance's; both of them were laughing hysterically and they were either rolling on the floor holding their sides or banging a fore hoof on floor as they laid there clutching their stomach. Both of their faces were red and tears flooding down their faces as they laugh and laugh and laugh. All the confidence Shining build up began to crumble instantly. Could he be wrong about the real Cadance hiding in the bedroom? He had to make sure.

"HEY. What's so funny?"

Both Cadance's was able to calm themselves from their laughing fit. After which they sat up properly on the haunches and wipe the tears from their eyes.

"Ha ha ha, whoo. That was hilarious. Thanks hubby that was very entertaining. Said Cadance A.

"Yeah, I thought I was going to die from laughter." Said Cadance 1.

Shining drops the suction cup back in its box and closed it. Tossing the gift back in the bigger box and slam it shut. He then trots back over to his original spot and sat before the two Cadance's; wanting answers.

"Ok tell me. Is the real Cadance hiding in this room?"

Both Cadance's answered at once. "NO"

But before either one of them could say anything further Shining interrupted. "Then she must be hiding somewhere else, isn't she? Hmmm. "I didn't sense any active spells, which means she's not using a spell to spy on us. So, she must be using some magical artifact to do it?" Shining took a moment to think. "She could be hiding in the highest tower of the castle using some scrying bowl filled with enchanted water to spy on us with ease."

That caught the real Cadance's interest. But she didn't show it. She actually had plans in the works to get many different mares from her staff to her soldiers, and three mares who wanted a foal to fuck her husband for three days. Keeping him busy while she watches it all from the highest tower of the palace. Using a scrying bowl filled with enchanted water. But that won't happen till a couple months later. Cadance knows Shining was just guessing. He knows about the scrying bowl from a book they read about magical artifacts of the Crystal Empire, last week. What he doesn't know is that Cadance kept its existence hidden from him. She told him it was probably destroyed. And she knows Shining knew this.

One of the Cadance's sighs. "Shining you know the scrying bowl no longer exist. We could never find it, so we assume it was destroyed."

The second Cadance spoke. "So how can I spy on you with something I don't even have?"

Shining lowered his head in shame he knew about the bowl being just missing or destroyed as he and Cadance agreed on.

Shining raises his head to speak. "you're right but that doesn't mean there aren't other ways, other artifacts that could do the job."

"Shining?" Cadance A. Spoke up. "Lets us make this perfectly clear." Clears her throat. "Though we admit your theories are sound."

Cadance 1 speaks. "They are false. One of us IS the real Cadance." Cadance 1 gestured between herself and her twin.

"So, no Shining, we are not trying to deceive you. Only one of us is a changeling, and the real Cadance is sitting right here in front you. Not hiding behind some spell or spying on you from afar." Cadance A said assumingly.

"And if you still doubt us. We'll prove to you that we're telling the truth." Said Cadance 1

Both Cadance's look at each other with a serious stern look their faces. They nodded to each other in silent agreement before turning to face Shining Armor once more. They then proceeded to speak perfectly at the same time.

"Shining Armor; we PINKIE PROMISE YOU that one of us is in fact the real Cadance and the other is Chrysalis. Cross our hearts, hope to fly, stick a cupcake in our eye." Both Cadance's went through motions in perfect synch.

Shining Armor knows all about the famous pinkie promise. Both him and Cadance learned about it from Pinkie pie herself, the day they were going to tell Twilight they were having a baby and Pinkie found out about it by accident. They also learned how very important it is to never break a Pinkie promise. When Shining asks Pinkie at the party, did anypony ever broke a Pinkie promise before and what happens when you do? The whole room went quiet. Shining and Cadance could feel the fear radiating from Twilight and the rest of her friends. The tension in the room only grew thicker as the silence continued. It only got worse when Pinkie spoke. Her hair was completely flat, her eyes narrowed, staring at the soon to be parents with a look that could literally kill anyone weak will enough. When she spoke; she spoke in a tone that sent shivers down the married couple spines.

"When somepony makes a pinkie promise, I can tell if you break it from my Pinkie sense. My Mane and tail will go flat; like you see now, out of nowhere. Even when I'm at my happiest. It doesn't matter where in the world you are. I will literally be there the INSTANT YOU BREAK SUCH SACRED PROMISE AND YOU WILL BE SEVERELY PUNISH BY-" Pinkie slowly put on a wicked smile. One would say she look like a derange serial killer. “-helping me bake.....Cupcakes.”

Shining and Cadance were confused. Baking cupcakes? That's the punishment? But one look at the others scared faces tells them that there's more to it than meets the eye. When Cadance asks what Pinkie meant by 'baking cupcakes' Rainbow Dash was the one to speak.

RD stared at the two-royal couple with a serious look. Showing them that her words should not be taken lightly. "Trust me when I say you do not want to know. But if you ever decide to use the Pinkie promise. Make sure you are able to keep it 120% or else you will suffer the consequences."

Everypony else nodded in agreement and Cadance and Shining learned to never take something like the pinkie promise for granted. So, If Cadance and Chrysalis are using the promise to prove they're not trying to pull a fast one on him and that their no sign of Pinkie pie popping out of nowhere and dragging the both of them away to a kitchen deep in the lowest depths of Tartarus to bake cupcakes. Was more than enough for him to believe them. Which mean he was back to square one.

"I believe you." Shining said sadly.

"Good. Now that little detour is over." said Cadance A

"Are you ready to choose or do you need another-" Cadance 1 slowly lick her lips. "-Test."

Both Cadance's smirk at Shining giving him sultry looks. Shining didn't know what to do anymore those theories were his last hope. But they were both proven wrong. He made no progress in figuring out who's the real Cadance, and whatever test they have plan next will no doubt be as useless as the other, not giving him any idea or clue on who's who. Shining look at each Cadance with a sadden look and hung his head in defeat.

"I....c-can't do it. I can't tell you two apart." His own words wound Shining deeply. Not being able to tell which one his wife has only reminded him of his failure to tell back at the wedding.

Both Cadance's took a side glance at each other before turning their gaze back at the distraught Unicorn.

"So, are you giving up?" Asked Cadance A.

Cadance 1 sighed shaking her head disappointedly. "Such a shame. I can't believe you couldn't tell who your own wife is."

Shining Armor fell to the floor. Laying on his stomach with forelegs covering his head. He looks like a sad mess. The thought about failing to tell which Cadence was the real one. Brought back the horrid memories of the Royal Canterlot Wedding. While Cadance was trap in caves deep within Canterlot mountain. Shining was spending time with a fake; he even had sex with Chrysalis multiple times before the wedding all while being none the wiser that she wasn't acting like Cadance at all. Twilight was able to see something was wrong during the first meeting; and Shining hadn't noticed once.

But how can he tell they were both perfectly Identical. Not a single hair out of place. Cadance plan ahead and told chrysalis all their secrets just in case he asks questions. So how is it possible for him to tell at all.

But even when Shining was at the verge of giving up. His mind still continued to try and solve this riddle. "Think Armor Think." There had to be away to tell them apart, there had to be something there that he's not seeing, there had to be a flaw somewhere; but where? Both of them are perfect identical twins in every way. They look the same, feel the same, taste, smell, knowledge, even the way they give fellatio are the same. Cadance and Chrysalis were very thorough when preparing for this; leaving no room for error. Chrysalis was able to mimic Cadance down to the very last detail.......

"Wait?" Shining thought to himself. "Cadance put a lot of work into making sure that Chrysalis disguise was perfect.... But only on the SURFACE." The new revelation hit Shining like a train. His confidence growing more and more the more he thought about it. He thought back to the days before his wedding. Even though he was brainwash at the time. He stills remembers the color of chrysalis magic aura around her horn was always green.

When Cadance’s aura is always light blue.

Chrysalis can't change the color of her aura when disguise as a unicorn or alicorn. Her aura will always remain green no matter what. So, in other words, Chrysalis disguise isn't 100% perfect. It doesn't matter how perfect they made her disguise. They can't change what's on the inside. Such as the core, the soul, a person's natural essence.

Of course, Shining remembered when he first tried to use magic earlier to figure out which is which, but they stop him and said “no magic” but now he can see that rule goes both ways. Neither of the two Cadances are going to use their magic either, because Chrysalis aura will always be green.

So, to win he needs to flip this around. Instead of focusing on the things Chrysalis can mimic, he should focus on the ones she can't. He knows he can't ask them to activate their magic. They'll just refuse for obvious reasons. So, Shining needs to think of an alternative. What else could he use that Chrysalis can't copy.

“Oh, surely it can't be that difficult.” “You know your wife better than anypony, right?”

"THAT'S IT!!!!" The second the thought came to his mind he regains his composures. He stood on all four hooves, straighten himself up and went into Captain of the Royal guard mode and spoke as if he was addressing his troops.

"I know what I have to do." He said in stern strong voice. "I know how settle this once and for all. I just need to subject you two in one. Final. Test." Shining Armor Declared.

Both Cadance's were surprised at Shining newfound confidence. They were both confused and intrigued at the same time. Interested to know what exactly Shining was planning.

"Oh, and what is this test of yours? Hmmm." Said Cadance A.

Shining Armor remain in Captain of the Royal Guard mode. Not showing any emotions and showing no signs of body language. The only things on him that move was his mouth when he spoke and his still hard cock bobbing up and down; and even that wasn't enough to tell the two Cadance's what shining was feeling. They know he's horny, but his unreadable face doesn't show it.

"It's a simple test. I will sit in front of one you and the two of us are going to have a little staring contest. Blinking is aloud; just make sure you keep constant eye contact in between. We will do this for 30 seconds after which the second Cadance will take her turn." Shining pause for a moment giving the Cadance's time to process the rules. "And after me and the second Cadance time is up, you two will turn around, present yourselves, and I will make my choice and fuck the real Cadance."

That declaration shock both Cadance's and not in a bad way. The two alicorns stared at Shining for a moment. Then they look at each other and back at Shining again. After taking the time process what the white unicorn said Cadance A spoke first.

"Hmmm. Sounds simple enough. But if you don't mind me asking, Shiny dear. What exactly are you looking for in this little test of yours?"

Cadance 1 speaks. "I hope you're not looking to see if one of our eyes flash greens?" Cadance 1 lightly chuckles. "Do you really believe that's going to happen." Cadance 1 shakes her head disappointedly. "Tsk tsk tsk sound like a waste of time."

Shining Armor still held his ground and didn't let Cadance 1 words affect him in the slightest. As he stood their unmoving, face unexpressive. He knew in is heart that this is the only way to win this game. Well, there was one idea that came to mind. Everypony knows that even when disguised all changelings bleed green blood. They simply cannot change the color of their own blood no matter what. And something tells Shining that these two won't agree to a blood test the same as they would a magic one. So, the staring contest is his only option.

"This test is what I want to do and nothing else." Shining said sternly. "We wasted enough time messing around and I know you two are just as eager to put an end to this." Shining raises an eyebrow. "Or is it you're afraid you'll lose after all the planning and preparation."

That hit the mark. Both Cadances flinch at the accusations. Shining was turning the tables on them. He got them in the same bind they had him in when they started this game.

"DAMN THAT STALLION! Thinking with his brain instead of his cock."

Both Cadances look at each other and nodded in Silent agreement.

"Ok hubby we agree to your test." Said Cadance 1

"So, let's get started already." Said Cadance A

Shining Armor simply nodded. He walked up Cadance A and sat down on his haunches in front of her and closed his eyes. Quickly figuring out why he closes his eyes; Cadance A did the same.

"Cadance 1. Would you mind doing the count down for us?" Shining asked.

"No problem." Said Cadance 1 "Ok when I say I go you will both open your eyes, and I will then start the count down from 30....Are you both ready?"

"Ready!" Answered Cadance A

"Ready!" Answered Shining Armor.

"Ok. On your marks. Get set.....GO!"

Shining and Cadance A open their eyes and began staring deep into the others, as Cadance began the countdown. They both just sat their staring. Cadance A would blink while Shining wouldn't blink at all. Years of royal guard training on how to stand like a statue was paying off.

As Cadance 1 got closer and closer to the end of her countdown. Shining still showed no signs of even the slightest hint of movement. As he remains completely unreadable. Thus, Cadance A can't tell if Shining Armor knows she the real Cadance or not; or if he still can't tell at all.

10 seconds left.

Still no change as the two royals stared each other down. Remaining stoic all the way to the end.

"ZERO. Times up."

It was finally over, at least for Cadance A. Now it was Cadance 1 turn. Shining stood and moved to sit in front of Cadance 1. Once settled he closed his eyes and Cadance 1 did the same.

Second verse same as the first. Cadance A took over as the count downer. She asks if the two of them were ready. They both said yes. The second they heard Cadance A yell GO, Both Cadance 1 and Shining Armor open their eyes and began their 30 seconds staring contest.

It was just the same as with Cadance A. The prince remains perfectly still and unreadable as before. Giving not even the slightest hint of what he was thinking. The 30 seconds came and went. Shining still kept his expressions completely neutral even when he spoke.

"It's time! I'm ready to make my choice."

This was it the final confrontation. Both Cadances have no clue what Shining was looking for or even if he found it or not, but that hardly matters right now. What matters is the 'choice' will he choose wrong, or right is all up to him.

Both Cadances stood a good little distance in front of Shining Armor. Standing side by side they turn around move their tails showing off their pussies to him once more.

"Once again Shiny...am I the real Cadance?" Both Alicorns look back at Shining. "Or am I?"

Even with his neutral face the sight of Shining Big, hard, throbbing cock, standing up in all its majesty, was enough to tell the mares how horny he is. It made both their pussy wet at just the sight alone and thought of that big pillar of flesh pounding them only made them wetter.

Shining Armor stood up and walk slowly towards the two Cadances. Each hoof step growing louder as he drew in closer, making the two Cadances writhe with anticipation. The clopping stop Shining was now within range. He glances at the Cadance on his left, then glance at the Cadance on his right. He stood behind one of them but did not mount her; instead, he sat on his haunches, grab both her flanks in his hooves and buried his muzzle in her soaking wet cunt.

The alicorn yelp in surprise at the sudden attack on her nethers. Moaning lustfully as shining begins to eat her out. The alicorn pussy wink rapidly as Shining toung dive deeper into her snatch, licking every crevice inside her moist cave before moving to her clit, sucking on it.

The first Cadance was on cloud nine as Shining Armor pleasured her. At first, she thought he had chosen her or at least was going to. When Shining stop, she got ready for him to mount her, but the loud moans of the second Cadance indicated that wasn't the case.

Shining was now eating out the second Princess of love. Giving her just as much pleasure as the first. Before pulling away, his muzzle once again coated with the fluids of the twins.

Shining wipe away as much mare fluids from his muzzle as he could. The two Cadance's let out more than they did before. But the fore play was over, it was now time for the main course. Shining watch for a moment longer as the two princesses pant heavily from the oral, he given them. He left them both on the edge of ecstasy and could see how desperate they both were from how much their pussies continued to wink. No reason to keep them waiting it was time to end this game.

Shining mounted one of the Cadance's. Once again feeling the heat of the wet pussy as the tip of his cock press against her cunt ready to penetrate.

“Are you sure, Honey?” The other Cadance words froze him for a moment.

Shining stops his advancement and glance over at the other Cadance. He saw the raised eyebrows, the slight hint of disapproval her expressions silently telling him he was about to make the wrong choice and that she was in fact the real Cadance. Shining stared into the other Cadance eyes for a moment after which for the first time in a while he dropped his neutral face and put on a sincere smile and said.

"Yes Chrysalis, I'm sure." and with those last words Shining penetrated Cadance A.

Without hesitation, he humped his hips forward in a well-practiced motion, shoving his tip into Cadance's hot, wet pussy. Goddess, she felt wonderful! He took more and more of her, moving up on her back as his shaft slid in deeper under her tail. Her pussy clenched around him, begging for more, and he gave her all of it, hilting deep inside.

"Congratulations, Shining Armor you have chosen wisely!" In a flash of green flames Cadance 1 reveal herself to be The Queen of The Changelings. Chrysalis sat on her haunches and applauded The Crystal Prince as she watches him fuck Cadance like crazy, clapping her hooves together as she does.

"Y-y-yeah, 'mmmmh' y-you really, 'OH FUCK YES,' earned your reward. OOOOHHHHH SWEET CELESTIA, GIVE IT TOO ME HARDER BABY!!!!"

Shining Armor was overjoyed with himself. He did it, he actually did it. He chose the right Cadance and won the game; he could only Imagine what his reward could be for accomplishing such a feat without blindly guessing or falling for Chrysalis trick at the end. But he'll worry about the reward later, right now he just wants to enjoy fucking the mare he loves.

Shining thrusted into Cadance with everything he had making sure to fuck her silly like she wanted. Cadance pussy sliding over his cock was working its hot, wet magic as it always had. He was getting close again, and Cadance squeaked with his every jerky thrust as his flare grew inside her.

Cadance shuddered, pushing herself back against him as a huge orgasm thundered through her. She cried out to the ceiling and clamped down hard on Shining's cock. The lips of her pussy pulsed open again and again around the thick base of his shaft, begging for what was to come.

And it did come. Shining gripped her hard as his own orgasm broke over him. He pressed his head against her neck as his cock throbbed streams of cum deep inside his wife. Some splashed out against his crotch and between her legs, and yet he still came more, pumping everything he had into Cadance, womb. Despite Chrysalis watching them Shining didn't hesitate as he trembled and unloaded his heavy balls into the princess of love.

Finally, the orgasmic wave receded, and the last few spurts dribbled out. He pulled out of her on weak legs and nearly fell to the messy floor when his knees buckled for a moment. Both of them panted in place for a moment, slowly recovering themselves.

Exhausted, Shining Armor collapsed back onto the bed, sitting down in the same place the two of them had given him a double blowjob. There was a little cold wetness in the spot from where their spit had dripped down, but he was beyond caring about that at the moment.

Chrysalis stood in front of him, grinning. He glanced over and saw Cadance still standing where he'd left her – her head drooped down, and her sides heaved as a thick stream of white cum slowly oozed out of her pink pussy. He glances back at the changeling queen and said.

"So....what did I win?"

Chrysalis chuckled. "All in due time, Prince Armor. Thats something your wife have to set up." Chrysalis glance over at the pony in question still a bit daze from her rough pounding before turning her attention back to Shining. "Now talk, how were you able tell us apart? And what was the purpose behind your staring contest test?"

"Yeah!" Cadance was able to recover herself and join the conversation sitting next to Chrysalis. "I set up this whole thing, so you only have 50/50 chance of guessing right. Me and Chrissy spent months preparing for this night making sure every detail on her disguise was absolutely perfect." Cadance stomps a hoof. "So how were you able to tell us apart by a silly staring contest?"

Shining chuckle at Cadance question. He understands Chrysalis not figuring it out, but Cadance shouldn't have no trouble at all. I mean she is the princess of love after all. Something like this should be a no brainer for her. Shining figure that her mind was solely on the game that she didn't notice when the two of them had their staring contest, and after everything that happen tonight, he couldn't blame her.

Shining took deep breath and exhale before speaking.

"I'm actually surprised Cadance that you haven't figured it out yourself."

Cadance raised an eyebrow. Clearly confused at Shining accusation.

Shining sighed. "I simply change my focus."

Cadance and Chrysalis took a quick side glance at one another and look back at Shining.

"What do you mean change your focus?" Asked Chrysalis.

"The tests you two gave me even the question test I gave; only showed how Chrysalis was able to imitate Cadance perfectly. So, after making a complete fool of myself and thanks to my determination to prove that I can tell which one of you is the real Cadance, I was able figure out that instead of focusing on the things Chrysalis can mimic I should focus on the things she can't. In other words, as perfect as Chrysalis disguise was, she couldn't copy who Cadance is at her core."

"I see now! you were focusing on what was on the inside? not the outside? clever boy." Praised Chrysalis.

"So how did your final test help you figure out which was the real me?" Asked Cadance.

"Think back to when you and I stared into each other eyes." Shining climb off the bed and sat before Cadance; he took one of her fore hooves in one of his whiles slowly and lovingly stroking it with the other as he looks deep into Cadance eyes. "I know you saw it too. It wouldn't be the first time either. From when we first met, through all our dates, and definitely at our wedding saying our vows."

Cadance stares into her husband eyes and it didn't take long for her to figure out what he was saying and how he was able tell that she was the one true Cadance.

"The spark" Cadance said "The spark of true love. A glimmer of light that only be seen in each other eyes if the two ponies are soulmates." The realization surprised Cadance and touch her heart deeply as she is reminded once again why her, and Shining were always meant to be.

No wonder why Shining was able to tell that she was the real Cadance. Only if the love is true can the two lovers see spark in each other eyes. Chrysalis wouldn't be able to fit those criteria. She may like Shining band Shining might like her now but there's no true love there at all. So, when Shining stared into Chrysalis eyes, he wouldn't see anything.

It's like Shining said he focus on the thing Chrysalis can't imitate. She can copy in many ways that she can make a very convincing fake but despite how perfect her disguise is on the surface she can't copy what truly matters on the inside. 'The soul' and after all the eyes are the windows to one's soul.

"And you were right Cady it wasn't difficult; after all." Shining pull Cadance in closer. "Who else know my wife better than me?"

"Oh Shining!" Cadance closes the gap between her and Shining and the two shared a loving kiss. But their moment of romance was soon interrupted by Chrysalis laughter.

The royal couple broke the kiss, separated from each other grasp and look at the laughing changeling.

"What's so funny Chrissy." Cadance said annoyingly.

"He he he, I'm sorry Cady, it's just; even though Shining solution to win the game was smart it was also CHEESY. HAHAHA."

Shining Armor blush in slight embarrassment after what Chrysalis had said. Putting some thought into it his plan to win was cheesy but it still helps him in the end and that all that matters.

"Ok ok that's enough of that." Said Cadance. Chrysalis stop her laughing and calm herself. "Now that game is over and you won, you probably want to know what your reward is hmmm."

Shining nodded

"Well, I can't give you your reward right now, I need time to prepare it but trust me." Cadance leans in close to Shining ear. "It will be worth the wait." She whispered. Causing Shining too shudder in anticipation.

"Quick question. What was my punishment if I had chosen wrong?" Shining asked.

Cadance and Chrysalis smiled wickedly at the stallion filling him with fear.

"If you had chosen wrong. The second you buried your cock deep inside Chrissy. I would get behind you and spank your ass over and over again, making you fuck her till you cum inside her."

"That doesn't sound so bad."

"Ah ah ah, that's not all. After you're done fucking me, I would transform into a tall, muscular, Stallion version of your sister with a big cock to match. You will suck me off getting my dick nice and wet and ready to pound your ass. Thus, giving you that threesome you always wanted."

Shining gulp. Yes, he wants a threesome with his wife and his sister and yes, he wants Twilight to fuck him in the ass with a cock of her own, but he per for her as a mare with a cock not a stallion.

"He he he, looks like I dodge the bullet there." Shining said nervously.

"That you have my love. Now I should go ahead and start preparations for your reward, you and Chrysalis can fuck while I do that, and I'll join you two right after."

Cadance walks over to her writing desk and sat in her chair using her magic she levitated a pen and parchment on to the desk and began writing a letter.

Shining watch as Cadance walks to her desk, he wanted to say something regarding what she said about fucking but the sound of someone climbing on to his bed and Chrysalis lustful voice drew his attention. Chrysalis was on his and Cadance bed. Her head down, ass up, and wet pussy that was ready to be fuck.

"mmmmm, come to me Shiny, come and fuck me." Chrysalis hiss. "Don't let Cadance have all the fun, I want your dick too."

Shining gulp. He had no reason to refuse, the game was over he didn't have worry about being punish and Cadance gave her consent for him to go ahead and enjoy himself. So that's exactly what he did. Without hesitating Shining join Chrysalis on the bed. He could see that Chrysalis was more than wet enough so no need for foreplay. So, he mounted her line his hard cock with her pussy and began to rut changeling queen.

~
Cadance could hear her husband and friend going at it like wild animals behind her and it made her happy that shining was able to get over his issues with Chrysalis. She could see the three of them getting along just fine. After a few minutes Cadance finish her letter. She rolled it up tied a ribbon around it and in a flash a magic of sent the letter off to its destination. "Now all we have to do is wait for her response." Cadance thought. She then turns her attention to her bed deciding to simply watch Shining and Chrysalis before joining them.

Ponyville, Twilight Castle.

Twilight was in her library, just relaxing on her couch reading the new issue of Daring Do. Her reading was interrupted when a scroll appeared above her a fell on her head. "Hey!" The scroll bounces off Twilight head and landed on the floor. Using her magic, she levitated it up to herself, she examines the ribbon recognizing its markings on it. "It's from Cadance!" Twilight quickly removed the ribbon and unfurled the letter and began to read it.

When Twilight finish reading the letter, she felt as if her heart was going to burst out her chest from the excitement she felt welling up inside her. Twilight squeed in excitement she teleported to her bedroom. Where she wrote and sent a reply letter back to Cadance. Minutes later she gets another letter telling her to come to the crystal empire.

Twilight smiled.