Starlight Glimmer Nearly Doesn't Get All The Mares

Ellie could sense something was up.

“You know, Maud, I know you wear that thing all the time. You don’t have to anything you’re uncomfortable with…“

“Oh, no. It’s just that…” Maud turned her eyes to look at Ellie and Starlight. “Growing up, I knew that I was… different than my sisters. I didn’t like feeling different, so I started wearing my frock so I could forget.”

The gears turned in Ellie’s head.

“I felt better about being different when I grew up. But by then I was used to always wearing it.“

Maud undid the belt of her frock of her teeth, then grabbed the collar with her teeth and pulled it forward, stepping backwards out of it. She sat down, naked.

It did not surprise Ellie at all to see what Maud meant. It surprised her a little just how adorable the effect was, the stiffness of her erection contrasting with the soft curve of her belly and the expressionless look on her face.

It also surprised Ellie that she was seeing Maud naked. It was somehow very arousing just by itself, in a way that seeing Rarity naked, or really any other pony naked, was not.

Maud spoke.

“Since you’re both marelovers, I also didn’t know how you would react.”

There was a slight pause. Starlight smiled, then laughed kindly.

“I wouldn’t worry about it, Maud. Back in my village, there was a unicorn mare like you, and trust me, she received an equal amount of attention from us.” Starlight paused. “Wait. I just realized that there may have been some pretty major consent issues with what we all did back then…”

“Let’s, uh, put a pin in that!” Ellie interjected. “Processing later. We’re here, on Maud’s bed. Just the four of us. All of us consenting adults.” She glanced over to the form of Trixie, who was lying down on the other side of the bed, fast asleep. “Okay, that only applies to those of us who are awake. But for the rest of us, I guess I can’t…” Ellie sighed. “Uh, do we have to do, like, a check-in?—”

“No, I think we’re fine,” assured Starlight. “You’re right, we can put a pin in that.” She patted Ellie’s hand. Maud turned to Ellie.

“Well, how about you, Ellie? How do marelovers on your world react to mares like me?”

Ellie’s eyes widened. “Oh, no. Nononononono, I am not talking about that.” Ellie shuddered at the thought. Damn it. Two bombs to defuse in a row?

She composed herself. “I can only speak for myself.” She sighed, then smiled. “What I see in front of me is a breathtakingly beautiful mare. With a beautiful clit.”

Maud smiled slightly. She really was breathtakingly beautiful.

Her clit was, too. A perfect, slightly-curved cylinder of smooth, dark-grey flesh, with one adorable ring in the middle and another around the tip. The proportions and overall effect were just… cute in a very similar way to how pony vulvas were. And just like pony vulvas…

Ellie’s mouth watered. She looked up at Maud.

“May I?”

Maud smiled slightly, and made a small noise of assent. She was so good with her words.

Ellie tentatively wrapped the tip of Maud’s clit with her lips, tasting her head with her tongue. She felt so nice and warm in her mouth. She sucked as she moved her lips downward, towards her medial ring. She closed her eyes to enjoy the sensation of her mouth being filled.

She’d never gotten the appeal of sucking a strap-on. But some of her past partners had been so into doing it that Ellie felt bad not playing along, even though she could only feel the shadows of the movements on her clit. She couldn’t imagine what it was in it for them, feeling nothing but dead plastic and rubber. But this. The warmth and softness of pony flesh against her tongue… The thought of Maud enjoying the feeling of her tonguestrokes and the softness of her lips…

“This feels good.” Maud said in her characteristic monotone.

Ellie took her out of her mouth to giggle. It was the highest of compliments, coming from her. She gave her a kiss, right on the medial ring, and Maud let out a slight moan.

“So, uh.” Ellie surprised herself with how nervously excited she was. “Do you want to try my… other side?”

“I would enjoy that.”

Maud got up on her legs and walked off the edge of the bed. Ellie watched, mesmerized, as her erect clit swayed in the air.

“Sorry if I’m not any good at this! It—” Ellie laughed as she turned to face her, seated on the edge of the bed. “It’s my first time doing this kind of thing.”

Maud gave a slight, reassuring smile.

“You’ll be fine.”

Ellie spread her legs, feeling a slight chill from the air as it evaporated her liquids. Maud planted her forehooves on either side of her hips, getting into position. Ellie bit her lower lip as the head of Maud’s clit brushed against her lower lips. Maud adjusted herself into position, then pushed.

“Oof,” she said, as Maud entered her. It was a very novel sensation. Maud probing her deeper than any set of fingers had ever gone. The sensation of suction as she both pushed in and pulled out.

At this point, she was very glad that pony torsos were so tiny and cute. If Maud had been Ellie’s size, and everything had scaled up proportionately, she would certainly not be having the good time she was.

She settled into the feeling, meditating on the fact that for every sensation she was feeling from Maud’s thrusts, Maud was feeling the corresponding one on the other side. It felt like a connection between their two cores of being. Maybe the straights were onto something…

No, she corrected herself. There was nothing straight about this. Staring into those lovely eyes, half-covered by those beautiful eyelids. The warm curve of her muzzle. The softness of her exhales. The adorable little pony breasts above the base of her clit trembling at the brake of every thrust.

No, this was the original. The clumsy machinations of the straights could imitate aspects of its form, but would never amount to anything more than a pale shadow of this pure, giving lovemaking, this perfect union that could only occur between two women.

Er, a woman and a mare. Yes, right, because she was having sex with a talking horse right now! How could she forget. It was so good, though…

Then, a new sensation. Ellie looked down with delight to see that her clit was being bathed in a teal aura, with an excited Starlight next to her looking on in fascination. Ellie moaned in appreciation. Starlight was good, projecting the sensation of a very skillful tongue working all around the base of her clit. Feeling that at the same time as Maud’s smooth thrusts inside her… Yes. She would have lived her whole entire life and died back in the human world without experiencing anything quite like this. Such narrowly avoided tragedy.

Ellie laughed as she moaned, the two sensations fighting with each other. What would the Ellie of a few months ago have thought if she were watching? Which of the many, many aspects of this would she have found the strangest? She never would have thought!

Yes, she never would have thought of a lot of things, actually. In her decade of being sexually active, there were quite a few things she had never had to think about, weren’t there?

Oh, no.

“Nope!” she yelled suddenly, and scrambled backwards. Starlight’s aura dissipated in surprise, and Maud was left thrusting into the open space between them, her breasts doing one final bounce. When she saw Maud’s concerned expression, Ellie immediately regretted the way she had disengaged.

“Are you okay, Ellie? Did I do something wrong?”

“Oh, no, no, no! You didn’t do anything wrong!” Ellie assured in a panic. “You did nothing wrong so much that the history books will say ‘Maud Pie did nothing wrong’.” She got forward on her elbows towards the edge of the bed, and planted soft, reassuring kisses on the tip of Maud’s erect clit. She then looked up at Maud.

“I just realized something I hadn’t considered, is all.“

“Oh.” Maud said. “Did you not like it?” She sounded confused.

“No, I loved it,” Ellie reassured her, and kissed her clit one more time for good measure. “I just, uh…” She couldn’t help but laugh, the situation was so absurd. “I was, uh, just worried about something. That you were about to… finish.”

“Oh.” Maud blinked. “I wasn’t close to finishing. But you should have been able to tell when I was.”

Ellie didn’t quite understand what she meant, either. This is what she got for being a weirdo who’s into another species. Damn it, Ellie! Did she really have to say it?

“I, uh, was afraid that if you somehow did that I’d get, like… pregnant? I mean, that’s silly, I know. Like, who knows if that would even work! Since we’re two different… y’know. But, uh, that kinda made me want to take that chance even less…”

“Oh.” Maud blinked.

“Yeah! And I, uh, am probably on the edge of the window right now? Ugh, sorry, I’ve never had a reason to pay attention to this.”

Maud blinked. “You’re saying that humans can get pregnant even when they don’t want to?”

“Oh, right. Yeah!” Ellie laughed nervously. “You would have no reason to know that, huh?”

“That’s a silly way to do things.” Maud blinked. “It could really cause some problems.”

“Oh, you have no idea…” Ellie trailed off.

“Well. I’m glad you were careful. If you had my foal, that would really affect Mudbriar and my relationship. I wouldn’t want to do that to him.”

“Yeah, I imagine it would…” Ellie said nervously, desperate to move on from this topic. “But I just wanted you to know that I really liked what we were doing. Really. Really really.”

She reached over to kiss Maud’s clit again, which was softening rapidly.

“Ellie…” Maud sighed. “I don’t know how to say this. I like your normal, weird self. But you’re not being that now. You’re acting different.”

“Oh, I’m so sorry, I didn’t mean to act any different—“

“That’s exactly what I’m talking about.” Maud sighed again. “You don’t normally talk like that. It’s like you’re trying to reassure be about something, but I can’t figure out what.”

“Oh.” Ellie blinked. “You… can’t?”

“No. It seemed… It seemed like you thought that I was afraid of something.”

“Oh.” The gears turned in Ellie’s head. “Um. When you took off your frock for us, what was the worst reaction you imagined, exactly?”

“That you and Starlight wouldn’t be interested in doing things with that part of me. But I don’t think I could call that reaction ‘bad’. We would’ve just kept doing what we were doing before, and I was enjoying that.”

“Oh.” Ellie blinked. “I just thought that with all the explanation before… That you were nervous about revealing something…”

“I just wanted to explain why I wore my frock all the time.” Maud blinked. “Did it sound like I was nervous?”

“Oh.” Ellie supposed that it didn’t sound any different from any other sentence Maud had ever said.

“What would a ‘bad’ reaction even be?”

Ellie teared up.

“That is so… beautiful…”

She hugged Maud, and cried happily.

“I’m just so happy for you, and I know you’ll have no idea why, and that makes it even better!”

Maud patted Ellie on the back with a forehoof, confused. “Is this one of those—”

“Weird human things that I don’t want to talk about, yeah.” Ellie sniffled. “Please, just ignore all of this.”

She continued to hug Maud and happy-cry. Maud exchanged concerned glances with Starlight.

“I’m sorry!” Ellie sniffed loudly as she finally recovered from the cry. “I’m sorry if I made things weird and ruined the mood.” She glanced down sadly at Maud’s now completely-flaccid clit, then looked at Maud. “I understand if I weirded you out too much…”

Maud looked at her. “I’m starting to get the feeling that you’re not just different from other ponies, but different from other humans, too.”

“Yeah.” Ellie said, smiling. “I am.”

Maud smiled. “I like that.”

She leaned over to kiss Ellie. Ellie’s eyelids fluttered as she kissed back. At the same time, she felt Starlight’s reassuring muzzle on the back of her neck as the unicorn planted comforting kisses. She felt so at peace. So held.

Smiling serenely, she turned around to give Starlight a kiss of thanks before turning back to Maud. She looked down with satisfaction to see that Maud’s clit was stirring. She looked up at Maud, who smiled and nodded.

She began stroking Maud’s clit with her fingers and tongue until she stiffened and lengthened enough to pop into her mouth. She continued to stroke the bottom of Maud’s clit with her tongue. The way Maud expanded to fill her mouth felt amazing.

She began moving her lips up and down her shaft, running her tongue along Maud’s length as she did so. Maud shifted some of her weight to her forelegs on either side of Ellie’s back and began thrusting gently. Ellie matched her rhythms, moaning.

Maud was moaning as well, low and slow at first, but slowly getting higher and quicker as Ellie continued. She could feel a trickle of some thin liquid begin to coat her lips, which just confused her, lacking the relevant experience. A bit late in the process for the lube to come out, wasn’t it? Shouldn’t that have happened at the beginning? And that wasn’t the only change. Yes. She wasn’t imagining it. The ring around the tip was definitely fitting much tighter in her mouth now than when she had started. Wait. Oh. So that’s what Maud meant…

“I’m coming.” Maud announced.

Maud came. Ellie felt the pony’s clit pulse against her lips and tongue as she filled her mouth with her payload. She took delight in the sensation.

Her favorite lassi flavor had always been salt, taken with no sugar. Just a random, unrelated fact.

Grinning elatedly, she gratefully swallowed the mouthful of pony cum. The part of her that had been on the Internet too much had a thought to share with all of us.

Ellie says trans rights.