Flitter's been having a toothache recently, but all the dentists in Cloudsdale are closed for the holidays. That's when she goes to Canterlot and runs into Minuette, who's a little too excited about her job.

Once Minuette finds out that Flitter has no plans for Hearth's Warming Eve, though, she makes it her mission to intervene. Will this end up being the best night ever or the worst? Is it better to take a leap of faith or forever wonder, "What if...?"