Your Hearth's Warming Herd.

by Neutral Boy

Rating: teen
Tags: Sex, Power Ponies, Sunset Shimmer, Anthro, Slice of Life, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Sad, Romance, Original Character, Trixie, Second Person, Starlight Glimmer
Length: 5039

You thought you would get some peace at the hospital when Hearth's Warming closes in, but yet you never consider of some beautiful mares visiting you. Even if you rather be alone than being with any pony else, these mares can help change your mind.

Ever since arriving in Equestria, you, a local male human in Maretropolis, had some hard time of adjusting among every pony while sometimes having restless sleeps and headaches. After getting into an accident, you wound up in a pony hospital where you can spend a few weeks of peace and quiet. Although, what you didn't realize that there would be some "friendly visitors" checking in on you every day before the snowy winter of Hearth's Warming Eve starts.

Published 2020-12-25 16:00:01 UTC
Last updated 2021-10-05 23:19:38 UTC

From hermit to a chance of love and holiday herd.

You know, it's a funny thing. Being a lonely worker and don't want any more troubles.

Yet now here you are, looking out the hospital window of snows starting to descend upon the surface.

Especially some nice gifts you got from the visitors, which you don't know why exactly they got you gifts to make you feel better when you leave the hospital soon.

Months ago, it all started back when you popped into another world filled with anthropomorphic sentients.

You didn't know on how exactly, but you guess that someone put something inside your meal.

Needless to say, you shrug the theory off and go ask around in a city close by from here.

Upon hours & hours of searching and talking, you eventually landed a decent job for delivering packages. Not that you minded for paper money since this strange world accept only bits than easily burned paper.

In the passing days of earning bits and renting a place to stay, you began to sometimes have restless sleeps and certain headaches. You tried to use anything like meditating or taking pills, but somehow it wasn't enough help.

On your working day however, that's when you encounter some super hero pony mares fighting off against some criminals and other powerful enemies. At first you didn't like this type of city having heroes vs villains, but soon found it more entertaining than watching the ones back in your own world.

In a few times, you merely help the hero mares in their struggle by casually tossing certain items with written words in the shadows where nobody can see you.

When the next few weeks passed by, you haven't notice that you were being watched by both sides.

On your daily routines, you would get out of your rent place and walk to several places, unaware that the hero mares were dressed in different disguises would sneakily follow you around. You had a sudden feeling that someone is following you, but only ignored it since you haven't caused any troubles yet.

Buying a newspaper from the stand, you found the names of the heroes calling themselves the Power Ponies. Each of them are called Masked Matterhorn, Fili-Second, Zapp, Radiance, Mistress Mare-velous, Saddle Rager, and a few others like Mistress Mare-Do-Well. The next news on paper were boring so you rolled it up to keep it and move in.

Walking into a meal diner, you ordered the usual favorite and wait for them to cook it.

You then take out the newspaper again and did some crossword puzzle & sudoku. When your meal is done, you thanked the mare waitress and dig in, not noticing the blush on her face and hearing the jealousy grumbles of several ponies nearby.

Minutes later after finishing up your delicious meal, you signed the paper cost and pay the tipping bits before getting up to walk out of the diner. After you left, you didn't hear the waitress whimpering to see you gone so soon and several ponies walking out as well.

Upon walking around the city, you heard a siren already went off and see a burglary take place in a bank.

"Alright, put the bits in the bags!" You hear one of thugs shouted.

A group of innocents were held hostage at gun point and a part of you is scared to death. You have a difficult decision; Either walk away or take a gamble and free the hostages.

"Ah what the hell, I'm only going to do this once." You grumbly mumbled.

Shaking your head, you sneak by the police force and surprise the criminal grunt nearby and choke him in a sleeper hold headlock until he fell unconscious. Searching around for anything useful, you were a bit shocked that the grunt has a smoke grenade.

Getting a brilliant idea, you threw the smoke grenade out near the thugs as the smoke is spreading. You then grab the metal bat from the downed grunt as you immediately sneak by and taken out each grunts one at a time.

Making sure the coast is clear, you made it to the hostages and cut the robes tied around the ponies.

"Hurry, get out of here if you want to live." You said to them.

They got your message and hurried outside to escape from here.

Distracted, you grunt in pain when something hit your back. You turn around to see a masked pony covered with a few C4 explosives while holding a small filly who he has in his left arm, crying for her mommy and daddy.

"If I'm going down then I'm taking you with me ya freak!" The masked stallion yelled out.

You see him press the button on his right as the timer counts down from 15 seconds. Thinking fast, you got up and threw the metal bat at the masked stallion's head. Screaming in pain, he drops the filly as you catch her and kick the criminal away.

"Hang on tight kid, we're going to brace for impact." You whisper to the filly.

Quickly running out of there, the explosive detonates as you and the filly your holding in your arms were sent flown away and your body impacted to the second building floor window.

Your ears were ringing from the explosive soundwave and you couldn't move your body.

The last thing you saw before blanking out is the filly in your arms crying out to you.

A few days later, you regain consciousness in the morning and look to see that your in a hospital bed.

You felt some pain on trying to get up as the nurse mare came to check on you.

"Ugh, w-what happen to me?" You weakly asked.

The nurse nodded and said her name is Nurse Redheart. She then went on to explain the heist aftermath story reports on how you saved the hostages in time, got the crooks arrested except for the deceased one, and the filly you saved has came in every day just to see you. She also said that your upper body got some burn marks, including both of yours legs being broken from a few shrapnel piercings so you won't be walking for a while.

"Well uh that's good to here, but I have to get back at my rent place."

Nurse Redheart asked which rent place you stayed at and you told her the place address number. You saw her ears flop down and asked her on what's wrong. She sadly told you the bad news on the place you stayed at got torn down by an unknown group during the bank heist.

Shocked at hearing this sudden news, you had your head down in sadness. All of your hard work hours, earning bits, and buying things got destroyed and burned up. To you, it felt like a bitter week. From saving a lot of lives to finding out your place got ran sacked and completely destroyed.

You didn't say anything else as you felt a pair of lips touch your forehead before the nurse left you alone.

Over the next weeks, you were paid a visit by a few ponies, including Masked Matterhorn and her hero friends.

You haven't spoken much to them since you were too occupied of being a depressed wreck. They did try to cheer you up, but nothing seems to be working and they can understand why you've been down when Nurse Redheart told them.

Then, you hear one of the heroes whispering something in secret as they walked out.

Now in the present, you were merely busy watching each snow outside falling down.

Back before you had a rent place, you have seen a calendar month chart of different naming holidays. One of them is called Hearth's Warming Eve similar to Christmas Eve in your world. Sadly, you didn't like to enjoy it since everything you have earned is now gone.

Especially you can't enjoy the holidays without your family when they couldn't find you here in another world.

"Hello there darling, we have brought some early presents for you~!"

Sighing under your breath, you turn your head to let them know you wanted to be alone.

However, you didn't say a single word as your mouth opens in awe, eyes widen, and your face heated with red when seeing the tipping tidal wave of Heaven. Nine mares in this very room you're in are wearing a revealing sexy nurse outfits and there upper body chests showing an open cleavages of nice sets of honkers.

One of the mares named Masked Matterhorn coughs and decides to speak.

"Since all nine of us have reached a slight difficult agreement, we've made a decision."

"D-Decision? Wha-" You tried to speak, but the purple mare put her fingers on your lips.

"Yes, we know that you were having a difficult time of adjusting among us ponies and we understand why you do seem down since you miss your family. So each of us has made a decision that we'd like you to be in a herd with us."

You gawked at the word "herd" she has said while noticing each mares blush in red. A part of you didn't know on what to think. Having one relationship is one thing, but with getting more than one relationship in a herd, it's so very sudden to you.

"I. . . U-Um. . ."

"It's okay if you feel uncomfortable, we don't want to force you into sex with us right now if that's what your wondering. We'll only take things slow as we get to know you and you get to know each of us like our real identities in secret."

You then see the purple mare climb on your bed and on top of you.

"I'll go first, in the city I go by Masked Matterhorn, but my real name is Twilight Sparkle."

She smiles before she opens her mouth a bit and kisses you. Your eyes widen of seeing her kissing you, but you felt relaxed and the both of you tasted each other's inside mouths, including the taste of blueberry. A minute after that heated moment, you both broke away and see Twilight get nervous and twiddling her fingers.

"Me next egghead."

Twilight is carried off the bed as you see the rainbow haired mare take Twilight's position onto you.

"I go by Zap to every pony fans, but I'm really Rainbow Dash and the fastest pegasi alive."

She quickly wrap both of her arms around your body and got kissed hard by her lips. You were surprised by her fast actions and feeling the spicy electric tongue of hers exploring your mouth. You got lost in thought on what kind of flavors Rainbow has with foods. What felt like minutes passing by, you see Rainbow pulled away by an orange mare.

"Simmer down Dashie, don't go hogging him out till he's already exhausted."

Ignoring Rainbow's grumbling curse, the orange mare is up next and you can see her well tone muscly arms.

"I'm known as Mistress Mare-velous sugarcube, but my real name is Applejack, the strongest earth mare."

You see her use a left hand to pull your head towards her before your lips make contact with hers and feeling the freckles of hair on her furry cheeks. You then felt her inside mouth taste like some different pies. Though you haven't tried any kind of pie before, you never guess that her mouth tastes so very delicious.

After what seemed like forever, Applejack broke away from you and kissed your cheek before getting up.

"Oh ummm, I-I guess I'm up next girls."

You saw the shy yellow pegasi mare gently climb up the bed and sat in front of you.

"I-I'm known as S-Saddle Rager, but I'm r-really Fluttershy and a c-caretaker animal mare."

Slowly leaning her head forward, you saw Fluttershy closes her eyes and her lips touches yours. A part of you did melt your heart of seeing this beautiful shy mare and her nice lips. Tasting her inside mouth, you thought they tasted like an aroma kind of honey and seem to like the flavor of hers.

When the both of you broke away, you can see her face flushing in red and murmuring to herself.

"Oh boy, my turn is checked in!"

You were surprised when the pink mare pick up Fluttershy's body and gently put her down with the group before the pink mare hops up and plops down in front of you.

"Mine is called Fili-Second, but I go by Pinkie Pie! The energetic party planner earth mare!"

Pinkie grabs your head with both of her hands puckers you up on her lips. The two things you weren't prepared for, her energetic movements and her inside mouth tasting like candy sweets & cake flavors. You didn't know on how exactly she has eaten many different sweets, but you never mind it at all as you relax to enjoy her sweet lips.

Breaking away from contact, you saw her face in red and smiling widely before hopping off the bed.

"I guess it's my turn up next darlings."

The next white mare you see climbed up and brushes her curly purple mane aside.

"My identity hero name is Radiance darling, but I'm known as Rarity Belle. The beautiful fashion designer."

You saw her right eye wink before pulling your upper body towards her and gave you a warm kiss. Feeling her inside mouth, you can perhaps guess is her tastes of tea, cinnamon, and maybe wine. Though not much of a tea or wine, you did somehow like the flavor of her saliva tastes. Parting away, Rarity gave you a sultry smile before getting up and her tail brush under your chin in delight.

"Get ready for the next grandest stage human!"

A puff of smoke appeared and you see the sky blue unicorn mare sitting in front of you.

"Some ponies have refer to me as Mistress Mare-Do-Well, but also the Great and Powerful Trrrrixie!"

You look at Trixie using her magic to expand her hat a bit. She then proceeds to pull your face toward her with her hands. As her hat covers both of your heads, you see her begin to hungrily kiss you hard. You tongue felt her mouth strangely taste like peanut butter and partially crackers. Back then you did miss having your favorite meals to eat and yet somehow the flavor you craved has returned to you. Parting away, Trixie pulls her hat up and licks your cheek before getting off the bed.

"Well, better not keep you waiting any longer."

You see another orange mare who's a unicorn as she climbs up and plops down to look at you.

"I'm known as the Solar Witch, a counter part of Mane-iac, but I'm actually Sunset Shimmer."

Sunset's mix mane color of red/yellow moves to life as they grab your shoulder and pulls you to her. She gently uses her arms to wrap around you before her lips contact with yours. In her mouth, you can feel the taste of morning breakfast like eggs, toast, and bacon. A shame you haven't had those one for a while, but didn't mind to relax with tasting this unicorn mare. Few minutes later, you both break away and she licked your lips then hops off.

"So I'm the best for last then, I won't make you feel disappointed."

The last mare you see who has a mix purple/pink fur coat hops up and plops down to you.

"I use to be a villain called Fallen Star and reformed as Shooting Star, but my real names Starlight Glimmer."

Starlight grabs your head in her right hand and your back in her left hand before your is shoved to forward to her open mouth lips. You were bombarded in amazement when you felt her mouth tastes like slushies, cherry berry, and glimmering melted cheese butter dip. A coupe of minutes later, both of you broke away as the both of you were shaded in red cheeks. She gave you a more sultry look than Rarity before giggling to herself and got up.

Twilight then began to make her speech to you.

"Since Hearth's Warming Eve is closing in, we would want to know if you'd like to spend the holiday with us and help you get back on your feet. Although, we'd understand if you prefer to be alone. Whatever decision you'll make, we'll gladly accept it."

You saw each of the mares fidgeting in nervously while you think to yourself for a moment. Even though a part of you thinks it's wrong to have any pony in your life, your beating heart did like each of these strange anthro pony mares. No matter if you didn't get to be with a human girl, you can at least gives these mares in this room a chance.

"I guess, i-it wouldn't hurt if you m-mares can spend some time f-freely with me." You whisper.

You hear each of them gasp in delight as Twilight uses her magic to expand your bed and you didn't expect to be bombarded by these mares kiss your lips and all over your body as you felt a lot of big honkers smothering you.

Hours later after accept being in a herd or harem, you wake up and hearing the snores of mares beside you. All nine of them were cuddling up the bed your in and feeling there furry body warm you up.

Smiling at them sleeping soundly, you gave each of them a soft ear scratching.

"Happy Hearth's Warming Eve girls." You whisper, earning each of them a smile and saying your name.

Not wanting to wake them up so soon, you go back to sleep and feeling your face press into a nice melon boobs.

Looking back in your dream, you popped into another world and your hard work got taken away, but on the good side you helped save some live and even somehow winning the hearts of lovely beautiful mares.

Well, you know what they say?

When life brings you down, your special mare herd can help you get back on your feet.

Author's Note

Merry Christmas everyone, just thought that I put in a one-shot story chapter of the Power Ponies for Hearth's Warming since I haven't seen any stories with them in it. If anyone would perhaps like to see the sequel some day or not, please let me know. Hope everyone's doing okay and wishing the best of luck as 2020 comes to a close and 2021 begins soon.

Also keep in mind that I haven't tried the um second person or self insert story before so I thought I tried one out in the Power Ponies world, but with a Hearth's Warming one-shot.

Warning & DLC herd pack. . . . . wait wha-?

Opening up your eyes, you see a white void and glance around to see that you're somewhere else.

"That's weird, I could've sworn I was back at the hospital bed."

You look at your body to see you got the patient gown on.

"At least I still got my gown and underwear."

Getting up off the ground, you walk around to call out for anybody in the white void.

"Hellooooooo~! Hero mane 6?! Trixie?! Sunset?! Starlight?! Redheart?! Isn't there anyone out here?!"

You yelled for about a minute or two, but got no response back.

"Great, now I don't know on how to get the hell out of here."

Sighing in defeat, you then heard something in the distance on your right side.

"Hm?"

You couldn't hear on what the chant voices are saying, but it's a possible way out.

"I better go check on the noise and find the exit door, maybe someone is here longer than me."

You then make your way of running toward the chanting voices.

Getting closer to the destination of a door, your surprised to heart the voices have stopped.

"Hmmmm, I better tread lightly on what I've discovered."

You walk over to the door which has a strange symbol on it.

"A symbol, where have I seen it before?"

Scratching your head, a voice whispers behind the door interrupting you.

". . . -destroyed, it's all gone."

"Huh?"

You tip toed to the door, putting your left ear by the door to hear a conversation going on.

"Filthy disgusting beasts, I warned them about abusing the power, but they're paid a heavy curse price."

"There's nothing we can do for them, their world would burn as well."

"But what about them and the human? We can't let them die because of those tyrant's actions!"

"Why save them? They're beyond saving or even unredeemable to give a chance."

"Don't let them die! Please! Can you at least reconsider leader?!"

". . . . . I'll send in a message for the meeting. Meanwhile, you deal with the planning while you send in some of your trusted guardians to protect him in case they come looking for him. Is that understood?"

"Y-Yes sir."

"Hmph! Fine."

"As long as they won't bother me."

"Then this meeting is over."

When the conversation were over, a sudden tremor arises under your feet.

You saw the door disappear and the white void change into a strange abandoned facility.

"Okay, this sure looks like a red flag. I better get going and-"

"What are you doing in here, intruder?"

Your body froze that someone has spotted you.

Slowly turning around, your eyes widen in fear of seeing multiple entities with eyes looking at you.

Including a robe figure with a weird mask, holding a knife or scalpel in the right hand.

"You do not belong here."

You were terrified on trying to speak out since there's no way of getting out of here alive.

"I-I. . . . . u-u-um. . . "

The robe figure points the small scalpel at you.

"No matter, it would seem I have no choice, but to cure you."

The robe mask figure walks over to you, gripping the scalpel and pointing at your heart spot.

You were too terrified to move and couldn't even move your legs when they're literally shaking.

The scalpel was a few inches away before touching you skin in less than a few seconds.

Until. . .

"Hee Hee Hee Hee Hee, I don't think so~!"

"WAAAHHHHHHHH!"

You shouted upon waking up, feeling the sweat on your head and heart beat fast bumps.

Looking around, you notice that you're back in the hospital bed, but it seems outside is still night time.

You then calm yourself down as the heart is slowing down to normal.

"Oh man, that was a crazy nightmare I had." You murmured.

Rubbing your head, you notice for some reason the hero mares are not beside you on the bed.

Meaning that they must've gone home or something.

"Weird, I could've sworn they haven't woken me up. Ah well, I better go get some water cause I'm thirsty as hell. Sure the doctors or nurses won't mind if I go fetch it myself."

Carefully getting off the large bed, your feet touch the ground floor and walk over out the patient room.

You then proceed to singing in hum a favorite music back on Earth to try & forget about the nightmare.

Unbeknownst to you, a couple of figure have snuck in the building watching you sing.

At a band bar somewhere, a group of musicians has started to play some music.

You twirl around in rhythm of the song, enjoying the feeling of it.

After for some walks, you got to the water machine and drink some water out of the cup in your hand.

Satisfied with the thirst, you then walk back to continue your song.

Some of the patients sleeping were swaying their heads while you walk by there rooms.

Mares & stallions at the bar began to slow dance along the music.

The band bar of guest were applauding to the band for the night of music as they pack up to go.

You however, yawned from feeling tired and wanting to go to bed.

Putting the empty cup at your small table, you got in the bed covers and going to sleep.

Only you didn't know that for some reason your bed is feeling too warm and cozy of soft fur.

The next day, you groan in your sleep when you've heard a loud shouting by your bed.

(Between 1:12 - 1:16 That screaming scene will never get old to me)

You then grunted when someone carried you out of bed.

"Who in Equestria are you two doing in our coltfriend's bed?!" You heard Zapp yell out.

"Speak to us lover! Don't tell me they've killed you in your sleep! Or they had rough sex with you while your sleeping! Or even tried to put make up on and paint your nails! Oh that would be the worst! Possible! Thing! WAHHHHH DON'T GO INTO THE LIIIIIIIIIGHT!" Shouting Pinkie, shaking your whole body.

"W-W-W-W-Wah-ah-ah-ah-ah-ah-ah-t-t-t-t-t-"

Thankfully, you felt someone else taken you back away from the sudden shaking.

"Pinkie Pie dear control yourself! I don't want you shaking our beloved coltfriend to death." Hearing Rarity say.

"Hee hee, sorry about that Rarity. I just kinda gotten carried away."

Your eyes were groggily opened, barely seeing your girlfriends into view.

"You feeling alright my dear? No wounds or anything at all?" Sunset whispering to you.

You saw Twilight & Fluttershy kissing your forehead and rubbing your hair in comfort.

Which you didn't mind it and feeling your cheeks went red of the girls got too close to you.

"I-I'm fine girls, I don't feel anything on me. Except for a couple of sore spots from Pinkie shaking me."

Getting back up, you see RD, Trixie, and Starlight glaring at two intruders in your bed. AJ however, had her lasso around the intruder so that they won't get away from the building.

One with twin pig hairs seems to be still asleep while the other covers her naked body with the blanket.

Yet something feels off, the one looks like a human female, but with . . . fluffy fox ears & multiple tails. . . . .

Your eyes widen upon realizing on who these two females are.

"Wait a second girls, I recognize those two human intruders."

Your girlfriends were surprised and all looked at you.

"You know them? Explain." AJ says to you, raising her eyebrow.

Although, you felt scared when you've sensed a dark massive aura of jealousy from the girls.

"Uh not particularly in contact, but I've seen these two several times on different days, I swear honestly."

You saw the naked fox girl sheepishly wave to you.

"Ummmm. . . . h-hi there. Nice to finally meet you." The female greeted.

You notice Trixie snorted and taps her footing, letting the fox girl look at her and wince from her jealous glare.

"Trixie thinks you've got some explaining to do, whoever you are." Trixie said in a serious tone.

You see the human fox girl sighing and her ears flop down similar to pony ears.

"It's sort of a long story, but I feel it would be better if things were in private, okay?"

Hearing this information, your girlfriend Twilight used a magic spell around the room.

"Alright, I've nullify the room so that nopony else can hear us outside. Now start talking."

Author's Note

Finally, the second chapter is done my faithful readers & followers! Took too damn long to fill it out since I've gotten so distracted lately and recently. Anyways, the next final part will be a teaser for the sequel of this story. The sequel will take place before and after the Heartswarming Eve with the mares sleeping there herd mate. It'll start with how the human arriving in another world and his journey there with many chapters of twists, turns, love, crossover, and so much more.

Leave a comment down on what do you think and smell ya later folks!

Sequel for the teaser.

"Okay, just play it cool and I'll be fine."

"Hello, never seen you around here. What can I do for you?"

"U-U-Um hi t-there, is there any chance of me getting a job around this city?"

"Girls, ah hate to say it, but ah think we're surrounded."

"Yeah no buck AJ, can't believe those fake heroes just set us up like that."

"Quite right Rainbow, here I thought my knight & shining armor is only an illusion."

"Wait a second, quiet down girls. I think I see someone in the distance up above."

"Curses! We've almost had them in our trap! How could this have happened?!"

"A minor setback, it appears someone has given them a surprising morale support."

"So what do you suggest we do then? He'll definitely terminate us if we failed for too long."

"Indeed, though I prefer to do nothing for now. I'll report to him that it was a parted plan successful. Meanwhile, send word to my guard to deal with those traitors. Those foolish weak heroes have no idea on what they're in for, be certain of that."

"Hello there, welcome to my Academy human!"

"Thank goodness, at least he's alright now."

"How long until we reveal ourselves?"

"Not yet, we just need to wait for a little longer."

"The tournament will begin!"

"Bring us the ones on the list. The rest however if they get in the way, kill them all."

"HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!" Finally, you have come to the sanctuary chamber at last!"

"Uhhhhhh. . . . . who are you?"

Author's Note

Sequel: Your Journey In Maretropolis & Beyond.

The sequel will mostly have an RGRE version. Also though, I'll be giving the human a name and having a second person view switched to different characters sometimes in chapters.

So yeah, keep an eye out for it soon and smell ya later!