A Nightmare Night to Remember

by PuzzlingInsanity

Rating: mature
Tags: Zebra, Narcotics, Anthro, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Self Insert, Porn, Sex
Length: 1601

Puzzling Insanity meets a zebra on Nightmare Night and they have a private party.

Puzzling Insanity, bored with foals' games on Nightmare Night, heads for the town's new nightclub, Hoofbeats. There, she meets Evander, a zebra who's taken a shining to her. They go back to his apartment for a more private party.

Narcotics tag is for casual marijuana use and mentions of drug paraphernalia.

Published 2020-12-29 22:40:00 UTC
Last updated 2020-12-29 22:40:00 UTC

Private Party

The waxing gibbous moon hung in a vast expanse of blackness peppered with thousands of stars, illuminating the world below it with its glow. In the town of Ponyville, foals were just winding down from a night chock full of Nightmare Night activities. Parents checked their foals’ candy for nasty surprises as they went back to their warm and cozy homes for the night, out of the cool crisp air.

For other creatures, however, the night was still young. The silence of the night was broken by the steady thump-thump-thump from bass-boosted speakers at the new nightclub in town, Hoofbeats. Inside the club, costumed creatures of all kinds partied and danced like there would be no tomorrow. One such creature sat at the bar, enjoying a fruity rum cocktail in a large glass.

Her orchid-gray coat was in contrast to the black of her Mareticia Addams dress. The dress flattered her curves and pushed her breasts up. She reached into her purse and pulled out a compact mirror, examining her hair and makeup. With her free hand, she brushed her raven black mane away from her olive yellow eyes and decided to reapply her makeup in the ladies’ room. Scooting off the barstool, she made her way to the restroom and went inside.

The ladies’ restroom was clean by nightclub standards, no trash to be seen or unpleasant odors to be smelled. The overweight mare pulled a black eye pencil and a tube of mascara from her bag, then pulled her hair back with a black elastic hair tie. Carefully, she applied the pencil to her water line and her lower lash line before giving her lashes exactly two coats of mascara.

Satisfied with her appearance, she left the restroom and returned to her seat at the bar, a half-finished cocktail waiting on her. She sipped on the drink through the black straw in the glass, only to be interrupted by a voice that drenched her panties.

“Well, what’s a mare like you doing in a place like this?”

The mare blushed hard and turned to behold a zebra stallion garbed in a skeleton costume. “Enjoying a night out,” she answered. “I’m Puzzling Insanity.”

“My name is Evander, my dear. Shall we have a more private party back at my abode?”

Puzzling nodded, slipping her soaked panties off and putting them in her purse before leaving the club with the zebra. “I thought zebras spoke in rhyme?”

“Not all zebras,” Evander chuckled. “Mostly shamans.” The pony nodded again, feeling the heat and moisture grow between her legs. The zebra stallion’s nostrils flared and he smirked. “Is someone getting a little excited?”

“More than a little,” Puzzling admitted. “I like zebras.” Her eyes darted between her surroundings and the bulge in Evander’s crotch. The walk from Hoofbeats to an apartment complex near the outskirts of the town took approximately 20 minutes, not counting the breather the mare had to take.

The stallion unlocked the door to his apartment, opening it. Puzzling’s nostrils flared as she smelled a blend of cannabis and masculinity, making her shudder. “Smell something you like?” the zebra teased.

“Why don’t we smoke in your room to relax a little more?” the mare asked in response. “Smells like high-quality kush.”

“I’d be happy to oblige,” Evander replied. “I’ll get my lighter while you head up to the bedroom and make yourself comfortable. Up the stairs and to the left.”

“Thank you,” Puzzling purred, flashing a fanged grin as she hiked up her dress and hoofed it upstairs. She proceeded to the left and crawled onto the bed, noticing the black and white grinder on the nightstand. Picking it up, she noted that there was a tribal shark on the lid. She set the grinder back where she found it just as her host ascended the stairs with a black lighter and a package of blunt wraps.

“Ah, I see you’ve found my grinder,” Evander commented, a playful smirk on his muzzle. “Grab it for me, please, dear.”

The pudgy pony obeyed, picking the requested object back up off the nightstand as the zebra sat beside her on the bed and opened the package. He took a blunt wrap and filled it with the contents of the grinder, lighting it and passing it to the mare.

She took the blunt in her fingers and put it in her mouth, taking two slow puffs and passing it back as a cloud of smoke escaped her lips. Evander accepted it and puffed on it, making little rings of smoke on the exhale.

It seemed like only minutes passed by before the blunt was finished, and the two creatures were relaxing in a haze of smoke. “Sooooo…” Puzzling started, only to be cut off by her own gasp as Evander tore her dress off and took her right nipple into his mouth.

Pleasure shot up and down her body as he bit down on the fleshy nub tipping her breast. She let out a mewl of need as she began to get wet again. He pulled away, taking a long inhale of her scent and snorting aggressively. “Ahh… nothing beats the scent of a mare,” the stallion hissed, nipping her ear and grabbing her hooves. “I wonder if you taste as wonderful as you smell.”

With a surprised yelp from the mare, he easily put her in a frontbend, holding her legs over her head as he admired her glistening flower.

Puzzling Insanity’s pussy was pudgy, her plump lips looking smooth and puffy. Her clitoris was tiny, but it throbbed in excitement. On her mons pubis, just above her slit, was a small scar from a rejected Christina piercing.

She blushed crimson and moaned loudly as he gave her clenching marehood a long teasing lick. “Such a pretty pussy,” he growled. He noted that she tasted musky-sweet with a spicy tang to it. “Delicious, too.”

“Fuuuuck~!” Puzzling cried out as Evander proceeded to bury his face in her cunt. “Faust, that feels so good!”

The zebra licked and sucked relentlessly, spitting on her pussy every so often. Puzzling gripped the sheets and quivered in pleasure. She could feel herself getting closer to cumming. Evander pulled away and let her go just as she got to the edge. “Not just yet,” he chuckled, removing his costume. His massive cock sprang out, much to the mare’s awe. “Like what you see?”

Puzzling Insanity nodded slowly, hanging her head over the edge of the bed and opening wide. With a deep breath, she pulled him in and took half his shaft on the first go. Shockwaves of pleasure rocketed up the zebra’s spine as he fucked her throat. She moaned and gurgled around his stallionhood, drool and makeup coating her face. He groaned as he felt his length pulse in her esophagus. He pulled out, not ready to finish just yet.

Once the two of them calmed down enough, Evander grabbed Puzzling’s hooves and teased her pussy with his dick, rubbing her clit with his cockhead. “Do you want this?” the zebra purred, listening to the pony’s needy whimpers. “Say it.”

“Pleeease,” Puzzling Insanity whined, “I need your cock in my tight little hole~!”

Slowly, he pushed his cock inside her clenching marehood. “Fuuuuuck,” he groaned, “you really are tight!” The mare’s vagina was like a heated velvet-lined vise, squeezing hard against the length inside of it. He began to steadily thrust into her, the tip kissing her cervix with each stroke.

“Oh, FAUST~!” Puzzling screamed, feeling the deep penetration as his cock stimulated her G-spot and her A-spot simultaneously. Her pussy spasmed and gushed around his penis, juices running down to his balls.

“That’s it,” Evander grunted. “Soak that dick, baby, cum all over it…” As he purred sweet obscenities into her ear, she whimpered and moaned into his, singing his praises. Suddenly, he flipped her over and gave her mountainous rear end a firm smack, thrusting hard into her and eliciting another melody of whines and cries of pleasure from her.

She mewled as he gripped her hair with one hand and pushed her down with the other, squishing her breasts into the bed. Her tail swished in arousal, trying to spread her scent. She gripped the sheets as she came again, more juices running down her thick thighs. As she squealed like a pig, he spanked her again and spread her ass cheeks apart, pulling out of her pussy with a wet pop and prodding at her asshole with his soaked cock. With a gasp from both parties, Evander popped inside Puzzling Insanity’s back door.

“Oh, my Faust,” the zebra moaned, “your asshole feels amazing~!”

“T-thank you,” the earth pony hissed through gritted teeth. “So big… so good…” Her ass felt even tighter and warmer than her pussy, kneading the stallionhood buried within it as he stimulated her sweet spots. She felt his length throb inside her ass and pushed back on it, triggering her own orgasm as more hot fluid covered her legs and the bed.

Evander let out a roar of passion and flooded her bowels with his seed, rope after thick rope shooting out of his cock. He slowly pulled his softening cock out of her ass with another wet pop, allowing his cum to leak out. As he lay back and caught his breath, Puzzling, having regained her bearings, made another blunt and passed it to him.

“Thank you,” he sighed, lighting and smoking it. As smoke issued from his nostrils, he passed the blunt to her, and they smoked for the rest of the night.