A Night with a Nightmare

by Twilight star

Rating: teen
Tags: Twilight Sparkle, Nightmare Moon, Princess Luna, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Comedy, Romance, Sex
Length: 1898

Twilight wakes up in the dungeons, with only Nightmare Moon as a companion. She feels nothing but tired about it.

Twilight had a busy week at the Friendship School, and anypony who works at the school knows that very well. As the handmare at the Friendship School, she has a greater responsibility than others, and it's makes her very tired after a full day. But nothing like a good night's sleep doesn't fix it.

But one night, she wakes up in the dungeons, with only Nightmare Moon as her companion. She would even let Nightmare Moon take revenge on her, if she wasn't so tired now.

Published 2021-01-02 16:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2021-01-02 16:30:01 UTC

Why Don't You Take Your Revenge when I'm Not so Tired?

Twilight left the Friendship School with tiredness present in her, closing the door behind her. Today was a busy day for her because it had a parents’ meeting. The meeting lasted an entire day, and the students did not have to come with their parents if they did not want to.

Some students seemed happy to not have class, while others were sad about it. But for Twilight, she knew she shouldn’t complain, since she loved working at her school as a handmare, but unfortunately, that came at a cost: she stayed at school all day, resulting in her feeling tired. But despite that, she liked her job, since education, books and friendship in one place were like a full plate for her. The teachers and parents of the students had already left school an hour ago, she was the last to leave due to having to keep the things in the meeting room.

She climbed the castle’s few steps and opened the door. Upon entering, she closed the door behind her and headed for the dining room. She planned to go to sleep after dinner. Normally, she would stay awake watching the night sky on the balcony, but as working at a school made her tired and she had to wake up early, she had to see the stars and night sky only on holidays, vacations and weekends from now on. However, this did not sadden her, because as tomorrow was Saturday, it would mean that she would have plenty of time to observe the night sky and be with her marefriend.

The Princess of Friendship sat on the chair and watched Spike go to the table, placing the plate of pasta for him and her. Spike soon sat down and they both started to eat. Twilight started thinking about her marefriend. What had she been doing these past few weeks? Did she miss her or think of her? She hoped so.

“So, Twilight? How was the parents’ meeting at Friendship School?” asked Spike, after swallowing the piece of pasta.

Twilight looked at Spike and said, “It was good, Spike. I was informed by my friends that most of the students are well dedicated to their studies.”

Spike agreed with what Twilight said. “This is great, Twilight! It is good to see that many students are interested and dedicated to learning about friendship.”

“I know, Spike! The idea of opening a friendship school was one of the best ideas I had,” said Twilight in a cheerful tone. Spike in response only smiled at the answer before eating again.

After about ten minutes, the two finished eating. Spike stacked the dishes and took them to the kitchen, and Twilight went to her room to go to sleep.

When walking in the hall, Twilight thought about her plans for Saturday. Maybe she could invite Luna on a date or invite her friends over for a picnic, or then read a book, but only if Luna was busy tomorrow. But she would see that tomorrow, because now, what she wanted most was to sleep.

Opening the door to her room, she entered and approached the bed, closing the door behind her. She uncovered the blanket a little and lay down, covering herself up to her neck and then fell into a peaceful sleep.

After a few hours, Twilight, still asleep, felt a chill wash over her. She felt that she was no longer covered in the blanket, with a hoof, she looked for the blanket, but did not find it. She opened her left eye, looking for the blanket and noticed that her blanket was nowhere to be found. Wait. She was no longer in her bed either! She opened her other eye and looked around, noticing that she was not in her room, but in a dungeon! She panicked, thinking of the worst.

Oh my Celestia! How did I get here? Am I sleepwalking and never noticed?

“Finally you woke up.”

Twilight’s ears drooped when she heard a voice she knew very well. She looked in the direction of the voice and saw a tall black alicorn with a light blue ethereal mane with stars in it, blue armor, and teal eyes with cat like pupils. Just seeing the panic in the purple alicorn’s eyes brought a mean smile on the black alicorn’s face. From the voice, expansive starry mane, cat like eyes, and blue armor on the black alicorn; Twilight immediately knew that the very first foe she and her friends faced a long time ago, Nightmare Moon, was back.

Nightmare Moon trotted towards the younger princess with a wicked smile on her face. Twilight wondered why Luna became Nightmare Moon again. Was it because they hadn’t seen each other for the past 5 days since her Friendship School opened?

“Did you really think that the elements would prevent me from returning? Well, you were wrong. Because now, I have returned, have you at my mercy, and I will execute my revenge, and then the night ... Will last ... Forever!” She started to laugh wildly.

Twilight still looked surprised that Nightmare Moon returned. But despite that, she didn’t want to know what the dark mare’s revenge would be. The only thing she wanted was to go back to sleep. “Nightmare Moon, I understand your desire for revenge and the night to last forever. But all life will perish if the night is eternal, you won’t have any subjects to rule over. Plus, can’t you put the revenge off for later? I’m too tired from my duties at my School of Friendship.”

Nightmare Moon stopped laughing and froze at what Twilight said, before she got angry. “No! You will not sleep on my beautiful night! Not when I will take my revenge on you!”

“But it’s an hour in the morning!” Twilight argued, pointing to a window that was capable of see the full moon in the sky.

“It doesn’t matter! I will have my revenge and I want you with your eyes wide open to witness my revenge on you!” said Nightmare Moon.

“Why don’t you leave your revenge for another day? Believe me, leaving for another day, you can feel more triumphant by defeating me when I’m not so tired.” Twilight tried to convince Nightmare Moon.

“I won’t leave my revenge for another day, Twilight Sparkle! Not now that I have you at my mercy!” Nightmare Moon denied it.

“But how are you going to get revenge on me?” asked Twilight. Nightmare Moon soon returned to smile and walk.

“Simple, as I was inside Luna’s mind, I could see by her memories that the you two are marefriends, and what better way to execute my revenge than to make you mine?”

Twilight blew out a breath. Knowing what Nightmare Moon wanted to do, she said, “Luna, I understand why you want to do this, but now it’s too late at night. Can’t we do this during the day?”

Nightmare Moon froze again, but this time it was when she heard her old name, and said in an angry tone, “That’s not my name, filly! I already said that I will take revenge on you now! Plus, there won’t be another day for you. The night will last forever!”

“So if you’re going to get revenge on me, do it when I’m not so tired. Good night,” said Twilight, now going back to sleep, even though she’s on the cold floor of the dungeon.

Nightmare Moon growled and stomped a hoof on the floor angrily, a crack forming in the floor. She then grabbed Twilight with her turquoise magic. The purple alicorn quickly opened her eyes in surprise and stay well below Nightmare Moon with her abdomen up. She pinned Twilight to the ground with her hooves and watched the little purple alicorn with a wicked smile through her blue helmet before starting to passionately kiss Twilight’s lips, which resulted in taking Twilight by surprise.

“Luna… hmph… please… hmph…” Twilight whispered between her breaths, closing her eyes.

“You like that, don’t you?” asked Nightmare Moon with a smile. “You love the feeling of being submissive to somepony who has more power than you, don’t you? I bet your princess never had the courage to give you something like that for you.”

Twilight felt a chill in her as she felt Nightmare Moon’s fangs slowly go to her neck, and she fought not to let out a groan. She turned her head to the left.

“L-Luna… s-stop… please…” said Twilight, now in a slightly louder tone, but the black alicorn did not hear her because she was still talking and going further down her body.

“After I make you mine, you will be my lovely love slave, and then, I will take your princess off the throne, destroy the Elements of Harmony and then the night ...” Nightmare Moon’s head was now very close to Twilight’s pussy and would start the job, but Twilight stopped her with a loud shout.

“Luna! Please stop!”

Nightmare Moon quickly stopped when she heard Twilight’s scream, causing the black alicorn to disappear and be replaced by Princess Luna, who looked at Twilight in confusion. “What happened, Twilight? Didn’t you like the roleplay?”

“Don’t get me wrong, Luna. I like a roleplay like any other marefriend, but now it’s really late at night, and all I want now is a night’s sleep after the full day I had at the Friendship School,” Twilight answered.

Luna looked sadly to the side, letting out a sigh for the answer and taking her hooves out of Twilight, allowing Twilight to rise from the floor. “I’m sorry, love. It’s just that I thought you would be feeling sad without being able to see me these last few days because you were busy with your duty of handmare in your school, so I thought I’d surprise you.”

Twilight, with pity, took Luna’s chin and lifted it up with a hoof, making her look at her. “Don’t blame yourself, Luna. I understand your reasons, but we’ll do it later when I’m not so tired, okay?”

Luna smiled at Twilight’s response and said, “Okay, love. Would you like to return to Ponyville now?”

Twilight thought for a few seconds before saying, “I think I better sleep here because I’m tired, I don’t want to end up falling on the street of so tired am I. But after you lower the moon, could you wake me up so I can go back to the castle early? I don’t want Spike to be worried that I’m gone.”

“Of course, love,” Luna replied.

They then went up the stairs and out of the dungeons, with the intention of going to the bedroom to sleep together. Twilight started to think about what had happened a few minutes ago. She would never have imagined that Luna would try to please her with a roleplay session, by account of they hadn’t seen each other since the founding of the Friendship School. If she wasn’t so tired, she would even allow Luna to continue, but she had to stop her, or else, she would be even more tired than she was already because of the pleasure she would receive. At least, they would have a roleplay session later to reward that failed roleplay session.