Rainbow Dash and Derpy go to an old haunted house, seeking some excitement. They come across several strange statues of ponies…covering their faces. While Derpy is busy speaking with a Pegasus who has mysteriously appeared at the door, Rainbow Dash gets dust caught in her eye. As she blinks to get the dust out she notices that one of the pony statues has moved closer. The nervous Rainbow Dash turns to go get Derpy suddenly she feels a stone hoof on her shoulder. When she turns around she sees a malicious cold-blooded look on the stone ponie's face. She is whisked back to 1940 and is never heard from again. Will Derpy be able to see her fellow Pegasus again? Will Dr. Whooves be able to help? Will the Weeping Ponies be stopped?