~ ❀ ~

Monday, December 24th, Year 8 of Princess Twilight

A great and bright fire roared in the chimney, spreading a cozy warmth in the crowded living room sheltering ponies from the raging winter storm. Pipsqueak was sitting next to Cheerilee, gently hugging the mare and sipping hot cocoa.

The room was utterly stuffed with ponies; here was the rest of the herd - Big Mac, Sugar Belle and Fluttershy -, their foals - Harvest Blossom, Orchard Breeze and Rain Hearth -, the Apple family - Granny Smith, Applejack and Applebloom -, Applebloom’s marefriends - Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo - and Cheerilee’s family - her parents and her twin sister Cherry Blossom.

Sugar Belle took position in the middle of the room, stomping her hooves to get everypony’s attention. The room fell silent, save for the fire’s crackling and the howling winds outside. Even the excited foals settled down. Sugar Belle tapped the floor a few times to set the rhythm then started singing gently, everypony joining in a choir.

“As dawn shines on us every morn
The fire of friendship is reborn
And all the friendships we have made
We cherish in every way

Loyalty binds us and makes us strong
Honesty shows that we belong
And kindness shared will unite us through each day

The fire of friendship lives in our hearts
As long as it burns, we cannot drift apart
Though quarrels arise, their numbers are few
Laughter and singing will see us through

We are a circle of pony friends
A circle of friends we'll be to the very end

Though the winter brings all its cold and storm
The glow in our hearts keeps us warm
The friends we now call our family
Will always see us through

Loyalty binds us and makes us strong
Honesty shows that we belong
And kindness shared will unite us through each day

The fire of friendship lives in our hearts
As long as it burns, we cannot drift apart
Though quarrels arise, their numbers are few
Laughter and singing will see us through

We are a circle of pony friends
A circle of friends we'll be to the very end”

The room erupted into cheers, foals joining in with their high pitched voices. The family shared hugs and kisses, happy feelings spreading amongst everypony. Pip kissed Cheerilee’s lips before Rain Hearth joined in between them. They hugged the little purple filly. Pip felt his heart melt as he stroked the mane of Big Mac and Cheerilee’s daughter, loving the foal as if he had sired her himself.

“Thank you everypony!” Sugar Belle said, starting a speech. “Thank you to all for being with us this Hearth’s Warming Eve!” She cleared her throat.

“When I married my very special somepony, Big Macintosh, 8 years ago, I never imagined how our family would grow so much. Two years ago, we married Fluttershy, officially forming a herd here at Sweet Apple Acres. Fluttershy, you’re a wonderful, kind pony and an amazing wife. We love you with all our hearts.”

The pegasus blushed brightly, hiding behind her bangs and hugging her colt tightly.

“Then, just last year, Cheerilee joined our herd too. Cheerilee, you’re an inspiration for us all. Ponyville’s fillies and colts are lucky to have you as their teacher. When you joined us, we decided it was finally time for us to have foals of our own.

“This year, we welcome our new fillies and colt into the world. Harvest Blossom, Rain Hearth, Orchard Breeze, we love you more than anything else.

“Finally, I’d like to welcome Pipsqueak. Pip, you were very brave to date a herd about to have foals. We’ve never regretted letting you in with us, and I hope you never did either. You’ve been an incredible help and a loving partner to all of us. Thank you!”

Pip had to wipe the tears forming in his eyes. He felt warm, accepted, happy.

“Now, before everypony opens their gifts,” Sugar Belle continued, “I’d like you to get up and join me, Pip.”

Surprised, Pip did so, trotting to Sugar Belle. Big Mac, Fluttershy and Cheerilee took positions on either sides of the unicorn, each smiling brightly.

“We - Mac, Fluttershy, Cheerilee and I - have a very special gift for you.” Sugar Belle levitated a small red box held shut by a golden ribbon.

Pip grabbed one end of the ribbon with his mouth and pulled to untie it. He released the ribbon and opened the little box. Inside was a golden chain and an ornate gold ring with a large diamond. He was left dumbstruck, unable to speak.

“Pip, we love you, and we want you with us for the rest of our lives. Will you marry us?”

Surprised gasps echoed across the room, everypony leaning closer to see Pip. His throat felt so tight he barely managed to squeak the response out.

“Yeah… yes, I love all of you. I want to marry you.” He picked up the ring and hung the chain around his neck, sealing their engagement.

The sound of pony cheers and stomping hooves shook the entire house. Words of congratulations and happiness echoed in Pip’s ears as he joined Big Mac, Sugar Belle, Fluttershy and Cheerilee in a group hug. He shared a kiss with each one.

The three foals jumped on Pip, hugging him with their tiny legs, probably having no idea of what was happening but wanting to join in the happiness nonetheless. Pip nuzzled into Harvest Blossom’s soft pink mane and planted a little kiss on her tiny horn, making the filly coo.

“Everypony, it’s time to celebrate!” Sugar Belle exclaimed, “gifts and sweets for all!”

Later that night, after the guests made their way back home, the entire herd, including Pip and the foals, collapsed together on the bed and quickly drifted into sleep, feeling utterly exhausted after a full day of play and celebrations.

~ ❀ ~

Tuesday, December 25th, Year 8 of Princess Twilight

Sugar Belle woke up early the next morning, hearing a foal’s whimper. She groggily looked around, seeing the entire herd still fast asleep. She spotted Rain Hearth getting a little agitated next to her.

Sugar Belle gently stroked the filly, comforting her. With a smile, she guided the foal to her lower belly, offering her udders and teats. As the unicorn expected, Rain Hearth stopped crying and began to eagerly suckle at her teat.

Feeding Cheerilee and Fluttershy’s foals always gave Sugar Belle a special thrill as she nursed them. She was bonding with Rain Hearth, the filly gulping down her warm, creamy milk. It tightened the herd’s bonds. The mare felt a similar warmth whenever she saw her own Harvest Blossom suckling at Cheerilee or Fluttershy’s teats.

The foals had grown since their births, and so had their appetites. Soon, Rain Hearth had swallowed the entire content of Sugar Belle’s udder. The filly simply lifted her head and moved to the other teat. Sugar Belle patted her little rump, letting the foal fill her belly with mare milk.

“Feeling better?” Sugar Belle whispered in the foal ear as she stopped suckling. Rain Hearth looked back at the alpha mare with her large, green eyes, the same color as Big Mac’s.

“Mmhmm,” the purple filly answered, looking content.

“Come, let’s get up before we wake the others.” Sugar Belle lifted Rain Heart in her magic and placed her on her back. She got out of bed and silently trotted out of the bedroom.

Sugar Belle brought Rain Hearth with her to the kitchen. She was surprised to see Cheerilee already up and eating.

Wait, that’s not Cheerilee…

“Oh, good morning, Cherry Blossom. You’re up early.”

Unlike the rest of yesterday’s guests, Cheerilee's twin sister wasn’t residing in Ponyville, so she had slept on the couch instead. Cherry Blossom waved a hoof. “I always get up early. Oh, you brought Rain Hearth! Mind if I take her off your hooves?”

Sugar Belle passed her the foal. Cherry Blossom happily nuzzled her twin’s daughter.

As usual, seeing Cheerilee’s sister was a very strange experience. Cherry Blossom, who was actually a professional wrestler living in Manehattan, was almost perfectly identical to Cheerilee, the only notable difference being her cutie mark. Sugar Belle hadn’t met her often, but it was always a bit unsettling, seeing somepony who looked exactly like her wife… but wasn’t.

~ ❀ ~

Cheerilee’s parents came back around noon, as they had announced. As an Hearth’s Warming gift to their daughter and her herd, the older couple were taking the three foals for a few days, thus giving the herd some well earned peace and quiet.

Soon enough, the foals, the grand-parents and auntie Cherry Blossom were on their way, leaving the two stallions and three mares alone together.

“Aww, I miss my little ones already,” Fluttershy said, looking longingly through the window.

Cheerilee giggled. “Yes, me too. But there’s something else I’m missing. Come on, Shy.”

The two mares joined Big Mac, Sugar Belle and Pip in the living room. Everypony looked very excited.

“Ladies and gentlecolts,” Sugar Belle announced with a grin, “the moment we have been all waiting for is finally here!”

The herd cheered.

“Today, Shy, Cheery, and myself are officially okay for intercourse. Aaaand, the house is guaranteed foal-free for the next few days. We have a very tight schedule, so I suggest we move on to the bedroom for our first activity: group sex!”

Cheerilee was beyond horny when she dropped into their herd-size bed. After foaling Rain Hearth, she had not had sex in over four entire months, except for giving an occasional blowjob to her stallions.

That was going to change immediately.

As Big Mac lay down with Fluttershy and Sugar Belle, Cheerilee grabbed Pip and pressed his body against her. She moaned as she felt his swelling sex rubbing against her flat belly. She put her hooves around his neck and drew him into her muzzle. Their tongues mingled like old friends, passionately caressing each other.

“Hmm, Pip, have you missed my body?” Cheerilee asked, a sultry expression of faux naivete in her eyes.

“Yeah… oh, you’re so warm. I want to come inside you right now.” The young stallion rubbed his cock against her crotch.

“Mmhmm, I want you inside me too. But, hang on-” Cheerilee wrapped her legs around Pip, holding him tight. She rolled to the side, taking him with her and making him yelp. A second later, she had wrestled him underneath her, pinning him down on his back. She grinded her vulva against the base of his cock.

She looked down at the handsome stallion beneath her, biting her lips in anticipation. She felt her fluids leak down on his sheath and balls. “Have you ever done it like this?”

Pip shook his head, his dark brown eyes not leaving her own.

“Yeah, this isn’t a very comfortable position when you’re ten months pregnant,” Cheerilee said, “but that’s not a problem anymore, isn’t it?” She pressed her belly to his, hugging his erect stallionhood between her udders, and brought her face right in front of his.

“You’ve been so patient, Pip. You’ve helped us with our foals, and soon you’ll be our husband. Now, let me take good care of you. Are you ready?”

Pip nodded. Cheerilee licked his face, smearing him with her saliva. She pushed back against him so she could sit on his crotch again.

Cheerilee lifted her rear and guided his tip to her sweet supple folds. “Oh, yes,” she moaned as the flare gently parted her entrance. Without waiting, she pressed down, slipping that wonderful length into her winking, needy snatch. Slowly, she took more and more of his stallionhood into her warm, silky vagina. Soon enough, she felt his nice, firm balls rubbing her asshole; she had taken his entire shaft into her foal canal, feeling his tip pushing at her cervix.

Cheerilee stayed there, teasing Pip and herself with regular contractions. He looked so cute, with his head rolled back and a blissful grin on his lips. She took his hoof and pushed it deeply into her lower belly. She smirked as his eyes grew wide. “Mmh, do you feel it? Yes, that’s you… that’s your cock, and it’s sooo~ deep in me.”

Cheerilee lifted her rump up and down a few times, settling for a slow, sensual rhythm. “Oooh… mmh… you’ve never fucked a mare… umm… while she wasn’t pregnant… oh yes… isn’t that right?”

She accelerated her thrusts, taking him harder into her well lubed vagina. “Yeah… oh yes… ah~ You’ll see it’s… mmh… when I’ll make you cum… mmh~ your seed won’t leak out of my cunt… oh, yeah… it’s going to get deep inside me, inside my womb. Ah! Mmh… And one day, we’ll do this again while I’m in heat. You’ll fill up my womb… with your seed. You’ll ejaculate your foal in me. A little filly or c-colt that… that we will have made together. Ah!~”

Cheerilee took her young stallion with fast, smooth strokes. The constant penetrations built her pleasure as the stallionhood in her snatch rubbed against her sensitive inner flesh.

Pip had always been a great student, and that had not stopped when they’d started dating. To his old teacher’s delighted surprise, he remembered her earlier lessons on how to pleasure a mare and stroked her winking clit with his hoof. This immediately raised her pleasure tenfold, making her whinny in ecstasy, “oooh, yeeeessss!”

Barely, Cheerilee contained her orgasm and instead increased her pace as she fucked her former student with wild intensity, making him moan with every penetration. After a few seconds, he gasped and she felt his tip flare in her canal.

Cheerilee slammed back down a final time and let herself orgasm around him. She collapsed, holding her stallion in a tight grip like she was afraid he’d disappear if she’d ever let go. She faced him, her eyes lost into his. “Aaahhh, do it! C-cum in my meeee~”

She pressed her muzzle into his, exchanging a deep kiss as she felt his tip stretch her cervix. Thick, virile seed gushed directly into her womb, the beautiful stallion underneath her shuddering as he coated a mare’s uterus for the first time.

She kept pleasuring Pip with her vagina, enjoying each twitch and moan she got from him. His seed pooled deep in her womb, filling the space that had been occupied by Rain Hearth until Cheerilee birthed the filly. Though she wasn’t in heat, and nor was she ready for another child just yet, she kind of wished Pip had given her a little brother or sister for her foal right there.

Once Pip grew limp and Cheerilee’s orgasm ebbed, she pulled off him and rolled on her back, letting his flaccid stallionhood drop back on his tummy. She simply relished the feeling of his gooey semen in her.

“That was awesome, Cheery,” he said, panting as he recovered from his own climax, his eyes half-lidded as his body was filled with a relaxing afterglow.

“Thanks, I love you, Pip.” She felt a certain warmth in her heart as she pronounced the words; it was the first time she'd said she loved him. It had felt too soon before, too pushy. But they were engaged now, he would soon join her herd. One day he would give her a foal like Big Mac had before him.

“I love you too.” He kissed her and rubbed her tummy.

She placed his hoof on her abdomen. “Right there. That’s where you left your cum, made me all messy inside. I still feel it in my womb, it’s so nice and warm.”

A loud whinny from Sugar Belle brought Cheerilee and Pip back to reality. They had phased out the rest of the herd during their lovemaking, but now it looked like Big Mac, Sugar Belle and Fluttershy were about to reach their climaxes. Cheerilee and Pip turned around and settled down to watch the threesome.

They were doing such nice things, too. Big Mac was ravaging Fluttershy, pounding her from behind as he took his pleasure in the pegasus swollen, oozing snatch. Fluttershy herself had her muzzle buried in Sugar Belle feverishly winking vulva, moaning constantly as she suckled the unicorn’s engorged clitoris.

Sugar Belle screamed, arching her spine and painted Fluttershy’s face with her marecum as she came. Big Mac hilted in the pegasus’ pussy and let out a low growl as he emptied the content of his heavy balls into Fluttershy’s welcoming womb and made her cum with a quiet gasp.

Cheerilee and Pip joined them and caressed the climaxing ponies, helping them transition into a blissful aftermath. Soon, all five ponies collapsed onto the mattress, gently cuddling and whispering loving words into each other’s ears.

~ ❀ ~

Half an hour later, the herd was hanging out in the kitchen, ponies gulping down holiday cakes and other festive snacks together.

“Alright everypony! Now that we all got a chance to blow off some steam after four months of sex break, why don’t we share our ‘Naughty Gifts’?” Sugar Belle proposed. “I can’t wait to see what you all brought.”

“That sounds like a mighty fine plan, sugarcube,” Big Mac approved.

The ‘Naughty Gifts’ had been Cheerilee’s idea. She had suggested that everypony would bring a sexy gift for the entire herd for Hearth’s Warming Eve. Obviously, the five secret packages had not been placed under the Hearth’s Warming tree with the rest of the family’s presents, but hidden until the foals were sent away.

Soon, the herd was lounging on the plush carpet in front of the fireplace. Each pony held a wrapped box holding their Naugthy Gifts.

“Which gift should we open first?” Fluttershy asked.

“Hmm, let’s select somepony at random, then we can go clockwise,” Sugar Belle answered. She levitated a nearby writing feather and dropped it in the middle of the circle they formed. The feather wobbled around before touching the ground, the tip pointing…

“Pip, you’re first!”

“Okay, sure!” Pip produced a long box and placed it in front of Sugar Belle.

The unicorn unwrapped and opened the present, revealing a set of five butt plugs, each ornate with a gem matching one the ponies’ coat color.

“Whoa, Pip! This is amazing!” Sugar Belle exclaimed, lifting the pink plug in her magic. The toy was composed of a short, rounded tip - which got narrower near the hilt so it would be held by the user’s anal sphincter -, a large base and a small handle which held the colored jewel.

“Oh… my…” Fluttershy looked wide eyed at the toys.

Cheerilee had never used a plug like these before. “Can we try them right now? Do we have lube somewhere?”

“Yeah! I got a bottle right here,” Pip replied. “Let’s put them on.”

Cheerilee grabbed the floating toy by the protruding gem with her teeths, then shot a saucy look at Sugar Belle. “Need some help with that, Belle?”

Sugar Belle grinned and lifted the bottle of lube, squeezing it over the toy’s tip. The alpha mare then presented her rump to Cheerilee, lifting her tail to allow access to her privates. Cheerilee gently pushed the plug into Sugar Belle’s ass, seeing the cute pink hole open as it swallowed the toy.

“Oooh~! This is so nice,” the unicorn commented, giving her rump a little shake. “Now show me your adorable little ponut, sweetie.” She picked and lubed the purple plug.

Cheerilee more than willingly showed her asshole to her alpha. The toy soon settled in her tight anus, followed by a kiss from the unicorn on her vulva. The toy indeed felt nice in her butt, giving her a constant, but discrete, pleasure.

Meanwhile, Pip was busy helping Fluttershy and Big Mac with their own plugs. Wanting to see what inserting the plug in a stallion looked like, Cheerilee grabbed and lubed the last plug - the one with a white gem. She approached Pip, who noticed her and willingly presented his backside. He had a really cute ass. Cheerilee pushed the toy in and - taking notes from Sugar Belle - kissed his beautiful balls.

Once they all had their plug inserted, they settled back down onto the floor.

“Oh, I like this,” Fluttershy commented, wiggling her butt. “That’s very thoughtful, Pip.”

“Thanks! But how about you show us your gift?” Pip replied.

“Oh… right. Here it is.” Fluttershy presented a tiny box, which produced soft tinkling sounds when handled, and offered it to Pip.

He unwrapped the package, revealing four miniature bottles of green potion, each tagged with a name: Big Mac, Pipsqueak, Sugar Belle, and Cheerilee.

“What’s this, Fluttershy?” Cheerilee asked, looking at the otherwise nondescript potions.

“Um, I asked Zecora to make these. Each dose of the potion is separated into two bottles. When two creatures each drink a bottle, they will swap their bodies, becoming the other for a while… Zecora made Angel and me drink this potion once, so I ended up spending the whole day as a bunny while Angel made a mess of the Sanctuary.”

Fluttershy noticed everypony looking wide eyed at her. She immediately withdrew, hiding behind her hairs. “Oh no, you h-hate it, don’t y-you? Oh, I’m so sorry that was a bad idea. I’ll just bring it back to Zecora-”

“Fluttershy!” Sugar Belle interrupted her, “this is amazing!”

Fluttershy moved her bangs out of her eyes. “Oh, so you do like it?”

“It’s incredible!” Cheerilee added. “You mean I’ll get to try being a stallion for a day?”

“Um, yes. I’m just not sure which one exactly; I mixed the stallions’ tags when I packed the bottles, so I don't know which mare they pair with. It will be a surprise, I guess…”

“I vote to save these for later and move on for now,” Sugar Belle suggested. Everypony agreed.

They continued the round of Naugthy Gifts. Big Mac had brought a flogging paddle, which could be used to slap other ponies’ rump. He demonstrated the toy on Sugar Belle butt, eliciting an excited yelp from the unicorn.

Sugar Belle’s gift contained a set of restraints for bondage. It included a muzzle bind, a bridle, a collar, a strap to link the wearer’s tail with the collar, a blindfold, and a rope. For some reason, everypony looked at Fluttershy.

Finally, it was Cheerilee’s turn. With a smirk, she gave her large, flat package to Sugar Belle.

The unicorn unwrapped the present, revealing a slim pink book. “Cum Cakes,” Sugar Belle read. “Wait, WHAT!?”

Cheerilee busted out laughing, “HAHAHA! Bon Bon told me about this a few weeks ago, and I just had to get it for our ‘Naugthy Gifts’! It’s just so crazy.”

Sugar Belle snorted loudly, barely holding her laughter. “This is either the coolest or most disgusting thing I've ever seen. Is that even for real?” The unicorn opened the book, browsing through pages. “Wait… That’s an actual cookbook for making desserts with stallion semen. There’s recipes and everything!”

“Oh, my…” Fluttershy commented.

“Well, what about you boys?” Cheerilee asked the two stallions with a wink. “Would you two like to provide the missing ingredient?”

Big Mac and Pip shared a look, more than a little perplexed. “Uh… maybe?” Pip eventually offered.

“Oooh, this looks promising!” Sugar Belle commented as she explored the book, “‘Cupcake frosting: for delicious cumcakes’. Oh, I really wanna try it now.”

And so, the herd found itself in the kitchen, watching Sugar Belle prepare her baking supplies. “So… we need to prepare the base for the frosting, cool it, stir in the seed from our handsome stallions, then leave it in the icebox for an hour,” the unicorn said, reading from the book, “then we can make the cupcakes.”

“Well, what are we waiting for?” Cheerilee asked, sensually looking at Big Mac.

As Sugar Belle prepared the sugary base of the frosting, Cheerilee passed a bottle to Fluttershy so she could ‘milk’ Pip while she did the same with Big Mac.

Getting Big Mac erect was pretty easy, especially when he had a plug inserted in his rectum. After just a few licks, Cheerilee swallowed his hardening sex into her throat and started to blow him properly.

“Uh, honey…” Big Mac interrupted after a couple minutes. Cheerilee felt him flare and pulled out. She placed the tip against the bottle’s opening just in time to catch the first load of thick, musky horse spunk. She licked Big Mac’s glans, encouraging the stallion to empty his big, bulging balls into the reservoir. Once the ejaculation stopped, Cheerilee closed the bottle and cleaned Big Mac’s tip with a lick. She brought the flask to eye level. The glass now contained an impressive amount of gooey semen. Fluttershy brought her own bottle filled with Pip’s seed.

“Alright, we’re ready to finish the frosting,” Sugar Belle said. “Uh, boys, would you be more comfortable trying the cumcakes if I made two batches of frosting, so you only have to taste the other one’s cupcakes?”

“Uh, sure…” Pip replied.

“Yup…”

Sugar Belle tagged two bowls with each stallion’s name and splitted the frosting. She measured one cup of semen from Fluttershy’s bottle and stirred it into the ‘Pip’ bowl, then did the same with Cheerilee’s bottle in the ‘Big Mac’ bowl. She covered both mixes and placed them in the icebox.

“Ok, now… let’s make these cupcakes,” Sugar Belle said. “Cheery, can you get the milk?”

Cheerilee gave her wife a sultry look. “Which milk did you want, sweetie?”

Sugar Belle froze. She snorted, giggling. “Oh, you are so bad… I love it! Come here, I’m going to milk you. Shy, you too.”

Cheerilee felt her teats manipulated by Sugar Belle’s magical grasp, the unicorn milking the content of her udders into a bowl. She then switched to Fluttershy, who gave a quiet “Eep!” as her sweet, creamy milk was harvested.

Taking the mares’ milk, Sugar Belle mixed the cupcake batter and poured it in muffin cups.

“Oh, this is going to be amazing,” Cheerilee gleefully commented as Sugar Belle put the cupcakes in the oven.

~ ❀ ~

Later that night, Pip was hanging out with the herd in the living room. It was a quieter, more sensual Hearth’s Warming Eve celebration than the one they had hosted the night before with the whole family, where the herd had proposed to him. They had shared a romantic, candlelit dinner while drinking the cellar’s best wines.

Pip was sitting next to the hearth, cuddling Fluttershy, enjoying the contact of his fur against her long, silky hairs, occasionally nuzzling the mare. In front of them, Big Mac was lovingly making out with Cheerilee.

“Alright everypony!” Sugar Belle said, arriving with a platter from the kitchen, “here is our very own, herd-flavored desserts… cumcakes!”

Pip curiously examined the platter. It contained a dozen vanilla cupcakes made with Fluttershy and Cheerilee’s milk. Each was now topped with a delicate white frosting, made from Mac and Pip’s semen. Half of the cupcakes had an apple slice on top, while the other half each had a cherry.

“The ones with Big Mac’s seed are the ones with an apple,” Sugar Belle explained, “and the ones with a cherry are Pip’s.”

Pip hesitated, but he had to admit it felt pretty hot to see cupcakes made from their fluids. After that time with Big Mac on Nightmare Night, he often had sex with the other stallion, and he had tasted his gooey, bitter seed several time. It couldn’t be worse when mixed with a bunch of sugar, so he picked one of the apple themed cupcakes.

“That’s the spirit, Pip,” Sugar Belle cheered. “C’mon, give it a taste.”

Courageously, Pip took a small bite of the cupcake, stallion frosting included. To his surprise, the taste wasn’t bad at all; he definitely tasted the musk and saltiness of Big Mac’s sperm, but the sugar took away the worst of the bitterness. The cupcake itself, made with fresh creamy mare milk, was tasty and moist. Pip gulped the cupcake in a few big bites, happily swallowing it.

The others were watching Pip expectantly, awaiting his verdict.

“Mmh, it’s actually pretty good!”

The herd grinned and each pony took a cupcake. Pip felt a peculiar thrill as he watched Cheerilee and Big Mac each taste a cupcake made from his own seed, seeing the bulge of their throat as they took his frosted semen into their guts.

“Wow, you’re right,” Sugar Belle commented, licking the remnants of Mac’s frosting from her lips. “I can’t believe that actually worked alright…”

“Mmhmm,” Fluttershy agreed. “Though, we should eat them all before our foals come back after tomorrow…”

Cheerilee giggled. “I would not want to explain why these cupcakes are ‘mommies-only’. It would blow their adorable little minds.”

The herd laughed, chatting merrily as they gulped the naugthy treats.

The five ponies eventually made their way to the bedroom, excited to mate with each other once more.

“Did you four, um, want to try the potions now?” Fluttershy asked timidly.

“In a minute, but first we’d like to thank you properly for the amazing gift,” Sugar Belle said, a predatory glint in her eye.

“Oh?”

Sugar Belle lifted the bit and bridle, as well as the matching straps and collar. Fluttershy’s eyes grew wide. “Oh… my…”

“Is that alright with you?” the alpha mare asked. “We don’t want to make you uncomfortable.”

“Oh no, it’s okay. It looks wonderful… I’m just teensy-bit nervous.”

“That mighty fine, you just tell us if ya wanna stop,” Big Mac reassured her.

The four ponies cornered the shy pegasus. Sugar Belle passed the bridle around her muzzle, and inserted the bit in her mouth; with it, Fluttershy could speak, albeit with some difficulty.

Cheerilee collared the mare, and passed the strap to Pip. He clamped the ring around Fluttershy’s pink, smooth tail, then attached the strap to its anchor at the back of the collar. The black strap was pretty short, so it forced Fluttershy’s fluffy tail up on her back, keeping the pegasus in a very compromising position, her most private parts exposed to any nearby onlookers. Pip gave her a kiss on her flushed folds, making her squirm.

Big Mac rolled Fluttershy on her back, and hogtied the mare with the last rope. Finally, Sugar Belle blindfolded her. Fluttershy looked so cute like that, blinded and helpless, her leaky vulva freely accessible.

“So, any of you stallions want to enjoy our little pegasus?” Sugar Belle proposed with a smirk.

Fluttershy opened her mouth as if to say something, but Sugar Belle shushed her with a hoof. “Hush now, Shy. Not a word. If you need us to stop, you can say so… but, until then, we decide how we want to enjoy your sexy body.

The pegasus just nodded.

“Do ya wanna try her ass, Pip?” Big Mac asked.

Pip agreed, “oh, yeah, that would be fun. I never had mare in the ass before. Do you want her pussy too?”

Big Mac nodded.

“Oh, this is so hot, you’re taking her together?” Cheerilee commented, her hoof rubbing her own wet snatch.

“Eeyup! Pip, lube up in her cunt. Ah’ll get in her after.”

With a grin, Pip licked Fluttershy’s excited pussy a few times to make sure she was ready, then pinned her under him. His tip met her winking sex and swiftly slipped inside her vagina.

Pip felt a naugthy thrill as he penetrated his mare without even asking her permission, violating the pegasus’ silky smooth vagina. His entire shaft was soon coated in her fluids, so he pulled out of her, making her gasp.

Big Mac untied Fluttershy’s legs so he could spread her hips. He mounted her, pressing her into the mattress and entering her puffy marehood. He gave her a few rough thrusts, then rolled onto his back, taking the pegasus along with him.

With Fluttershy on top, belly to belly with Mac, Pip had perfect access to her exposed ass. He gently grabbed the butt plug still obstructing her hole and pulled it out, revealing her gaping rectum. It looked so lovely, there just above the pussy Big Mac occupied. Pip’s stallionhood, still drenched in her vaginal lubricant, quickly found its way into the loose tunnel. After a few thrusts in Fluttershy’s welcoming anus, Pip hilted his entire shaft inside her.

Pip had taken Big Mac’s ass a few times in the last couple months, so he wasn’t a complete novice. Fluttershy’s rectum felt much the same as Mac’s, though she was definitely tighter. However, Pip had not been expecting to feel the bigger stallion’s penis through the thin membranes separating Shy’s bowels and vagina. It was so exciting to rub against the other stallion while inside their shared mare.

“Oh, yeah… you stallions have fun with our little pet,” Cheerilee said, still masturbating with Sugar Belle, “but don’t have too much fun. We’re trying your handsome stallion bodies next, and we don’t want you to cum before we get to try it.”

“Mmhmm,” Sugar Belle moaned approvingly.

Both stallions nodded and went to work on the bound pegasus. Instead of focusing on their own pleasure, they instead proceeded to stimulate Fluttershy’s entire body, using their hooves, mouths, and cocks. They bit her ears, stroked her wings, licked her mane, rubbed her clit and, of course, pounded her holes.

Fluttershy, sandwiched between her two stallions, caressed everywhere, quickly reached her peak. She let out a long “Aaaah!” around the bit in her muzzle as she came, her vagina and rectum trying to milk the stallions for their seed.

Pip pulled out his hard, flared stallionhood out of her tailhole. He almost came just from the cool outside air on his shaft, but he managed to hold himself.

Pip did his best to think about that one time he went bowling with other town hall’s employees. The incredibly dull memory actually worked wonders, making his erection shrink considerably. While Big Mac disentangled himself from the spent Fluttershy and proceeded to remove her collar and bridle, Pip washed his own stallionhood with an antiseptic wipe.

“Mmmh, that was wonderful,” Fluttershy said quietly. “It’s too bad you couldn’t fill me with your seed, but I came so hard.”

“Oh, so you can talk now, sweetie? I thought our stallions broke you for a moment.” Cheerilee giggled. “Well, can you show us how to use your potions now? I think I’m ready to be a stallion.”

“Of course.” Fluttershy distributed the four tiny bottles to their assigned pony.

Pip examined his bottle. It was a simple glass container with a cork containing a green potion, just enough liquid for a single sip. On a tag tied to the bottleneck, the word ‘Pipsqueak’ was written in Fluttershy’s elegant, flowing cursives.

“Okay everypony, each potion has a pair. Like I said, I’m not sure which pony has your pair, but I’m quite sure Cheerilee and Sugar Belle are not together. So, when you all swallow the potion, you will swap body with somepony of the other gender.”

Pip was quite excited. He looked at Cheerilee and Sugar Belle, feeling a thrill knowing he would soon be one of these two gorgeous mares.

They all uncorked the bottles. “To your health!” Sugar Belle toasted before gulping down her potion. Pip, Cheerilee and Big Mac downed their dose.

The potion didn’t taste much, just blend herbs. Pip waited for a few seconds, the liquid flowing down in his stomach. With no warning whatsoever, the world instantly shifted around him and he fell face first into the bed. He felt… different.

The first thing Pip noticed was the long curly purple mane he felt on his head. Instead of white and brown, the hoof he brought to touch his hairs was a brilliant shade of pink. He touched his face, exploring his new, shorter mare muzzle. His hoof bumped with something on his forehead: an unicorn’s horn.

He was in Sugar Belle’s body. “Woah- uh?” Pip exclamation was cut short when the sound came out with a much higher pitch than usual, a feminine voice.

“Oh, wow, I’m huge!” Cheerilee exclaimed near him, with Big Mac’s bass voice, but without the usual drawl. She jumped to the floor, crashing down then getting up undeterred. She looked down at her new stallion body. “Woah, you all look so small. My little ponies, hahaha!”

Sugar Belle, in Pip’s own body, jumped down next to her, a little more gracefully since he was closer to her own natural height. “Hang on, I’m going to get the big mirror.”

She trotted toward the bedroom's door… only to slam her head on it. “Ow!” She rubbed her face. “I forgot… you don’t have a horn, Pip…” She opened the door with her hooves and dragged in the large, full height mirror from the bathroom. All four ponies huddled together so they could look at their new bodies.

Pip curiously prodded his new horn. “Do you think I can use magic with your horn?” he asked Sugar Belle.

“I don’t know, maybe,” she said with Pip’s own voice. “Magic takes a long time to learn, but you can try lighting it up. If you focus, you should feel a kind current through the horn.”

Closing his eyes, Pip focused his attention on the sensitive horn. With a start, he realised he did feel a tingling sensation in it, like a calm wind blowing along the fluting.

This is so strange…

“You feel it? Good, now just absorb the ether into it.”

Pip wasn’t too sure how to do that, but it turned out to be incredibly simple. The horn’s spiral drained the energy around it, gorging itself with power.

Looking through the mirror, Pip saw Sugar Belle’s horn surrounded by an unstable aura. Interestingly, the magic was not cyan like Sugar Belle usual aura: it was orange.

My magic…

“Woah!” Pip exclaimed.

He looked around, trying to find something to levitate. He settled on Cheerilee’s alarm clock. His orange aura immediately surrounded the device. Pip could feel the object, as if grasping it at a distance with an unknown phantom limb. He tried to move it.

In an instant, Pip lost control of the magic. A bolt of energy struck the alarm clock, shattering it. The aura around Sugar Belle’s horn violently dispersed, leaving behind an intense, deep pain. “OW!”

Everypony surrounded him, looking concerned.

“Pip! You alright?” Sugar Belle asked.

He rubbed the sore horn. “Yeah, uh… I’m fine. I guess I shouldn’t try using magic for now.” The pain was starting to fade.

“That would probably be for the best,” Fluttershy agreed.

Cheerilee playfully nibbled his ears. “Don’t worry, there’s another type of magic I’d like to show you,” she said with her deep stallion voice. She went behind his rump and licked his sensitive pussy. Pip jumped at the sensation; he had almost forgotten he was a mare now.

“Let’s get into bed,” Sugar Belle suggested. “I want to play with your parts, Pip.”

They hopped back on the herd-size bed.

Pip contorted, doing his best to explore Sugar Belle’s lower body. There was no sheath nor balls between his hindlegs, just a smooth crotch. On his lower abdomen, there were two swollen masses that jiggled pleasantly as he moved: Sugar Belle’s udders, each filled with her rich, creamy milk. He played with those for a moment, then explored further down.

His hooves soon met with the slit of his vulva. Touching his marehood sent pleasurable sensation throughout his body. Arousal manifested itself differently as a mare than as a stallion; instead of spreading outside in his sheath and balls, it flowed deep inside, making him loose and wet.

As he masturbated his wet snatch, he thought about the udders and the teats. “Uh, Fluttershy, can you, um… m-milk me?”

“Oh, of course Bel- uh, Pip.” The pegasus brought her face to one of the teats and suckled. Pip felt a pleasant, calm feeling as he fed Fluttershy like a filly.

Big Mac, in Cheerilee’s body, soon approached and joined the pegasus. He suckled on the second teat, tasting Pip’s creamy mare milk.

A minute later, both udders were empty. Fluttershy wiped her muzzle. “Feels good, isn’t it? Feeding your foals?”

“Yeah…”

Fluttershy moved on to Big Mac udders, and started to drink Cheerilee’s milk too. Curious, Pip suckled at the second teat. Sweet milk surged from the udder, filling his muzzle with the delicious taste of a mare. He swallowed the entire content of Mac’s udder, feeling the luscious substance settle in his stomach.

“So, how do I taste?” Cheerilee asked gaily, playing with her cock and balls as Pip pulled off from Mac.

Pip licked his lips. “Mmh, perfect. It’s worth being a foal just for having this all the time.”

Cheerilee pulled him toward her. Since Pip was in an unicorn body, he didn’t have access to his latent earth magic: Cheerilee, with Big Mac size and power, was overwhelmingly strong. She dominated him completely. She pressed the big red muzzle against his cute pink snout and kissed him.

“Pip,” she said with Mac’s deep voice, “I’m going to show you how it feels to be a mare.”

Cheerilee grabbed his flank and lapped at his pussy. She had obviously done this many times before, her tongue skillfully caressing his vulva’s most sensitive zones. She sometimes suckled on his engorged clit, making him shudder with intense pleasure.

“Oh, yes, yes~ hmmm… YES! Ah! Hmm…” Pip screamed loudly with Sugar Belle’s cute voice. His clit was now continuously serviced by Cheerilee, making him orgasm within seconds.

“Kyaah~ Hmm…” Pip buried his face in the mattress, trying to muffle his feminine screams.

Orgasm felt very different as a mare. His entire vagina contracted several times around nothing, making him feel achingly empty. When he came down from the peak, he realized he wasn’t drowsy at all; he wanted more. He desperately wanted something to fill his unoccupied foal canal.

Cheerilee lightly rubbed his gaping snatch, teasing him. “Want something, sweetie?”

“Hmm, yeah… please.”

“What do you want? My big handsome cock?

“Yeah…”

“Well, where do you want it?” Cheerilee teased.

“Urg, i-inside. In my pussy. Please…”

“So, you want me to take you as my mare, so I can fill you up with my foal? Oh, well, since you ask nicely…”

Cheerilee mounted him and pushed his head down. His curly purple tail politely moved aside, offering his marehood to the stallion on top of him. His labia kissed her swollen glans.

“Now, you stay put like a good filly so I can enjoy your body,” Cheerilee said, rubbing his cupcake cutie marks.

She entered his folds, making him gasp. In one flowing motion, Cheerilee filled him with her stallionhood. To Pip, the throbbing erection in his silky depths felt absolutely amazing. He could feel it deep inside his vagina, even poking at his cervix.

It was very comfortable. Unlike when he had taken it in his rectum, the cock in his pussy felt perfectly at home, gliding against the sensitive inner walls that were meant to take it.

Noticing Fluttershy masturbating right in front of him, Pip dragued her rump toward him so he could bury his pink muzzle into her swollen udders, sucking her teats. Fluttershy’s creamy milk flowed in his throat as Cheerilee buried her stallionhood in his foal-canal.

“Oh, Belle!” Cheerilee exclaimed. “Your pussy feels… mmh, so good!”

“Yes, yours too! No wonder our stallions always want to mount us… this is amazing,” Sugar Belle replied while thrusting in Big Mac’s cunt with Pip’s body.

“Wanna try your own?” Cheerilee asked, still thrusting into Pip’s twitching vagina.

Pip felt awfully empty when Cheerilee pulled Mac’s erect penis from his swollen marehood. He whinied, trying to get the thick member back inside by pushing back toward her hips, but she just pinned him down and slid out of his cunt. The big red stallion body left his back, leaving Pip dripping mare fluids from his gaping hole as he suckled Fluttershy’s erect teat.

Fortunately, another stallion’s body took the vacant spot on his back. Pip saw his own white-spotted-brown forelegs grasp him from behind as Sugar Belle mounted him. He felt his own, wet stallionhood and balls rubbing on his back.

“Ready for this?” Sugar Belle asked him with his own voice.

Pip felt incredible relief as is vagina was once again filled with a cock. Sugar Belle hilted inside him, letting the balls rub his clit. Pip could feel his own stallionhood deep in his borrowed foal canal, sensing the thunderous pony heartbeat in the hardened member.

“I’m going to show you how it feels when your stallion takes your pussy, when he cum inside and claims your womb for his foal.” Sugar Belle moaned, thrusting hard and fast into him. “Pip! Your cock feels so good in my pussy, it’s so sensitive! I’m going to cum inside, and there’s nothing you can do about it! Aaah~!”

Pip felt the glans deep in his vagina flare and push at his cervix. Sugar Belle hugged him tight from behind and hilted the cock deep inside one final time. The intense sensation pushed Pip back over the edge and made him orgasm a second time. His tight vagina shuddered around the stallionhood in him, milking it for its seed. He let go of Fluttershy’s teats, letting her masturbate.

Something gooey and warm gushed in Pip’s womb; it pooled deep in his abdomen, filling his uterus. Sugar Belle cried out her pleasure, unloading her balls deep into her own twitching body.

It was amazing to be filled like this, being ejaculated into by a loving stallion.

When Sugar Belle went limp on top of him, Pip finally relaxed with her, feeling utterly satisfied with his second orgasm, and the load of cum settling in his belly. The softening penis slipped out of his snatch, giving him one last dose of lovely pleasure. Sugar Belle rolled off him, her blissful afterglow showing on Pip’s burrowed face.

Seconds later, Cheerilee and Big Mac - still in each other’s body - dropped down next to them, also enjoying the aftermath of their union.

With a throaty moan, Fluttershy joined the pony pile, hooves still slick from her intense masturbation. “Oh, that was marvelous!”

“Eeyup!” four ponies responded at once.

Cum oozing between his legs from his vagina, his stomach pleasantly full of warm pony milk, Pip slipped into a deep, restful slumber.

~ ❀ ~

Wednesday, December 26th, Year 8 of Princess Twilight

Sugar Belle awoke the next morning, still in Pip’s handsome body, the stallionhood between her legs annoyingly hard. Her borrowed bladder felt uncomfortably full too. She begrudgingly got out of bed.

That’s what they call a ‘morning wood’? Uh, it’s no fun at all… and kind of painful.

Sugar Belle arrived at the toilet, not even sure what to do. She tentatively lifted the seat.

Urg, how do stallions even aim this thing?

The hard shaft was pointing straight forward, so Sugar Belle couldn’t even aim after mounting the bowl. She twisted her spine, used her hoof to push down the tip. She even tried to use her magic, before realising she still didn’t have her horn.

Once she managed to more or less target the toilet, she noticed it was difficult to actually get the urine to flow through the rigid shaft. Sugar Belle managed to relax the internal muscles and pee in a powerful but unsteady flow, generating a splashing sound as it impacted toilet water. She felt the bladder emptying, and eventually the stream halted.

Ah! Nothing to it.

Feeling quite proud of herself, Sugar Belle dismounted the toilet, only to feel a watery puddle on the floor. Looking down, she noticed the mess.

Oh, fucking hell!

Author's Note

Lyrics are from “The Heart Carol” (Extended version). The text is adapted from the My Little Pony Friendship is Magic Wiki.

Also, as it turns out, writing a sex scene with 5 characters, 4 of which having been body-swapped with another character’s of opposite gender, is kind of tricky. Who would have thought?

I hoped it remained mostly understandable (and enjoyable)!