Super Secret Petting

You lay upon the bed, with two cute little ponies flanking you on both sides, their heads resting on your thighs. The pegasus known as Rainbow Dash was on the right and the earth pony you knew as Pinkie Pie on the left. Your massive cock stood tall and proud into the air between said mares. It stood 35 to 40 inches long, and 6 to 8 inches thick. They had a supermassive cock to worship to their heart’s content. A dark shadow loomed over them as they lay beneath your towering member.

You had two lovely pony butts to play with. Even Rainbow Dash’s rump with her thin, overall athletic body had a rather thick, round, bubble-butt shape to it. Pinkie Pie’s rump on the other hand was much more pronounced in thickness, and slightly more saggy with the extra fat content. That came with a plus side, her rear tended to be far more bouncy, and jiggly when she walked when compared to Rainbow’s. Nonetheless, Pinkie Pie had a very smoothly shaped, round rump despite her being substantially thicker than Rainbow. What’s more, Pinkie’s thighs and legs were much thicker, which complemented her even further. This made her rump seem even larger over Rainbow’s rump.

You had the best of both worlds. Rainbow’s tight, cute small butt. And Pinkie’s big fat ghetto booty to join alongside it.

Pinkie Pie was by no means not athletic. She was probably physically stronger than Rainbow with her being an earth pony. She was just a little on the chubby side due to her inhaling large amounts of cakes, sweets, and other sugary goods into her body on a daily basis.

Currently, these mares were licking your hands as you petted each of their respective cheeks upon their faces. Pinkie Pie was giggling as you pet her, Rainbow on the other hand was making a series of moans and happy horse sounds as you pet her.

They seemed content for quite some time just to lick your hands as you pet them. You were not annoyed. There was no rush. The mares were content to make cute happy sounds as you gave them non-stop pets.

Eventually, one of them decided to move on. Tentatively, Pinkie Pie leaned her head toward your left ball-sack. She opened her mouth as she approached, taking out her large tongue, which was considerably larger than Rainbow's.

You moaned softly as Pinkie began to gently lick your left ball with enthusiastic swipes of her tongue over it. Pinkie for her part was giggling in joy at the taste of your salty ball against her tongue. In no time at all your ball was drenched in her saliva.

Rainbow soon joined Pinkie Pie. She leaned her head toward your right ball-sack, opening her mouth and taking out her large equine tongue. The pegasus moaned softly as she licked your hefty ballsack with great swings of her wet appendage upon it.

Loud slurping could be heard in the room as the two mares licked your balls with great eagerness. You found yourself moaning in bliss at the feeling. The two mares moaned at the taste of your man-flesh.

Pinkie Pie made a dramatic gasping sound as she opened her muzzle wide, before lovingly taking your left ball into her mouth. Rainbow stopped licking your hand, and soon joined her on the other side, and took your right ball into her mouth. The two mares uttered deep, throaty moans as they sucked heartily on your testicles.

Through their ball-licking, you continued to pet them with eagerness. However, you soon wished to pet them someplace else. Slowly, you moved both of your hands down their bodies, away from their faces. You didn't want to upset them by pulling your hands away. Your hands gently caressed their soft fur as your hands rolled down their necks. The mares trembled at your touch. Your hands soon made contact with their upper backs.

You stopped advancing from there. You made to gently rub your left hand back and forth over Pinkie Pie's upper back. This caused you to hear for the first time Pinkie Pie make a muffled, happy, horsey whinny sound around her mouthful. You could see a splash of her creamy goodness escape out of her marehood, wetting the bed below her.

As for Rainbow, you had something far more special for her in mind. With loving tenderness, you began to gently stroke Rainbow's wings. You smiled from hearing Rainbow utter a loud, muffled neigh around your ball in her mouth.

Repeatedly, without mercy nor pity you rubbed Rainbow’s wings. She ceased her ball-sucking, she merely held your ball in her mouth. Your tender strokes upon her wings caused her body to shake erratically like she was having an electric shock. The mare was constantly uttering muffled neighs and moans as you relentlessly pet her wings. In some, regards you had Rainbow completely paralyzed. You didn't mind that Rainbow wasn't paying you full attention. You were motivated to pet the hell out of her to see her so happy. It still felt nice to have your ball resting in her mouth.

Rainbow was the embodiment of loyalty, at least according to the elements of harmony. This may translate with even more awesome blow jobs from her, due to your loving petting of her wings.

You kept your right hand in that area over her wings, making sure to keep Rainbow out of commission. You moved your left hand further down Pinkie’s back. Momentarily, you stopped to rub Pinkie Pie's lower back before moving onto her huge, fat rump. You moved your hand to touch Pinkie Pie's three blue balloons upon her cutie mark on her left asscheek.

You applied pressure, pushing your hand into her soft, plush rear. Your hand sank deeply into her squishy soft rump. You marveled at the sheer thickness of her ass, it was much thicker than Rainbow's. Eventually, you reach the hard muscles deep beneath the thicknesses of her fat bubbly rear. You kneaded the soft flesh between your fingers like pizza dough.

As much as you loved Pinkie Pie’s big fat ass. You wanted to feel up Rainbow’s lovely ass as well. You finally pulled your hand away from Rainbow’s wings. In reaction, Rainbow uttered a sad whine, and immediately released your ball out of her mouth with a loud pop.

Your heart ached at the hurt look of betrayal on her face. Her cute, rosy red eyes looked at you with a pleading doggy eye look.

Her mouth formed an ‘O’ shape upon feeling your hand coming to land on her right buttcheek on her cutie mark. She smiled at you, her sad look of betrayal leaving her face. She then gave you a small nod, before leaning her head back down, and taking your ball back into her mouth. Loud slurping and moans could be heard from her as she lovingly suckled on your ball-flesh.

You kneaded Rainbow’s ass alongside Pinkie’s ass. Rainbow’s ass was far less thicker than Pinkie’s, but you didn’t care. If you had a choice, you would still pick Rainbow’s ass over Pinkie’s ass. Rainbow Dash gave you a blow job on your first day in Equestria.

You lov…. err, trust her more than any other mare you ever met. Rainbow liked to act tough to hide her insecurities, but beneath it all, she was a softie. She was a cute little pony that loved to be petted and told how cool she is.

Pinkie released your ball with a loud pop. The mare left a soft kiss on your ball-sack with a well-defined smooching sound, before she brought out her large equine tongue. The mare tilted her head to the side as she began to lovingly lick your lower shaft with her long, thick tongue. Rainbow for her part was content to suckle on your right ball-sack.

Pinkie Pie’s swiping tongue drenched your cock in her saliva. She slowly moved up her head, traveling up your towering member. Eventually, she came to a point where she could not reach the top of your long, thick cock. This forced Pinkie Pie to stand up on her four legs.

Pinkie Pie licked her lips at the sight of your bloated tip below her head. “Watch me make this big cock disappear!” she exclaimed.

She took a deep breath and closed her eyes. She then opened her mouth wide and dropped her head to take the tip of your fat cock into her maw. You grunted, your legs kicking weakly from the feeling. In reaction, Pinkie uttered a muffled giggle around her mouthful. You watched in amazement as Pinkie Pie, seemingly without any issue took your cock slowly into her. Inch after inch of your cock vanished into her. It became quite clear Pinkie Pie had some sort of hyperspace inside her. She now had about half of your length inside her. 15 inches of long and thick cock.

And still, she kept going. Lower, and lower she went, until she eventually gently bumped her head against Rainbow’s, who was busy licking your left ball. Rainbow pulled her head away, allowing Pinkie Pie to go lower.

Pinkie Pie dropped her head down to your base…. and beyond. She sank even lower and took both of your balls into her mouth at the same time. You saw her cheek bloated from both of your balls inside her mouth.

Rainbow stared in utter shock, with her jaw dropped. “Pinkie… how did you do that. That’s impossible.”

Pinkie Pie quickly pulled her head back, releasing your cock with a loud pop. “Nothing is impossible.”

“But…” Rainbow began, before waving her hoof dismissively. “Well, you are Pinkie Pie. I should have known.”

“Yep. You want a turn sucking him off?”

Without a word, Rainbow stood up. The mare looked anxious as she stared down at your intimidating length below. You could not stand to see Rainbow being nervous. You reached your right hand out and gently began to pet her mane.

Rainbow sighed happily, closing her eyes with a look of bliss on her face. The mare dipped her head down and took your tip into her mouth. Slowly, Rainbow’s head sank lower and lower down your long, thick shaft. Inch after inch of your cock slipped inside her.

Unfortunately, you soon felt your cock bump against the back of her throat. Rainbow’s eyes opened to see she had not even reached halfway down the great length of your cock.

Rainbow frantically tried to take more of your length into her mouth, but all she managed to achieve was getting herself to choke on your cock. Rainbow quickly pulled her head back and released your cock with a loud pop.

The mare coughed and gasped for breath. “I-I…. I can’t do it.” she said in a low voice, tears falling down her cheeks.

You could not stand to see Rainbow so upset. You reached down and took the mare into your arms, and placed her on your chest on top of you. Her rosy red, badly bloodshot eyes lay before you. You used your left hand to guide your massive cock to rest between Rainbow’s buttcheeks. Once that was done, you placed your left hand on her cutie mark, and your right hand upon her mane.

Rainbow leaned her head into your shoulder and began to cry, her tears soaking your bare skin. Pinkie Pie found herself tearing up at the sight of Rainbow being so upset. Pinkie Pie lay herself down on your left, and leaned her head into the other shoulder, and began to cry as well.

You pet both mares manes. You felt a little guilty about having a massive erection standing tall and proud into the air between Rainbow’s ass cheeks. You petted, petted, and petted non-stop the poor distraught mares.

“Rainbow, I don’t care if you can’t take my freakishly large cock all the way into your mouth. I still…. love you.”

“I love you.. Anon! You're such an awesome dude.” came her muffled scream into your shoulder.

Nothing eventful happened for several minutes. You just kept petting both mares non-stop. Their cries slowly faded away to be replaced with happy whinnies, moans, and other horsey sounds.

Eventually, Rainbow lifted her head. “Can you do me first Anon?” she asked, a hopeful look on her face.

You answered her question by leaning down to kiss her forehead. You then quickly brought your right hand down to her other cutie mark. You did this to make sure you did not upset her with your hand’s absence from petting her mane.

With both hands on her ass, you tightly squeezed her cheeks. Both of your hands sank into her soft plush rear a good few inches, before meeting her hard, and firm muscles underneath. You kneaded the flesh of her ass, gently stroking her firm buttocks with nonstop strokes. At the same time, you thrust your long, big fat cock between her buttcheeks, hot dogging the cheeks of her ass.

Rainbow craned her neck back and uttered a deep throaty moan. The mare then leaned forward to take you into a passionate kiss. Human and pony lips and tongues joined together in tender intimacy. Your tongues swirled about in each other’s mouths.

Pinkie Pie lifted her head off your shoulder and made to position herself behind Rainbow. Pinkie leaned down, her head bumped against your member, causing it to slip away from Rainbow's buttcheeks.

Pinkie used this opportunity to slip her head between Rainbow’s cheeks. You tightly squeezed Rainbow’s asscheeks and spread them for Pinkie. This left Rainbow’s delicate flower fully open for Pinkie Pie.

Pinkie Pie brought out her huge tongue and began to feverishly lick out Rainbow's marehood. Rainbow uttered a loud, muffled whinny in your mouth. The mare’s body erratically shook on top of you.

Pinkie with loving tenderness licked and ate out Rainbow’s cute pink lips of her vagina. Rainbow’s wings were flared out, and her whole body was shaking. Orgasm, after orgasm, was rocking Rainbow’s body.

Once Rainbow was wet with her saliva, Pinkie pulled her head back and smiled at her work. A river of her cum was flowing down between Rainbow’s birth canal. It fell down onto the bed below, soaking it.

Pinkie Pie wrapped her hooves around Rainbow’s rump and took a tight grip. Pinkie Pie then used her earth pony strength to lift Rainbow into the air. At the same time, you slipped your hands to Rainbow’s lower abdomen and helped Pinkie lift Rainbow up to make sure she didn’t fall with your additional help.

Your thick, long cock soon came to bump against Rainbow’s marehood. Rainbow whimpered at the sight. “Anon, I’m scared. Put me back down and just hug me.” said Rainbow in a low voice, looking down at the massive tip of your cock with a look of fear in her eyes.

“Yeah. I agree. I think this would just end up killing you. You're more grounded and realistic than Pinkie. Even by crazy magic horse world standards.”

With that, you and Pinkie brought Rainbow back down to your chest. With her now safe, you simply wrapped your arms around Rainbow and hugged her. You didn’t want to take the risk of hurting Rainbow with your massive cock. Rainbow cried into your shoulder. Her body shook from the whole ordeal. Pinkie Pie lay herself down next to you on the right and rested her head on your shoulder.

“Sorry for nearly killing you, Dashie. That was a bad idea.” said Pinkie.

“It’s okay, Pinkie. I know you didn’t mean to rip me in half with Anon’s dick inside me.”

“Let me just pet the both of you. That’s nice and safe,” you said.

Rainbow rolled herself off you onto the right side of the bed and rested her head on your shoulder. You were now flanked by both mares on either side. You placed a hand on each of their respective manes and simply pet them. The two moaned softly, made happy whinnies, and other horsey sounds.

Rainbow sighed sadly. “I think we may need a powerful alicorn here to make sure Anon doesn’t kill me with his huge dick inside me next time we try this.”

“Ooooh! I bet I could take Anon’s big cock inside me without an alicorn’s help to protect me,” said Pinkie with her right hoof raised in the air.

“Well, of course, you can. You are Pinkie Pie. You defy logic.” said Rainbow, waving her right hoof.