To Be Two with New Beginnings

Truffle - a small but stout colt - had ducked behind the wall of the school, hoping he hadn't been found out. He'd witnessed the whole thing: both fillies being unbirthed by his teacher. He wiped some sweat from his ash-colored forehead, hoof flicking his messy, dark brown hair. "That was a close one..." he huffed to himself, thinking Cheerilee probably hadn't noticed.

"And just what are you doing here, young colt?" He heard from nearby after a few seconds. Cheerilee's tone was firm, but there was a hint of playfulness to it. When he turned the corner to face her, her belly was still relatively large but was shrinking by the second. Her expression was also stern, but it was clear that he wasn't actually in trouble just yet.

As the belly shrank, so too did the mind of the pink filly within - memories being lost like clockwork. And she welcomed her devolution into being a foal, now licking Silver's neck as well with no obvious intent, other than maybe a baby's form of affection.

Truffle gulped in the presence of the imposing mare. Glancing between her face and her stomach, he began to sweat again. "U-um... I was coming here to play on the playground. Then I saw you were... busy..." There was the rouge of embarrassment on his cheeks, and it only turned a brighter crimson as he continued. "I-I thought it looked really cool... so I stayed around to watch until you were done..."

Cheerilee smiled a bit as she rubbed her ever-shrinking belly before turning her attention to that of the colt standing before her. "And what do you think of the idea of two of your classmates becoming my daughters? I hope you don't have any objections. It's too late to reverse the process," she said with a light chuckle before gently ruffling his mane playfully.

"You mean it's permanent?" he asked with an undertone of nervousness, focusing intently upon the tummy. Almost all the fillies' thoughts were gone now. All their memories. Waiting for that last "push" to make them Cheerilee's daughters now and forever. The two foals were hugging one another, hardly even knowing why they were doing it at all. The cords attached to either of their belly buttons were siphoning out the last of those pesky former lives, but somehow, they weren't able to get quite everything. Something else was needed to truly cement their regression, and Cheerilee had a fairly good idea of what that was.

"Indeed it is permanent," Cheerilee said with a nod. "But I didn't just do this on a whim. All three of us wanted this, and I'm more than happy to call them my daughters. When they are born, their names will be Lilac Petals and Cheery Sunshine." Her tone was full of loving conviction for the fillies in her belly.

"Those are... nice names," he smiled, looking back up into the teacher's eyes. "I'm... a little jealous you're not my mom," the colt admitted, blushing profusely still as he rubbed the back of his neck.

"Are you asking me to turn you into their brother?" Cheerilee asked, quirking an eyebrow. "I mean, if you want me to I will, but it's my understanding that you have very loving parents."

Truffle bit his lip, looking behind him as though his parents might be there. "Yeeeeeah..." he admitted with a sigh. "I guess you're right, Miss Cheerilee..."

"But there is another thing you can do," Cheerilee said with a soft smile, looking down at the colt's crotch. "There's one more thing to help make this permanent for them."

"And I can help?" he asked, brightening up again, tail flicking eagerly behind him. "What is it, what is it?!"

"I know how much you adore me. I mean, you did give me a card during Hearts and Hooves day every year," she said with a smile.

The blush returned with a vengeance. The colt rubbed one cheek as though he might wipe away his obvious embarrassment. "Shucks... you're right, Miss Cheerilee," he admitted, smiling coyly.

"-and I bet you've had certain... fantasies about the two of us together, haven't you?" she asked, giving him a knowing smirk.

The colt looked down, averting his gaze. But he couldn't hide his smile. Nor the smell of his need as his stout cock drooped down from its sheath and began to harden. "I know I'm not supposed to..." he murmured, trying hard (but failing) to stop grinning as he thought about the times he'd touched himself thinking of his hoof as Cheerilee's.

"Even though some would object, I know the love you feel for me is real," Cheerilee said, smiling as well. Her own arousal was increasing by the second, both from the sensation of Diamond joining Silver, and the smell of Truffle's arousal. "And you can get to be the final piece to complete their new life. And I'd be happy to accept you."

Truffle, likewise, couldn't ignore the strong scent of his teacher's musk just begging for a stallion to come along and breed her. And though he was no stallion, he was certainly capable of filling his teacher. And his teacher was more than capable of sating his desires. He gulped, looking up with soft eyes. "You won't tell my parents, will you..?" he asked - the big softie.

"As long as you don't tell mine," Cheerilee joked, but her expression gave the colt all the answer he needed. She laid back and spread her legs wide to allow him access to her entrance.

Truffle's small-but-girthy cock throbbed seeing the welcome folds and winking clit. He walked forward until he was above her. The colt's blue eyes locked with his teacher's as he properly positioned himself, bending his knees so that his virgin penis twitched against her. It looked a little awkward, but missionary was simple enough for Truffle to not mess up royally bad. "A-are you sure this is okay..?" he swallowed, biting his lip from the pleasure he felt just from his flared head touching the entrance.

"I'm more than sure," Cheerilee said, already moaning lightly from the touch of his cock against her. She was eager to get this started, so she started pushing against him. "Go on, stick it in me," she said in a lusty tone that was far from her usual teacherly voice.

The colt gave a nod and a smile despite his nerves, and he obliged the mare; he thrust himself into her, easily hilting inside of her thanks to his youth. Already he saw stars, moaning like the little boy he was. He threw his head back. "Th-this feels so much better than masturbating..!" he exclaimed, straining his voice through his pleasure.

"Heh, it feels the same for me as well," she moaned loudly, pumping herself against him. Already she could feel his actions start to finalize the foals inside of her, and he hadn't even cum yet.

The fur on the fillies' bodies was going away - magically fading from existence. Their manes and tails too. They were losing their ability to see, to make sound. All the things a developing foal just couldn't do yet. Soon, all they had left were their cutie marks. Babies didn't need those, so it would be the colt's orgasm to wipe those away for good. Truffle pistoned himself in and out of his teacher, letting his head sink into her chest as he moaned. Every thrust was a wild ride for the schoolkid, and his every noise of pleasure informed Cheerilee of that. "It's... so warm and wet!" he forced between two moans.

"And it's getting better by the second!" Cheerilee moaned out, pumping against him harder and harder. With each thrust, she was brought closer and closer to orgasm herself, grinning the whole time. Fucking one of her students was absolutely amazing.

With every squelch, every penetration, Truffle was getting closer and closer to climax. His virgin body couldn't take the pressure of the pleasure he was feeling. Pre was practically spewing from his cock as he clenched his teeth and tried to hold back, having learned that usually made finishing feel better. "I-it's happening!!" he shouted in a shrill voice, his boyish orgasm imminent. His cock quivering with need.

"Do it, Truffle!" Cheerilee screamed out, her voice filled with desperate need. She knew his orgasm was pretty close, and so was hers. The moment he orgasmed, three lives would be changed forever, and she couldn't wait for it.

"Ahhh! Cumming!" the colt cried, his small balls wapping against Cheerilee's base as he unleashed inside of her. His warm spunk shot deep into her, straight into her womb - properly impregnating the mare. The seed that fell upon the undeveloped twins washed away any remaining thoughts they may have had and took with it all their memories. Their cutie marks were washed away too - the final shred of their old identity, lost forever as they became the daughters of their new mommy.

The feeling of his seed sent her over the edge, and she threw her head back as she moaned. Her juices flowed over his cock, and she loved every second of it. She felt the changes to the foals within her settle into permanence. "Oh yes, Truffle! That did the trick!"

Panting, spent as he'd never been before, Truffle smiled faintly and slumped down - knees giving out. He lay there, his cock still wrapped up nicely in his crush's folds as he snuggled up to her. He lazily turned his head so that his chin rested on Cheerilee's chest. He was blushing, looking so happily up at her. "Does this make me a daddy?" he giggled.

"Heh, I guess it does. Maybe we should get married?" she asked with a joking chuckle. Though part of her did genuinely consider her question, she knew he was too young.

The colt chuckled back, and when his laughter - like his body - was spent, he closed his eyes and cuddled the mare he adored. basking in his afterglow. Letting himself slip into a very special "naptime."

She smiled as she gently pet him, letting him sleep. She looked forward to the next few months when she'd give birth to her children, and the life they'd live.

The grip the foals had on one another weakened, both from their natural atrophy throughout their regression, and because they were falling into a peaceful slumber. Aided by the warm cream covering both of them. As they fell asleep, they didn't even know why they were holding each other. All they knew, was that they were happy.

"Sleep tight my darlings. It won't be too long before we start life as a family," she said to the fillies in her belly. With that, she laid back and went to sleep herself.