Sairenraifu: Siren Life (Vol. 1)

The rest of the day went without any more sexual activities, aside from the occasional grope or kiss. Sonata especially seemed rather clingy for some reason. As it became time for dinner, you ordered two peperoni pizzas, knowing it was one of the girls' favorites. Aria, especially, seemed to like pepperoni pizza. When the doorbell rings, the sirens hide so the pizza delivery guy won't see them naked. You're back in your sweat pants and sweat shirt. Opening the door, you pay the man and take the pizza. Closing the door, you lock it and head into the kitchen. The three sirens are already sitting at the table. Setting the pizza box down, you flip open the top box.

"Alright, dig in," you say, taking a piece for yourself.

Each siren takes a slice to start off, Aria being the last one and Sonata being the first. You look around the table as everyone eats and see Aria eyeing you. She is sitting across from you with Adagio on your left and Sonata on your right. You're about to say something when you hear Sonata gasp. Looking over, you see a glob of pizza sauce on her left nipple.

"S-So hot," she moans, before wiping it up with her finger. Licking it off, she smiles and eyes you. "What?" She asks, seemingly completely oblivious. Is she really this dense or is it all an act? You were never quite sure, and your definitely aren't sure now. Maybe she sprinkles a little fake stupid in with her real stupid? Either way, she is an adorable blue siren.

"So, school tomorrow," you say, ignoring Sonata's question. "Can we avoid picking fights this time?"

Adagio chuckles. "Sunset started it."

"She was just saying hi," you tell her. "Besides, didn't you just tell me today that we aren't in a relationship?"

"Oooo, Adagio's jealous," Sonata sang with a giggle.

The yellow siren snarls under her breath. "Not jealous. I'm just not a fan of how she proudly swings her melons around."

"She's just walking," you say, before taking a bite of your pizza. "I think you're imagining things to give yourself a reason to hate her."

"Sunset Shimmer and us have a rocky past," Adagio reminds you. "Plus, didn't she turn you and your classmates into mind-controlled zombies?"

"Were you three any better?" You ask her, her angry expression turning to surprise. "Look..." you say, hoping to deflate the situation. "Both Sunset and you three have come a long way from where you were, each one of you trying to become a better person. You and Sunset are more alike than you care to admit. So, can we try to get along tomorrow?"

Adagio lets out a growl before crossing her arms. "I suppose I can give Tits a chance."

"Thank you," you say, before looking at where Sonata was sitting, to find her gone. Her slice of pizza is also gone. Nothing but crumbs remain. "Um... Where's..." Your question gets answered when you feel a pair of hand pull your pants down just enough to free your rod. "Dammit."

"Oh, look, he's gotten hard thinking about Sunset's boobies," you hear Sonata say.

"I actually got hard when you had sauce on your nipple," you tell her, before leaning back in your chair to look at her. "Done eating?"

She nods with a wide grin. "I want dessert. How about a nice cream pie?"

"Sonata wants a cream pie?" Adagio asks with a smile, getting up. "I guess that's my cue. Unless Aria wants to."

The purple siren rolls her eyes. "Hard pass." It would seem that eating her out in the pool wasn't enough to get her to open up to you. You are determined to get an answer by the end of the day.

Adagio shrugs and walks over behind you. Gripping your chair, she pulls you back from the table. Moving around front, she sits on the edge of the table and spreads her legs. Sonata slides out from under the table and smiles at you. Letting out a sigh, you stand up and step up to the yellow siren, who reaches back and grabs a slice of pizza. Holding her hips, you push your cock inside her pussy. Both of you moan out before Adagio takes a bite of pizza. This usually happens at dinner. Sonata eagerly finishes first and asks for a cream pie. However, Adagio usually isn't finished eating, so she has to eat while you fuck her.

While you bone the siren, Sonata takes the yellow foot nearest her and starts sucking on the toes. Adagio giggles as she bites off some pizza and chews. The more she moans and eats, the more her breath smells like pepperoni. It's probably a good thing you like pepperoni pizza. When she finishes, you see a little bit of sauce around her mouth. Leaning in, you lick it off for her before pushing your tongue in her mouth. She returns the affection as you both enjoy a pizza-flavored kiss.

You can never last too long with these girls, given their super tight pussies, and you already feel like you're about to cum. After a few more thrusts, you break the kiss and pull out so just your cock's tip is in. You then jerk off the exposed part of your shaft. Sonata watches with a happy smile when she sees cum start to leak from Adagio's slit. The second you pull out, the blue siren is on her knees with her tongue in the yellow crotch, enjoying her pie.

Not wanting to be done, you sit down and slide up against the blue siren. Pulling her into your lap, you slip your rod inside her ass. Sonata lets out a deep groan but continues to eat out Adagio. Your left hand starts to finger Sonata's pussy while your right hand rubs her chest. Feeling the additional pleasure, Sonata moans more and starts bouncing up and down on your cock. The only hole tighter than their pussy was their ass, so any chance you got to fuck it, you would. And, they offered many chances. Especially Aria.

The anal walls squeeze another load out of you as Adagio coats Sonata's face in love juice. The blue siren giggles at feeling her ass fill with cum while having her face splashed with Adagio's orgasmic fluids. You slide your hands to her butt as Adagio looks over at Aria.

"Care to join us?" She asks.

Aria scoffs and gets up, before walking towards the hallway.

"What's wrong?" You ask her, wanting an answer. "Why won't you ever join us?"

The purple siren stops in the entranceway, before turning around to face you. "You wanna know?" She asks, sounding agitated. "You really wanna know?"

"Yeah, I really wanna know," you reply, equally agitated.

"Because, we won't be able to be together forever!" Aria shouts, tears filling her eyes. "And, I care about you the most!" She then takes off running towards the bedroom.

"A-Aria?" You ask, pulling out of Sonata and standing up. You look over at Adagio to see her giving you a knowing look. "You feel the same, don't you? That's why you said we're just fuck friends."

Adagio slides off the table, gently rubbing Sonata's head. "We're immortal beings, and you're not. You didn't think there'd be complications."

"I didn't care," you respond, before looking where the purple siren was standing. "Shit, Aria," you mutter, before heading off to the bedroom.