The adventures of Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo book 2: Consequences

by Thaddeus Risher

Rating: mature
Tags: Profanity, Aunt Lofty, Non-consensual, Scootaloo, Violence, Sex, Aunt Holiday, Narcotics, Gore, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Death, Sad, Original Character, Suicide / Self Harm, Tragedy
Length: 2064

Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo try to help out a filly.

Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo try helping out a filly. Things spiral out of control. Secrets are revealed. Continuing the adventure.

Published 2021-08-06 16:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2021-08-06 16:30:01 UTC

The story

Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo boarded the Ponyville train to Hoofington. A mysterious voice whispered in the wind.
“Here we go I am ready to begin”

“Wow I can’t believe that I am going to meet your aunts!” Exclaimed Sugar Cookie

“I can’t wait to meet your friend” Scootaloo said with excitement

The train arrives and Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo step off. They then walk to a Scootaloo’s aunt's house and knock on the door.

“Hello Scootaloo and friend come on in” Holiday said warmly.
Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo stepped in, unpacked, and went to meet Sugar Cookie’s friend. They walked over to the school where they met a red pegasus filly with a black mane and tail, a heart shaped gumdrop cutie mark and a scar over her right eye.

“Scootaloo this Gumdrop Heart, Gumdrop Heart this is Scootaloo. You stated in your letter that you were having trouble with your new classmates” Said Sugar Cookie

“Yes the kids are scared of me and the adults too and my parents are too busy with their own lives to do anything or even notice” Said Gumdrop Heart

Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo followed Gumdrop Heart when they met a white unicorn colt with a blue mane and tail and a pair of sunglasses for a cutie mark.

“Hey Gumdrop how's it going” he said shakingly

“It’s going fine, Ruckus. Nice to see you again” Gumdrop Heart said glumly reaching out her front left hoof
Ruckus reached out his front right hoof to shake Gumdrop’s hoof. Ruckus missed and tripped.

“I knew it, Gumdrop is being mean again” Ruckus said with fear

All the colts and fillies around, with fear and anger, began to scream “Freak, why do you have to be so mean”.

“Now hold on everypony I know that Gumdrop looks scary but she is a really sweet filly once you get to know her” Sugar Cookie confidently said

“How do you know?” Ruckus asked

“I have aspergers syndrome sometimes when I am trying to speak honestly it can come off as mean” Sugar Cookie said meaning that she her honesty is her trying to be helpful but doesn’t always come off that way

“So you are one of those mean freaks like Gumdrop” Ruckus said with fear and the whole crowd joined in

“Sorry Sugar Cookie I know you tried but it looks like I am going to have to go with plan B” Gumdrop Heart said to herself.

Early in the morning Sugar Cookie and Scootaloo woke up to parents screaming because they couldn’t find their children. In their search they noticed that Gumdrop Hearts house didn’t look broken into the same way that the others were. They decided to look into, noticed a trap door, and decided to look into it. It was there that they noticed all the children and Gumdrop Heart’s parents had been tied up and Gumdrop Heart was at the center of it. They listened in on the conversation and tried to stay hidden.

“I am sorry that it had to come to this but I had to get your attention somehow” Gumdrop Heart regretfully said “Now I can show you that you have nothing to fear from me”

Gumdrop Heart’s parents, a white unicorn stallion with a black mane and tail and a cough drop cutie mark and a white pegasus mare with a pink mane and tail and a veil cutie mark looked at each other. Fear visible in their eyes.
“Cough Drop” The mare said with trembling to the stallion

“Yes Veil I know but it could be worse imagine if she found about...oops” Cough Drop said trembling

“What are you two talking about tell me now” Gumdrop roared with intimidation

“What do you think the secret is” Scootaloo whispered to Sugar Cookie

“I don’t know but I want to find out” Sugar Cookie whispered back

“I’m scared” Scootaloo whispered back

Scootaloo began to whimper quietly. By the time Sugar Cookie had calmed her down they were done talking and it was out. What was that secret? Maybe if they observed a little more they could get a clue.

Gumdrop heart slapped her parents with her front left hoof. Anger and betrayal were visible on her face.

“You mother fucking bitches!” Screamed Gumdrop Heart “I swear to Celestia that all of you will pay!”

“Honey, we still loved you and…” Veil struggled to get out

“Yeah I know how about putting it to the test” Gumdrop Heart said menacingly

Gumdrop Heart got a knife out and cut off a couple of small pieces of her front right leg, dipped it in her blood, sealed the wound with a couple of small bandages, and forced her parents to eat the blood soaked pieces of her skin.

“Please stop, I can bear to see this!” Shouted a colt

“Oh if you don’t want to see this then I can arrange that” Gumdrop Heart said calmly

Gumdrop heart grabbed a couple of berries and forced that colt to eat it. Meanwhile she lit a cigarette and forced the receiving end up his nose. As the berries kicked in she put out the cigarette with the colt’s front right leg and he screamed in pain. The colt began to see clown ponies with sharp teeth and menacing looks and he screamed in fear.

“Stay calm maybe we can arrange something” said a filly with fear in her voice

“I think we can” Gumdrop heart said thinking hard

Gumdrop Heart grabbed her knife and cut off the filly’s front left leg and back right leg and she screamed as blood went all over the place. Then sewed her back right leg where her front left leg is supposed to go and her front left leg where her back right leg and all she could do is cry from all the pain she was experiencing,

“Please we are trying to help you before this situation explodes” said another colt with fear and sadness

Without saying anything Gumdrop Heart grabbed a bomb and activated it. Then she uses her knife to cut open the colt’s chest and stomach and put the active bomb in him; in so much pain all he could do was cry. She proceeded to sew his chest and stomach together. Then she activated the trigger. His parts blew all over the place. Everyone looked in horror except for Gumdrop who had an indifferent look on her. What was left of the colt’s head landed on Sugar Cookie and she freaked out blowing their cover.

“Hey Gumdrop” Sugar Cookie said nervously “So we know what you did but we want to know why.”

“Relax I am not going to hurt you I just want you to know what shit these fucking sluts concocted” Gumdrop Heart said calmly

The two of them, though a little afraid, agreed to follow Gumdrop Heart. Gumdrop Heart carried her knife with her. The two of them reached Scootaloo’s aunt's house. Gumdrop Heart knocked on the door where Holiday and Lofty met them and the three of them walked in.

“Holiday and Lofty, why don’t you tell Scootaloo the truth...about her parents.” Gumdrop heart said in a calm and menacing voice

“We aren’t your aunt’s, Gumdrop's parents aren’t her real parents, and your parents aren’t your real parents...let me explain” Holiday said with regret

*Flashback*

Holiday laid in bed with a black earth pony stallion with a black mane and tail and a pistol cutie mark. The two of them, covered in sweat.

“That sex was amazing Pistol Whip who knew you had such great moves” Holiday said

“Well I am sorry to have to leave now but I have to go” Pistol Whip said

The two of them said goodbye to each other as he left the room. While he was walking away he got to thinking to himself “I really like Holiday but I also like Lofty. I know I have to choose one but it’s so hard”.

Meanwhile Holiday went to the grocery store to pick up a few items. Along the way she ran into Lofty.

“Oh hey you look like you're in love” Holiday said

“Yeah so do you” Lofty said “I am dating a handsome black stallion named Pistol Whip what about you?”

“Wait a second, that is the guy I am dating!” Exclaimed Holiday

“So what’s the plan?” Lofty asked

"You try to break things off with him and I will try to do the same. If anything goes wrong I will be at my friend’s house.” Holiday said

The two of them got into position. Lofty began to speak.

“Pistol I don’t know how to say this but we need to break up. I know that you will find another mare like me who knows maybe you will even land a pegasus this time...oops. I swear only me and Holiday know about it...oops” Said Lofty

“You found out, didn't you? Well I know how to make sure you ladies don’t talk” Said Pistol Whip said attempting to sound calm

Pistol Whip pinned Loftys’ front legs with his front legs and her back legs with his back legs to the bed. He began to thrust himself against her. Lofty was so drenched in fear she couldn’t speak and only cried a little. A million thoughts ran through her head. When he was done he threatened to torture her farther if she didn’t tell him where Holiday was. She told him where Holiday was at and he ran after her to do the same thing with Lofty trying to keep up with him.

When he reached Holiday he burst through the door. Scootaloo’s parents who just put baby Scootaloo to bed rushed to take the guy down. Though they tried hard they were no match and Pistol Whip ended up killing both of them. But while he was doing that Holiday came up from behind and whacked him with a baseball bat. Too weak to fight back all Pistol Whip could do is watch as he got hit a few more times with the bat. Finally he laid lifeless on the blood soaked floor.

Holiday and Lofty felt responsible for leaving Scootaloo without parents. So the two of them had Lofty’s friend and her husband pose as Scootaloo’s parents. A couple of months later they found out that Lofty was pregnant and because they couldn’t pass the Scootaloo and Gumdrop Heart off as siblings or twins; they had another one of their friends and her husband act as Gumdrop Heart’s parents. And the silence pact was formed.

*End of flashback*

“Well now that you two lying pieces of shit are done we can get back to killing the bitches that started this whole fucking shit show” Gumdrop Heart said calmly

Gumdrop Heart thrusted her knife into Lofty’s chest and she fell onto the floor lifeless and in a pool of her own blood. In so much shock Holiday could barely cry.

“Holiday how does it feel I bet you want to die too” Gumdrop Heart said with amusement

“Yes please I can’t afford to lose another friend” Holiday said with tears running like a river

“Wait hold on, weren't you supposed to be in love with her?” Gumdrop Heart said confused

“Well I…” Holiday began to explain

It turns out Holiday had been stalling Gumdrop Heart so that Scootaloo and Sugar Cookie could grab knives. Gumdrop Heart stabbed Holiday in the chest and she fell to the floor lifeless and covered in her own blood then she ran after Scootaloo and Sugar Cookie.

Gumdrop heart thrust her knife at the two of them. They both blocked. The process was repeated multiple times. Gumdrop Heart knocked Scootaloo backwards. Sugar Cookie tried to continue without her but was no match. Just as Gumdrop heart was about to kill Sugar Cookie Scootaloo stabbed Gumdrop Heart in the back of her chest and she fell onto the ground lifeless and in her own blood.

“Well one ingredient down and two more to go” Whispered the same mysterious voice as before

“I’ll go get the authorities and you go get the paramedics” Said Sugar Cookie

The two of them went to get who they were assigned to get. Meanwhile all Scootaloo could think to herself is “What have I done? I have just killed somepony.” completely shaken by this whole scenario.