Who's The Bigger Butt Slut?

Pinkie was behind the counter at Sugar Cube Corner as usual, the sun was shining, birds were singing and she was baking some black and white chocolate chip cookies as she waited for her hundredth customer that day, sometimes people would actually wait outside Sugar Cube Corner and count the customers just so that they could be customer one hundred and get their hands on a piece of Pinkie Pie's juicy fat ass to play with all to themselves, the horny little rascals. As Pinkie was taking the cookies out of the oven to put them in bags and place in the display cabinet, who should walk in but Rumble, a boy that the girls in town tended to fawn over to the point of flirting and even attempting to sexually entice him, being nineteen years old with a chiseled muscular physique had its perks.

All of the girls that had pussies aching for Rumble's touch however knew that he was a bit picky, though if you were lucky enough to get picked then the fucking he would deliver far outweighed the negative points of waiting and hoping that he'd be in the mood for you. Pinkie was one such lucky girl , she did have the most easily available and irresistible ass in town, although the "easy availability" factor was, unbeknownst to Pinkie, no longer attributed to her and her fuckable rear. Pinkie smiled and said "Hi Rumble! Good news! One, I just got some cookies out of the oven and two, you are my one hundredth customer! I'm assuming you want to visit me around the back, same as usual?" Pinkie couldn't help but punctuate the end of her sentence with a smile and a wink.

Rumble chuckled and said "Very tempting Pinkie but I've already fucked a good piece of ass today, though I suppose a blow job wouldn't come amiss".

Pinkie went "No problem! Now did you wanna fuck my ass right here or did you- wait, what?" Rumble's words actually reached Pinkie's ears this time, Rumble was always in the mood to give her booty a good banging.

Rumble said "I've already fucked some broad in the ass today, I'm happy to just let you suck me off though". Pinkie was actually somewhat disappointed but disregarded it, interested to find out who he had already paid a visit to.

"Ooh, so who was the lucky lady?" Pinkie let Rumble behind the counter as she got on her knees.

Rumble went "Well it wasn't any of the usual girls that tend to follow me like a pack of sex-starved wolves, I was at Carousel Boutique hoping to pick up some new clothes, I was in the changing room when suddenly a hand reached through the curtain and started jerking me off".

Pinkie was intrigued as she unbuckled Rumble's belt and started to pull his jeans and underpants down "Really?"

Rumble said "I know right? Weird, I was so shocked by what was going on that by the time I was at full mast I wasn't even able to register who it was before I was suddenly balls deep in some well-used female ass".

Pinkie took hold of Rumble's shaft and said "Was it Sweetie Belle? She's so into anal I'm surprised she hasn't just had her pussy stitched shut with a big piece of duct tape hiding the fact she ever had one at all" shortly before engulfing his semi-erect cock into her mouth.

Rumble casually put a hand on Pinkie's head and said "Yeah but I heard she was going out with Button, she's not really the type to cheat on him, I dunno. Whatever the case I've fulfilled my personal goal of "pound some ass" today, I actually came in to buy a chocolate muffin and a coffee, though I'm not one to say no to a bonus blow job from the baker", Rumble chuckled while Pinkie continued her eager sucking on his warm stiff member. Pinkie bobbed her head back and forth at a slow gentle pace, she always found that blow jobs were more enjoyable when she took a relaxed approach that allowed her to fully immerse herself in the act and focus on the texture and taste of a thick pulsating cock sliding in and out of mouth, her lips gliding over every contour of the delicious skin. As Pinkie sensed Rumble's heart rate quickening through the throbbing of his cock and his pelvic muscles tensing, she knew that his orgasm was imminent and effortlessly slipped his cock down into the silky moist depths of her throat.

Rumble groaned as his dick was taken in to the hilt just seconds before his balls sent a decent payload of his spunk bursting out from his tip and directly into Pinkie Pie's waiting stomach. Rumble let out a pleased sigh as he pulled his quickly softening cock from Pinkie's mouth before tucking it back into his jeans while Pinkie stood up to make and serve him his coffee, "Oh by the way..." said Pinkie "You really should give some of the girls that follow you around a chance, they are so obviously desperate for you to slam their pussies, it's almost cruel that you leave them constantly hanging!"

Rumble said "I know, I can't help it if I like playing hard to get" he smiled wickedly and gave Pinkie $4.20 as she handed him his coffee and muffin, "Anyways, see you later Pinkie!" The day carried on as usual, people came and went ordering all sorts of baked goods, though one customer got Pinkie's attention, in a bizarre twist of fate it seemed Sweetie Belle wanted something from Sugar Cube Corner that day.

"Well hey there Sweetie Belle! How's your day been? Been jerking off strangers at the boutique recently?" Sweetie Belle raised an eyebrow at Pinkie, she knew Pinkie was odd but that was possibly the most strangely specific and out-of-the-blue question Pinkie had ever asked her.

"Um... no" she said "I've just come in here to pick up some cupcakes for a picnic I'm having with my boyfriend... what's with that odd question?"

Pinkie said "Oh, well Rumble was in here earlier today saying that someone at the boutique surprised him by engaging in some anonymous anal action in the changing rooms, seeing as you're a fellow anal whore I figured it was you". Sweetie Belle thought it was a bit presumptuous of Pinkie to assume that and found it almost offensive that she thought that she would cheat on Button just to get some cock in her ass, something that was already readily available to her.

"Well for your information..." said Sweetie Belle, "I am not the only girl who visits the boutique, I don't even live there any more, plus there are plenty of girls who'd be more than happy to give up their ass to Rumble but I'm not one of them".

Pinkie gave a fake and theatrical over-the-top gasp as she said "Sweetie Belle! Are you not the young hot piece of ass and self-proclaimed tight little butt slut I thought you were?" Pinkie giggled while Sweetie Belle adopted a wry smile on her face and made her way behind the counter.

"Well, let's put it this way Pinkie..." Sweetie Belle said as she pushed Pinkie against the wall and whispered in her ear "If you had a cock, like a real cock and not some cold, lifeless, piece of shit fucking strap-on, a real long, thick, hard and veiny throbbing cock and a fat set of heavy nuts ready to pump load after load into me, I'd have you balls deep inside my tight little butt as soon and as often as possible..." Sweetie Belle turned around and leaned forward slightly as she pressed her butt right up against Pinkie's groin before she started rubbing up and down. Pinkie was sweating, Sweetie Belle was well trained in the art of seduction and the way her grinding made Pinkie's pussy soaking wet just made Pinkie conflicted about whether she needed a cock inside her or wanted to own a cock to fuck Sweetie Belle with.

Sweetie Belle stopped and immediately returned back to the customer side of the counter, once again a picture of innocence and said "As it stands though, Button is my sweetheart, I'm his whore and my cute little butt is reserved for his dick and his dick alone I'm afraid!" Pinkie gulped, she got the picture, she handed over the pre-paid cupcakes Sweetie Belle had ordered then immediately rushed upstairs to get Pound to fuck her pussy as hard as he could.