Who's The Bigger Butt Slut?

After fucking Pip in the ass, which he thoroughly enjoyed if the cum stains on Pinkie's bed were any indication, Pinkie still felt the need to find out who this new woman in town was that was stealing all the precious opportunities for anal sex that she had. Pinkie decided that before she went for an all out search for this woman, she'd go around town to see if there was any boy or any girl with a strap-on who hadn't yet fucked this mystery girl in the ass to see if she could get to them before her and ask those who had already fucked her in the ass if they would be willing to reveal her identity. As Pinkie went house by house, she soon recognized that only one half of her plan was possible, every single legal guy and every single legal girl with a strap-on cock had fucked this woman's booty and was keeping their promise of not revealing her identity, it was ludicrous! This woman was better than she initially thought, it seemed Pinkie couldn't find a single person who hadn't pounded this woman's rear entrance, meaning that nobody felt the need to pay any attention to Pinkie's poor unattended pucker!

Pinkie went back home feeling disheartened, had she been beaten? Was she no longer the biggest butt slut in town? No, she was still always ready to have her rump pumped, that's what was important! Pinkie realized she might have been a little bit selfish in thinking that this mysterious woman had no right to take all the cocks she could get in her butt, after all if anyone knew how awesome anal sex was, it was Pinkie! Pinkie put on a smile and decided she'd get back on to her laptop to see if she could book a slot with an animal at the club before it closed for the day. She went to book a slot with Chester and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Chester today have been booked, please try again another time".

OK, no problem, Chester was her favorite animal but then again why wouldn't he be everyone else's favorite animal as well? He was a powerful muscular beast with a deliciously enormous cock, there were other animals to choose from. Pinkie went to book a slot with Maximus and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Maximus today have been booked, please try again another time".

Maybe this was a technical issue? No no no, Fluttershy and Applejack would have mentioned that on the website. Well Maximus was still a horse and horses were popular, Pinkie wouldn't mind having some fun with a dog instead, she went to book a slot with Lance and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Lance today have been booked, please try again another time".

There was no way this was happening, this had to be a joke, Pinkie frantically went to book a slot with Sparky and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Sparky today have been booked, please try again another time".

NO FUCKING WAY! Pinkie could handle having to compete with another butt slut in town but what she couldn't handle was the fact that she may never get her own ass fucked again because this bitch was hogging all the fun to herself! She had to find out who this woman was and stop her, Pinkie wasn't about to get usurped by some other whore and she knew that the last available slots must have been booked by her, it just made sense. This was the perfect time to find out for herself just who this woman was, she immediately left Sugar Cube Corner to make her way to the bestiality club. Applejack and Fluttershy were kissing passionately at the desk of the club when Pinkie burst through the doors with all the strength of a raging fire. Fluttershy and Applejack separated, surprised at Pinkie's sudden entrance, Fluttershy went "Um... can we help you Pinkie? You do know that you can't just show up here to-"

Fluttershy was interrupted when Pinkie went "Where and who is she?!"

They both immediately knew who she meant, Applejack went "Now Pinkie, you know we can't reveal that information".

Pinkie went "OK, Fine, then I guess I'll just have to go and check myself then won't I?" Pinkie started making her way to the first door before Applejack leapt out from behind the desk to block her path.

"Pinkie..." she said "Please don't make me have to suspend you from club activities for the next month and more than that don't make me regret not hiring security guards, I will not allow you to go through any of these doors".

Pinkie was too pissed off to be threatened by Applejack, Fluttershy could sense this and brought herself out from behind the desk in case Applejack needed support. Pinkie shoved Applejack and said "Oh yeah? What are you gonna do about it bitch?!"

That was it, without a moment's hesitation Applejack reeled back and punched Pinkie directly in the face, as Pinkie staggered back from the impact Fluttershy then swiftly swung her leg to kick Pinkie's ankles and make her fall to the floor. Pinkie wiped the blood from her nose and sat there as Applejack and Fluttershy looked at her with a clear look of wishing they hadn't just had to do that to protect the integrity of the club. It was just then that the silence and the intense drama of the situation was shattered, when who should walk out of the door leading to Chester but Rarity. "Ooh, darlings! I have to say that even after a day of countless men, women and dogs having their way with my rear, Chester never fails to impress! Whew!"

It was just then that she noticed Pinkie sat on the floor staring at her with wide eyes, Pinkie almost shrieked "RARITY?! You're the woman who's been getting butt-fucked left right and center?!"

Rarity chuckled and said "Well, I don't know that I'd say that but I have certainly developed somewhat of a penchant for having my posterior pounded that's for sure, why do you ask?"

Pinkie stood up and said "Well thanks to you being the newest anal whore on the block, it's been about two or three days since I've last been able to get some decent dick in my demanding derriere!"

Rarity was confused, was Pinkie jealous of her? "Well... what about Pound darling?"

Pinkie scoffed and said "Please, that boy isn't interested in my ass which I think makes him clinically insane, he's only good for pussy. Don't ask me about any of the boys and girls in town because it seems that they are all getting their fix of fucking from a woman who has asked them all to keep quiet but I know for a fact that it must be you! Same goes for the same someone who keeps buying up the few time slots for all the male animals here!"

Rarity giggled nervously with sweat rolling down her temple, she'd never seen Pinkie so angry since the time she forgot her own birthday party, "Well dear... it seems I've been enjoying anal sex perhaps a tad bit more than I should have..."

Pinkie wasn't satisfied "Well I say we have a competition! A contest! Biggest butt slut wins the right to have their ass be the only one the people and animals in this town can rely on!"

Applejack was interested now, "Well, technically we could arrange that if you really wanna go through with that, Fluttershy, what's the situation on making sure their pussies aren't fucked?"

Fluttershy thought for a moment before saying "Well, although they aren't strictly for vaginal use, a good sized butt plug should do the job of making sure nothing goes in there, though getting them back out of their pussies afterwards would be difficult it is still possible".

Applejack went "Alright, well that settles it! You two come back to the club tomorrow for this odd little tournament while we take care of bringing in the customers!"