Who's The Bigger Butt Slut?

by PegPony

Rating: mature
Tags: Fetish, Profanity, Sex, Human, Pinkie Pie (EqG), Alternate Universe, Rarity (EqG), Equestria Girls, Porn
Length: 6563

Pinkie and Rarity determine which of them is the bigger butt slut.

Pinkie has noticed that, recently, people aren't coming to her for anal sex as much as they used to which worries her because she considered herself the town's resident butt slut. It seemed like there was a new girl on the block who liked anal just as much as Pinkie did...... but which of them was the better butt slut?

This story takes place in the FG/AC universe.

Published 2021-05-15 00:00:02 UTC
Last updated 2021-05-15 00:00:02 UTC

Anonymous Anal

Pinkie was behind the counter at Sugar Cube Corner as usual, the sun was shining, birds were singing and she was baking some black and white chocolate chip cookies as she waited for her hundredth customer that day, sometimes people would actually wait outside Sugar Cube Corner and count the customers just so that they could be customer one hundred and get their hands on a piece of Pinkie Pie's juicy fat ass to play with all to themselves, the horny little rascals. As Pinkie was taking the cookies out of the oven to put them in bags and place in the display cabinet, who should walk in but Rumble, a boy that the girls in town tended to fawn over to the point of flirting and even attempting to sexually entice him, being nineteen years old with a chiseled muscular physique had its perks.

All of the girls that had pussies aching for Rumble's touch however knew that he was a bit picky, though if you were lucky enough to get picked then the fucking he would deliver far outweighed the negative points of waiting and hoping that he'd be in the mood for you. Pinkie was one such lucky girl , she did have the most easily available and irresistible ass in town, although the "easy availability" factor was, unbeknownst to Pinkie, no longer attributed to her and her fuckable rear. Pinkie smiled and said "Hi Rumble! Good news! One, I just got some cookies out of the oven and two, you are my one hundredth customer! I'm assuming you want to visit me around the back, same as usual?" Pinkie couldn't help but punctuate the end of her sentence with a smile and a wink.

Rumble chuckled and said "Very tempting Pinkie but I've already fucked a good piece of ass today, though I suppose a blow job wouldn't come amiss".

Pinkie went "No problem! Now did you wanna fuck my ass right here or did you- wait, what?" Rumble's words actually reached Pinkie's ears this time, Rumble was always in the mood to give her booty a good banging.

Rumble said "I've already fucked some broad in the ass today, I'm happy to just let you suck me off though". Pinkie was actually somewhat disappointed but disregarded it, interested to find out who he had already paid a visit to.

"Ooh, so who was the lucky lady?" Pinkie let Rumble behind the counter as she got on her knees.

Rumble went "Well it wasn't any of the usual girls that tend to follow me like a pack of sex-starved wolves, I was at Carousel Boutique hoping to pick up some new clothes, I was in the changing room when suddenly a hand reached through the curtain and started jerking me off".

Pinkie was intrigued as she unbuckled Rumble's belt and started to pull his jeans and underpants down "Really?"

Rumble said "I know right? Weird, I was so shocked by what was going on that by the time I was at full mast I wasn't even able to register who it was before I was suddenly balls deep in some well-used female ass".

Pinkie took hold of Rumble's shaft and said "Was it Sweetie Belle? She's so into anal I'm surprised she hasn't just had her pussy stitched shut with a big piece of duct tape hiding the fact she ever had one at all" shortly before engulfing his semi-erect cock into her mouth.

Rumble casually put a hand on Pinkie's head and said "Yeah but I heard she was going out with Button, she's not really the type to cheat on him, I dunno. Whatever the case I've fulfilled my personal goal of "pound some ass" today, I actually came in to buy a chocolate muffin and a coffee, though I'm not one to say no to a bonus blow job from the baker", Rumble chuckled while Pinkie continued her eager sucking on his warm stiff member. Pinkie bobbed her head back and forth at a slow gentle pace, she always found that blow jobs were more enjoyable when she took a relaxed approach that allowed her to fully immerse herself in the act and focus on the texture and taste of a thick pulsating cock sliding in and out of mouth, her lips gliding over every contour of the delicious skin. As Pinkie sensed Rumble's heart rate quickening through the throbbing of his cock and his pelvic muscles tensing, she knew that his orgasm was imminent and effortlessly slipped his cock down into the silky moist depths of her throat.

Rumble groaned as his dick was taken in to the hilt just seconds before his balls sent a decent payload of his spunk bursting out from his tip and directly into Pinkie Pie's waiting stomach. Rumble let out a pleased sigh as he pulled his quickly softening cock from Pinkie's mouth before tucking it back into his jeans while Pinkie stood up to make and serve him his coffee, "Oh by the way..." said Pinkie "You really should give some of the girls that follow you around a chance, they are so obviously desperate for you to slam their pussies, it's almost cruel that you leave them constantly hanging!"

Rumble said "I know, I can't help it if I like playing hard to get" he smiled wickedly and gave Pinkie $4.20 as she handed him his coffee and muffin, "Anyways, see you later Pinkie!" The day carried on as usual, people came and went ordering all sorts of baked goods, though one customer got Pinkie's attention, in a bizarre twist of fate it seemed Sweetie Belle wanted something from Sugar Cube Corner that day.

"Well hey there Sweetie Belle! How's your day been? Been jerking off strangers at the boutique recently?" Sweetie Belle raised an eyebrow at Pinkie, she knew Pinkie was odd but that was possibly the most strangely specific and out-of-the-blue question Pinkie had ever asked her.

"Um... no" she said "I've just come in here to pick up some cupcakes for a picnic I'm having with my boyfriend... what's with that odd question?"

Pinkie said "Oh, well Rumble was in here earlier today saying that someone at the boutique surprised him by engaging in some anonymous anal action in the changing rooms, seeing as you're a fellow anal whore I figured it was you". Sweetie Belle thought it was a bit presumptuous of Pinkie to assume that and found it almost offensive that she thought that she would cheat on Button just to get some cock in her ass, something that was already readily available to her.

"Well for your information..." said Sweetie Belle, "I am not the only girl who visits the boutique, I don't even live there any more, plus there are plenty of girls who'd be more than happy to give up their ass to Rumble but I'm not one of them".

Pinkie gave a fake and theatrical over-the-top gasp as she said "Sweetie Belle! Are you not the young hot piece of ass and self-proclaimed tight little butt slut I thought you were?" Pinkie giggled while Sweetie Belle adopted a wry smile on her face and made her way behind the counter.

"Well, let's put it this way Pinkie..." Sweetie Belle said as she pushed Pinkie against the wall and whispered in her ear "If you had a cock, like a real cock and not some cold, lifeless, piece of shit fucking strap-on, a real long, thick, hard and veiny throbbing cock and a fat set of heavy nuts ready to pump load after load into me, I'd have you balls deep inside my tight little butt as soon and as often as possible..." Sweetie Belle turned around and leaned forward slightly as she pressed her butt right up against Pinkie's groin before she started rubbing up and down. Pinkie was sweating, Sweetie Belle was well trained in the art of seduction and the way her grinding made Pinkie's pussy soaking wet just made Pinkie conflicted about whether she needed a cock inside her or wanted to own a cock to fuck Sweetie Belle with.

Sweetie Belle stopped and immediately returned back to the customer side of the counter, once again a picture of innocence and said "As it stands though, Button is my sweetheart, I'm his whore and my cute little butt is reserved for his dick and his dick alone I'm afraid!" Pinkie gulped, she got the picture, she handed over the pre-paid cupcakes Sweetie Belle had ordered then immediately rushed upstairs to get Pound to fuck her pussy as hard as he could.

The Pinkie Pie Problem

After Pinkie was fully satisfied after riding Pound until he felt like an abused teeter-totter, she decided that she'd used her mouth and her pussy that day, it was time to make use of her favorite hole which, to her, was feeling prodigiously empty and was in need of the cock it was so obviously hungry for. Pinkie went to her bedroom and hopped onto her laptop, she immediately went to to book a slot with an animal who would give her rump a good pumping. As she went to book a slot with Chester she received an automatic message.

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Chester today have been booked, please try again another time".

Pinkie pouted, Chester was her favorite animal, all she had to do was bend over and wiggle her rear end and that was all he needed, hard within seconds and ready to cram his massive horse dong into her butt. No matter, there were other animals, she went to try and get the next best thing by booking a slot with Maximus instead only to be greeted with a similar message.

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Maximus today have been booked, please try again another time".

What was going on? The club was very popular sure but how were two animals unavailable for a fuck? Pinkie sighed and figured the third time would be the charm and tried to book a slot with Lance, a dog who loved anal sex.

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Lance today have been booked, please try again another time".

FUCK. There was only one male animal left! Was Pinkie going to have to close up shop and go to bed without her ass having been fucked that day? That kind of thing was unheard of for an anal whore of her caliber! She tried to book a slot with the other dog, Sparky.

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Sparky today have been booked, please try again another time".

This was bullshit, Pinkie refused to go to bed without at least having something penetrate her ass. Pinkie closed her laptop and went to her drawer to retrieve her trusty and reliable horse cock dildo and a bottle of lube, she stuck the dildo on the usual chair and coated it in lube before impatiently pulling down her skirt and panties to lube up her own asshole. Pinkie got in position, angling the dildo so the the head was pressed right up against her pucker, before ramming herself down on it until her big jiggling ass cheeks clapped against the chair with the entirety of the dildo entombed in the warm confines of Pinkie's rear. Pinkie let out a sigh of pleasure as she sat as still as possible, simply enjoying the feeling of her butt being so wonderfully full, she loved how the dildo was just nestled so comfortably in her back door.

In fact, Pinkie didn't even feel the need to fuck herself on it. She briefly panicked and wondered if this was a sign of her slowing down, then giggled as she remembered that even women as old as her mother still got into mischief, what did she have to worry about? Rather than fucking herself that night, she simply pulled up her panties as much as she could so as to ensure the dildo would be guaranteed an extended overnight stay in her rump while she got ready for bed.

the next morning -

Pinkie woke with a yawn, she'd never had a more relaxing sleep in her life. She briefly wondered why it had been such a restful sleep until she got out of bed and felt the familiar feeling of a big horse cock dildo still in her ass, just barely held in place by her panties. She smiled and removed her panties, allowing the dildo to unceremoniously fall out of her ass and thud to the floor, Pinkie shuddered at the odd sensation of being so suddenly empty in a hole she liked having stuffed with thick cock as much as possible. Time for her daily anal exercises! Pinkie put on her usual exercise get-up, light blue headband with matching shorts, light yellow shirt with matching knee high socks, all topped off with striped light yellow and light blue bands on her arms. Once she was ready, she got up her exercise mix playlist up on her phone and pressed "play", immediately her room was filled with the thumps and booms of music made to trigger feelings of the need to knuckle down and get to work!

Pinkie always considered it important to flex her anal muscles and keep them trained, while it may have been easier and perfectly safe to just let her ass be as loose as possible, she liked to think that having her back door put up at least a little bit of resistance added an extra something to the constant butt-fucking she casually engaged in for both her and whoever was doing the fucking. Speaking of which, she had a bakery to run and a one hundredth customer to look forward to! Pinkie Pie took off all of her exercise gear, got dressed, brushed her teeth and immediately went downstairs where she had just enough time to eat a hearty breakfast of pancakes covered in syrup before the first customer arrived. After serving several customers that morning, number one hundred arrived in the form of Pip, this was exciting for Pinkie because she had just days ago arranged his 18th birthday party and now she had the chance to give him his first taste of anal sex, she would have done it at the party but his mother knew what kind of girl Pinkie was and didn't want her son Pip immediately diving dick-first into the nearest fuck hole on the day he finally became legal.

"Well hello there Pip! Nice to see you! It's good timing as well, because surely you've heard of my one hundredth customer policy? So what do you say? Wanna head upstairs and bang this baker's booty?" Pinkie turned around, showing off her large buttocks.

Pip thought before going "No that's OK, I've already had some anal sex today", Pinkie's jaw hit the floor and her eyes widened cartoonishly as she gave a genuine gasp, how had someone gotten to him before she did?! Pip continued "There was a brief window of time at the birthday party where my mother wasn't watching over me and before I knew it i was in my bedroom balls deep in a woman's ass, it was so magnificent I just had to visit her again today! I assumed you would have gotten to me first but it looks like someone beat you to it!" Pinkie Pie was majorly pissed off, it looked like there was a new anal whore in town and she wasn't too pleased that this girl had enough skill and determination to bag a barely legal boy she'd had her eye on for a while.

Pinkie glared and said "Who is she?"

Pip chuckled nervously and said "Uh... she asked me not to say...", Pinkie had to find out who this girl was but she wasn't about to sacrifice her principals, she still had a one hundredth customer to serve.

"So, what can I get you Pip? Oh and more importantly, what kind of sex are you in the mood for if not anal?"

Pip said "Well I just wanted to pick up an apple pie, as for the sex... um, well I have always wanted to kind of try... pegging......", Pinkie's face lit up a little, she did always like the kinky ones.

"Hmm, not exactly my first choice..." said Pinkie "But I like it! Alright Pip, let's do this!" Pinkie grabbed him by the arm and dragged him upstairs to her bedroom.

The Rarity Revelation

After fucking Pip in the ass, which he thoroughly enjoyed if the cum stains on Pinkie's bed were any indication, Pinkie still felt the need to find out who this new woman in town was that was stealing all the precious opportunities for anal sex that she had. Pinkie decided that before she went for an all out search for this woman, she'd go around town to see if there was any boy or any girl with a strap-on who hadn't yet fucked this mystery girl in the ass to see if she could get to them before her and ask those who had already fucked her in the ass if they would be willing to reveal her identity. As Pinkie went house by house, she soon recognized that only one half of her plan was possible, every single legal guy and every single legal girl with a strap-on cock had fucked this woman's booty and was keeping their promise of not revealing her identity, it was ludicrous! This woman was better than she initially thought, it seemed Pinkie couldn't find a single person who hadn't pounded this woman's rear entrance, meaning that nobody felt the need to pay any attention to Pinkie's poor unattended pucker!

Pinkie went back home feeling disheartened, had she been beaten? Was she no longer the biggest butt slut in town? No, she was still always ready to have her rump pumped, that's what was important! Pinkie realized she might have been a little bit selfish in thinking that this mysterious woman had no right to take all the cocks she could get in her butt, after all if anyone knew how awesome anal sex was, it was Pinkie! Pinkie put on a smile and decided she'd get back on to her laptop to see if she could book a slot with an animal at the club before it closed for the day. She went to book a slot with Chester and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Chester today have been booked, please try again another time".

OK, no problem, Chester was her favorite animal but then again why wouldn't he be everyone else's favorite animal as well? He was a powerful muscular beast with a deliciously enormous cock, there were other animals to choose from. Pinkie went to book a slot with Maximus and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Maximus today have been booked, please try again another time".

Maybe this was a technical issue? No no no, Fluttershy and Applejack would have mentioned that on the website. Well Maximus was still a horse and horses were popular, Pinkie wouldn't mind having some fun with a dog instead, she went to book a slot with Lance and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Lance today have been booked, please try again another time".

There was no way this was happening, this had to be a joke, Pinkie frantically went to book a slot with Sparky and...

"We are sorry, it would appear that all available slots for a session with Sparky today have been booked, please try again another time".

NO FUCKING WAY! Pinkie could handle having to compete with another butt slut in town but what she couldn't handle was the fact that she may never get her own ass fucked again because this bitch was hogging all the fun to herself! She had to find out who this woman was and stop her, Pinkie wasn't about to get usurped by some other whore and she knew that the last available slots must have been booked by her, it just made sense. This was the perfect time to find out for herself just who this woman was, she immediately left Sugar Cube Corner to make her way to the bestiality club. Applejack and Fluttershy were kissing passionately at the desk of the club when Pinkie burst through the doors with all the strength of a raging fire. Fluttershy and Applejack separated, surprised at Pinkie's sudden entrance, Fluttershy went "Um... can we help you Pinkie? You do know that you can't just show up here to-"

Fluttershy was interrupted when Pinkie went "Where and who is she?!"

They both immediately knew who she meant, Applejack went "Now Pinkie, you know we can't reveal that information".

Pinkie went "OK, Fine, then I guess I'll just have to go and check myself then won't I?" Pinkie started making her way to the first door before Applejack leapt out from behind the desk to block her path.

"Pinkie..." she said "Please don't make me have to suspend you from club activities for the next month and more than that don't make me regret not hiring security guards, I will not allow you to go through any of these doors".

Pinkie was too pissed off to be threatened by Applejack, Fluttershy could sense this and brought herself out from behind the desk in case Applejack needed support. Pinkie shoved Applejack and said "Oh yeah? What are you gonna do about it bitch?!"

That was it, without a moment's hesitation Applejack reeled back and punched Pinkie directly in the face, as Pinkie staggered back from the impact Fluttershy then swiftly swung her leg to kick Pinkie's ankles and make her fall to the floor. Pinkie wiped the blood from her nose and sat there as Applejack and Fluttershy looked at her with a clear look of wishing they hadn't just had to do that to protect the integrity of the club. It was just then that the silence and the intense drama of the situation was shattered, when who should walk out of the door leading to Chester but Rarity. "Ooh, darlings! I have to say that even after a day of countless men, women and dogs having their way with my rear, Chester never fails to impress! Whew!"

It was just then that she noticed Pinkie sat on the floor staring at her with wide eyes, Pinkie almost shrieked "RARITY?! You're the woman who's been getting butt-fucked left right and center?!"

Rarity chuckled and said "Well, I don't know that I'd say that but I have certainly developed somewhat of a penchant for having my posterior pounded that's for sure, why do you ask?"

Pinkie stood up and said "Well thanks to you being the newest anal whore on the block, it's been about two or three days since I've last been able to get some decent dick in my demanding derriere!"

Rarity was confused, was Pinkie jealous of her? "Well... what about Pound darling?"

Pinkie scoffed and said "Please, that boy isn't interested in my ass which I think makes him clinically insane, he's only good for pussy. Don't ask me about any of the boys and girls in town because it seems that they are all getting their fix of fucking from a woman who has asked them all to keep quiet but I know for a fact that it must be you! Same goes for the same someone who keeps buying up the few time slots for all the male animals here!"

Rarity giggled nervously with sweat rolling down her temple, she'd never seen Pinkie so angry since the time she forgot her own birthday party, "Well dear... it seems I've been enjoying anal sex perhaps a tad bit more than I should have..."

Pinkie wasn't satisfied "Well I say we have a competition! A contest! Biggest butt slut wins the right to have their ass be the only one the people and animals in this town can rely on!"

Applejack was interested now, "Well, technically we could arrange that if you really wanna go through with that, Fluttershy, what's the situation on making sure their pussies aren't fucked?"

Fluttershy thought for a moment before saying "Well, although they aren't strictly for vaginal use, a good sized butt plug should do the job of making sure nothing goes in there, though getting them back out of their pussies afterwards would be difficult it is still possible".

Applejack went "Alright, well that settles it! You two come back to the club tomorrow for this odd little tournament while we take care of bringing in the customers!"

Battle of the Butts

That night an announcement went up on the club website.

"Howdy y'all! Tomorrow we have a special treat for all club members old and new! While we don't usually offer sex services of a human nature, for one day and one day only that is exactly what we are doing! Two women are kindly offering up their asses to be fucked all day, whether you're a boy with an appreciation for backsides or a girl with a strap-on that you want to put to good use, they are here for you to use! Couple of rules, don't fuck their pussies, they aren't interested. Second of all, they'd prefer not to meet anybody face to face on this particular occasion, so you don't get to know who they are, the only part of their bodies you may get well acquainted with is their slutty assholes and nothing else. Finally, be sure to have fun and let us know which ass you preferred by leaving a dollar! See you then!"

The next day, the game was on. Pinkie and Rarity were in a specially designed room where the front half of their bodies went through a hole in the wall to hide them from view, leaving only their hindquarters on full display. The response to the news of two whores practically serving up their asses on a silver platter to be fucked was phenomenal, there was actually a long line of men and women outside the doors of the bestiality club waiting for the place to open, Applejack and Fluttershy were just raking in the cash. The day went pretty much as all of them had expected, Pinkie and Rarity were in a constant state of quivering pleasure as their orgasms never seemed to end and just rolled into each other while they were repeatedly fucked in the ass over and over and over again, they were fucking loving it.

The room where everyone got the chance to fuck both Pinkie and Rarity also had two buckets, one next to Rarity and one next to Pinkie Pie and as requested, everyone who participated in fucking them left one dollar in the bucket next to the ass they liked more. Most of them observed that one ass (Rarity) was quite loose and took cock very easily, so willing and welcoming that it almost acted like it was meant to be the primary fuck hole instead of the vagina, while the other ass (Pinkie Pie) took slightly more effort to penetrate and fuck. For hours and hours on end, Pinkie Pie and Rarity had their butts continually pounded, some girls had even decided not to bring their own strap-ons for the event, meaning most of them ended up borrowing ones from the club which included the horse and dog cock strap-ons, so they both got to experience a decent variety of shapes and sizes in their bottoms.

The effect that all of this constant anal sex had on Rarity and Pinkie was almost frightening, aside from the never-ending moaning, groaning and whimpering from the satisfaction and pain of their bodies having orgasms forcibly shudder through every nerve ending, they were dehydrated, drooling everywhere with their tongues hanging out of their mouths, eyes crossed, their hair matted and unkempt as sweat soaked their bodies. Never before had they endured so much dizzying amounts of sex, all for the sake of proving which of them was the better butt slut, even Applejack and Fluttershy were starting to wonder if they had made the right choice in encouraging them to follow through on this silly plan, though they could hardly go back now, they were well past the point of no return. Applejack tried to distract herself by putting out some job vacancies out on the club website, after their small bout with Pinkie Pie they decided that they probably should hire a couple of people to be security guards or bouncers at the very least to deal with anybody who decided to disrespect the rules of the club in future, Fluttershy distracted herself by hiding herself under the desk to masturbate, insatiable as always.

As the day went on, the amount of people relieving their sexual frustration on Rarity and Pinkie became less and less, it was lucky that Applejack and Fluttershy had such an advanced diary system for the club, otherwise they never would have been able to keep track of just how many people had arrived to get a double helping of derriere. Despite the amount of lube that had been provided, Rarity and Pinkie couldn't deny the intense searing pain from all the friction their poor unprepared assholes had to go through from the constant onslaught of stiff cocks being thrust inside, they were both hot, in pain, regretting agreeing to do this and probably most of all......... still enjoying every single fucking second, no matter how good or bad they were feeling at the time. Another thing they had noticed is that some of the participants decided to stray from the simple "fuck and leave" approach, deciding to get adventurous and loosen them up with butt plugs, fingering, fisting, some of them even did things just for the sheer pleasure of enjoying some fine pieces of ass like kissing, licking and no small amount of spanking with various implements.

When all was said and done their butts were red, bruised, tingling and looking in just as bad a state as the front of their bodies, not to mention their behinds were packed full of untold amounts of jizz that actually managed to swell their bellies and while they couldn't communicate or comprehend it effectively, they swore that at some point their bodies had become so full of semen that they actually started to cough it up as their bodies attempted to expel the excess fluid that failed to just leak out of their over-fucked asses and onto the floor. This was going to be a huge clean-up job for both the girls and the room.

Finally it was over, all the boys left the club with their nuts fully drained and all the girls left having released their pussy fluids on top of the immense feeling of satisfaction from being the ones to wield a cock for once. Applejack and Fluttershy closed the club and checked in on Pinkie and Rarity, they were both wrecks, barely able to talk or move, tears streaming down both of their faces with tired bloodshot eyes, hot and flushed....... but at least both of the buckets had at least one hundred dollars or so in them.

After Rarity and Pinkie had been nursed back to a normal state, they were both eager to find out who had won. They were stood in the reception of the club as Applejack and Fluttershy stood there to tell them the results, "OK girls..." said Applejack "We've tallied it all up and a total of three-hundred and ninety-two people turned up at the club to fuck you".

Pinkie said "Whoa... that must be a new record huh?"

Rarity went "I should certainly hope so after what we went through! So who won?"

Fluttershy interjected and said "Um... well neither of you actually, both buckets had exactly one-hundred and ninety-six dollars in them, it was split exactly down the middle about which butt people thought was better, seems some people liked Rarity for her loose and easy butt while others preferred Pinkie for her well-trained and slightly more challenging butt."

They couldn't believe it, all of that effort was wasted, it was all for nothing, at least that's what they thought until Rarity suddenly turn towards Pinkie pie, slapped her in the face and went "Go out with me!"

That was confusing, Pinkie Pie went "W...what?"

Rarity went "You heard me! Be my girlfriend! We can both be butt sluts forever, butt sluts together!"

Pinkie smiled slightly and went "Really?"

Rarity nodded and went "Really Really! Butt sluts forever! Butt sluts forever and ever!"

Epilogue

It made sense, Twilight was with Spike, Rainbow was with Tink, Applejack was with Fluttershy, it only seemed natural that Rarity and Pinkie would get together. All it took for it to happen was for Rarity to become a total anal slut. Pinkie had offered to teach Rarity her daily anal exercise regime but Rarity refused every time, saying that she preferred her ass to be loose enough to take just about anything that was up for it while Pinkie could be the one people went to if they fancied something that wasn't like throwing a long, hard and thick hot dog down a warm, slippery and accommodating hallway. Rarity had explained that her slightly manic way of asking Pinkie out happened due to an epiphany, though she never fully understood just what that epiphany was, many people assumed it was love and to be fair, even Rarity assumed that love was the most likely candidate, love was the strongest force in the universe and Rarity never would have considered a relationship with Pinkie before that day.

Soon after that, the rate at which they both got their butts reamed seemed to level out, they both agreed that despite being an item they would acknowledge that they both had a very active and sexual lifestyle that they weren't willing to give up, not even for each other. Though it seemed that a very open relationship worked for them and even created a weirdly romantic bond and dynamic between the two girls, it was actually slightly rare that they had sex with each other which didn't really bother them too much because sex wasn't the focus of their love. Of course as time went on, their love only grew and built until the day came when they both decided to get married, people were astonished that two such opposite people could get together and not only that but make it work perfectly when so many other "conventional" couples seemed to crash and burn so easily. It was truly proof of the power of love... and anal.

One thing that came up through all of this that never seemed to go away was the idea of children, Applejack and Fluttershy had always been told by people that they should have children and now people were doing the same with Pinkie and Rarity. Obviously biological children weren't an option but there was such a thing as adoption, sperm donors and the fact that a horse or a well-endowed dog could impregnate them, Rainbow Dash had even gotten slightly pissed off at people suggesting that either she or Tink get themselves pregnant for the sake of children, which was a mistake because Rainbow had an extreme distaste for dicks and was not willing to share her wife in any capacity. Either way, Applejack, Fluttershy, Pinkie and Rarity didn't know how to feel about the concept of children, however they did think about and consider it, they had all the time in the world to have children, for now they simply enjoyed the feeling of being in love and having every available orifice on their bodies filled.

The End.

Prologue

Ass, that's what it was all about in town, there wasn't a single man or woman who could claim they didn't like ass play to some degree. Most of the time the people in town were like Mrs.Cake or Cream Heart, women who didn't mind taking it in the butt every now and then, then there were other girls like Fluttershy and Twilight, who were particularly fond of anal activities to go along with their passion for pussy action and just a tad slutty, Sweetie Belle famously wasn't at all fond of pussy action and was only willing to take it in the ass which was lucky considering her boyfriend, Button, was only willing to fuck her in the ass due to his preference for the canine pussy available to him at Applejack's club. Even the animals at the club came under the influence of the town's bizarre admiration of the back door, the two biggest examples being Twilight's son, Lance, who pounded ass like it was his life's mission and the mare known as Angel, a horse who couldn't resist the pumping of a cock in her rear.

Pound was a guy who liked to take it in the ass from his sister but was deprived of that luxury ever since she got together with Photo Finish, no matter where you went in town the fact was inescapable, everybody loved ass whether they were giving or receiving. However, there was one particular person who was the top of the heap when it came to people who were all about the booty and that person was none other than Pinkie Pie, Pinkie Pie was the crème de la crème of getting her caboose creamed and although she did love having her pussy tended to, nine times out of ten she'd take it in the ass. Pinkie Pie had everything, she had a butt that was just an inch or so shy of reaching Mrs.Cake's extraordinary size, she had a very popular "every one-hundredth customer" policy, so gifted was she in the art of taking dicks in the derriere that she had a personalized anal muscle exercise regimen that she performed daily!

Then, the impossible and unthinkable happened, Rarity. Rarity was famous for never ever having anything go near her ass, the closest anyone had ever gotten previously was her friend Pistachio, he had held the cheeks, kissed them, even managed to grind his cock up against them but her pucker remained unpenetrated. One day however, she bit the bullet and allowed someone to fuck her ass for the very first time and thus Pandora's box was opened, Rarity had enjoyed it far more than she thought and ever since she had taken every opportunity to have her behind wrecked and destroyed by anyone and everyone, even Pinkie took a strap-on to Rarity's butt, assuming it was a one time thing and was just glad Rarity was enjoying anal sex now. Little did she realize that Rarity had become a total back door whore.

It begged the question......... who was the bigger butt slut?