Making A Perfect Lover 2

Chapters

Chapter 1 - Moving In
Chapter 2 - The Mares
Chapter 3 - Breeding

Chapter 1 - Moving In

Shining tried his best to grin and bear it as he and his now-conjoined fellow stallions followed Cadance down into the Crystal Sanctum beneath the Crystal Palace, with Sugar Belle following dutifully behind. He was having to grin and bear it a lot lately. Not that he regretted being joined with the other stallions – it was more than worth it in order to be a tri-headed stud with traits of all three pony races ... finally an alicorn worthy of the Princess of Love. And as much as he might have reason to complain about them, he and the other two stallions actually made a really good team together. Though living with Zephyr at all times could get a little old now and then. Especially right now.

“I still can’t believe that becoming a prince involves being imprisoned in some dungeon! That wasn’t in the deal!” Zephyr whined. When nopony replied to or validated his complaint, he only took it further: “How am I supposed to pursue Rainbows when I’m stuck down here, underground? She’s always in the sky, not down here! She should be a part of this ceremony if she’s going to be my wife!”

“You tried,” Shining reminded him. “She made it pretty clear that she didn’t want to do any such thing.” Actually, her exact words were more along the lines of, ‘Never in a million years!’ ... to which, Zephyr had unhelpfully explained that he was now immortal and would be happy to keep asking her for a million years. That had not brightened Rainbow’s mood.

Big Macintosh nodded. “Eeyup,” he said with feeling.

“I was working on it!” Zephyr let out a big sigh ... which Shining felt, since it took their shared lungs to do so. Zephyr looked at their other two heads mournfully. “It takes time to romance a mare as fine as Rainbows!”

Cadance paused up ahead, in the middle of a wide open crystal chamber, a big dome with other exits leading off into other rooms. “Don’t worry, Zephyr,” she said. “You’ll have plenty of time to pursue her after our Alicorning Ceremony is complete.”

Shining wasn’t looking forward to that. Seeing Zephyr ‘pursue’ Rainbow Dash always made him cringe with second-hand embarrassment ... which was made even worse because Zephyr didn’t seem to be embarrassed by what he was doing in the slightest. It wasn’t easy being attached to the other stallion during such times. He never knew if the blush growing on his own face was because of how awkward the situation was, or if it was a side-effect of Zephyr’s ever-present arousal. At least if Shining and Big Mac worked together, they could keep their self-control and keep their cock in their sheath. That was a blessing. And Rainbow probably appreciated it as well.

“I put it off as long as I could, you know,” Cadance continued, “in hopes that you and Shining could find your second wives before it started. But the tradition of the Crystal Empire is adamant: after the alicorn princess finds an alicorn husband, the two must descend into the Crystal Sanctum along with all their husbands, wives, and concubines, for the Alicorning Ceremony. Once all the mares who came down emerge heavy with foal, the alicorn prince and princess become the Crystal Empress and Crystal Emperor. But if I waited any longer to start the ceremony, it would break tradition and make everypony in the entire Crystal Empire question whether we’re really even supposed to be their rulers or not.”

Zephyr shook his head. “I know, I know...” He pouted melodramatically. “I just really wish Rainbows could be here. Especially for the ‘heavy with foal’ part. She’s going to be so sad she missed out!”

Pop!

The instant Zephyr said that, a glowing image of Rainbow Dash appeared right in front of them. She looked entirely real, only slightly blurred and glowing around the edges. “Your wish is my command,” the glowing image said.

For a moment, all three stallions stared at her, their mouths gaping. Zephyr was the first to overcome the shock. “Rainbows!” he said with glee. “I knew you’d change your mind! I’m so glad you came!”

Taking control of their body, Zephyr lunged forward to embrace the image ... and to Shining’s astonishment, Zephyr was actually able to. He could feel their forehooves wrapped around the back of Rainbow’s neck as Zephyr nuzzled her. He could even feel the warmth of her fur and the hairs of her rainbow-colored mane against the side of their hoof.

Shining looked to Cadance, and she must have seen the confusion in his face. She came over to them and kissed him on his cheek. And when Big Mac looked a little jealous, she kissed him, too. Zephyr was obviously too preoccupied with Rainbow Dash to worry about getting a kiss of his own.

Cadance seemed pretty interested in looking at the image of Rainbow, too. “The sages said that the Crystal Sanctum would have ‘spirit guides’ available at the slightest call. That’s why they said we wouldn’t need any help or servants down here. I never thought they would be so lifelike, though... How does this place even know what Rainbow Dash looks like?”

“I’m based on the Rainbow Dash in your minds,” the image said. “And I exist to please all residents of the Crystal Sanctum. Your wish is my command. I will do anything you ask.”

“She’s ... perfect,” Zephyr said, on the verge of tears.

“Eenope.”

Now that Shining looked closer, he had to agree with Big Mac. “Yeah, he’s right. She’s a little off.” The image had actually gotten Rainbow’s hair colors in the wrong order, and the tip of her lightning bolt cutie mark was facing the wrong way. Whose memories was it working off of, anyway?

“Don’t you talk about Rainbows that way!” Zephyr almost snarled at the other two heads.

Shining looked back at him. “Uh... You know that’s not really Rainbow Dash, right?”

“Sssh!” Zephyr held up one of their forehooves against Shining’s lips. “Don’t ruin this for me!”

Shining rolled his eyes and Big Mac shook his head ... as Zephyr went back to stroking Rainbow’s mane lovingly. And she stared right back at him just as lovingly. Before he knew it, Zephyr and the Rainbow image were kissing – kissing passionately ... if a little sloppily. And the stallions’ cock was beginning to emerge out of their sheath. It had happened too quickly for Shining to get control of it, and he wasn’t even sure if Big Mac was even trying to control it. But the more it slipped out, the more unstoppable it would be, he knew. Their shared body was getting aroused, all thanks to Zephyr’s infatuation. Rainbow was a fine mare, yes, but why did Zephyr have to be so obsessed with her in particular?

When Zephyr finally separated from the kiss, he looked down at the image adoringly. “Can we... You know, do the dirty with you?”

Big Mac craned his head around to look at Zephyr’s head sharply. “What the hay are you thinkin’, Zeph?”

Their body took a couple steps backward, away from the image. Shining wasn’t sure if it was Big Mac or Zephyr doing it, because Zephyr was now looking at Rainbow with a critical eye.

“Hm...” Zephyr said, rubbing his chin with one of their forehooves as he looked her over. “Yes, you’re right. It could be a little bit better, couldn’t it?” Suddenly, his eyes lit up. “Ooh! A maid costume! Do a maid costume!”

The image flickered for just a moment before reappearing in a frilly black and white maid costume, complete with a little lace bonnet and a very short skirt. Zephyr immediately dragged them in a circle around her, lingering behind much more than necessary. “You’re right, Mac! She’s much better this way!” Their cock throbbed harder beneath their body. “Come on! Let’s get this party started!”

“No!” Shining shouted, helping Big Mac stop Zephyr’s advance toward the image’s backside in their tracks. “Big Mac wasn’t talking about giving her a maid outfit! Come on!” Leaning to the side a little, he managed to poke Zephyr’s head with his horn. “Why would you waste time with this ... spirit image thing, when we have two very beautiful and very real mares down here with us?” He gestured with one of their forelegs toward Cadance and Sugar Belle, both of whom were watching in what looked to be bemusement.

“But... Rainbows!”

“It’s just a ... a hologram thing,” Shining said, his voice growling a little. “How could you want that instead of the literal Princess of Love?”

“Or Sugar Belle!” Big Mac said with deliberate insistence. “She’s real nice too!” Off to the side, Sugar Belle blushed and gave him a loving look.

“Actually...”

All three of their heads swiveled over to look at Cadance. It was almost as if they’d forgotten she could speak, or that she’d have any say in the matter ... they’d just gotten too busy arguing among themselves. They all felt chagrined about that. Or, at least, Shining felt a little chagrined about that. And he couldn’t help but imagine that the other two stallions would interpret the sinking feeling in their shared gut the same way.

But Cadance smiled disarmingly. “Actually, you boys should take a little time and have your fun. Sugar Belle and I need to prepare with the fertility ritual, just to make extra-sure it takes.”

Shining’s jaw dropped. “Really? You’re sure?”

“It doesn’t count as cheating if it’s just an image projection.” Cadance shrugged. “Just make sure you save some for the two of us! When we get back from the fertility ritual, we’ll both need you in tip-top shape, ready to pump us full of as much as we can hold!”

The thought of that made Shining blush ... and it made their cock throb even harder. “What’s the fertility ritual? How long does it take?” He couldn’t wait to skip to that part, to finally impregnating his wife with a beautiful alicorn foal ... and impregnating Sugar Belle, too!

“Oh, don’t worry, the fertility ritual will take us a while.” Cadance winked. “Sanctum, please give us the stallions for the fertility ritual.”

Instantly, six stallions – identical except that they came in a spectrum of different colors – appeared. Sugar Belle jumped, startled at the six stallions appearing right next to her, but Cadance seemed to have been expecting it. She barely even looked at them.

Shining sure looked at them, though. All of them had close-trimmed manes and docked tails. All were crystal ponies ... but they were all stockier, beefier than most crystal pony stallions he’d ever seen. And from what little he could see of their sheaths, it looked like their packages would be equally impressive. “Hey,” he said warily. “What kind of fertility ritual is this?”

“Nothing that Sugar Belle and I can’t handle. Don’t worry about it,” Cadance said, turning toward one of the room’s exits. “We’ll be just over here in the next room. You boys have fun with ‘Rainbows’ while you wait!”

Shining stared at his wife, at their wife, as she quickly trotted off into the next room, closely followed by Sugar Belle and no less than six beefy stallions. He couldn't help but have mixed feelings about what was likely to happen in that room. But if it was a necessary part of the ritual...

While Big Mac seemed even more concerned about what both of his wives would be doing in there, Zephyr obviously wasn’t worried about it in the slightest. He was already staring at Rainbow and licking his lips in anticipation. Well ... Shining couldn’t quite fault him for that. Now that the two mares had left him and the other two stallions alone with the Rainbow image, he had to admit, there was good reason for their cock to be rock hard right now. Though his love was first and foremost always for Cadance, Shining had to admit to himself that he’d of course noticed all of his sister’s friends at some point or other, and Rainbow was no exception. One of the best, even. Her petite and lithe body didn’t have an ounce of fat on it. Instead, she was defined by tight, lean curves and perfectly toned muscles. Every part of her body exuded athletic perfection.

It was a little odd to see her in a maid outfit – something he was sure the real Rainbow Dash would never be caught dead in – but maybe that actually made it a little bit hotter? It was certainly intriguing. And now that Big Mac had stopped pining over Sugar Belle, it seemed that he was coming to the same realization, too. Had Big Mac ever been with Rainbow before? He spent a lot more time in Ponyville than Shining ever did – there would have been opportunity. He must have at least noticed her at some point. And now all three of them were finally going to find out what it was like to be with the legendary flyer ... or at least an imperfect version of her.

In an unspoken agreement, they rushed up behind Rainbow. And she seemed to know what they wanted, obligingly spreading her hind legs apart and raising her tail to give them the best view possible.

Though Shining was still a little preoccupied with thoughts of what Cadance and Sugar Belle were doing in the other room, he had to admit that Rainbow’s ass was a pretty good distraction. Her tight and pert curves were just so perfect, despite being so small, and her cute little pussy nestled deep between those well-defined cheeks like the perfect little gem to complete the picture. Even the prismatic colors of her tail arching over it all really helped enhance the sight of her. Shining couldn’t wait!

And neither could the other stallions. They all seemed in agreement about raising a hoof up to lovingly stroke the chiseled lines of her ass cheeks, running the soft inner part of their hoof through the velvety fuzz of her fur. When they wandered inward, her pussy was so warm and springy-soft, just utter perfection. And that was before it winked open for them, planting a hot wet kiss of sorts against their probing hoof.

What they weren’t in agreement about, though, was what to do next. Both Shining and Big Mac tried to immediately mount the image, but Zephyr yanked their body to the side at the last minute, making them stumble off of her. They only avoided crashing completely to the floor by a little quick-thinking wing work, which Shining and Big Mac were thankfully getting a lot better at these days.

“Hey!” Shining cried out. “What gives? I thought you wanted to do her!”

“Eeyup!” Big Mac said grouchily.

“No no no no!” Zephyr shook his head vehemently. “A filly as fine as Rainbows is a filly you’ve got to romance first. You can’t just jump on top of her right away.”

Shining rolled his eyes. “It’s just a spirit imagery thing. What are you going to do to romance her? Take her out to dinner and a show first?”

Ignoring him, Zephyr gave his best, winningest smile at Rainbow and wagged his eyebrows. “So, Rainbows. Feel like having a little taste of the Z?” He turned their body to the side a little, giving the image a good look at their enormous alicorn cock.

“Of course,” Rainbow replied. It really was uncanny how close her voice was to the real mare’s. “What would you ask of me?”

Rearing their body up onto its hind legs, Zeph looked down at her triumphantly. “Suck it!”

Shining’s jaw dropped. This was Zephyr’s idea of ‘romance’? It was a miracle that the real Rainbow Dash hadn’t killed him yet!

It worked just fine on this projected image, though. She eagerly leapt into action, rushing up to them before they lost their balance and planting her mouth against their enormous tip right away. She even took it perfectly gracefully – as if it was expected – when Zephyr lowered their forelegs right down onto her back, holding them up at the expense of overburdening the poor little mare.

She didn’t complain at all, though. Possibly because her mouth was full. More likely because she wouldn’t have said anything anyway. Instead, she somehow – impossibly – squeezed the fat tip of their cock into her mouth, beginning to work her way down it.

Shining couldn’t really see what she was doing, not from his angle. Had no idea how she was managing it. But he could feel it. And thanks to many wonderful nights with Cadance, he knew very well the feeling of skilled lips sliding their way down their shaft, of her throat squeezing tightly around their shaft, of their tip plunging its way down her neck. Somehow, this version of Rainbow was able to do it more gracefully and effortlessly than Cadance herself, especially after this alicorn transformation. Cadance was getting better at taking their huge size, but it was still nothing like this. This reminded him of how Cadance was able to take him back when he had just a normal stallion-sized cock, rather than an alicorn cock. He had no idea how this petite mare could take such a gargantuan thing in her mouth ... except just by the sheer magic of her.

In a stunningly short amount of time, Rainbow managed to swallow their cock all the way to the hilt, until her lips were kissing against their sheath. Another sensation Shining was blessedly familiar with. And while he was still absorbed in the sheer marvel that this mare was able to do it – their cock must have been knocking at the door to her stomach by now! – both Big Mac and Zephyr seemed happy to not question it, instead beginning to thrust into her mouth, rutting her face like it was no big deal at all.

And when Shining felt the sensations of fucking the little mare’s throat, he had to admit that the other two stallions probably had the right idea all along. She was unbelievably tight, to the point where it would have been choking an ordinary mare horribly. But the Rainbow image seemed to have no problem at all with it. She used the convulsions of her throat to massage their shaft, and she even took the time to lick the edge of their sheath with her outstretched tongue. With one of her hooves, she caressed their three shared balls, given each one equally tender attention.

“Mmm, that’s it!” Zephyr said dreamily. “Take it, Rainbows! Take what you’ve always wanted!”

Shining very much had his doubts that any of this was what the real Rainbow Dash would have wanted, but at this point, he was ready to go along with it and let Zephyr have his fun. After all, it did feel awfully good!

After minutes of shamelessly rutting the image’s mouth – any normal mare would have passed out from lack of air long ago – Zephyr finally seemed to have gotten his fill. “Enough foreplay!” he said abruptly, their cock still hilted in Rainbow’s mouth. “It’s time to show Rainbows what we can really do!”

“Eeyup,” Big Mac agreed, his voice already sounding strained.

Some ‘foreplay’, Shining thought. He was truly glad that he and Big Mac were there to curb Zephyr’s worst impulses when it came to being with real mares. But he didn’t see any reason to complain about how they were treating this image of a mare. Hopefully an image like her wouldn’t have any real feelings or anything. It was just a magical construct, right? Just an illusion to make them feel better. Hopefully. At least she didn’t seem to have any problem with this.

Pulling out of Rainbow’s throat took longer than Shining would have thought. He was still getting used to how massively long that cock of theirs really was. It still felt amazing, though. A shudder ran through him – both through the three stallions’ shared body and through his own neck, and he knew the other two were feeling it just as intensely as he was.

And as the three of them pranced backward so they’d have enough room to drop back onto their hooves, their huge tip finally popped free from the Rainbow image’s mouth. That’s when Shining finally got a good look at her taking it. It was crazy, almost comical to see her small mouth stretching out around the broad head of their cock to let it pop free. It shouldn’t have been possible for a mare her size. At all. But thanks to her magical nature, she was able to do it with only the slightest apparent discomfort. She gave a theatrical little cough as the stallions dropped back down to their hooves, and she wiped her lips a little with one foreleg.

Shining himself felt like taking a moment to recover from the intense experience as well ... but the other two stallions didn’t seem to have any such inclination. They trotted their body right around behind her without hesitation.

And, of course, he wasn’t immune to Rainbow’s charms. He was still only a stallion, after all. The lacy black-and-white flare of skirt around her hips framed her perfectly petite ass very nicely, making a breathtaking image of her cute little rump. Her pussy was absolutely dripping now, winking like crazy to show them flash after flash of hot pink amid all her delicious blue curves. Her tail flagged high, almost completely inverted, in the most blatant invitation possible. And while the real Rainbow Dash might have been looking back at them with fiery challenge in her eyes, this image looked over her skirt-shrouded haunches at them with the most subservient, needy gaze Shining had ever seen. It looked completely wrong to him, completely at odds with the Rainbow he knew ... but in a way, that made it all the hotter, as if they’d somehow gotten the Rainbow Dash into such a desperate state that she’d do anything just to get their giant cock inside her.

Not that she needed to do anything, of course. His eyes burning with lust, Zephyr was already rearing their body up and lunging for her.

Rainbow accepted the hefty weight of their triple-headed alicorn body on top of her backside with only the slightest grunt of effort. And now that they were on top of her, instinct took over. Even Shining was helping the other two stallions control their forelegs and the rest of their body, pulling themselves farther up onto her, pulling her closer with their forehooves. Then ... boom. The heavy impact of their thick tip against the soft warmth of Rainbow’s pussy lips.

Shining was sure it wouldn't fit. He could feel the entirety of her pussy winking against just a part of their tip.

But the other two stallions didn’t seem to have any such doubt, and he was getting to the point of giving it a try no matter what, too. At this point, he just wanted to be inside somepony, and Rainbow was too tempting to ignore.

As he probably should have expected by this point, all his doubts were for nothing. When they pressed their enormous cock forward it ... somehow squeezed its way inside Rainbow’s tiny pussy. He could distinctly feel her ass cheeks sliding along either side of their shaft as they slowly, steadily crammed it into the petite mare. And beyond that ... wow! He’d never felt any mare so tight inside! Her warm inner walls squeezed their cock hard, but they pushed even harder, sliding deeper and deeper inside her.

The Rainbow image moaned and squeaked in her scratchy little voice as they shoved their cock inside of her, as if making her little more than a sock stretched tightly around their girth. Every time Shining was sure they must have reached the little mare’s limits, she just let out another strained little squeak as they pressed onward, deeper inside her. It was impossible, he knew. Just couldn’t be biologically possible. Their tip must have been probing inward somewhere around her lungs right now, and still pushing!

Being biologically impossible didn’t stop this magical projection of Rainbow, though. She took everything they had to offer, accommodating their huge cock inside her all the way to the hilt. The thick base of their shaft stretched her so wide she couldn’t even wink anymore. Shining could feel the occasional pulses of extra tightness around their base as her pussy tried to wink, but it didn’t result in the slightest bit of motion. She was absolutely transfixed by the enormous cock stretching her from the inside.

There was plenty of motion, though, once they started thrusting inside her.

Big Mac’s influence on the initial insertion had been obvious – so slow, steady, and smooth. But now that they’d hilted her once, he seemed to think that his job was done. Shining was left as the only one putting any kind of restraint on Zephyr’s wildly rutting thrusts.

It wasn’t easy to hold Zephyr's impulses back. Despite Shining’s efforts, they slammed into the poor mare over and over again, each heavy thrust causing a teensy little squirt of Rainbow’s juices to splash out against their triple balls. She wasn’t orgasming – at least he didn’t think so – it was more like they were just squeezing it out of her, as if there were no more room left in her little body and something had to come out to make room for their huge alicorn cock.

And really ... as the pleasure inside them started to build, as the cute little sounds Rainbow made started to go to his head, and as the awe-inspiring tightness of her inner walls glided against all sides of their shaft, Shining found himself less and less concerned about trying to hold Zephyr back. Why try so hard? Judging from the desperately lewd moans Rainbow made, she sure wasn’t suffering from it. And the harder he allowed Zephyr to pound her, the better it started to feel.

Soon, he abandoned all pretense and just let Zephyr take control, rutting the poor mare wildly. She bounced forward a little with every slam of their hips against her, and he could feel the pleasurable pressure building inside them, as if they were about to cum ... but just something was missing.

Big Mac was actually the one to figure out what it was. At first, Shining didn’t have any idea why he’d lower his head down next to Rainbow’s and whisper in her ear, but it became clear soon after...

“Please,” the Rainbow-maid mewled, her voice desperate and pathetic. “Please, Zephyr, give me your cum! I need it so bad!”

Again, Big Mac whispered into her ear.

“You were right!” Rainbow squeaked out. “You were always right. I’ve wanted your huge cock inside me ever since the first time I met you. I’ve always tried to hide it, but somehow you knew just how bad I wanted you.” She cried out as they gave a particularly forceful thrust, slamming into her. “Please, Zephyr – please cum inside me. I need it. Give me your foals – give me what I’ve always wanted!”

That did it. All that silly talk might not have done much for Shining, but for Zephyr... Well, Shining could tell it was pushing Zephyr over the edge.

It was a little strange, feeling the physical orgasm building up to its full potential even though the mental element wasn’t quite there for him. It still felt amazing, of course, but without the frenzied lustful thoughts, without the mental fog, without all the effort that reaching orgasm usually involved. Zephyr was definitely feeling all of that as he nuzzled tightly against Rainbow’s neck, but all Shining felt was the building pressure, the familiar tingling, and the sudden release. It was strange feeling it all so clearly, without distractions ... well, without as much distraction. The heady pleasure of it did still make him go a little bit cross-eyed.

Who knew if the magical projection was faking it for their benefit or not, but as their flared tip locked them inside her tight pussy and as their cock swelled with the first heavy rush of cum, Rainbow cried out in her own orgasm, her inner walls clenching down even tighter against them in a futile effort to squeeze down on their cock and squeeze more out of them.

She didn’t need to squeeze. She was already destined to get plenty of cum. With their three huge balls working together, the stallions produced an overwhelming wave of it that stuffed her absolutely full before the first stream of it was even halfway done.

But that was just the beginning. Rainbow’s orgasming pussy drank deeply as their cock forced more cum into her womb. Much of it squirted and sprayed out around her tightly-stretched entrance, but not nearly as much as their enormous alicorn cock was pumping into her. Shining couldn’t help feeling a bit of pride along with the orgasmic glow as he felt the mare’s sides gradually expanding between their forelegs. Every powerful throb of their cock caused an answering swell in her belly, stretching her out absurdly as they made her into a wobbling, sloshing vessel for their prodigious, creamy load.

By the time they’d finally finished, the Rainbow image’s belly was touching the floor, even as she stood upright on all four hooves. When they pulled out of her, a fountain of cum squirted out from her still-gaping pussy lips, splattering onto the floor and their forelegs ... and still that didn’t seem to help her swelling problem any.

By that point, they were panting heavily and Shining Armor was more than ready to call this done and dismiss the magical projection.

Zephyr, though, had other ideas. “Oh, Rainbows... Since you’re in a maid outfit and all, wouldn’t it be appropriate if you cleaned this mess up?” He gestured at the sticky white puddle spreading over the crystal floor, then smirked. “With your tongue.”

The very idea of it made Shining want to stick his own tongue out in disgust, but Rainbow went straight to it. Even though her belly dragged on the floor as she turned around, she turned right away and bent down as low as she could still reach to start lapping cum off the floor. Shining had no idea where she’d keep all that excess inside her already-stuffed body, but Rainbow licked it up hungrily.

“Thank you, Master,” she said between mouthfuls, looking up at Zephyr with her lips dripping white. “I live to serve you!”

“That’s right.” Zephyr’s grin was growing downright lecherous now. “Lick up all my cum!”

“Our cum,” Big Mac corrected, as if it mattered.

Shining, though, was much too preoccupied with other things to worry about who this sticky mess on the floor actually belonged to. Who cared? Now that he wasn’t so distracted by the image of Rainbow Dash, he was much more concerned about how Cadance and Sugar Belle were doing. Okay, mostly about Cadance. What might they be doing there in that other room...?

Author's Note

This story was suggested and chosen by my SubscribeStar supporters! Every month, I take suggestions from my supporters and they vote to decide which story idea I'll write next.

If you want to help tell me which stories to write, go to my SubscribeStar page and pledge $5 or more. Then you'll get to vote on which story from my ideas list gets written next and add your own ideas directly to that list!

Chapter 2 - The Mares

Sugar Belle glanced over her shoulder one last time as they left the main entrance hall of the sanctum, following their six colorful stallions into this smaller side room. “Are you sure they’ll be alright without us?” she asked, looking back to Cadance.

Cadance snickered. “It’s only a spirit guide – a projection created by this Crystal Sanctum. Don’t worry, they’re not cheating on us. No more than we’re about to, anyway...” She looked over at the six patiently waiting stallions and licked her lips a little.

“So, um, Princess... What is this fertility ritual, anyway?”

“I told you, Sugar. We’re basically married to each other now. You don’t have to call me ‘Princess’ anymore.”

“But you are a princess, aren’t you?”

Cadance nudged her side. “And you are as well. Or, at least you’ll be a ‘princess consort’, as the crystal ponies call it, as soon as we finish down here and come back to the surface.”

Sugar Belle stopped and stared at her. “Little old me? A ... a princess?”

“You’ll make for a wonderful one.” Cadance came closer and kissed Sugar Belle, gently, right on the muzzle. “Ready for the ritual, Princess?”

Blushing, Sugar Belle glanced away. “I... I thought we weren’t calling each other ‘Princess’ anymore...”

“That’s the spirit! Now, for our preparation ritual, these kind stallions will be providing us with a cocktail brew of potions. Just your standard stuff, of course. Stamina enhancement, fertility enhancement, elasticity boosters, that sort of thing.”

“Elasticity boosters?” Sugar Belle’s face scrunched.

“Well, have you seen our husband’s endowment since their transformation?”

Sugar Belle nodded seriously. She’d seen it quite a lot, actually. Couldn’t stop looking at it.

“I’m sure you have some experience with bigger stallions, being Big Mac’s wife and all. But even I could use a little help in that respect, given the size they are now.”

Sugar Belle sighed. It was true she hadn’t been able to be properly intimate with her husband since the combination. “Are we going to have to do this every time?”

“Oh, no. Of course not. This time is just special, for the ritual. For our normal, everyday fun, we can keep some potions around that are far easier and more convenient to take.”

Squinting suspiciously at the stallions, Sugar Belle took a half step back. “More convenient ... than what?”

Cadance stepped over to the nearest stallion, the orange one, getting down on the floor next to him. She reached right past his already-hanging cock to heft his substantial balls. “Our potions are in here. And the purpose of the ritual is to get them inside us where they can do us some good.”

“Really?” Sugar Belle eyed the other five stallions, who stared blithely back at her. “That’s how we’re supposed to take our potions?”

Cadance ducked her head beneath the orange stallion. “Well, it’s part of the ritual.” With that, she started sucking him, pulling his half-hard cock into her mouth as only the Princess of Love could. Her tail flicked behind her, and underneath it her pink pussy winked feverishly. Sugar Belle suspected that Cadance wouldn’t mind taking all her potions this way, given the chance.

Right before her very eyes, the orange stallion’s cock disappeared. Despite its substantial size – almost as big as Big Mac used to be – Cadance was able to swallow it down like it was nothing. Well, not nothing. She seemed to enjoy it far more than she’d enjoy nothing!

Well, she wasn’t the only one with talents. After all, Sugar Belle had gotten plenty of practice with her husband. She’d never actually done this side-by-side with her sort of wife before... It was time to show what she could do. No matter if it was a bit weird to suck a cock that wasn’t Big Mac’s.

Which one to choose, though?

Each stallion was differentiated only by color, and Cadance had already claimed the orange one. Which left Sugar Belle with blue, yellow, green, red, and purple to choose from.

The answer was instant and instinctive: Sugar Belle trotted straight over to the red one. He very obviously wasn’t Big Mac ... but the color was almost the same, and that little touch of familiarity made it feel much less weird to her.

The red stallion watched her expectantly as she approached, but otherwise didn’t move.

She stopped right in front of him. “Um... Hi, I guess. What’s your name?” It didn’t feel right, sucking a stallion’s cock without knowing his name.

“I don’t have a name.”

She stared up at him. “Oh...”

He stared back. Her tail instinctively twitched a little.

Despite the building response of her own body, though, Sugar Belle wasn’t sure how to proceed. This felt ... wrong, somehow. Even if it wasn’t actually cheating, even if her husband was probably doing the same or worse with that Rainbow Dash projection at this very moment ... this just didn’t feel right.

She glanced over at Cadance, but that wasn’t much help. Cadance was noisily slurping up and down the orange stallion’s cock, which was very hard now, and two of the other stallions were already sniffing around her uplifted tail.

Sugar Belle gulped. “So, um, do you want to lie down on your back and...?”

“I am happy to please you in any way you like.” Helpfully, the red stallion was quick to drop down to the floor, then rolled over, still facing her.

Which left his deep red cock lying heavily on his belly.

Sugar Belle couldn’t help it – it just happened on its own. She bit her lip a little, and her tail flagged a little higher. It was exactly the same position she’d had Big Mac in so many times before...

It was almost automatic for her to come over to her stallion’s side, to dip her head low, almost nuzzling that big red cock already. The only thing that stopped her was the lack of Big Mac’s usual nuzzling and caresses. He could be so gentle, so loving. But this stallion was just lying there and waiting for her.

She tore her eyes away from his cock, looking back toward his face. “Um... Could you, uh, touch and nuzzle me a little while I do it?”

“Of course.”

Without a single moment wasted, the stallion reached for her with his hooves, pulling her in closer. He kissed her hind legs, her flanks, and soon after, her sensitive teats.

Oh! Oh goodness! Big Mac never did play with those nearly as much as Sugar Belle wanted. As much as she asked for it and made encouraging noises when he did, he always seemed to forget about doing it again later, and then she’d feel bad about asking for it again and again, even though he said he didn’t mind. It was ... complicated.

It was also her guilty pleasure, and all the more guilty because this random stallion who wasn’t him and wasn’t even real was doing it more readily and better than Big Mac usually did. Sugar Belle gasped at the feeling of his lips squeezing one nipple tightly, at the feeling of his tongue teasing the exposed tip with quick darting motions that made her whole tummy quiver.

She was so engrossed in the sudden, intense feeling that she almost forgot about the cock right in front of her face.

Almost.

It wasn’t easy to forget about, after all. Bright red – a slightly lighter red than Big Mac’s used to be – strongly veined, and quickly twitching its way toward full hardness.

Still a little breathless from the attention to her teats, Sugar Belle wondered – was this stallion, this projection actually getting turned on?

Off to the left, Cadance let out a deep, muffled moan. When Sugar Belle looked, she found the Princess of Love getting mounted and filled by the blue stallion, her head still working away under the orange stallion’s belly. But not for much longer. Because Cadance’s throat was visibly pulsing as she swallowed ... something, and bright orange cum was starting to drip from her nose and the corners of her mouth.

Bright orange...? Would her own stallion cum red?

She turned back to him. Well, only one way to find out. And she’d better get started! Cadance had already gotten one stallion to cum already! And Sugar Belle hadn’t even started! She had a lot of catching up to do.

With that odd sense of urgency in mind, Sugar Belle dipped her head down and took the big red cock into her mouth. Nothing new for her – the size wasn’t all that different, nor even the color. But there was just something about her husband’s cock, some kind of living vitality, that this projection didn’t quite have.

Still, it wasn’t bad or anything, and it sure helped that he was moving on to burying his muzzle in her pussy as she worked on him. Not as passionately as Big Mac always did, but this red stallion definitely knew what he was doing, making Sugar Belle moan around his cock as she pressed it deeper inside.

No stranger to deep throating big cocks, she took a deep breath before plunging deeper. Ah, the feeling of a thick cock spreading her throat open ... now that was always the same!

If she strained her eyes to the side, she could just make out what Cadance was doing, or rather who Cadance was doing. Namely, the blue, green, and yellow stallions. All three at the same time, one for each hole. Hm... And here she’d thought that Cadance didn’t like anal very much. Apparently, she was making an exception here. And she was very far ahead of Sugar Belle, because the cum leaking out around those stallions’ cocks did not match their colors. Had she really already taken more than one in each?

Luckily for Sugar Belle, her red stallion was already starting to flare in her throat. Huh ... these guys had kind of hair triggers, didn’t they? Now it made sense why Cadance was able to finish them up so quickly!

Before she knew it, his girth was pulsing wider in her mouth, pumping his cum – presumably red cum, though she didn’t get to see a single drop of it – straight down into her belly.

She allowed it to surge straight in, no need for her to swallow. It’s what she’d always done for Big Mac, and the whole point was for her to get these ‘potions’ inside of her, right?

Unlike every other stallion she’d ever been with – except her husband when he was especially worked up – this stallion’s cock didn’t go soft as soon as he’d finished his last few squirts inside her. When she pulled her face up off of his cock, incidentally sitting her rump down over his head, that big red cock of his was just as hard as before. She ... she wondered if she was supposed to go right back down on it...

“Here you go, Sugar. I’ve gotten him almost ready to pop for you.”

At the sound of Cadance’s voice, Sugar Belle looked up from her stallion’s red cock ... to find another stallion’s blue cock hard, twitching, and already flared, right in front of her.

“Huh?” she said in its general direction.

“I’ve already gotten plenty, and you’re going to need the potions more than I do.” With a gentle hoof, Cadance nudged Sugar Belle’s head forward. “Go ahead.”

It took an effort of will to push her misgivings aside, but Sugar Belle did it. She could just barely stretch her mouth open around that big blue flare, and she really wasn’t sure if she’d be able to squeeze it down her throat or not.

No need. When Cadance had said he was ready to pop, she meant he was ready. By the time he even touched the back of her throat, thick pulses of cum began erupting out of him.

She swallowed as much as she could. And she was good at it – she had practice. But there was a lot of it, and she just couldn’t keep up. Not quite. Her mouth filled with cum, but not musty, salty, and slimy like she was expecting – thick sweet and creamy! It reminded her of a custard pie filling ... how strange! And when a little leaked out past her lips, it was indeed blue. She’d never seen – or tasted – anything quite so bizarre.

“Nice, isn’t it?” Cadance whispered into her ear.

Her mouth still full and busy swallowing the stallion’s last few squirts, Sugar Belle nodded slightly. It was quite nice tasting, actually. And now that she was getting used to the idea, she might not mind having a bit more.

Lucky for her, there was plenty more to be had. The green stallion was still going at it, his forelegs gripping tightly around Cadance’s body as he humped into her, the other five stallions were completely available for her.

The red one and the blue one, she’d already tasted, so why not the others? Now... How would she take them...? “Purple,” she said. “Um... Can I call you Purple?”

“You may call us anything you like, Princess.”

That kind of attitude was really going to take some getting used to! But at least it would make things easier. Time to take charge a little.

“Okay then,” she said, “Purple, I’d like you to, um, take me from behind.” She had to bite off a ‘if that’s okay’ at the end. She was sure by now that it was okay. No need to be so hesitant. “And, uh, Yellow and orange, I’d like you both up on your hind legs in front of me.”

Cadance moaned a little as the green stallion came inside her, his cock visibly throbbing as multicolored excess seeped out around it. “That’s more like it! We’ll make a princess consort out of you yet!”

As the stallions got into position in front of and behind her, Sugar Belle felt her cheeks heat up in a vivid blush. “Um... Thank you Prin— I mean, Cadance.”

“I mean it.” Cadance leaned over and kissed her. “Now... Are you finished with Red there? I haven’t tasted him yet...”

“Oh, of course!” Did they all taste different? Sugar Belle supposed she was about to find out. But she did shuffle to the side a little to let the red stallion get out from underneath her. She smiled. “As strange as this all is, I think I’m starting to— Aah!”

In one quick, fluid motion that didn’t waste a moment of time, the purple stallion had mounted her and plunged his ready cock deep into her pussy. It slid in so easily! She hadn’t realized she was that wet already! Or was it because he was still slick from Cadance?

Either way, it was lovely. She hadn’t been properly mounted since her husband combined himself with the other two stallions and became an alicorn. Even if she’d been able to get over how inappropriate that would seem at this point, their cock was simply too big for her now.

Thankfully, these potions would fix that. Even more thankfully, this purple stallion was filling her in a way she’d been sorely missing all this time. Suddenly, Cadance’s imminent blowjob with the red stallion blurred into the background, as did the other stallions. The only thing that mattered was the thick, warm cock spreading her insides and going even deeper with every smooth, gentle thrust. Her inner walls clenched down against him. Wouldn’t be long now. She hadn’t realized how badly she needed this.

Her attention was finally torn away – at least a little – though, when two more cocks presented themselves right in front of her: one yellow, one orange. The color combination gave her citrusy ideas, but to her slight disappointment, they didn’t taste like orange and lemon candy – only like warm stallion cock and Cadance’s juices.

Didn’t matter. She’d be tasting their cum soon instead.

As the purple stallion bottomed out and started pressing her forward with his strong thrusts, she happily went along with it and used the motion to guide her tongue up and down the two cocks in front of her. All her world was hazy except for those three shafts; she just didn’t have the attention to spare for anything else. She was barely even giving these two enough attention – she was just on fire from the inside out, her body eagerly awaiting the long-needed filling she knew must be coming soon.

Apparently, though, Cadance had no such limitations. Even as she serviced the red stallion and replaced the green one with the blue one inside her pussy, she somehow also made time to magically stroke the two stallions Sugar Belle was licking, probably more than making up for Sugar Belle’s distraction.

That was good, because less and less of her attention was being paid to those two. Her pussy clenched hard around the purple stallion’s cock. Somehow, he’d known to squeeze her sides even tighter between his forelegs at just the right time – it was driving her wild, sending off fireworks inside her, and... and...

Suddenly, explosively, Sugar Belle came. The two cocks pressed up against her muzzle did nothing to muffle her love cries. If she’d had more presence of mind in the moment, she might have wondered if her husband might hear it from the next room. As it was, though, she only had attention for the wonderfully stiff cock flaring deep inside her, stretching her out just perfectly where she needed it most.

She squirted like mad, as much or more than she ever had with Big Mac, and when her pussy instinctively milked him from the inside out, the purple stallion soon squirted as well. She could feel each powerful stream of it jetting against and through her innermost barrier. Instead of pumping her full of foals, pumping her full of the potions she’d need to give her husband foals. And yet, the feeling was just as satisfying as ever.

If she thought it was over when he stopped cumming inside her, she was in for a surprise. And for a treat. “Now, Blue!” Cadance said through a mouthful of red cum. “Sugar Belle’s ready for you!”

Quick as a dream, the red stallion pulled out of her, and the blue stallion took his place. Even with Sugar Belle still trembling and clenching in orgasm, the blue stallion shoved his own cock deep inside her, right where the red’s had been. With Cadance’s careful prep work, he was already on the verge of finishing, and plunging into a brand new mare seemed to be just enough to finish him off. Before Sugar Belle’s orgasm even ended, the blue stallion came inside her as well, adding his own potent potion to the growing mix inside her. It was almost as if the purple stallion’s orgasm hadn’t ended at all...

Somehow, the words “open wide” in Cadance’s voice managed to get through her orgasmic haze. And of course she did what she was told.

Her mouth was flooded by staccato bursts of orange and yellow cum. She had no hope of swallowing the efforts of two of these stallions at once, but she did her best. The worst part of it was that their cum was truly delicious – the idea of it running down her chin and neck, of it dripping uselessly to the floor, was heartbreaking.

Thankfully, Cadance was there to catch it before that happened, greedily licking it from Sugar Belle’s fur.

And once the stallions were done, once all three of them pulled away from her, Cadance was there with a big wet – and very sloppy – kiss. It began with both of their muzzles streaked with orange and yellow, and with Cadance’s cheeks puffed out full. It ended with both of their faces clean and Sugar Belle’s belly full.

“There.” Cadance gave her one more little kiss. “Feeling ready for our husband now?”

Sugar Belle blushed and looked at the green stallion, who she hadn’t had at all yet. “Maybe just a few more? To be sure?”

Cadance giggled and pranced in place. “That’s the spirit!” Unceremoniously, she pounced on the yellow stallion, pinned him underneath herself, and pressed herself down on his cock until it completely disappeared inside her. “I’m sure they won’t mind waiting just a little bit longer, if it’s just to make sure the potions are in full effect.” She moaned a little as the stallion bucked his hips upward to meet her, his juicy yellow balls bouncing off of Cadance’s ass cheeks.

For her own part, Sugar Belle was ready for a treat. As sensitive as she still was from her first orgasm so far, this was no time to hesitate, no time to hold back. “You and you,” she said, pointing to the orange stallion and the red one. Entirely coincidence that they were the colors of her husband and her sister-in-law. “I want you two on my teats, while he—” she pointed to the green one “—fucks me silly.”

In order to give them full access for what she wanted, and heedless of the mess already accumulating on the floor, she rolled onto her back and spread her hind legs wide. And to think ... this was just he appetizer...

Author's Note

This story was suggested and chosen by my SubscribeStar supporters! Every month, I take suggestions from my supporters and they vote to decide which story idea I'll write next.

Chapter 3 - Breeding

Sugar Belle was already feeling stuffed quite full as she followed Cadance out of the side room and back into the main chamber. Though both of them had already been through a lot – and were still leaking a bit of multicolored potion from just about every hole – she actually felt perfectly well rested and ready, and not at all sore. It must have been one of the effects of those potions. She really ought to have been sore after all she went through in there!

Just ahead of her, Cadance stopped dead in her tracks. When Sugar Belle stepped around her, she quickly found out why.

Their husband was absolutely buried in Rainbow Dashes. At least a dozen of them. All different varieties of them. Wonderbolt Rainbow, cheerleader Rainbow, nurse Rainbow, stripper Rainbow, filly Rainbow, firefighter Rainbow, big buff bodybuilder Rainbow, and was that a ... sexy librarian Rainbow? And a bunch more she couldn’t readily identify. Barely anything of their husband was visible beneath all the writhing and dripping image projection Rainbow Dashes.

Sugar Belle was left speechless at the sight, but Cadance – maybe due to her experience as the Princess of Love – wasn’t quite so overcome with shock. She laughed. “A little obsessed with Rainbow Dash, are we?”

One by one, their husband’s three heads popped up out of the colorful pile, each one with a messy, dripping muzzle. Two of them looked rather chagrined. Zephyr, of course, was being pretty Zephyr about it.

“Don’t blame us!” Shining Armor said. “It was Zephyr’s idea.”

“Eeyup.”

Zephyr huffed. “Practice makes perfect, and when it’s time for us to get with the real Rainbows, I want to be perfect!”

“You’re already perfect enough for me,” Cadance said with a smile.

Sugar Belle scrunched her nose, though. “Didn’t Rainbow Dash say something along the lines of ‘never in a million years’?”

“It’s a work in progress!” With that, Zephyr ducked his head back into the pile. Sexy librarian Rainbow Dash gasped and cooed happily ... probably as a result of whatever it was Zephyr was doing with her down there.

Shining looked down into the pile where Zephyr’s head had gone. “Hey, our real wives are back. Don’t you think we should take care of them instead?”

No response came from the pile. Big Mac shook his head and rolled his eyes.

Shining looked back over at Cadance and Sugar Belle. “How are are you supposed to dismiss all these image projections, anyway? How do you get them to go away when you don’t need them anymore?”

Instantly, all the projections vanished. Along with them vanished all the various fluids they had produced, leaving their husband clean ... but only for a moment. Because all the cum they’d pumped into all of those projections – quite the substantial amount – didn’t vanish. It fell with them to the floor, splattering all over them and the floor shortly after.

They picked themselves up, shook themselves off. It was only marginally successful at getting some of the cum off.

Zephyr used their forehoof to wipe a big splotch off his face. “You could have warned us first, Shiney.”

“I didn’t know it was going to happen like that!” Shining groaned and shook his head again. A bit of cum was dripping from his horn. “But at least now we can focus on the real reason we’re here.” He looked over at Cadance and Sugar Belle, smiling that big dopey grin of his.

“Eeyup.” Big Mac was finally able to take his own turn with one of their forehooves, wiping some of the heavy drizzle away from his neck. He looked up at Cadance. “Uh... A little help?”

Sugar Belle would have been tempted to leave them like that, as a sort of light payback for being so obviously obsessed with a mare they weren’t even married to. But apparently Cadance was less prone to holding a grudge. She fired up her ever-useful cum-zapping spell, quickly and efficiently removing every drop, which only splattered more of it onto the floor.

Sugar Belle was really going to have to see if she could learn that spell...

Now that they were clean, the stallion trio quickly trotted over to Cadance and Sugar Belle. Even Zephyr seemed to have gotten over it, now paying full attention to them.

At first, Sugar Belle kissed Big Mac while Cadance made out with Zephyr and Shining. That was the usual arrangement ... but when Shining nuzzled closer to her, Sugar Belle willingly gave him a little sugar, too. After all, she was starting to come to terms better with the idea that they were all her husband. Even Zephyr got a nice little kiss from her – no tongue though – while Big Mac took some time with Cadance.

“That’s more like it,” Sugar Belle said, giving Big Mac one last peck on the cheek. She then looked over and up at Cadance. “So, um... How should we start?”

Cadance grinned. “How about we get them going with a nice blowjob first?”

Sugar Belle glanced underneath her husband’s belly, finding his giant cock at the ready and already throbbing hard. “Uh... Looks like they’ve already ‘got going’...”

Cadance didn’t reply ... quite possibly because she’d already worked her way underneath their belly and had squeezed the tip of their cock into her mouth.

Well, that settles it, Sugar Belle supposed.

What she really wanted could wait a few more minutes. In the meantime, she was not about to let Cadance have all the fun by herself!

Cadance was bobbing her way forward and back, slowly working their shaft into her throat, and that suited Sugar Belle just fine. Even with the benefit of those potions, she suspected that she’d never be able to fit that giant thing entirely in her mouth like Cadance was trying to. Instead, she ducked underneath their belly from the other side, going straight for the thick base of their cock, where she planted her lips in a wide kiss against the side of it.

Their shaft was just hopelessly huge. Even with her mouth stretched as wide as she could go, her lips didn’t even go halfway around it. That wouldn’t stop her from helping make her stallions fell good, though! Slowly, delicately, she slid her mouth up and down their shaft, dragging her lips across the soft, supple skin over the firm core of it, tracing the contours of their thick veins with her tongue, kissing and suckling on the ridge of their medial ring...

And that’s where her lips met Cadance’s. What a kiss!

Sugar Belle pulled back a little and stared. Had Cadance really made it all the way to their medial ring already? As she watched, Cadance took a deep breath through her nose, then plunged a bit deeper still, until their medial ring made a noticeable bulge in her neck.

“Wow,” Sugar Belle whispered. “You’re really going for it this time, aren’t you?”

“Mm-hm!” The look in Cadance’s eyes was both blissful and determined. Like she knew she was finally going to do it.

Oh yes, Sugar Belle was aware of the Love Princess’s quest to finally deep-throat her husband’s new and improved cock. And she was only jealous that she’d probably never be able to do the same. She was just a unicorn, after all, not an alicorn ... and she knew she had her limits.

Even Cadance had her limits. By the time the two mares’ lips touched again, the poor Love Princess was very obviously struggling. Red face, tightly shut eyes with tears welling up at the edges, and drool pouring from between her wide-stretched mouth and the even wider base of their husband’s cock. But Cadance, apparently dead-set on pushing those limits, just kept going. Maybe it was the three sets of appreciative gasps and moans coming from above – that was certainly music to Sugar Belle’s ears.

As Cadance edged closer and closer, Sugar Belle shuffled a little further back, beginning to work on her husband’s three huge balls instead. She didn’t mind letting Cadance have her way with their cock. While she’d been a little off-put by these triple balls at first, with their unorthodox shape and mismatched colors, now that she’d had some time to get used to them, she considered it one of her favorite things ever. Just another way that no other stallion could ever compare to her Big Mac, Shining, and Zephyr. She nuzzled right up against them, letting two of the heavy orbs rest against her muzzle as she licked the third. Just like his cock, these things were so huge she’d never have the slightest chance of getting even one of them inside her mouth, but that didn’t stop her from kissing and wetly dragging her tongue over every last bit of their bulbous curves.

Goodness! Even after everything they’d pumped into those Rainbow Dashes, their balls still seemed so solid and brimming full of more! She lavished attention on them shamelessly ... though nopony could blame her if she tended to spend a little more time on the red nut, rather than the white or green ones.

A supremely satisfied grunt from above – Big Mac’s voice, she’d recognize it anywhere – drew her attention back to matters that weren’t round, bulging, and brimming with cum. She pulled her face away from their shared sack and opened her eyes to see Cadance kissing her husband’s sheath. Gagging and sputtering as she did so, but she was doing it!

“You ... you did it!” Sugar Belle whispered.

Cadance’s success was short-lived, though. After a massive gag that made her whole body convulse, she quickly shuffled backward, pulling herself off their husband’s cock in a lengthy process that finally culminated in their big flat tip finally popping free from her mouth.

She stood there, head hanging down, sides heaving, and drool draining out of her mouth ... but she was also grinning like mad.

Sugar Belle was so proud of her!

But not so proud that she let herself get too distracted from what she was doing. After all, there was a great big horsecock in front of her now, unclaimed and slathered in Cadance’s throat slime. Sugar Belle went at it eagerly, dragging not only her tongue, but her whole face up and down their massive shaft.

Somewhere up above, in a part of the universe with a lot less cock in it, Cadance said something to their triple stud: “Since I’ve already had you, how about we give Sugar Belle the first try?”

“Nice!” Zephyr said. “I’ve been waiting a long time to finally get a bit of that cute little unicorn’s cunny!”

Shining groaned. “You could have worded that better, Zeph. Like, a lot better. But still, yeah I’m more than okay with that. How about you, Mac?”

“EEYUP!”

Sugar Belle stopped where she was, with that huge slab of horsecock against her face, looking down the immense length of it. As much as she had been wanting to finally please her husband again – and get properly bred by them – the idea of it had been much easier to deal with when it was in terms of a hypothetical time in the future, even if that future was only a few minutes away. The idea of trying it right now ... well, that was a different prospect entirely. A decidedly intimidating prospect.

Cadance peeked her head underneath their husband’s belly, meeting Sugar Belle’s eyes over the top of their cock. “So... Feel like giving our boys some sugar?”

Sugar Belle winced. “Is it, um ... is it too late to back out?”

Cadance rushed around to Sugar Belle’s side, pulling her slightly away from their husband and into a deep hug. “Of course it isn’t! We would never want to push you into anything you aren’t comfortable with!”

“Or push anything into you that you’re not comfortable with!” Zephyr said, as the stallions came in to join the hug, wrapping their forehooves around both mares.

“This isn’t really the time for jokes,” Shining chided.

Big Mac kissed Sugar Belle lightly and tenderly, just the way she liked best. “I believe in you, Sugar. You’re the strongest mare I know.”

Oh goodness, the sound of that being said in his deep voice – even deeper now that he was an alicorn – it sent shivers through her whole body. Especially a certain part of her body. Big Mac didn’t often talk very much ... but when he did, he always made sure to say something that mattered.

“You’re right,” she whispered, feeling like she was melting inside. “I can do this.” She kissed Big Mac back, fully and hungrily on the lips. “I want you to take me just like you did after our first wedding night.”

Both of the other stallions looked over at Big Mac’s head. “How’d you take her on her wedding night?” Zephyr had the impertinence to ask. Shining at least was gracious enough to keep his questions to himself.

Big Mac gave a big, calm grin. “You two just let me handle it, and I’ll show ya.”

First, he bent down and nuzzled her cheeks sweetly. Sugar Belle closed her eyes and practically purred. She knew exactly how this was going to go and exactly how it was going to make her feel in the end, and she couldn’t wait.

Only, she wasn’t exactly right about how it was going to go. Because soon Big Mac wasn’t the only one nuzzling her. Zephyr quickly came in on the other side, nuzzling her other cheek. Shining came in the middle, planting sweet kisses in a line up from her nose to the base of her horn.

She gasped and tittered a little at that – she’d always had a very sensitive horn. And getting cuddles and kisses from the other two stallions she was now married to was surprising to her ... surprising in how fast it had gone from weird to, well, exciting and comforting at the same time. A feeling she could only call bliss.

Soon, Big Mac led the way, nuzzling and kissing his way down her neck, over her back, over her rump. Both other stallions followed his lead, tripling the tingling sensation and making her tail rise insatiably.

Before she knew it, they were behind her. Without realizing it, she’d somehow assumed the classic pony breeding stance – tail raised, hind legs slightly apart, back arched. Her body knew what to do. She only had to drift along in that instinctual flow. It was all going to be fine. She was in good hooves. She’d trust Big Mac with anything, anything at all. And she was even growing to trust Shining and Zephyr the same way.

Just like on their first wedding night, Big Mac didn’t leap onto her right away – he planted his big wide muzzle firmly between her ass cheeks, pressing his mouth and nose against her pussy gently and firmly. She could feel his hot, powerful breath on her as he drank in her scent. Her pussy was winking like mad, kissing him back over and over again.

Big Mac, though, didn’t rush things. He planted his broad, warm tongue against her pussy lips and slowly slid it upward, cupping her entire vulva in a long, deliberate lick that stopped only barely short of her tail-hole.

To her slight surprise, though, he didn’t repeat that like he had before. Instead, he allowed Shining and Zephyr to repeat it.

Shining was almost perfect. His muzzle wasn’t quite as big as Big Mac’s, his tongue not quite as broad and all-encompassing. But he was a quick learner and did an excellent job mimicking Big Mac’s style.

Zephyr, on the other hoof... Well, he was obviously still feeling a bit competitive, because he apparently felt the need to add some flourishes. He zig-zagged his tongue side to side over her pussy lips, then ran circles around the bulb hiding her clit, before sticking his tongue inside and running it from bottom to top on the inside.

Not that it didn’t feel good ... it just wasn’t what Sugar Belle had been hoping for, and it didn’t live up to the way Big Mac could treat her. Oh well. Zephyr would learn in time. For now, though...

For now, she was ready to really do it with her new and improved husband. Or, at least, she was as ready as she’d ever be. She looked over her shoulder at them. “Big Mac...”

“Sugar Belle?”

“I’m ... I’m ready to try it.”

For a lovely little moment, a predatory gleam came to his eyes. Oh, how he must have been missing her! They hadn’t been able to properly make love together since that last night in the Crystal Palace before his fusion with the other two stallions.

But Big Mac was always conscientious, to a fault. “You sure, Sugar Buns? Last time we tried, well...”

Cadance kissed him on his cheek. “You’re so sweet. It’s one of the reasons I love you. But don’t worry about Sugar Belle. Now that she’s gotten plenty of those potions, she should have no problem handling your new size.” She slapped their rump. “And besides, you know perfectly well how to be gentle, don’t you?”

Big Mac thought about it for a moment. “Eeyup.”

“Come on, then!” Shining moaned. “Even I’m getting antsy to get started. And I think if we wait any longer, Zephyr’s going to have an aneurysm or something...”

Sugar Belle had to giggle about that. Because it was true. When she took a moment to look at Zephyr’s face, he was looking positively neurotic staring down at her rump. Hm... Despite his obsession with Rainbow Dash, despite having as much of the Princess of Love as he wanted, he was still excited about having her? Sugar Belle usually didn’t think of herself as being at all competitive in that kind of comparison ... but this was no mere flattery – his desire for her was obviously genuine. Was she really that special of a mare? Well, it certainly felt good to feel so special. Her heart was getting fluttery, and her body was getting warm deep inside. Her pussy winked more fervently than ever.

And this time, finally, her pussy got what it wanted.

The gentle way they mounted her reassured Sugar Belle that Big Mac was definitely in control of every movement. When she felt the gigantic flat tip of their cock softly pressing against her under her tail, she didn’t even flinch. She trusted him. She trusted Cadance and her potions. And more than anything, she wanted to be one with him again. To be one with all three of her wonderful stallions.

As expertly as ever, Big Mac nudged their tip up and down, side to side against her pussy, spreading her slick wetness everywhere it would be needed for that crucial first penetration.

Sugar Belle’s legs were trembling, and not because of their substantial weight on top of her. She was intensely nervous – there was no denying that. But she was not afraid. She was ready.

Before Sugar Belle even realized she was coming, Cadance was right in front of her. “Just relax.” Cadance kissed her, fully on the lips. Her horn glowed, sending a cascade of tingling, warming magic over Sugar Belle’s whole body. “All you need to do is feel the love...”

Sugar Belle wasn’t sure what Cadance had just done to her. Even with her unicorn’s sense for magic, that spell seemed completely mysterious. But she did feel the love, more strongly than ever before. Love for Big Macintosh, love for Shining Armor, love for Zephyr Breeze, and even love for Cadance herself. Sugar Belle quickly came forward and kissed Cadance again, deep and heartfelt and needy.

And in that moment, without any struggle or Sugar Belle thinking about it in the slightest, her husband’s cock entered her.

Unlike her earlier struggles, it now felt like the most natural thing in the world, just as it had with Big Mac before the fusion. As slowly and gently as ever, that wonderful cock worked its way inside of her. One gentle little thrust at a time, they delved her depths and filled her with loving warmth.

She wasn’t even able to gasp at the sensation, not with Cadance’s tongue frolicking in her mouth. She could only moan into her fellow wife’s muzzle as she was absolutely stuffed to the brim ... and yet, without the slightest pain or even discomfort.

It was so strange. She could feel that massive cock forcing her insides to rearrange to accommodate it, stretching her poor inner walls to and beyond their limit, forcing her ass cheeks apart with its sheer girth. And yet, none of that felt the slightest bit bad or wrong. If anything, it felt wonderful. She’d never before felt such a sense of belonging and wholeness.

Cadance broke their kiss. “How does that feel, Sugar Belle?”

A tremulous whimper was all that Sugar Belle could manage.

“I’ll take that as a good sign.” Cadance kissed her on the nose. Now ... about how to make it even better...

Sugar Belle was far too distracted to check what Cadance was doing when she slipped down and to the side. Because her husband’s cock had finally met her limits. Gentle as their thrusts were, they no longer penetrated any deeper – they only pressed her forward. Their tip must have been pushing right against her cervix, but it didn’t hurt in the slightest. An effect of the potion or Cadance’s spell?

Big Mac had certainly felt it. He stopped instantly. “Are you alright, Sugar Belle?”

She didn’t trust her voice to do anything more than whimper in that moment, but she managed a definitive nod. She felt more ‘alright’ than she ever had in her whole life. More – please!

Before they even started moving again, Sugar Belle felt a new – and very welcome – touch. Cadance had nuzzled her way down to Sugar Belle’s underbelly and was now very busy having her way with Sugar Belle’s teats.

Yes! Sugar Belle shuddered, her pussy squeezing down even tighter around her husband’s cock. Finally, she was married to somepony who remembered how much she liked that! And this was the first time she’d ever felt it in the middle of having sex before – obviously Big Mac couldn’t reach when it was just the two of them alone. And not only was Cadance doing it, she was a master at it. A feather-light teasing touch at first, gentle licks building into bold suckling, and even a tiny pinch of teeth that sent sparks shooting up through her whole body. Her eyes rolled backward and her fur stood on end. This was perfect.

And it only got better when her husband resumed their gentle thrusting inside her. Still under Big Mac’s careful control, they never went too deep again, instead pulsing perfectly in and out, almost to her limit.

Before long, all three stallions were groaning. Their body shuddered against hers.

“Gonna ... bust ... soon,” Zephyr said between their heavy breaths. “No offense, Cady-candy, but Sugar is way tighter than you!”

“He’s right,” Shining agreed, “we’re ... we’re not going to last ... much longer...”

Cadance didn’t even pull her mouth away from Sugar Belle’s teats, stimulating her even as she spoke. “Don’t hold back, boys. That spell I cast on you all has tied your orgasms together. She won’t cum until you do, and you won’t cum until she does.”

Between the heavenly pussy filling she was getting from behind and the luxuriantly skilled nipple suckling she was getting from below, Sugar Belle certainly felt like she was well past the verge of orgasm herself! Was this what holding back an orgasm felt like? She’d ... she’d never actually tried that herself. She’d always been focused on getting off as soon as possible, because Big Mac seemed to love seeing it happen so much...

She didn’t have to wait much longer. As the stallions had said, they were very close. She could already feel their massive flare expanding deep, deep inside her, feeling like it was almost as wide as her whole body!

Shining bit down on the base of her mane, huffing hot breaths against her withers. Zephyr nuzzled the side of her neck, kissing as he went. And Big Mac leaned his head forward to whisper into her ear through clenched teeth: “I ... love you ... Sugar!”

With that, the flood came. Absolutely titanic streams of cum gushing directly into her potion-enhanced womb, quickly stuffing her full and beginning to make her swell from the inside out.

She barely noticed. Because at that very moment, her own orgasm hit her – the most intense she’d ever felt, by far. So much pleasure pumped through her that she felt like she was exploding, physically bursting all over the room from the excess sensation. Though her eyes were wide open, they saw nothing. The only things in all of Equestria that mattered were the pulsing of her husband’s cock inside of her, the answering throbs of her pussy squeezing down and milking them for even more, and their heartbeat beating as one with hers.

Her whole body shuddered and shook. Her belly swelled absurdly, as if she was already well along in the pregnancy that was only now beginning. She didn’t breathe. She couldn’t. There was no room inside her to make a single gasp or sound. The only thing she had room for was her husband’s love. And their enormous cock pumping prodigious loads of cum into her.

When it finally ended, she was actually relieved. She wasn’t sure how much more of that she could take without quite literally exploding ... or just going outright insane from her brain being fried with pleasure. For a long moment, her husband rested with their cock inside her, just savoring the afterglow.

When they pulled out, Sugar Belle shuddered. Perhaps she would have felt empty inside after losing such a huge visitor, but the lasting gift they’d given her ensured that she’d feel far from empty. Even though it poured out of her when their still-flared tip popped free, she still knew that she wouldn’t be feeling empty inside for at least a week ... or, more likely, for eleven months, for the full term of the foal – or foals – they’d just pumped into her.

Briefly, her vision came back. She was able to see Cadance again, to hear the voices of her husband saying how much each one of them loved her and how good her pussy had felt. But it was still all very fuzzy and indistinct. She dropped to a kneeling position, then gave up and flopped sideways on the crystal floor instead. The floor was good. The floor was cool and solid when everything else was overwhelmingly warm and fuzzy. Voices of concern echoed in her ears; she paid them no mind. Her vision went blank again, and this time she welcomed it, blissfully allowing her eyes to close. The cum draining from her was beginning to form a substantial puddle, and she was more than willing to bask in that puddle as if it was a relaxing hot tub she could gently fall asleep in...

🫧 🫧 🫧

Sugar Belle awoke slowly, reluctantly, to the sound of a mare moaning, crying in passion. It was ... it was Cadance’s voice, from somewhere behind her.

She still felt very bloated and round in her belly, which a quick touch confirmed. She was huge in the middle right now. How long had it been? Was she already pregnant, was she already about to foal?

Blinking a few times cleared her eyes, and she found herself still in the big, vaulted central chamber of the Crystal Sanctum. Okay, not very long, then. And she was probably still full of liquid cum, not young foals about to be born. And she was on ... a bed? Yes – the luxuriant warmth and softness beneath her was definitely a bed, and a rather nice one at that. How? There hadn’t been any beds here when they... Oh. It was glowing slightly. It seemed the Sanctum’s magic could conjure more than just assorted varieties of Rainbow Dashes or multicolored potion-jizzing stallions. It could provide her with a luxuriantly comfortable bed, complete with pillows and sheets. Cadance and the stallions must have seen to taking care of her before they ... they...

Sugar Belle blinked again, then laboriously rolled over in the bed to see what was happening behind her.

Her husband was on their back on the floor, with Cadance straddling their hips and bouncing on top of them. Unlike Sugar Belle, Cadance was able to take their entire length, making the whole thing disappear inside her at the bottom of every bounce. The stallions’ hooves gripped and squeezed the juicy curves of Cadance’s ass, helping her bounce all the more vigorously. No careful and gentle touch here – no, they were truly giving it their all, all of them were.

For the briefest of moments, that made Sugar Belle jealous. That quickly faded, though, when she remembered her own recent experience. She had been so overwhelmed with love and pleasure that she’d passed out! How could she possibly ask for more than that? And if she did ever work up the nerve to ask for it ... well, she was certain that they’d be more than happy to give it to her.

Slowly, she sat up on the edge of the glowing bed.

That movement was enough to finally draw Cadance’s attention. She suddenly stopped bouncing. “Sugar Belle, you’re awake!”

With a small gasp, Big Mac turned his head upside down to look at her. “Are you okay? We didn’t hurt ya none, did we?”

“I’m perfectly fine.” She smiled warmly, hoping he’d believe her. “Did I, uh, miss much?”

Shining was still staring straight up at Cadance’s body, but he must have still been paying attention anyway. “Don’t worry, you’ve only been out for a few minutes.”

“A few minutes of the most amazing, glorious, raunchy sex Equestria has ever seen!” Zephyr laughed a little and slapped Cadance’s ass with a hoof ... or at least Sugar Belle assumed he was the one controlling their hoof when they did that.

Cadance rolled her eyes at that ... but she also smiled and nodded, beginning to grind her hips against theirs again. “Would you like to join back in?” she asked. “Only if you’re feeling up to it, of course.”

Sugar Belle could see the bulge in Cadance’s belly caused by their massive cock inside her. It sent a shudder through her body once more, as if her pussy had a mind of its own and could remember what that felt like. But still, she was feeling awfully weak and still a little bit woozy.

“Um... Maybe just some cuddles and kissing?”

The adoring love in Cadance’s eyes was unmistakable. “Come on over,” she said, “there’s plenty to go around!”

With that, she started bouncing in earnest again, filling the domed chamber with the echoing plap-plap-plap of her ass against the stallions’ hips ... soon followed by appreciative moans from all three stallions.

Carefully, Sugar Belle got back up onto her hooves next to the bed. It actually wasn’t as bad as she’d thought it might be. The dizziness was quickly retreating, leaving her only feeling refreshed. Refreshed, and so very, very sloshing full inside.

Walking over to them wasn’t nearly the challenge she’d feared it might be. And once there, she went straight to Big Mac. Sure, she was married to all of them now, but Big Mac would always be her first, foremost, and favorite husband. Nothing would change that. So it was his muzzle she dipped down toward first, for her first eager kiss.

As she made out with him, Cadance leaned forward, moving to a more stroking motion instead of bouncing so that she could join in the fun as well, sharing a three-way kiss with Shining and Zephyr.

Sugar Belle wasn’t about to neglect her other husbands, though. As soon as she’d properly expressed her love for Big Mac – and his tongue – she moved over to take Cadance’s place with Shining and Zephyr, leaving Big Mac’s lips in Cadance’s capable care.

Somehow, there was no longer the slightest hint of awkwardness when it came to kissing the other two. They were hers now, and she was theirs, and what they’d just been through together somehow cemented that in her mind, finally made it real to her. She enjoyed the gentle pressing of Shining’s lips, she enjoyed the intense writhing of Zephyr’s tongue inside her mouth. And now, it felt like the most natural thing in the world.

There was one still left out, though... Once she’d given the other two boys enough affection, Sugar Belle grabbed Cadance by the horn and pulled her upward, away from Big Mac.

The instant their eyes met, Cadance seemed to know just what Sugar Belle wanted. Resting both forehooves on Sugar Belle’s withers, Cadance pulled her fellow wife in for a close and very passionate kiss, sharing the flavors of all three stallions between them, all while Cadance continued riding their cock like she owned it.

Sugar Belle’s kiss with Cadance was cut a little short, though, when Zephyr barked out, “Hey! What the heck are you two doing?”

It took Sugar Belle a moment to realize that he wasn’t talking about her and Cadance. When she looked down, she found Shining and Big Mac kissing each other just as passionately.

The sight made her bubble with joy inside. So adorable! She hadn’t even thought about it that way, but now that she did ... well, they were all married to each other, weren’t they? All each other’s husbands as well. And it was wonderful to see them getting along so nicely, to see their broad, powerful tongues slipping against one another. And, well, maybe it was getting her a little wet and winky under the tail as well.

Zephyr still seemed repulsed by the idea, though, staring at them as if he was very much regretting being attached to the two. Could he feel what they were feeling? How kissing made them feel? Surely he’d come around eventually...

Cadance had a more immediate plan, though. Quickly, she whispered into Sugar Belle’s ear, then dove back down to distract Zephyr with a very messy, passionate kiss of her own.

Sugar Belle was happy to follow Cadance’s whispered instructions. She hurried around behind them all, between the stallions’ outstretched hind legs, to the, well ... to the business end of their lovemaking.

Very little of their cock was visible – only a bit of their sheath, with Cadance’s juices slowly drizzling down it as she rocked her hips on top of them. But their three balls were nicely exposed and fair game to any wife with an unoccupied tongue...

Sugar Belle sprawled onto the floor between their hind legs, holding their triple sack between her forehooves as she started licking. She gave it her all, putting her whole muzzle into it and slathering her tongue across each of the three huge balls in turn. With every caress, she imagined her efforts redoubling the load of cum that would soon be inside Cadance. Their balls still felt so firm, heavy, and full, even after all they’d already done today. Alicorn vitality was amazing, and she was here all the way, to give them even more, to boost them beyond even alicorn prowess, to finally give Cadance the breeding she deserved!

It didn’t take much longer. Just like when they were with Sugar Belle, the stallions climaxed at the exact same moment as Cadance. Cadance moaned into Zephyr’s mouth and planted herself firmly all the way down their sheath, her pussy convulsing around them. In the same instant, their balls clenched and their sheath bulged, sending a flood of virile cum straight up into the alicorn princess. Shining and Big Mac’s moans were muffled as well ... were they still kissing each other?

Sugar Belle didn’t miss a single beat. She kept hard at work on her husband’s balls, caressing every curve and crevice of their shared sack with her tongue. Even as their cum overflowed Cadance and began spurting out from between their cock and her pussy, Sugar Belle kept at it. It wasn’t as if she’d never tasted their cum before, after all, and of course she’d had it on her face before. So she kept going, kept teasing them, even as it splattered all over her face, even as she had to start repeatedly swallowing to take care of all the cum she was licking off of their balls.

Even a male alicorn’s vitality couldn’t keep them going forever. Not that they needed to keep going. Cadance had already swelled quite full, even as they gave their last few feeble spurts.

Her whole head still splattered in cum, Sugar Belle came around them again, bringing herself back face to face to face to face to face with her husband and her wife.

The stallions were all lying completely flat against the floor, their chest heaving in deep breaths. Even Cadance seemed utterly spent, barely holding herself up, and in no condition to kiss the cum off of Sugar Belle’s face.

Oh well. She was sure there would be times for that later. For now... Well, it was time to care for them as they’d cared for her.

“Sanctum,” Sugar Belle said, still not quite sure how to address this magical entity, “can we have, um...” What did they need, exactly? “Another bed, bigger and closer than the other one, and, uh, a few big strong stallions to lift them onto it ... oh, and a warm towel, too!”

Instantly, it all appeared. Sugar Belle left her spouses in the capable hands of the Sanctum-conjured stallions while she wiped her face clean with the delightfully warm and soft towel.

Once done, she joined them on the bed, with the stallions in the middle and Cadance across from her. At some point, they’d pulled their cock out of her, and it now slowly retreated into their sheath, leaving a thick trail of residual cum along their stomach as it went. They would all need a good shower after they’d had a little rest. Sugar Belle really hoped that one of the other doors around this chamber would lead to a cozy bathroom with a hot, steamy shower... For now, though, she needed cuddles.

Snuggling up against her husband put her right up against Big Mac’s head, which served her just fine, She buried her face in the crook of his neck, enjoying his warmth, the sound of his still-labored breath, and even the slight sheen of strong-scented sweat in his red fur.

Cadance cuddled up against their other side as much as her swollen belly would allow and gave a well-contented sigh. “Now... Now we just need to do this over and over again every day until Sugar Belle and I are ‘heavy with foal’. Until the two of us are visibly pregnant, this will be our new daily routine.”

“No complaints from me!” Zephyr said with a little laugh.

“Eeyup.”

“Love you, Honey,” Shining said. “Love all of you.”

Author's Note

This story was suggested and chosen by my SubscribeStar supporters! Every month, I take suggestions from my supporters and they vote to decide which story idea I'll write next.

You can also offer support – and get the same benefits – with Direct Support! No other accounts or other websites needed. All you need is a PayPal account or other way to send payments.