Author's Note

This is a follow-up to my previous story. Whilst it's not super necessary to have read that one first you might want to read it for the full plot! Busted!

The Morning After

The morning sunlight crept in through the window of Twilight Sparkle’s bedroom. Tidmouth Milk yawned and blinked awake. He looked down Twilight and smiled, running his fingers through her dark blue hair. Twilight stirred and smiled back at him. “Good morning, Tidmouth.” There was a pause before her eyes widened “Morning?!” She hurriedly rolled over, staring at her alarm clock. “W-what are you still doing here?! It’s morning! Someone is bound to see you!”

Tidmouth sat up and put a hand on her shoulder “Uhh… why don’t we just say I woke up early and decided to come over and drop off the keys to the laundry room?”

Twilight rubbed her temples nervously. “Oh gosh, I hadn’t even thought about that. We still need to clear everyone’s stuff off the floor.” Tidmouth mumbled apologetically. Twilight stood up and took a deep breath. “Okay, you get dressed and stay in here. I’ll sneak downstairs, put everything back to how it was and lock up.” Tidmouth nodded and started to pick his discarded clothes off the floor.

Tidmouth was sat on the bed waiting when Twilight returned a few minutes later. She quietly shut the door behind her and walked over, ushering him to get up. Tidmouth stood back as she started stripping the bedsheets. “What’re you doing?”

“I’m changing my bedsheets. How often do you use sheets after you’ve got cum all over them? …actually, please don’t answer that.” Tidmouth looked guiltily at the floor, but Twilight looked over her shoulder and gave him a cocky smile.

There was a sudden knock at the door. Tidmouth flushed with panic and looked frantically between it and Twilight, who waved a hand at him to get him to keep quiet. “Uh, hello?”

“Hey, Twilight.” It was Sunset Shimmer “Can you drop Tidmouth a text and find out when he’s coming over with the key?”

“Oh, hey Sunny. Y-yeah, I’ll see if he’s awake yet.” Twilight and Tidmouth listened to the sound of her footsteps retreating. “Now what? You can’t sneak out of here now someone else is awake.”

Tidmouth rubbed his chin in thought and looked around the room. “I guess I’ll have to drop out of the window.”

Twilight looked at him with concern. “It’s quite a long drop. What if you hurt yourself?”

Tidmouth wandered over to the window and looked down. He was never fond of heights, and he could feel his gut twisting already at the thought of falling. Still, there wasn’t a lot of choice. “I-it’s only 1 storey. I should be fine.” He said, with uncertainty.

Twilight put a hand to his cheek. “Just… be careful, okay?” She leant forward and kissed him.

Tidmouth returned the kiss and smiled “I’ll see you downstairs in a few minutes.” Twilight nodded and gathered together her bedsheets before heading out of the room.

Tidmouth waited until she had shut the door before opening the window. It was an old-fashioned window that pulled up and slotted into position above. He quietly pulled up the window and pulled his knees up onto the balcony. He had decided to shimmy his way out backwards so he could lower himself down before dropping to the floor, or rather, the bushes below Twilight’s window. He slowly lowered one leg off the edge, firmly grabbing hold of the ledge in his hands before lowering the other. He hugged the windowsill and scrabbled at the log wall with his feet trying to get a footing to step down as low as he could.

He gently eased his way down, now only holding the ledge by the tips of his fingers. There was a sudden gust of wind through the trees nearby. Tidmouth held still, determined not to let the wind shake his grip. The wind had other ideas. It rattled the window causing it to slip loose from its slot and come slamming down, right onto Tidmouth’s fingers. Tidmouth gasped in surprise and pulled his fingers away, falling backwards off the wall and into the bushes below in a flurry of leaves. He winced through the pain and tried to stay as still as possible. Fortunately, it seemed no-one had heard anything, and he scrambled to his feet, dusting the brambles from his clothes before making his way around to the front door.

Twilight greeted him cheerily as he made his way in. “Good morning, Tidmouth!”

“Morning Twilight. Here’s your key. Safe and-” He went to pass her the key, but it was snatched from his grasp by Sunset Shimmer. The orange-haired girl purposefully put the key into the lock and opened the door, glancing around suspiciously.

“See, Sunset?” Twilight said, “Everything is completely as it was.”

“Maybe so, but that doesn’t mean we haven’t had any unwanted visitors.”

“Oh, come on now. There’s only one key and Tidmouth has had it with him all night, haven’t you, Tidmouth?” Tidmouth quickly nodded.

“Well unless he’s sat awake staring at it all night, forgive me if I take that with a pinch of salt.” Sunset strode over to the corner of the room and picked up a small object.

“What’s that?” asked Twilight.

“It’s a game camera. I borrowed it from Fluttershy. It only records when it detects movement.”

Tidmouth and Twilight shared a nervous glance. “Oh, w-well it’d be pitch dark in that room at night. Surely a camera like that couldn’t possibly see anything!” said Tidmouth with a shy chuckle.

Sunset rolled her eyes. “It records night-vision, dummy. Come on. We’ll plug it into Twi’s laptop and have a look.” She marched past them and headed up the stairs.

Tidmouth pleadingly grabbed Twilight “What’re we gonna do? She’s going to find out! And then, she’s gonna braid my kneecaps!”

Twilight bit her lip. “Just… stay calm. I’ll think of something. Don’t worry. I promised you no-one would find out and I intend to keep that promise.”

The pair shuffled upstairs and into Twilight’s room. Sunset had already made herself comfortable on a beanbag chair and was idly playing with the camera in her hand. Twilight went into her bag and pulled out her laptop, switching it on and placing it on her desk. Tidmouth looked at her desktop background. It was a photograph of Twilight and her friends, minus himself as he’d been behind the camera.

He smiled to himself, reminiscing for a moment. Though his daydreaming was cut off by Sunset barging in front of him. She proffered the game camera to Twilight, along with a connector cable. Twilight cautiously took it and plugged it in. Sunset leant in and reached to take control for herself, but Twilight deftly blocked her wandering hand. “Be, patient, Sunset.” Twilight needed to stall and think up a plan. Could she wipe the contents? Theoretically, yes. But there was no way she’d be able to do it quickly and certainly not with Sunset, literally, right over her shoulder.

“Come on Twi! Just load the files already!”

“Okay, okay!” Twilight opened the camera’s storage and the screen filled with a long list of files. She clicked on the first one on the list. The video file opened and now on the screen was a night-vision shot of the nearby forest. The scene seemed fairly still besides the gentle swaying of the trees. There was a sudden movement from screen right and a bunny rabbit poked its head into frame, snuffling along the ground. “Daww.” Twilight cooed.

Sunset furrowed her brow “This is old footage! We need the footage from last night! Give it here and let me find it!”

Twilight scooted the laptop slightly further away “NO! …I’ll find it.” She weighed up her options. “I can’t claim the camera is faulty. It’s clearly working fine…”

Twilight saw some filenames with the previous days date on them. She clicked on the first one. The screen was suddenly filled with an extreme close-up of Sunset’s face. “-sure this is going to work, Fluttershy?” Sunset stepped back revealing Fluttershy standing beside her.

“Oh yes. I use this camera all the time. I’ve managed to get some wonderful videos of animals in the forest. In fact, the other day I–"

“Yeah, yeah. Cool. Tell me later.” Sunset waved her hand dismissively and left the room. Fluttershy gave one last look down the lens, shrugged and followed her out.

“Okay. That was when we set it up. Try later!”

Twilight scrolled a little further. The next video opened with Rainbow Dash and Applejack standing together. “That was some good running out there, sugarcube.”

“Thanks. You almost caught me up at one point.”

Applejack chuckled “I’m happy to trail behind a little. …Your ass is cute in those running shorts.”

Rainbow Dash blushed and stepped back against one of the machines “Applejack! …someone might hear!”

Applejack grinned devilishly and pressed herself up against the other girl. “I won’t squeal if you won’t.” and she leant in for a passionate smooch.

Before their lips met, Twilight quickly clicked off the video.

Sunset was unphased “Still too early. Look, just let me—"

“Sunset, please. I’m doing the best I can.” Twilight scrolled a little further and clicked on a video file marked at around midnight. The video, now in night-vision showed the room completely empty. The three leaned toward the screen, unable to see anything moving. Then, from the top a screen a spider hung down right in front of the lens. Tidmouth yelped. Sunset gave him a critical look and he coughed with embarrassment.

“Well, there we are. I expect the camera just kept getting tripped by that spider all night. No need to look at the rest!” said Twilight, quickly.

Sunset squinted at Twilight “You’re hiding something, aren’t you?”

Twilight went wide-eyed “What! Why would I be hiding something?”

“You’ve been acting strange all morning. You’ve got something to hide, Twilight Sparkle, and this camera has the evidence!”

Twilight looked over at Tidmouth. He sighed and nodded. Twilight gave him an apologetic look before scrolling to a file from 3am. The video started much like the last one, however this time there was a faint clunking sound from the other side of the door. There was one final loud click and the door slowly opened. Then creeping through the open door came Tidmouth.

Sunset wheeled around and stared at him. “I knew it. You, filthy little PERVERT!” she lunged toward him, but Twilight stood up and put herself between them.

“Sunset, please! Calm down. It isn’t what it looks like.”

“Oh, I think it’s exactly what it looks like. Your boyfriend is a nasty little creep!”

“Look, just… keep your voice down! You might wake the others.”

“Good! They deserve to know that Tidmouth Milk is a perverted little fu—”

Sunset’s expletive was cut short by Twilight shoving a hand over her mouth. The fiery-haired girl growled and struggled against Twilight’s hand, but she looked into Twilight’s pleading eyes and backed down. Sunset sat down on the bed and put her head in her hands. “How long have you been covering this up?”

“I only found out last night. But, Tidmouth has promised to return what he stole.”

Sunset grimaced. “And what exactly has that freak been doing with them in the week since he stole them?” Twilight stammered; she wasn’t actually sure herself. The two girls fixed their gaze on the cowering guy in the corner. “Well?” demanded Sunset.

Tidmouth gulped. “Well, I liked to… l-look at them… w-wear them sometimes in my room.”

“…go on.”

“I s…s-smelled them… a-and…” Tidmouth faltered, he was almost on the verge of tears.

Sunset stared daggers at him. “And what?”

“I… I c-came into one of them.” Tidmouth admitted. Before Twilight could react to block her, Sunset shot back to her feet and grabbed Tidmouth by the shoulders.

“Sunset! No!” cried Twilight, desperately trying to pull her off.

Rainbow Dash walked out of her room, on her way out to morning practice. She overheard a commotion in Twilight’s room and hurried in to find out what was going on. Her eyes widened as she saw Sunset Shimmer pinning Tidmouth Milk to the wall whilst Twilight Sparkle was desperately trying to separate them. “H-hey! Leave him alone Sunset!”

Rainbow sprinted over and helped Twilight pull Sunset away from Tidmouth. “No! He’s a nasty little creep and I’m going to kick his ass!”

Rainbow forced Sunset down onto the bed. “Just, slow down. What’s going on here?”

“He is the sock thief!”

Rainbow looked over at Tidmouth, standing against the wall, fiddling nervously with his hands. “Wait, you were the one who stole my socks?” Tidmouth nodded and looked at the floor.

Rainbow slowly walked up to him, and he shrunk back in fear. “Tidmouth… thank you!” much to his surprise, Tidmouth felt himself enveloped into a hug. “I was gonna sneak downstairs first thing in the morning and get those back before anyone actually washed them!”

Twilight gave her a disappointed look “Oh, Rainbow Dash...”

“What?! They’re my lucky socks, Twilight! I wore them during my first winning game of soccer in Junior High and haven’t washed them since!” Rainbow rubbed the back of her neck shyly. “I wouldn’t expect you guys to understand but just… the feeling of putting them on before a big game filled me with that little bit of extra confidence. …and the smell afterwards…” Rainbow shuddered slightly at the thought. “I don’t blame you for picking up on it Tid. Those socks are soaked in the sweat of many victories. …where are they, anyway?”

Tidmouth gulped quietly. He’d been trying to stop himself from getting a boner. “T-they’re over in my room.”

“Awesome! Come on then. Let’s go over and grab them.”

Before they could leave Sunset interjected. “Hold on, you’re not seriously going to accept those socks back after what that weirdo has been doing with them, are you?”

“He’s not a weirdo, Sunset!” insisted Twilight. “Look, I have an idea. Let’s all meet back here tonight, and we can show you what it’s all about.”

Sunset looked initially disgusted at the idea but with a couple of pleading looks from Twilight and Rainbow she eventually conceded. “Fine. But if don’t like what I see I’m out.”

Rainbow nodded. “Of course. Right, come on Tid.”

Rainbow jogged over to the boy’s lodge at a brisk pace. Tidmouth breathlessly hobbled after her, trying to keep up. They made their way quickly up to Tidmouth’s room and shut the door behind them.

Tidmouth shuffled over to his chest of drawers and pulled out Rainbow’s socks from the back, offering them to her.

“Hold up a sec.” said Rainbow, making her way over to the bed. She pulled off her trainers, revealing a pair of light pink socks underneath. She gently pulled them off and lifted them to her nose. “Mmh… yeah…” She held them out towards Tidmouth, who gave a puzzled look in response. “We’ll do a swap. You give me back my lucky socks and I’ll let you borrow these. They’re not as strong but I think you’ll still get some enjoyment from them.”

Tidmouth timidly took them and passed Rainbow the white pair. Rainbow took a deep whiff and exhaled happily “Awh yeah… you’ve kept them nice and fresh, Tidmouth. …Mfh~.” She took another sniff and squirmed, slipping a hand down the waistband of her shorts. She grinned to herself as she smelled her socks and energetically rubbed one out.

Tidmouth blushed and tried to look away, but he couldn’t help but stare as Rainbow’s lewd display continued. It seemed Rainbow wasn’t just fast when it came to sporting activities as she’d barely been going for a minute when she shuddered and came. She sighed relievedly and met Tidmouth’s nervous gaze. “Oh, uhh… sorry Tidmouth. I kinda got a little excited and forgot you were there.” Tidmouth stammered a reply and waved off her concern.

Rainbow cleared her throat and got her shoes and socks on. “Well, I’d better get going. Gotta get these bad girls warmed up for tonight.” She grinned and winked at Tidmouth causing him to blush even deeper. “I’ll see you later. …I’ll leave you three alone.” She said, pointing to the pink pair in Tidmouth’s hands. She leant in and whispered. “They got real sweaty in the fun run yesterday.” She gave one last smirk before slinking out of the room, shutting the door after herself.

Tidmouth scrambled to quickly lock the door and undressed himself. Free from the confines of his underwear his cock sprung out. Watching Rainbow fingering herself followed by her teasing meant that it was painfully hard at this point and Tidmouth was desperate to get off himself.

He threw himself onto the bed and examined the pair of socks in his hands. Rainbow wasn’t lying, they certainly looked sweat stained and Tidmouth could even make out the shape of Rainbow’s feet on the bottom. He raised them to his nose as he started to jerk off. The smell was similar to the white pair, though definitely not as strong. Though they were still good to Tidmouth’s nose, and he moaned quietly as he took another long sniff. Rainbow’s words reverberated through Tidmouth’s mind “They got real sweaty in the fun run yesterday.” He moaned again and clenched, cumming hard.

He sighed in ecstasy and took one last sniff of the socks before sitting up, deciding to put them on and wear them for the day. No-one should notice if he was wearing his long trousers. He pulled them up. They were slightly below knee length. His cock twinged as he admired himself, playfully rubbing his socked feet over one another. He was once again brought out of his reverie by a knock on the door. “Come on, Tidmouth! Time to get up!”