Fluttershy was confused at first. She wasn't ignorant of this particular kink, but she honestly didn't see it coming. Dull Quartz was always so open in their relationship, and even more so when they started getting intimate.
Am I a bad marefriend?
She had some bleak thoughts bouncing around her head. No matter how hard she tried to remember, she couldn't recall any hints that he may have dropped. The first time they lost their virginity together he had mentioned he was nervous and couldn't stay hard. The fix they found out was for her to constantly reassure him which in turn helped her calm down as well.
Dull once surprised her about something she never noticed, she loves getting her tail pulled. Not right away, but at key moments where he just seems to know when. Moments like those were the foundation of the current great relationship they both have and yet Fluttershy was at a loss right now. How could she be so content when Dull was not.
A few more moments had passed after her shocking discovery. Fluttershy has grown the past few years and has done great feats before. This won't stop her, and in fact she now has the perfect gift idea for this upcoming vacation. With a new determined, although blind, plan of action she set off to a close friend to help her with her task. She was stronger willed now, but having a friend by her side was still much appreciated.
"So I know I said I would help with anything Fluttershy but this may be a bit ... much." Twilight Sparkle was interrupted briefly by a nearby toy activating and giving off a soft moan. Fluttershy put the dildo back onto the shelf after deciding it wasn't what she was looking for.
"I know and I'm sorry Twilight but you're the only pony who wouldn't judge me." Fluttershy was already walking on deeper into LSD&P store turning to see if Twilight was following. With a sigh Twilight followed her kinky friend deeper into the sex shop.
The piano section was nice to look at though. Not sure why a toy sex shop sells pianos and what the implications are between the two.
Twilight pointedly tried to not look at all of the sex toys around her and focus on the nearby pianos. Briefly entertaining the thought of buying one and where to put it. Fluttershy's light coughing brought her attention back to the task at hoof and she did a double take at what Fluttershy was holding.
"Too big? I should probably start small, but what if he has already experimented and needs something bigger? I could buy both sizes but I may not have enough." Fluttershy was mostly talking to herself but would occasionally look towards Twilight for reassurance. Twilight's pained smile did not help the slightest.
"Oh silly me, I was in such a rush I forgot to tell you the reason. You see Dull likes the idea of pegging. Pegging is-" Fluttershy was cut off quickly by a blushing Princess of Friendship.
"I know what pegging is Fluttershy. What I don't know is why I'm here helping you. Normally I question the other girls whenever they ask me for help but you were always a safe bet, until now." Twilight gave her best stern look at her friend despite the drooping dongs being held in her hoofs. With a giggle Fluttershy put back the silicone pleasure sticks and turned to the still blushing Twilight who was currently failing to look serious. A few moments later Twilight finally let out a half chuckle before giving in to a small fit of giggles with Fluttershy.
"This is going to be the weirdest friendship lesson ever." Twilight said while magicking on her signature study glasses. Fluttershy smiled as she knew her friend was going to help her plan the best surprise ever.
"Oof! Aaaaaaaahhhh this bed is sooooo soft." Dull spoke into the hotel bed as he stretched his limbs. Fluttershy followed in shortly after hauling in the bags Dull left at the door entrance.
"Shy dear, you need to get on this bed right now. This feels like a cloud."
"That's because it is a cloud." Fluttershy gave herself a small nod of approval at the pile of bags at the foot of the bed before looking at her prostate coltfriend. His swishing tail brought her eyes to his butt and she suddenly started to blush at what will soon come.
"Oh. Well, I don't remember adding that to the hotel reservation. I hope they don't charge extra." Dull finally rolled over onto his back and attempted to strike a sexy pose. His sheath did its job and held his shaft but the view of his nuts got an eye roll and a smirk from Fluttershy's blushing face.
"You have been stuck to my side the entire ride here and even kissed me in public. You're either super horny or you have a surprise." Dull rolled back over after reading Fluttershy's shocked face. With a smile he put his snout right up to hers.
"Fluttershy my love, you are a horrible actor, now spill the beans." Dull knew to follow Fluttershy's eye whenever she was about to answer something. And once again he was proven right by following her eyes to the last minute bag she brought onto the trip. Dull knew something was off about that little bag but knew better than to ask. Spending as much time with Fluttershy taught him that the best results were often when he let her go at her own pace. Perhaps a few nudges here and there but ultimately it was her initiative that brought her to where she is now.
"You don't have to talk about it now, but wheneve-" Dull was cut off by Fluttershy leaping onto his body and giving him a desperate hug. Startled he returned the hug with as much gusto as he could.
"I'm sorry." Fluttershy mumbled into his neck. His well practiced ears caught her words and he started to pet her head and wings. Choosing to remain silent he offered the unsaid question of "What are you sorry for?" With a heavy sigh Fluttershy turned her head just enough to get one eye to look at Dull.
"I read your diary." Fluttershy mumbled into his neck again and followed up with a slight flinch and a squeeze to his body. Ready to face his wrath at destroying his trust and hopefully able to gift him something to earn his trust back. Tense as she was, she did not expect him to kiss her forehead and to laugh softly.
"Fluttershy dear, I know. You left the book back in a different spot. I work with rocks for a living and so that means keeping track of the small details." Dull spoke into her mane while still hugging her back and petting her.
"Really it was my fault for leaving it out but ah well, I was going to show you it eventually. Kinda ruined the surprise though. I hope you aren't disappointed to find out that way." Dull felt her pull back as she raised her upper body and put her hooves besides his head.
"Why would I be disappointed? I found out about your kink and never once asked about how you felt in bed." Fluttershy saw the flash of shock on his face and decided to push forward before she lost her nerve. After a brief kiss on his nose, Fluttershy leaped off the bed and glided over to her bag.
"Uh. Shy, Honey I think we hav-" Dull was cut off at the over the top presentation of what Fluttershy was holding. In her hooves was a modestly sized black colt cock with straps hanging from the base.
Huh, that's almost slightly smaller than mine.
"I'm going to fuck you tonight dear." Fluttershy declared while opening her wings to make herself look bigger. She was panting with fear and excitement, she never took the lead before and was waiting to see Dull's reaction. She was not disappointed as she saw his shaft slowly emerge from his sheath.
"I ... uhm. Wow. Shy are you sure?" Dull swallowed back a cough. He was both aroused and so proud of his yellow butterfly right now taking charge. Fluttershy could only nod her head without speaking for fear of her voice cracking. With a smile Dull rolled over and shimmied off the edge of the bed. Dropping his rear hooves he presented himself much like how Fluttershy used to always present herself to him.
His tail began to rhythmically swish to an invisible yet alluring tune to Fluttershy's joy. Twilight's gift began to take effect once Fluttershy rubbed a small gem on the many straps. Dull watch in amazement as the strap on began to float and snag Fluttershy's plot. With a gasp she was mare handled in place as the strap on began to size to her lower half and even began to leak!
While Dull's show had aroused Fluttershy, her unintentional show now had Dull at full mast, matching the strap on and beating it by an inch or so. His cock was blocked by the bed and was now pointing to the ground.
Panting, Fluttershy took a look at Dull and her already expanded wings went rigged. Before her was her blushing coltfriend. Cock and balls in full display between his spread legs. His tail had stopped swinging and was now shifted over to the side giving Fluttershy a clear display of his ponut. Pre was already dripping from his cock head onto the floor beneath him.
No words were spoken between the two as they were equally afraid that they might disturb this magical moment. Fluttershy slowly walked to her prey with an odd gait. She learned how to manage having such a massive cock between her by the time she reached Dull. With a sudden inspiration she quickly lowered her head and licked Dull's hanging shaft and nuts.
With a gasp and groan of need Dull lowered his head into the bed. She suckled his cock head to the best of her ability and slowly left a trail of spit up his shaft to his nuts and swirled them around in her mouth. She was trying her best to recreate what Dull has done to her multiple times before mounting her. After a few minutes of worshiping his balls she went even further up to his protruding ponut.
Following the tips she read in the sex book she bought she started small and kissed around the sinful hole. With every wink she would lick the outside briefly causing a moan to rise from Dull. Soft kisses soon turned into her licking the outside of his ponut. Never once pressing inside but to get it used to what she was about to introduce to it.
Stepping back, Fluttershy lifted her body and set her hooves besides her lovers barrel. She mistimed her new appendage and slapped the shaft onto his back, messily pushing through his tail hair and riding the crack of his ass. Dull responded by grinding his ass to her surprisingly warm cock. Fluttershy pulled back and with better care took aim to his slick ponut.
"Ready?" Fluttershy asked softly. With a slow nod from Dull she slowly pushed her back legs forward. Gasping Dull tried his best to relax and bit the bed sheets. Slowly gyrating her hips, Fluttershy let the flat tip of her cock massage the entrance to Dull's anus.
Gently they both rocked back and forth much like how they first started with Fluttershy on the bottom and Dull on top. And much like that last time, the same thing eventually happened, with a shock Dull moaned into the bed as Fluttershy's cock entered his ass. She stopped as soon as it entered and lowered her head to his ears and whispered encouragement to him.
"You have been such a good colt lately. And do you know what good colts get?" Fluttershy watched as an extremely blushing Dull shook his head side to side. With a smile she nibbled Dull's ear and pushed in further.
"Good colts get fucked."
"Oooohh fuck me."
"I will. But I need you to ask me nicely." Fluttershy kept her thrust small and around her tip. Mainly trying to get used to this foreign movement but to also tease her lover like he would to her sometimes. Overwhelmed by the feeling of his ass being stretch Dull tried his best to focus on what she was saying.
"Please..." Dull moaned at a particular fast thrust and retreat. Her body movement was cause his cock to rub on the bed, pleasuring him on both ends.
"Please what dear?" Fluttershy was having fun. She knew exactly what was going on in his head right now. Normally she would be the one on the bed, bent over and panting wildly as Dull teased her pussy. He would have her ride the edge until finally giving into what she wanted but by then she would climax as he would hilt into her. But her first climax was always just the start of a night of passionate fucking. She planned on doing the same thing to Dull.
"P-please fuck me Fluttershy." Dull was slowly getting his thoughts together, but every time he would clear his mind Fluttershy would go slightly deeper or angle her thrust and he was back into a shrouded lust fog. Fluttershy knew to look out for his sign of climaxing, shortness of breath and a particular gasp he always made before he flooded her womb with his semen. She heard it start just like anytime she would normally hear it below him, squirming and screaming as he pounded her silly.
"Please f-fuck meeeee F-fluttersssshy. Auuuuuugghh gods." Dull was so close to release. He knew this was payback for what he would do to her but right now all he wanted was sweet release. She kept up her slow pace but was getting deeper with every thrust until suddenly she recognized his gasp of pleasure. With a much faster pace she worked her shaft in and out of his ass and just as he raised his head she slammed her entire cock into him.
"FUCK!" Dull screamed and his cock exploded below him and noisily splattering the floor with his cum. Fluttershy's wings fought the extremely arousing scene and went below her body to pump his cock. Shaking, Dull's mind finally cleared enough to look up to Fluttershy.
"That was amazing Shy..." Dull closed his eyes and leaned up to kiss her.
"That was round one." Fluttershy spoke and she gripped his cock hard with her wings. Ignoring his shocked face she began to pump into him earnestly much like how he did after filling her up the first time.
"Oh OH oh OH FLUTTERSHY!" Dull lowered his face into the bed sheets once more and held onto dear life. Pumping his cock with her wings, whispering sweet promises of domination and pumping a thick cock into his ass, Fluttershy briefly controlled her lover for the rest of the night.
Dull woke up to a very sore ass. Fluttershy was laying on top of him with her pussy directly on his crotch. At some point Dull was released and returned the favor to Fluttershy who gladly took her "punishment". One of them having her take his cock and the strap on at the same time in her ass and pussy.
"Mmmmng. Good morning Dull." Fluttershy's own ass was sore as well from the mutual fucking they gave each other. Sore in all the right places she kissed Dull and together they woke up from last nights fun.
"You know Fluttershy. You actually surprised me more than twice last night." Dull spoke while grinding his hardening cock against her pussy and ponut. With a slight gasp she tried to move but was held in place by his hooves. Dull enjoyed being back in control as opposed to the start of last night.
"You enjoyed it r-right? I- mnf read your book an-" Fluttershy had to take a moment to breath while trying to think clearly. Dull smiled and reached behind his head underneath a pile of pillows. His pause gave Fluttershy just enough time to get her thoughts together as she watched him retrieve a black box.
"If you would have kept reading, you would have found the latest chapter of me hyping myself up to ask the most beautiful mare in the world, to marry me." Dull opened the box to show a pair of metal bands. With a gasp Fluttershy leaned into Dull and gave him the biggest hug.
"ohmygosh ohmygosh ohmygosh."
"So uh, is that a yes?"
"YES!"
