As Alex had expected, when he told Rainbow Dash how the fight with Fluttershy went, she had busted out laughing, saying that he had been doing bad these last few matches. The laughing stopped when Alex reminded his girlfriend that he had lasted longer with her than Fluttershy, which said more about Rainbow than it did about him. Alex went to bed with a black eye that night.

A week had passed and not a single notification, Alex was constantly checking his phone over and over again, but nothing new popped up. Finally, on a warm evening, when Alex was just getting out of the shower his doorbell began to ring.

Ding dong!

Ding dong!

“Coming!” Alex said as he hurriedly put his bath robe on. maybe it’s Derpy trying to give me a package I didn’t order again Alex thought with a sigh. He knew Derpy meant well and he always was polite about correcting her, after all she was new at the job and mix ups were bound to happen, but if he was right this would be the fourth time it’s happened and it was getting a little annoying.

Finally making it to the front door, Alex opened the door, only to see that it wasn’t Derpy, but none other than Rarity wearing a beautiful white shirt and blue miniskirt.

“Rarity!” Alex exclaimed with surprise as she stood there with a cute smile on her face. “I...wow...what an unexpected and pleasant surprise.”

“Why hello Alex Darling, how are you...” Rarity stopped herself as she saw he was in his bathrobe. “Oh goodness Darling did I come at a bad time?”

Alex was confused at first until he remembered what he was wearing. “Oh no no no no you’re fine Rares I just got out of the shower that’s all.” Alex scratched his head with a goofy smile, internally chastising himself about looking like an idiot.

“Oh I see.” Rarity said with a giggle. Then she gave him a sly look. “And do you always greet visitors in your bathrobe at this time or am I just that lucky?”

Alex flushed red and quickly decided to change the subject, “would you like to come in?” He asked.

“Why thank you Darling, but you don’t need to let me in if you’re getting ready for bed.” Rarity said.

“I wasn’t going to bed yet” Alex assured her. “Plus I hate to think you came all this way for nothing, come on in.”

After inviting Rarity in, the two sat down to some nice mint tea. Alex had always liked Rarity (platonically of course), not only was she the most beautiful girl in Canterlot High, she was the authority when it came to fashion. Needed to know what clothes were in style this season? You go to Rarity, want to know the secret to making a fashion statement without making a fool out of yourself? Rarity had your back, need to decorate for a formal event? Give Rarity a call. But it wasn’t just that, unlike many of the beautiful and popular girls at school, Rarity was neither vapid or vain, nor was her beauty skin deep.

Alex remembered one year at Winter Formal when Gilda “accidentally” spilled punch on Fluttershy’s dress. Rainbow Dash wanted to knock her teeth out then and there(which she did after the dance), but Rarity was having none of it, she sped home real quick and came back wearing a new dress and gave Fluttershy her old one.

After tea, the two friends sat on the couch catching up on what they’ve been up to recently.

“So Rares”
Alex finally asked “what brought you out here this evening?”

“Well Darling you know I abhor violence, the thought of hurting someone, especially a friend like you, just doesn’t appeal to me.” Rarity then began running her finger across Alex’s thigh “but then I thought of something”

Alex was doing his best to keep his cool as Rarity spoke. The most beautiful girl in Canterlot High was at his house and was now touching him. “Oh? And...um..what would that be?”

“Weeeeell” Rarity began running her hand further up his thigh. “We’re both good friends are we not?”

“Y-yes”

“And we would never intentionally hurt one another would we?”

“N-no n-never” Alex was hoping and silently praying that Rarity didn’t run her hand further up or she might notice...

“And you obviously want it” Rarity said with a little lust in her voice. Her hand was soon playing with his member gently. “Of course I have had second thoughts, I think we should give it a go.”

Alex could only moan and nod in response as his erection got bigger from the fashionista playing with it.

“Of course I wouldn’t do anything so vulgar as fisticuffs, how about a simple wrestling match you and me hmmm?” By now Rarity was playing a little harder with Alex’s member and all the poor guy could do was nod and moan.

“Good let us begin” Rarity got up from the couch and before Alex’s eyes she took off her clothes and took off her bra and panties, standing before him naked.

Alex was both shocked and turned on. “R-R-Rarity wh-what...what are you..”

“Oh come now Darling you really didn’t think I’d want to get my clothes all wrinkled and sweaty did you?” Rarity asked while tying her hair in a ponytail. “Besides” she added slyly with a smirk “it’s not like you’ve never seen a naked girl before.”

Alex admitted that it was true, especially in recent weeks, he got up and untied his bath robe revealing his naked body. Rarity looked him up and down, cheeks flushed with red as she felt her womanhood heat up, especially when looking at his member “well well well” she finally said after regaining her composure “looks like I have something to look forward to”

Alex responded by tackling Rarity in the midsection sending them both on the floor. He lost to Pinkie Pie, he lost to Fluttershy, he’d be damned if he lost to the girliest member of the group. After they fell to the ground, Alex quickly straddled her thighs and pinned her hands on either side of her head.

“Looks like I win already” He said confidently. That confidence quickly shattered when Rarity began moving her hips against his groin grinding him. Alex was fighting not to groan as his grip on her hands loosened and he began to move with her.

Suddenly Rarity sat herself up quickly and tackled Alex, switching their roles as she lay on top and pinned his hands. “Are you sure about that?” She asked in a sultry tone. Fighting his wanting to take her then and there, Alex rolled over on top of her with ease, Rarity didn’t seem to be that strong.

Then Alex decided on a little pay back and leaned his head down to Rarity’s neck and began playfully nibbling, causing the young fashionista to moan. Still holding his wrists, Rarity decided to switch tactics and used one her knees to lift him by the crotch and get him off.

Alex soon felt a sensation in his nether regions as the knee dug into him and pushed him off of the girl as he fell to the floor. Now both opponents got up and began circling around each other, both thoroughly aroused. Alex charged at Rarity’s midsection again, but this time she was ready and planted her feet firmly on the ground as he grabbed hold of her. Finding he couldn’t put her on the ground like last time, Alex instead pushed Rarity into a wall.

Grabbing his shoulders Rarity pushed herself up and wrapped her legs around his waist before taking his head in both hands “let’s just drop this charade shall we?” She then smashed her lips into his. Alex instantly melted into the kiss and soon the two were making out, tongues wrestling for dominance.

Alex carried Rarity to the bedroom as they continued to kiss passionately, he finally broke the kiss and tossed her effortlessly on the bed. He then crawled up to her and lined his member with her womanhood.

“You ready?” Alex asked. Rarity rapidly nodded her head. Having been granted permission, Alex pushed inside her and began thrusting slowly.

“Aaaaaah! Ah hah hah hah hah oh yes! God how I’ve wanted this!” Rarity cried as she rewrapped her legs around Alex’s waist. “Oh God! Ah hah hah hah hah hah hah my only hah regret is th-that ah hah yes that Rainbow Dash got to you before me aaah!”

Alex continued thrusting as he began groping her breasts and then sucking on them. After half an hour of thrusting Alex was near his limit. “Aah! Hah hah hah Rares! I’m gonna..”

“Oh! Ah! Me too D-Darling! Give me all hah hah hah hah you got!” Rarity screamed as she matched his thrusts with her own. Finally both climaxed together and collapsed on the bed.

The two laid together and cuddled, panting. “So” Alex finally panted “does this mean I win?”

“Oh yes Darling” Rarity said with a satisfied smile. “You win. That was...Simply Divine! No wonder Rainbow Dash is always bragging about you.”

“Oh good I was confused who won that bout and I was afraid to have to admit to Rainbow that I lost to you...no offense.”

“Oh none taken darling, like I said I’m more into fashion than fighting.” Rarity then began caressing his side. “Of course...we could always go for best two out of three.”

Alex took her hand and gently pushed it away “sorry Rares, I promised RD that she would be the only one I’d do it with more than once.”

Rarity smiled genuinely. “I understand darling, but could we just stay here for a while until I get my energy back?” Alex nodded and soon Rarity fell asleep as he still laid on his bed looking at the ceiling.

Five down two to go Alex thought as he laid there. He wasn’t going to lie, he kind of liked this activity. Some would think it strange and even abhorrent to like fighting and later having sex with your female friends, but from what Alex gathered from Rainbow Dash (and other sources just so it wasn’t biased), the other girls had no problem with it. It was almost like a fun personal activity that bonded them, like an inside joke that only they got. Finally Alex drifted off to sleep, wondering what the next day would bring.

Author's Note

Finally I got that Chapter done and over with. Not gonna lie, this was the hardest one to do. It was easier writing the other fights since I could imagine them in a scuffle (even Fluttershy if she was pushed hard enough could throw down) but Rarity, It was hard to create a situation where it didn’t come out as right out abuse. Next Chapter will be coming soon.