Fluttershy Takes Manehattan

by rei_san

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Rainbow Dash, Romance, Drama, Fluttershy
Length: 1127

- ALTERNATE ENDING OF SEASON 4 EPISODE 22 : TRADE YA - Instead of cancelling the trade, Rainbow Dash sees this as a complete win. Fluttershy agrees to move in with Teddie Safari in Manehattan, but what's to come for the animal-loving pony?

After Rainbow Dash flies off to show her friends her brand new signed copy of Daring Do and the Quest for the Sapphire Stone, Fluttershy is forced to move in with Teddie Safari, the pony who traded with Rainbow Dash. Fluttershy has only been to Manehattan once or twice before, but she wasn't a big fan. It was loud and rowdy, and frankly the ponies there weren't the kindest. However, she knew she had to go, and it made her happy knowing her friend was happy. She sighed, holding the leash of the two-headed pet, and turned to face the future.

Published 2021-08-21 14:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2021-08-21 14:40:01 UTC

Chapter One: Traded

Her eyes sparkled as she watched her rainbow friend dash through the sky, desperately looking for their other friends. She knew Rainbow Dash would’ve wanted to show off her brand-new book as soon as she received it. She smiled sadly, turning to the yellow haired pony standing before her. She was packing up her stand, placing all her Daring Do memorabilia into the cardboard boxes that they were brought in. Fluttershy sighed, giving the Orthros another pat. Teddie Safari turned around, leaning on one of the closed boxes.

“Well, that’s the last of ‘em.” She said, stacking the boxes on top on one another.
“Oh wonderful, might we be able to stop by my cottage so I can grab a few things?” Fluttershy asked in a soft voice.

“Sure thing! We can catch the night train back to Manehattan.” She replied with a smile. Fluttershy took one more glance back at the Traders Exchange before walking out, pulling the Orthros along with her.

»» ────── ∘◦❀◦∘ ────── ««

After a quick stop at her cottage, the two ponies (and the dog- thing-) boarded the train. Fluttershy yawned, snuggling into the train seat. Teddie flipped a page of a Daring Do book she’d most certainly already read. Her eyes flicked up to the pony sitting next to her. A warm blush rose to her cheeks seeing the smaller pony sleep. Teddie had never found anypony so attractive, and she felt slightly guilty about demanding that she move in with her. The real reason that she wanted her with her wasn’t to train the pet, it was because, well, frankly, Teddie was lonely. Fluttershy was also the most attractive pony she’d ever laid her eyes on, and figured she’d kill two birds with one stone. She smiled, shutting her book, and closing her eyes. She yawned, drifting off into sleep as the train bumped gently.

»» ────── ∘◦❀◦∘ ────── ««

The two ponies awoke to a loud yell, rubbing their eyes in sync. They grabbed their things, exiting the train. Teddie motioned for Fluttershy to follow her, and they walked for quite some time. By the time they got to Teddie’s house, Fluttershy’s hooves were exhausted. However, she quickly forgot about how tired she was when she laid eyes on Teddie’s mansion. Her mouth fell open as she gaped at the incredibly large house.

“T-This is where you live?” She tried to say as politely as possible. Teddie blushed in response, looking away.

“Yeah... is it okay?” She asked, swallowing hard.

“Okay?! It’s beautiful!” She exclaimed, walking up to the entrance. Teddie’s face brightened, taking her luggage into the house. Fluttershy only got more amazed as they entered the house. Teddie quickly brought the Orthros out to the backyard, which, surprise surprise, was also huge. Once she closed the door, she found Fluttershy trotting around the house, gaping at everything she saw. She giggled, grabbing her hoof.

“C’mon, I’ll show you to your room.” She pulled her along as Fluttershy blinked in awe. They went up a set of spiral stairs, the smell of fresh laundry filling Fluttershy’s nose. It was beautiful. All of it. Once they got to her room, she took a weary step inside. It was breath-taking. All Fluttershy had known was the quaint town of Ponyville and her sweet cottage. This was so new, so different. And she loved it. She turned around; her eyes wide as she took everything in. There was a large bed with draping curtains, a writing desk with paper and a quill sitting neatly on top. There was a huge wardrobe that Fluttershy dreaded she wouldn’t be able to fill. She turned back to Teddie, who was staring at her with a small hint of blush in her cheeks. Seeing her made Fluttershy blush, looking down and letting her bubblegum hair fall over her face.

“Thank you… so much!” She said, looking back up and giving her a small hug. Teddie almost forgot her own name, blinking a few times and replying.

“O-Of course! If you’re gonna help me with the dog it’s no trouble at all.” Fluttershy pulled back, smiling brightly. Teddie pointed her to the bathroom, and they decided to call it a night. Unfortunately, neither of them could sleep.

»» ────── ∘◦❀◦∘ ────── ««

Fluttershy blushed as she slid underneath the covers. Her mind flashed to a mental calendar, groaning as she realized how soon her heat was coming. While it wasn’t supposed to come for a few days, Fluttershy was feeling it full force right now. She swallowed, trailing a desperate hoof down to her marehood. She licked her lips as she felt herself press against her warm, wet, sex. She moaned louder than she wanted to, biting her bottom lip as she moved her hoof in small circles against her clit. She panted, sitting up and standing on all fours. Her tongue lulled out of her mouth as she worked harder against herself. She fell forward, her hind legs still standing. Her face was pressed into the sheets, her hoof working faster and faster. She squeezed her eyes shut, her climax racing towards her. Her breathing hitched, screaming as she came, her eyes widening as she heard the name that came out of her mouth.

“T-Teddie!” She cried, her rump thrusting against her hoof. She panted, breathing audibly as her hoof dropped onto the bed. Her back half fell, and she shut her eyes, falling fast asleep.

»» ────── ∘◦❀◦∘ ────── ««

On the other side of the house, Teddie was in a similar situation. She worked against herself violently, groaning and grunting much less elegantly than Fluttershy. However, the effect was the same. She had one hoof inside of herself, the other attacking her clit. She gasped, her third orgasm already upon her. She shuddered, her whole body shaking as she whispered Fluttershy’s name once again. She groaned angrily, still feeling unsatisfied. She blushed thinking of asking Fluttershy for help. Once she got to her room, however, she was fast asleep. Teddie cursed at herself, trotting back to her own room as she dealt with her rut by herself. After losing count of how many times she'd brought herself to orgasm, she fell asleep from pure exhaustion, the smell of sex filling her room.

Author's Note

Hey there! It's Rei, thanks so much for reading! I hope you enjoy! I was sitting on my couch, watching Trade Ya and I desperately wanted to know what it would've been like if Teddie (this is a filler name by the way, her name in the show is Daring Do Collector) hadn't let Fluttershy go, or if Rainbow Dash simply didn't care. So here you have it! Stay tuned for more!