Don't Stick Your Dick In Crazy

by Arume_Lux

Rating: mature
Tags: Drama, Original Character, Porn, Non-consensual, Random, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 3794

An earth pony named Phoenix Quill gets a strange visit.

Being stalked isn't fun, and when you ignore a problem it wont go away. Don't stick your dick in crazy goes the saying, but what if you have no choice?

This story includes references to rape, mentally unwell mares and sex. You probably do not want to read this.

Published 2021-07-16 21:40:01 UTC
Last updated 2024-07-09 06:10:09 UTC

3:07 AM Rewrite

Author's Note

see you in 6 more years

3:07 AM Rewrite

Pheonix Quill wasn't quite sure why he had woken up at first. He was dazed, a combination of the lingering drowsiness and the sudden awakening. There was a subtle feeling of agitation, but it was washed away as he yawned, preparing to go back to his dreams. He took a quick look at his digital alarm clock.

3:07 AM

Pheonix counted how many more hours of sleep he could get before work, feeling happy at the amount of hours.

Thud.

Something bumped from within his home, dashing any hope of going back to sleep. She was here again.

It was always in the small hours of the morning she would come to disturb him. Sometimes, she would leave him disturbingly scrawled notes around the house. Or she would come to check his fridge for food, Pheonix coming home to discover missing items here and there or a mess that he hadn't made himself.

On the rare occasion, he would find more disturbing things waiting for him.

Transcendental Dancer had been a former client of his, the first time they had met she had seemed disturbed and messy, her disorganized thoughts reflecting clearly on her appearance. Her mane had been dull and in a state of tangles, her eyes were glassy and lacked any spark of life. He had to strain himself to remain polite when she so greatly disturbed him. They had spent hours trying to make sense of her finances, which were in utter shambles. Her home had been on the line, and although he had done all he could to try and untangle her debt, she would never manage to make her next payment.

Pheonix wondered if he had been too nice to her at the time. There was something he found interesting about her, but it wasn't easy to pinpoint what exactly that could have been. He was interesting to her as well. Maybe his overly friendly demeanor had spoken to her in some way, leading her to follow him home after their very last appointment. It was chilling to know she had found her way into his home, and when he discovered it for the first time with a slice of his garlic loaf between her teeth.

That was when he learned she had a talent for vanishing. It had shaken him viscerally when her horn lit up and she vanished from his sight, bread and all. He had immediately gone to the chief of police, telling him what had happened. Despite their word that they would monitor the situation, they were never able to successfully find her.

Pheonix had labeled her a crazy bitch. Now, she really had gone insane.

Suddenly, the door handle moved. It was subtle but he didn't miss it. His body sat up under the covers, his heart rate spiking. He was so sure he had figured out her antics by now. Yet, she had never dared to come into his room. It had been his sanctuary.

Apparently, she no longer wanted to keep to the kitchen, daring to probe further into his house.

The door clicked open, swinging slowly inwards with a slight creak. He saw an eerily familiar glow of red magic on the handle, the caster illuminated in pale crimson light, reflecting especially brightly on her haunted, empty, and seeking eyes. Eyes that were fixated on him.

Pheonix found himself in a cold sweat, with the hairs on the back of his neck bristling, while the rest of him remained frozen. The mare stepped over the threshold of the doorway, officially entering his room. No longer did he have an illusion of sanctuary. Her quiet steps stopped for a moment, and her magic burned brightly again for a single moment as she used it to close the door behind her with an ominous click.

Then there was darkness again. Once it might have been a safe, comforting darkness, knowing his window was secured and bolted shut. Now, it was the opposite of comforting. Phoenix was trapped in here. His ears strained, catching the subtle shifting of her hooves and the sounds of her breathing.

"Hello, Phoenix," Her voice was soft and quiet, yet at the same time loud and disturbing. "I'm s-sorry for disturbing you..." The sound of a hoof sliding along the metal bedframe followed. "I- I was feeling really lonely... I hoped you could h-help me feel better" A low, wistful sigh escaped her lips. "It's been such a long time since we've actually, really spoken, you know you... You don't ever talk to me anymore." The words were haunting and sad but didn't really make him feel any sympathy at all.

The last time he had ever acknowledged her was to tell her to leave his property. Of course, she was delusional and wouldn't listen to him. Instead, she had increased the frequency of her visits. Clearly talking to her wasn't the right move to get her to piss off.

His mattress shifted under the weight of her body as she clambered onto his mattress.

Suddenly, there was light. Her magic ignited, a spark of it fastening onto stray locks of his hair and moving them out of the way of his face. Her wide eyes pressed in on him, stopping only once they were inches apart. He could see the dark circles of her sunken eyes. Did she ever sleep? In addition, her magic illuminated something else too, dry crimson stains around her mouth and smeared up her cheek. Her breath hit him just then, causing him to flinch as bile rose in his throat. The smell was foul beyond anything, stale and rotten.

Her hoof hovered just above his jaw, touching it with a gentleness he didn't anticipate. She stroked circles on the side of his face, feeling her body trembling in the contact. As Pheonix dared to move away, her horn burned brighter, magic grasping at his forelegs, trapping him no matter how much he strained.

Despite himself, he let out a nervous chuckle. "Listen, D- Dancer.." He cleared his throat as it wavered. "This is crazy, please let me go." Each word was enunciated slowly, and he watched her face transform from blissful to angry.

That made him panic. Could she be capable of killing him? He had seen the dead things she had left around his house, and that blood around her face... And now he was completely at her mercy. Maybe he should choose his future words more carefully.

"I'm not crazy!" Dancer exclaimed, though her tone did little to convince him.

"I just want something from you... only you..." she cooed, moving her face closer to his. Her muzzle brushed against his, and her foul breath invaded his mouth. He wanted to gag, his eyes screwing shut as his whole body tensed.

For a brief moment, he thought maybe this was worse than her killing him. If all she wanted was to kiss him with her filthy mouth...

Then, her shaking hindquarters came to rest on his lap, her hoof pressing against his shoulder, forcing him back against the headboard. It was an unbearably long amount of time before she finally pulled away and let him take a breath of fresh air.

“Please stop...” he breathed, “I don’t want to do any more kissing...” He pleaded.

The mare laughed softly in response, leaning close to him and pressing her cheek against his, nuzzling his face. “But I do. I want it very badly.”

"You're insane," he squeaked out. He realized immediately that it was probably the wrong thing to say, as the magical grip on his legs tightened painfully. He winced and looked up at her face, now a mask of rage. Phoenix had seen more expressions from her in the past few minutes than he ever had since he met her.

“Don’t call me that!” Dancer snapped at him, her voice cracking and raw with emotion. Her voice cracked as she snapped at him. The magic shackles continued to tighten around his legs, the pressure she was applying growing rapidly more painful by the second. Phoenix hissed out a breath between his clenched teeth.

“Call me..." she searched for the right words. "...pretty, c-call me a pretty mare... Call me lovely." It was a soft demand, but the force in her magical shackles was all the persuasion he needed.

"Okay! Okay... Ow, ow, ow... You're a pretty mare, a lovely pony!" With each word, he grew more desperate for relief.

Dancer bent forward, their muzzles too close once again. "You called me pretty..." Her wide eyes were the only things he could see, and he stared as her eyes welled with tears, her face shifting rapidly into anguish. Or perhaps she was happy and they were tears of joy. Her breathing was rapid and heavy, each uneven breath gracing his nostrils with more of that uncomfortable scent.

At least her grip lessened.

"Nibble on my neck." Pheonix wasn't sure if he had heard her correctly, or if he had imagined it until she shifted and exposed the side of her neck for him. It was definitely an order and not a suggestion. Remembering the squeezing pain, he begrudgingly opened his mouth, letting his teeth pass over the area offered to him. It tasted salty and musky with sweat. Her body seemed to vibrate as she let out a soft, unsettling moan.

Phoenix was not enjoying performing an act of love and intimacy on his captor, but she seemed to be in heaven, shivering and wriggling on his lap as if she'd never been touched like this before. Her hips pushed into him at an awkward angle, causing his heart to beat faster. The wetness of her inner thighs was unmistakable as her rear hovered inches away from his cock, and he desperately tried to suck his gut in- to do anything to keep her away from him.

His efforts were in vain as she planted herself firmly back on his lap, her body dangerously close, her magic light pulsing brighter. A sweet, yet unwelcome aroma wafted into his nostrils, a stark contrast to what he yearned for. Her musky, earthy scent, redolent of readiness and desire, assaulted him, and he recoiled, shaking his head vigorously in an attempt to clear the overwhelming odor.

Groaning in protest only fueled her, the mare above him reacting by grinding against him more fiercely. She was much too close, her hooves pressing against his shoulders, digging into them and causing him to gasp as she held herself steady and lowered herself down directly onto his cock.

Already, he had been trying to battle the hormones and the scents, being at her mercy. But now, it could barely hold back, rapidly hardening between their bodies.

Dancer looked between them with a delighted smile, and he wondered if she had been expecting this all along. He wondered if she had done this before, or if she was just a crazed, touch-starved virgin.

Phoenix tried to look away from her when she fixed him with a stare, feeling his face growing much, much too hot. Unfortunately, he didn't have much choice, her magic forcing his head to move towards her and her piercing gaze.

"You're getting hard, that means you like it, right?" Her eyes seemed to grow wider as she anticipated an answer, but he said nothing which caused her to frown in disappointment. Dancer arched her body so she could look downward, a hoof going to his length, and stroking it awkwardly.

Gritting his teeth was a disservice, causing the sigh that came from him to turn into an audible hiss as he felt his body jerk under her touch. It wasn't even all that pleasant, just sensitive. He at least seemed to remain half-flaccid, though he wasn't sure how long that was going to last with all the attention she was paying him.

Despite his lack of full arousal, Dancer tried to unsteadily mount him, and he struggled again, futilely, against her magical bonds. The heat making contact with him caused his cock to twitch, the blood in his body racing downward. Against his very will, he was stiff as a rock, allowing her to assault him further. He took a shuddering breath as she successfully enveloped his tip. Phoenix felt like he could throw up.

Dancer didn't seem to notice his inner turmoil, huffing as she found the right angle, his length spearing into her further, until it stopped suddenly. She seemed to hesitate for a moment before lowering herself further, uttering a small, sharp cry as she did so.

Suddenly, he realized the answer to his own question. She was a virgin. The keyword being was. Sure enough, the tang of fresh blood lingered with the other scents in the air, coppery and sharp. Now the warmth and tightness gripping him felt even more wrong. He groaned in frustration, wishing he could command his body to stop reacting so favorably. If only he could just... Go soft. He wondered how Dancer would react to such a situation.

Apparently not satisfied from earlier, her mouth was back on his, lips flush against each other and her tongue probing into his mouth in a chaotic frenzy. His gasping only allowed her to probe further into his mouth, and he almost choked as her hot, sweaty body rocked itself from side to side on his stiff cock.

After a few moments, the trembling mess pulled away from him. "Ahh, this feels so much better than I ever thought it would. You feel and taste so good!" Dancer seemed to lose her train of thought and desire for speaking as her breath hitched, focusing on rocking herself on him.

All at once, Dancer hit her high. She let out a high-pitched keen, her forelegs bracing against his chest while her entire body arched and buckled. Her magic flickered bright and dim. Phoenix found himself transfixed as Dancer completely lost control of herself all at once. She panted and moaned, having trouble keeping her breath under control. But what he noticed most of all was the squeezing, rhythmic sensation that squeezed against his cock, massaging it in such a way that he couldn't help making a small noise of his own, his eyes shutting.

Phoenix could feel a trickle of warm liquid coming from her, soaking into the fur of his stomach as the scent of her musk grew much heavier. It was incredibly intoxicating, and for a brief moment, he forgot the situation he was in.

His jaw set as the deranged mare pressed her face in close, their foreheads touching.

"Can't you see how much I love you?" Her voice broke and cracked from overuse. Phoenix was not sure this was love, but he could see the effect he had on her. He decided not to say this out loud.

After a few moments, Dancer jerked her body, her hips rising and falling. His shaft scraped along her warm walls, and he had to choke back a yelp. Did she want more from him? Phoenix let his neck go limp, the back of his head hitting the headboard. This was torture. He supposed at this point all she wanted was to enjoy herself... And then she'd leave.

Pheonix wanted to believe that.

Dancer's low, husky moan filled the air as she reached between them, her hoof tracing across her clit with reckless abandon. She seemed to crave every last drop of pleasure, every shuddering tremor of ecstasy, and she was determined to wring it all from him. The stallion's body glistened with sweat, his muscles taut and trembling as he fought to hold back a moan of his own. Gods help him, he was on the brink of succumbing to her desires, slowly running out of reasons to resist.

The mare was moving faster now, rocking herself up and down his length with an unbridled ferocity. Her face was fully flushed, and she couldn't stop staring into his eyes, searching, judging. Phoenix wished he had his eyes shut or anything else to focus on, yet he held her gaze, transfixed by the raw intensity. Phoenix could feel himself breathing heavier, his chest heaving with each ragged breath, and his cock giving a violent twitch inside the wild mare. The sensations overwhelming him were both terrible and pleasurable, a contradictory mix that left him reeling.

The more he refused to give in to the increasingly blissful feelings she was giving him, the more frustrated his body seemed to become. It was as if his very flesh was rebelling against his mental resolve, begging him to surrender to the act. As her depths began tightening around him a second time, he let out a low moan, which he regretted instantly for it seemed to only heighten her pleasure, and she knew it would only encourage her more.

The rhythmic muscle movements gripped him a second time, and he could feel liquid splashing onto his torso, a warm, sticky sensation. His face grew hot as he watched, almost in awe, at what could only be described as pure pleasure cross over her features. The mare bit her lip and let out a soft contented moan through her nose, her eyes closed in rapture as she savored the bliss that had taken hold of her.

She did not stop. The mare continued to pump herself on his shaft, her body glistening with sweat as strands of her mane clung to her moist face. Her hind legs looked strained from all the effort, muscles trembling with each movement. She couldn't keep this up, could she? Dancer leaned forward, her eyes locking onto his, and attempted to kiss him again. This time, her mouth seemed a little more warm and inviting, and he slowly, cautiously let his jaw part for her of his own free will. Once again, she eagerly probed into his mouth, still sloppy, but he didn't care. He wanted to indulge in this moment.

Tentatively, he flicked his tongue at her, and she reacted by moaning into the kiss, her body shuddering with pleasure. His cock throbbed in response, and he realized he was losing himself. Maybe it was a good thing. Maybe he should feel good too.

Her kiss grew more aggressive and invasive, and so in turn he fought back with increasing fervor. Pheonix came to realize that at some point she had released him because as he moved his legs he found there was no force stopping him any longer. However, it was too little, too late, for he was still under her spell. He reached a foreleg up and pulled at the back of her neck, forcing her head down while the other foreleg traveled to her hip. The voice urging him to escape was overshadowed by a louder, more urgent voice that was demanding his own release.

Soon, he broke their mouths apart, pushing her forward with force. Dancer fell off of him with a gasp, her eyes wide with shock. Her trembling body lay before him, and now he was the one in control. Not wasting any time, he forced himself back inside her inviting folds. He pushed into her, his hips moving instinctually and with purpose.

"You- you lo-" Pheonix pressed a hoof to her throat, cutting off whatever it is she might have said, her eyes screwing up and small high-pitched noises finding their way out of her mouth instead. The words weren't needed. The pure glee that was written on her flushed, sweaty face told him all he needed to know. It was telling him what they both knew. Dancer had won.

Phoenix leaned down, his tongue lapping at all the saltiness that had collected on her coat and the heat from her skin. After only a few moments, he could feel her squeezing him, her walls gripping and so desperately trying to extract all he had to offer for a third time tonight.

There was no surviving this. He released her throat, letting her make all the whorish sounds she desired while bracing himself against the mattress. The rhythm he was the master of now increased as he rutted her with increasing intensity, and as her climax subsided, his finally began.

It took every shred of the remaining resolve he had within her to resist the temptation to spill all he had deep inside of her. Though he knew it would feel fantastic, he also knew it was a dangerous gamble. It wasn't one he wanted to take right now.

With a groan of frustration, he tore himself out of her, his hot member flopping on her warm belly instead just as the first hot rope of cum shot from his tip. The warm liquid covered her, first her face, then her chest, a few spurts even landing on her dirty mane. All the while she stared on with round eyes. He deliberately jerked his hips, smirking to himself as some of his final drops landed in her eyes, causing her to quickly close them and rub at it.

The light from her horn finally faded, and Pheonix was left in darkness. With the event over, he was left feeling less than satisfied. A strange feeling of guilt and shame washed over him, regret of his actions flooding into the chasm his rapidly retreating arousal had left behind.

Pheonix felt truly, and wholly awful about what had just happened.

Not only did he feel truly used, there was another feeling prickling at him. There was a part of his brain trying to convince him that he should feel bad for taking advantage of her. Obviously she wasn't mentally all there. But then, despite that she was the blame for instigating this in the first place.

His inner monologue quieted when he felt her move closer, pressing her body to his, the feeling of his own spent seed pressing into his coat. He honestly was feeling too exhausted to even bother with avoiding her. As he fell backwards, head hitting his pillow, she followed him. Weariness pulled at his eyelids. For a moment he wondered how he could be so comfortable and able to fall back asleep with her still here. Then, he realized there was nowhere left in his life that was safe from her. Nowhere he could go that she wouldn't try to follow.

He looked at his alarm clock.

3:38 AM

Tomorrow morning was going to bring many consequences. But for now, with his energy spent, and the warm body of Dancer close to him, all he could do was give in to the exhaustion and close his eyes, sleep washing over him.