Too Much Pony

by Bendy

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Human, Main 6, Anon, Porn, Second Person, Comedy
Length: 1221

You really like ponies, but you are afraid of being rejected by them. For they are way too big.

You really like ponies, but you are afraid of being rejected by them. For they are way too big.

Published 2021-08-13 22:30:03 UTC
Last updated 2021-08-13 22:30:03 UTC

Too Much

You, the human, sat alone in the corner of a dark and gloomy bar. You were finally dressed for this occasion, wearing a black tuxedo. However, everyone else in the whole place was naked. You were in fact the only human here. You are no longer on Earth. You have become well acquainted with your interdimensional pastel alien pony friends. They seem friendly, a little too friendly. The ponies towered into the air, standing about 30 hands high, or ten feet. And that was the average-sized pony, there were some others you met in the past who were even beyond that.

The smell of sex was in the air as the ponies casually mounted one another in public. They were not in the least bit shy about public sex it seemed. You stared in awe at the sexual activity that was happening in the bar. Mares, with huge beach-ball-like buttcheeks, had mighty stallions mounting them from behind. The sounds of flesh, slapping against flesh could be heard as the stallions repeatedly thrust their huge cocks against the fertile mares in front of them. Both parties uttered a series of loud moans, groans, and neighs during their coitus.

You found yourself pulling a stiffy from the sight of them. However, you were too shy to publicly masturbate. Even though there were others here like yourself that simply wanted to watch ponies have sex. Unfortunately, those others were actually ponies, while you were but a mere human. Your average pony had a cock that seemed at least 30 inches long or so. You were far too embarrassed to take out your little human pecker. You didn't want to be laughed at by the far superior stallions here.

Thankfully, you have yet to encounter a pony to mock you for being far smaller downstairs. At the same time, you were never really approached by any mare. None of them seemed interested in you. Apart from one. Who you were doing your best to hide from.

However, you knew in your heart that your mission would end in failure. The particular pony you were hiding from seemed to have psychic powers. Or Pinkie Sense, or whatever she calls it. You liked Pinkie Pie, you really do. However, you did not have the courage to do the deed with her. The thought of her laughing at your penis would shatter your pride and totally push you over the edge.

But then again Pinkie Pie seemed to be a really nice mare. The big pink pony really lit up your day. You wondered if you could have a chance with her? As luck would have it Pinkie Pie mysteriously teleported into view in front of you. She teleported by at least your perspective, you were pretty sure this mare could move at the speed of light if she wanted to. You have seen her do things that seemed physically impossible. Like floating in mid-air and stuff like that.

“Anon!” she said, giving you a friendly wave with her hoof. “I’ve been looking all over for you.”

“Errrrr, hello,” you said in a low voice.

Without a word, Pinkie Pie made to sit down next to you upon a much larger wooden chair than your own. There soon came a creaking sound, before the chair subsequently collapsed from under Pinkie Pie’s heavy weight. With a loud slam, her huge butt came crashing to the floor. The chair underneath her was crushed into a fine sawdust from the impact of her heavy rump.

“Hehe,” she giggled with a hoof over her mouth. “Looks like I have been eating far too many cakes lately.”

“You can never eat enough cakes, Pinkie,” you openly confessed.

Pinkie Pie gave you a smug grin and then spoke in a sultry tone. “Huh? I thought you said you didn't like ponies that way? You wanna show me what you got, big guy?” You opened your mouth to speak but no words came out. “You wanna go somewhere private?” she said in a low voice.

You simply nodded. She nodded back in understanding, and then made to stand up. You followed from behind Pinkie Pie through the bar. She swayed her hips from side to side, causing her fat bubbly cheeks to smack against one another with loud meaty slapping sounds of flesh, slapping against flesh.

You followed your hot date back home tonight. However, your confidence was completely shattered when you were taken back home into her bedroom. For she was not alone here. You could see her friends; Twilight Sparkle, Fluttershy, Applejack, Rarity, and Rainbow Dash all staring at you. Pinkie Pie lay upon her bed with her asscheeks spread wide open for you to see all her delicious meaty assets that were her plump marehood and ponut.

You stood under the shadow of Pinkie Pie’s massive ass looming over you. You twiddled your thumbs nervously. You were absolutely terrified. Your body was shaking in place. You could not mount the courage to pull down your pants.

You then felt butterflies flow through your stomach as you heard Pinkie Pie’s concerned voice speaking. “Are you okay, Anonny? We don’t have to do this. We can just cuddle and kiss if you want.”

“I… I-I…. I…--- you said, before being cut off by Rainbow Dash.

“Oh, come on! Mount her already!” she exclaimed, crossing her hooves.

“But… but… you will--

“Laugh at you? No way, you are my friend. You are a nice, cute little stallion who needs a big fat mare’s ass to make you happy.”

“Ah agree. Quit yer bellyaching and mare-up. Our cunts can squeeze down pretty hard. Ya don’t need to have a big long cock like mah brother’s,” said Applejack.

“Nor my brother’s. And I know from personal experience,” said Twilight.

Applejack gave her a salute with her hat. “Right-on sister from another mother. Ah love mah brother’s big cock as well.”

You became somewhat disturbed from the acquired knowledge that Twilight and Applejack had slept with each of their own brothers.

“Go on darling. Pinkie Pie is waiting for you. None of us will mock you for being less equipped downstairs than a stallion,” said Rarity.

“I actually find small penises cute. Don't be afraid to mount me after you are done with Pinkie Pie,” said Fluttershy.

You took a deep breath before you pulled down your pants along with your underpants in quick succession. Your erection was exposed to them all to judge you. You looked around the room to gaze at their reactions. Every mare in the room was giving you a warm smile, and looking down at you with love in their eyes.

Even Rainbow Dash. You were pretty sure that this mare would point and laugh at you for having a far smaller penis than a stallion. You were thankful to be proven wrong.

With the last of your fears evaporated away, you subsequently dove your head between Pinkie Pie’s fat asscheeks and began to eat out her plump marehood. You cried out in pure bliss as her cotton candy-tasting marecum flowed into your mouth. The sounds of Pinkie Pie giggling, moaning, and the horsey sounds she made as you ate her out were music to your ears.

At long last, you embraced big fat pony butts without fear of rejection.