Ponyville After School

(Vectors by Remul-Lemlem, FrownFactory, & thebosscamacho)

~ ✭ ~

Rare Find was studying an antique pendant when he heard somepony knock on his office door. He was a rather dashing unicorn stallion, with a brown coat, a white mane, blue eyes, and a cutie mark consisting of three green jewels.

"Come in!" Rare Find said, loud enough to be heard by whoever was behind the door. It creaked open, revealing a familiar face. "Oh, hello, Cheerilee! What can I do for you today?"

The earth pony smiled. "Hi, Rare Find! It's good to see you. As for why I'm here, it's because it's Friday, and this week's winner has asked to spend his night with you. It's Tender Taps; you might have seen him dance before."

"Oh, I see! I didn't even realize what day it was… So, it's a colt?"

Cheerilee nodded, looking a little worried. "Yes, indeed. I hope it's not an issue?"

"No, no," Rare Find assured her. "It's been a while since I laid with another stallion, but I do enjoy it. It'll be my pleasure to show Tender Taps a good time. I suppose that I shall pick him up after school today?"

"Ah, good! Yes," Cheerilee said. "And, if that is not too much to ask… You see, Tender Taps recently began to date another colt from the class, and he'd like to know if he could come too. They never have been intimate with each other, and it would be a great opportunity to have a responsible stallion to guide them during their first time. Skeedaddle is a good student too, so I suppose it's okay if he shares the prize just this once, but, of course, I need to know if you're comfortable with that as well."

Rare Find took a moment to think about it before answering, "Sure, that's no trouble. His coltfriend is more than welcome to join! I'll pick them both after class."

~ ✭ ~

Later that afternoon, Tender Taps was waiting with his coltfriend in Rare Find's living room, the stallion having gone to the kitchen to prepare some snacks. The young orange earth pony checked around the place; the room was full of intriguing antiquities, like clocks, paintings, jewelry, and a lot more.

Rare Find had explained that he worked with antique stores and museums to find, identify, and analyze ancient objects from all over Equestria. His home had a cozy, old-timey feel that was quite to Tender Taps' taste. "This place is pretty cool, huh? What do you think, Skeedaddle?"

Tender Taps' coltfriend was a young blue unicorn with a spiky blue and yellow mane, and a knot cutie mark. Skeedaddle gave the room a quick glance. "Yeah, I guess it's kinda neat. I'm more interested in you, though…"

Both colts blushed, and shared a long, deep look. Tender Taps' heart skipped a beat; Skeedaddle was so wonderful, and he was sitting right next to him on the couch, his face mere inches from his own. Of a common, unspoken accord, they each closed their eyes, and pressed their muzzles forward.

Tender Taps felt sparks of tingly, nervous excitement all over his body as his mouth met the other colt's soft lips. Kissing Skeedaddle was simply extraordinary, triggering strange new feelings Tender Taps had never felt from anypony else. They had only been together for a couple weeks, and he couldn't get enough of him. His cock slipped from its sheath, slowly growing between his legs.

Their kiss was cut short, however, by Rare Find's return, the stallion levitating a tea set and a platter of scones. Tender Taps and Skeedaddle parted, their cheeks red from embarrassment of having been caught like this.

The older unicorn let out a little laugh, cutting through some of the awkward tension. "Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you two. The tea is ready, if you want a cup."

The two colts nodded, and joined the stallion around the table. Using his magic, Rare Find expertly poured three cups of tea. "Sugar, or maybe some milk? I have honey too, if you prefer."

"Sugar for me," Tender Taps said.

"Yeah, me too," added Skeedaddle.

Once every teacup was ready, Rare Find levitated his own, and took a sip. "Mmh, exquisite."

The two colts gingerly used their forehooves to hold their own cups; though Skeedaddle was an unicorn too, his magic was still too unsteady to risk levitating their host's precious china.

"So," Rare Find said after a few minutes, "Miss Cheerilee said you two were a couple. Do you want to tell me about it?"

Put at ease by the stallion's gentle smile and friendly attitude, Tender Taps lowered his cup, glancing at his coltfriend. "Well, sure. Uh… I switched to Miss Cheerilee's class this year, and she put us in a team for the first group project. Skeedaddle started hanging out with me after that."

"One day, we kinda just… kissed," Skeedaddle continued. "I'm not sure why… He was just so cute, and it felt so good… I couldn't hold it."

Tender Taps sighed dreamily. "Yeah… And we want to… you know, go further than that, it's just… I'm not sure what we should do." The other colt nodded.

Rare Find finished his tea and left his cup on the table. "That's nothing to be ashamed of. We all have start somewhere, even with sex, but it really is worth it. So, how about we finish here, and move on to the bedroom? We'll start with simple things, and we'll go on from there. Okay?"

Tender Taps and Skeedaddle nodded in unison, nervous but excited.

~ ✭ ~

Rare Find settled down on the bed, inviting the colts to join him. They both laid down on their belly with their tails down, shyly hiding their genitals.

"Let's start with simply touching each other," the stallion proposed. "Skeedaddle, if that's okay, could you roll on your back so Tender Taps can explore you?"

Skeedaddle hesitated for a moment, but the sight of his coltfriend soothed his nerves. "Y-Yeah, sure!"

Tender Taps watched his special somepony expose his colthood; Skeedaddle was blushing, but he spread his hindlegs willingly, letting him peek in-between. Here it was: his coltfriend's penis. A couple inches had come out of his sheath, though the pink length was still soft. At the base, Skeedaddle's balls were nice and full, bulging with his seed. Tender Taps was fascinated; he had seen his friend's sex before, but never in such gorgeous details. It was amazing.

For Skeedaddle though, it was a bit embarrassing to be showing himself like this, not just to Tender Taps, but to Rare Find as well. It also triggered some deep seated insecurities. "Erm, it's not weird, isn't it…?"

"What? No!" Tender Taps blurted out, taken off guard.

Rare Find was more measured in his response. "Nope, there's nothing strange at all," he said, caressing the colt's inner thigh. "You have a lovely cock, Skeedaddle. You know, every penis is different, so it really is nothing to worry about. Becoming comfortable with yours is just part of growing up as a colt."

"Ah, okay. I see," Skeedaddle said, visibly relieved.

Looking up at Rare Find, Tender Taps asked, "Can… C-Can I touch it?"

The stallion cocked an eyebrow. "Well, I'm not actually the one you should ask, isn't it?"

"Oh, right… Sorry… Um, Skeedaddle? Can I touch your, um… your cock?"

Skeedaddle bit his lips. "Uh-uh! Please do it! Just, uh… be careful, ‘kay?"

Slowly, gently, Tender Taps caressed his coltfriend's sex, feeling its smoothness, its warmth. His touch elicited a soft gasp from the colt, making him smile. As Tender Taps lovingly stroked it, Skeedaddle's penis pulsed and grew, visibly hardening. It excited him even more: he was giving his special somepony an erection, and, in response, his own cock hardened under him. This was fun!

"Don't neglect his balls," Rare Find said, lounging comfortably on the bed. "Here, like this…" The stallion gently cupped Skeedaddle's testicles with his hoof, which got an immediate moan from the little colt.

Intrigued, Tender Taps fondled the little blue sack, feeling the pillowy softness of colt seed inside. It was a beautiful thing to behold, though it didn't beat Skeedaddle's blissful expression. "Huh, does it feel good?" Tender Taps asked.

"Y-Yeah… unf… so good~" Skeedaddle said, panting. "Could you, aah… do my dick again? A little faster, too…"

"I'll take over down there for you," Rare Find whispered in Tender Taps' ear. "Go on, you can make him cum."

Tender Taps stroked Skeedaddle's erection again, going up and down the hard, smooth length with his hoof. Meanwhile, Rare Find dipped his head behind the younger unicorn's butt. He admired Skeedaddle's cute little anus and quivering balls for a moment, then kissed the colt's sweet testes, and licked the entire sack. The stallion tenderly nibbled the wrinkly skin, careful not to hurt the colt, of course.

Seeing his coltfriend squirm in delight drove Tender Taps to go harder, faster on his cock. He masturbated him, his own penis throbbing in sync as he gave him everything he had. What Rare Find was doing was incredible too; the stallion had taken Skeedaddle's balls in his mouth, wrapping his lips around the base, and suckled his testicles.

"Mmmh! Aaaah! Yes!" Skeedaddle's flare swelled under their combined care, the colt gasping and moaning. Tender Taps' foreleg was tiring quickly, but he didn't stop. He couldn’t. He needed to see Skeedaddle's orgasm.

"T-Tender… ahh!" Arching his little spine, Skeedaddle came. White, gooey cum gushed from his penis, squirting all over his heaving chest. Marveling at the sight, Tender Taps continued to masturbate him. He could feel Skeedaddle's colthood twitch under his hoof as he ejaculated, load after load of sperm pouring in short bursts from his urethra.

Skeedaddle went limp, his head slumping backward on the bedsheet, and the flow of semen ebbed. His cock softened, and Tender Taps finally let go of it, Rare Find doing the same with his balls. The orange colt had never seen anything more arousing than his coltfriend lying in blissful afterglow, his fur soiled with his own sperm, his soft penis exposed for all to see.

Tender Taps wanted to cum. He wanted to add his own seed to the mess, to claim Skeedaddle as his own. Without a word, he mounted the spent colt and rubbed his testicles on his sheath. Holding Skeedaddle's flanks with his thighs for balance and standing upright over him, Tender Taps used his forehooves to grasp his erection. He masturbated without shame, letting himself go.

He noticed Rare Find shuffling closer, taking a similar position beside Skeedaddle, his much larger stallionhood erect and aiming for the younger unicorn's messy tummy. "Mind if I join you?" the stallion asked with a wink.

Tender Taps shook his head: seeing a stallion masturbate sure seemed like a lot of fun. Rare Find stroked himself, his forehooves blurred by the speed of his motion, and Tender Taps imitated him.

Meanwhile, Skeedaddle observed in awe the two cocks pointing at the mess of cum staining his belly. His semen was cooling down, feeling kinda icky, but it wouldn't be for long. With a loud, ecstatic whinny, Tender Taps ejaculated, spilling his warm seed on him. A second later, Rare Find let out a grunt, and his own semen gushed from his flared sex. Stallion and colt ejaculated together, emptying their testes on Skeedaddle.

When they eventually collapsed on either side of him, Skeedaddle's tummy was a mess of gooey sperm, the combined fruits of their three orgasms. As his coltfriend and Rare Find recovered from their climax, the young unicorn idly played with their cum, lazily swirling it around his chest with his hoof. It was sticky, droopy, and — quite frankly — really smelly, but it hardly mattered.

Rare Find stretched his back, his flaccid stallionhood flopping freely between his legs. "Mmmmh! Yep… That was fun!" He lazily settled down next to Skeedaddle, scooping some of the semen with his hoof. "We'll have to clean you up… though, maybe you'd like to try some first?"

"Try some? As in… tasting it?" Tender Taps asked, puzzled, as he laid himself down beside his coltfriend.

"Mmhmm!" Demonstrating it, Rare Find licked the cum off his hoof, gulping down their combined essences. Skeedaddle tentatively tasted his own hoof, and immediately made a face. The stallion smiled. "It can take a while to get used to the taste, but it's a lot of fun!" Lowering his head, Rare Find licked Skeedaddle's belly directly, sloppily cleaning his fur.

Tender Taps decided to imitate him. Closing his eyes, he licked a bit of cum, and immediately understood his coltfriend reaction: the stuff was bitter, salty, and the texture was pretty gross… and yet, it was sort of fun too. Without really thinking about it, the young earth pony started lapping Skeedaddle. Some of the sperm he was ingesting was most certainly his own, but he ignored it.

Rare Find and Tender Taps swallowed the bulk of the cum off Skeedaddle. It wasn't exactly a great cleanup, though, so the unicorn stallion went to pick up a wet bath sponge and some soap from the washroom. With a good scrub, Skeedaddle was eventually clean, his blue fur free of dried semen.

Everypony was feeling pretty drowsy from their ejaculations, so the three of them settled down for a nap, cuddling together and falling asleep in each other’s hooves.

~ ✭ ~

After the nap, Rare Find baked some pizzas in the oven, and the three shared dinner in the kitchen.

The colts' little chit chat as they ate was so cute. Tender Taps and Skeedaddle were experiencing their first love, their first relationship. It was a wonderful thing; shy, awkward, but beautifully intense. The young unicorn was more forward with his desire, and he often stole little kisses from his coltfriend. Not that Tender Taps was complaining…

It brought warm, fuzzy feelings to Rare Find as he watched over them. The stallion was usually more interested in mares, but the two colts were adorable together. It was a privilege to be able to share this with them, and to see them masturbate and ejaculate, to taste their seed. And there was so much more he could teach them. Rare Find was already working mentally on the next step of their sexual education.

When they finished cleaning up the dishes, Rare Find brought the two colts back to his bed. They were staring bright eyed at him, visibly eager to continue, their semi-erect penises proudly on display.

"Do you two want to try oral sex, now?" Rare Find asked, adventuring a hoof under Tender Taps' tail and caressing the colt's balls. "Giving blowjobs is a lot of fun, and a great way to have sex with another colt."

"Mmh, yeah! I don't know how, though…" Tender Taps said as he enjoyed the stallion's intimate touch.

"Uh-uh! Me neither!" Skeedaddle nodded, and Rare Find fondled his testicles too.

"That's alright. I'll demonstrate, then you can try yourself later, okay? First, you two sit down with a pillow against your back. This way you'll have a better view."

The two colts followed his instructions, getting in position. Rare Find made them sit as close as possible, their flanks touching, and invited them to spread their back legs. The stallion crouched down in front of them, getting at eye level with the two excited colthoods.

"When you begin, start by simply exploring your partner's penis," Rare Find said. "You can kiss it, lick it, nuzzle it, whatever you feel like." Demonstrating, the older unicorn gently kissed the flat tip of Tender Taps' glans, and rubbed his muzzle along his shaft, then did the same to Skeedaddle.

Going back and forth between the two foals, Rare Find played with their sexes. He explored their entire genitals, going all over their cute lengths, and lower still, licking their sheaths, their balls, and even their tight anus. Precum pearled from their urethras, and the stallion licked that too. Tender Taps and Skeedaddle's cocks quickly grew to full size, their erections pointing up like two tiny towers.

"Once you're ready, take the penis in your mouth," Rare Find said after a final kiss on Tender Taps' glans. "You don't have to go deeper than you're comfortable with: simply sucking the tip and using your hooves to stroke the rest feels amazing too. Just watch your teeth, and have fun."

Opening wide, the stallion took Tender Taps' erection in his mouth. He wrapped his lips around the swollen flare and suckled on it for a moment, then pushed down. The colt's smooth shaft slid in Rare Find's muzzle, and the stallion began to gently fellate him, bobbing his head. Tender Taps' penis was of a nice size… for a colt, which meant the stallion could comfortably fit him in his mouth, and he took full advantage of it.

After a minute, Rare Find moved on to Skeedaddle's colthood. It was a little shorter than Tender Taps', though the young unicorn had more girth. Moaning as he experienced his first fellation, Skeedaddle craned his neck, searching for his coltfriend's lips. The two colts tenderly made out, expressing their love in a way simple words could not. Rare Find sucked their penises in turns, going from one to the other in alternance.

Tender Taps was the first to cum. He gasped in his friend's mouth, and Rare Find suddenly tasted the colt's sticky, bitter sperm. He happily gulped it down. The colt's penis throbbed and twitched as he climaxed, his balls clenching as he emptied them in the older unicorn's muzzle. Panting, Tender Taps let out several spurt before his ejaculation ended.

Keeping a good mouthful of cum in his muzzle, Rare Find moved to kiss Skeedaddle. This time, the young unicorn didn't shy away and opened his maw, letting the stallion's tongue and his coltfriend's semen in. The two unicorns rubbed their penises on each other's before Rare Find returned to fellate the little colt. Skeedaddle was getting close to orgasm, and the stallion bobbed his head up and down to make it happen.

Unsurprisingly, Skeedaddle came too, and his gooey seed gushed in the stallion's mouth. Rare Find swished it around his mouth, savoring the colt's fresh sperm. He found it tasted saltier, and felt less bitter than Tender Taps' cum had been: Skeedaddle tasted pretty good, actually.

After a few loads of semen, Rare Find's gaze crossed Tender Taps' hungry stare. Giving him an unspoken invite, the stallion pulled back from Skeedaddle, receiving a squirt of goopy colt sperm on his snout before Tender Taps took over for him. Skeedaddle stroked his coltfriend's mane as he ejaculated in his mouth, making him taste his seed.

Rare Find watched them finish, a smile on his lips and the feeling of a job well done. He licked the cum off his muzzle as they relaxed, spent for the time being.

He was still hard, however, and he needed to relieve himself, so he levitated a bottle of lube from his drawer. "Mind if I mount one of you?" the stallion asked, squeezing a generous amount of clear, slippery gel over his erect cock.

The colts looked at each other, and Tender Taps blushed. "I… I'd like to." Biting his lip in anticipation, the orange colt lifted his rump and presented his tailhole.

Rare Find mounted him, lining his glans with the colt's pert anus, teasing the tight sphincter. "Have you done this before?" Tender Taps shook his head in response, and the stallion reassuringly petted him, caressing his purple mane. "Don't worry, I'll take it slow. You just have to relax, and I'll do the rest."

With Skeedaddle observing from the side, Rare Find pushed gently with his tip on Tender Taps' tailhole. He wasn't exactly the most well-endowed stallion in Equestria, but he wasn't small either. Nothing really happened at first, but the stallion was patient; if the colt was to have a good first experience from anal sex, he needed to be careful with him. Rushing would only make it hurt, or even cause damage, something the stallion wanted to avoid at all cost.

Sure enough, Tender Taps' anus eventually loosened up to the point where the stallion could safely enter him. Rare Find pushed down with his pelvis, leveraging his weight to penetrate the colt. Tender Taps' ponut stretched around the stallion's engorged glans until the wide flare slipped inside.

Tender Taps groaned from the momentary discomfort, so Rare Find gently stroked his mane. "There, there… You're doing great. That was the hard part." It was indeed much easier afterward. With slow, shallow thrusts, Rare Find steadily made his way into the colt's rectum, until, eventually, he hilted his entire stallionhood inside the foal, his heavy balls nudging the colt's smaller sack. Rare Find inhaled deeply, closing his eyes. "Aaaah… You feel sooo good, Tender Taps!"

"R-Really?"

"Mmhmm!" That was an understatement, actually: the colt's insides were perfect, tight and warm and incredibly cozy. The stallion began to mate with him in earnest, thrusting in and out of his ass. His testicles jiggled freely under his tail, bumping the colt's ballsack with every penetration.

Wide eyed, Skeedaddle watched his coltfriend mate with the stallion. Rare Find saw the colt's erection was recovering swiftly from his previous climax, and it made him smile. "Wanna try it too?" the stallion asked between thrusts.

Skeedaddle expression lit up. "Can I?

"Uh-uh! Just give me a minute, and he's all yours. You can lube yourself in the meantime." Rare Find plunged once more in Tender Taps' butt, picking up speed.

"Aaah! Yeah! That's so good!" the little colt cried out. The stallionhood in his ass was providing his prostate quite a pounding, and his own cock bounced between his hindlegs, growing harder with each penetration.

With Skeedaddle waiting for his turn, Rare Find wasted no time to finish himself. He pounded into Tender Taps with all he had, enjoying everything the foal's tight little body had to offer, until, finally, he slammed hard into him, his glans flaring deep inside.

Tender Taps felt the stallion's heavy balls throb against his own testes, and then a twitch running through the shaft in his rectum. Warm, creamy stallion sperm gushed deep inside: Rare Find was ejaculating inside him. The older unicorn stayed there, emptying his quivering ballsack in the orange colt's bowels, his seed flowing in his colon. Rare Find eventually pulled out of Tender Taps and dismounted him, leaving his gooey semen inside the colt. He settled down beside him, nuzzling and kissing his ears as a gesture of gratitude for the good times had.

Skeedaddle quickly took Rare Find's place, mounting his coltfriend's rump and lining his cock with the gaping tailhole under his tail. The stallion observed the little unicorn vigilantly, ready to intervene in case he wasn't careful enough, but Skeedaddle penetrated the other colt with great tenderness. His sex easily entered Tender Taps' already loose rectum, the lubricant and Rare Find's sperm aiding its passage.

Once fully inside, rather than immediately thrusting in and out, Skeedaddle wrapped his forelegs around Tender Taps' neck and buried his face in his soft purple mane. "T-Tender… I… I love you… Mmmh! I love you so much! I wanna feel all of you! Aaaah!" With a grunt, Skeedaddle pulled back a couple inches, and pushed back inside, their testicles meeting with a soft slap.

"Skee… Skeedaddle… Aaah! I-I love you too! Unf! Oh, yes… Please!" Tender Taps pushed back with his rump, getting more of his coltfriend in him.

Rare Find watched the foals make love from the sideline, seeing their little bodies coming together in shared pleasure. A warm feeling spread inside him, something that wasn’t caused by the sex, but by the ardent glow of young love on full display before him. The two colts were sweaty, disheveled as they shared this wonderful embrace.

Skeedaddle was lovingly pounding his friend’s luscious butt, giving everything he had to their mutual pleasure. His cock, shorter than Rare Find’s stallionhood, actually let his glans stroke Tender Taps’ prostate with every thrust, and it made the orange colt’s penis pulse in sync with Skeedaddle’s penetrations.

Rare Find gently caressed their bodies with his hoof as they mated. He stroked Tender Taps’ colthood, then explored under their tails to fondle their testicles. The colts’ balls were smaller and wrinklier than they had been before their previous ejaculations, but they still held some seed for another. The stallion petted Skeedaddle’s virgin tailhole, making the little blue unicorn gasp even more.

Tender Taps let out a throaty moan, his mouth wide open and his eyes closed. A jet of sperm squirted from his cock, followed by a couple more, the foal ejaculating the rest of his semen on Rare Find’s bedsheets, staining the fabric with fresh colt cum. His rectum clenched hard around Skeedaddle’s flaring sex, and the young unicorn rammed deep into him, hugging him tight from behind. He held Tender Taps with all his strength, biting his ear, telling him he was in him to stay. Skeedaddle’s balls twitched, and he ejaculated inside his coltfriend, his viscous cum mingling with Rare Find’s semen in Tender Taps’ bowels.

Skeedaddle trembled atop Tender Taps, until finally his strength faltered. Both colts went limp, gasping for breath, the goopy result of their love oozing around Skeedaddle’s receding sex. The unicorn foal left his flaccid length in his coltfriend’s anus, perhaps too exhausted to even pull out, or perhaps simply not wanting to. Tender Taps closed his eyes and fell asleep, utterly content. Skeedaddle sleepily nuzzled the side of his face, planting a little kiss on his cheek. “Love you…” he murmured, before he dozed off as well.

Rare Find tucked them under the blanket, and gave each colt a little kiss on the forehead. Deciding to leave them together for the moment, the stallion quietly got out of bed.

He peeked at his old grandsire clock on the wall; it wasn’t very late. Tender Taps and Skeedaddle would probably wake up before actually settling down for the night.

Rare Find wondered if they’d be up for another round.