Pear Butter is a lonely widow. While she has some desire for Rarity, she knows Rarity is with her daughter. Rarity, while loyal to AJ can't help but notice how attractive Pear Butter is. But when Applejack cheats on Rarity, will Rarity embrace thoughts she previously found taboo?

Note: In this world, there are some noticeable changes: Pear Butter is the matriarch, Granny Smith has passed on, and AJ isn't the Element of Honesty. Her work ethic is almost non-existent and she displays the qualities of a 'free spirit'. Seeing little value in a committed relationship, she plays the field. Because her mother survived though her father still perished, AJ feels no need to step up and be strong for others. She also never left for Manehatten and she never had that "rainbow moment."