The best gifts unwrap themselves
Author's Note
King: Welp, this has happened then. I don't expect to win or anything, it's literally the first 'mature' story I've written. It isn't very long or overly detailed. The 'scenes' aren't too long either. This is mostly an excuse to get my feet wet, so to speak, in the genre. Thank you for your understanding and your read/reactions.
The best gifts unwrap themselves
“Okay. I can do this. I can do this!” Twilight paced back and forth in the room. As she looked into the mirror, she instantly deflated and growled in frustration. “No! No, I’m not backing out now.”
Twilight was a girl of many interests. She liked scientific experimentation, research, board games, the occasional trip to the beach, building machines, etcetera. Somewhat recently, she’d taken up dancing. A very specific type of dancing that she’d started learning at 16 and now, aged 18 for the past five months, was finally ready to be put to use.
Twilight looked at herself in the mirror again. She was wearing something very un-Twilight. Two somethings actually. The first was the pair of black lace panties, far too bold for her any other day. Then there was the matching bra which didn't so much hide her assets, but put more focus on them. She had a set of thigh high black stockings sitting on her bed with a white blouse, red skirt, and a pair of red boots that reached up just below her knees.
All the pieces were in place now. She had her outfit, she'd basically high jacked the hiring, and prepared everything for tonight. But her nerves were still getting the better of her. It was her brother's birthday today, and she'd been hired as a stripper for the event.
Okay, slight lie. His friend, Sunken Silver, had hired her unaware of her true identity. Or that she wasn't actually a stripper. Or that she basically hacked his phone and used common advertising methods to get him to call a burner phone she'd bought for this exact occasion in order to do so. But those were superfluous details!
What mattered was that it was happening, and it was happening tonight! Now, that's not to say she was just going in without a plan. She'd thought this through. She had a false identity, a wardrobe she'd never wear otherwise, and a little magic to help her out. A masquerade mask sitting on the bed. It was an Equestrian artifact called the Masque of the Shadow Walker. Apparently, it was created by a unicorn that wanted others to leave her alone, so she created a mask that makes it so no one could recognize her. Twilight tested the mask and found that it did actually work. However, upon borrowing it from her Equestrian counterpart, she was warned that if someone knew about the mask, it wouldn’t work. She’s kept it a secret for the better part of a month, just in case.
And now, at last, it was time to put everything into motion. And it was even easier to get away with doing this since she’s been housesitting for Sunset for another few days as the displaced unicorn returned home to make amends with her family. Sunset’s loft was fairly close to Shining’s home, allowing her time to prepare, sneak over, perform, and get back before Shining stopped by to visit after his party like he promised to.
Of course that got Twilight thinking about what could happen in such a circumstance. It didn't help that Sunset had basically given Twilight her blessing to do anything, or anyone, she wanted to in the loft while she was away. The only caveat was that she had to clean everything after the fact.
Twilight quickly suppressed that mental image and the desires it created. She can dream and fantasize all she wants, but she'll only ever have what she's about to do.
With one last glance in the mirror, Twilight slapped her palms against her cheeks and put on the most determined face she could. "Get dressed, Twilight. It's showtime."
Twilight, after the short drive to the small suburban home that housed her brother, used a little magic to put her plan together. A false, hollow cake was built and ready for her. The top-most section was a real cake though, made by Twilight of course. Pinkie would’ve had her head if there wasn’t a cake. If she knew this was happening at all, and Twilight made sure the pink-themed party girl was as unaware as possible. Twilight made her way to the homestead and was greeted by Sunken Silver. Thanks to her mask, her brother’s friend didn’t recognize her or even question why she had a mask. After crawling into her ‘cake’ and being moved inside, Twilight waited. She could hear them speaking, but couldn’t see what was happening. A part of her overthinking mind constantly had her checking her mask was on her face, anxious that someone would somehow know.
She heard Sunken Silver laugh, “Here’s your cake, man~”
Then Shining responded, “Silver… What am I looking at?”
“Your cake.”
“Bullshit.” A third voice, Banner Lord, followed suit. “Knowing you, there’s a stripper in there or something.”
Twilight chuckled to herself. Mostly at the irony of that Sunken Silver would, but also because he did.
Silver just laughed again. “Maybe there is. For the birthday boy!”
And that was her signal. Slowly, she pressed her hand onto the top section and pushed it upward. Most people think of bursting out of the cake, but Twilight was always more methodical, and she played with that. She stood up before propping herself up onto the upper lip, cake raised in both hands. She sat with her back to the group of young men, the tight skirt and position accenting her butt. He glanced back with a side-eye smirk, hearing the whoops of the others but eyes locked on the stunned face of her brother as he sat on a wooden chair. She slowly turned to place her legs forward and onto the lower section of the cake, allowing her to step down onto the floor again. With cake in hand, she slowly sauntered to her brother and placed the confectionary onto a side table next to him.
Twilight leaned closer, a sultry smirk painting her face, “I hope you don’t mind me dropping by, hot stuff~” She leaned down, her hands landing on his thighs, “I heard it’s your birthday today~”
“Uh…” Shining looked like a deer in the headlights. He never was good at dealing with girls.
But some part of Twilight was scared her mask wasn’t working. She glanced to the others around them and found no one saying anything odd. No one seemed to notice. Good. She turned back to Shining as she stood back up again. Confident it was still working, she smirked down to him again. “Hope you’re ready, birthday boy.” Twilight unbuttoned the first button of her blouse, then her second, with one hand. She’d practiced this long enough, she wasn’t going to mess this up. Her free hand returned to Shining’s knee and slowly slid up along his leg. She knew this angle showed off her cleavage as she slowly continued down her path. “Unfortunately, your gift is going to unwrap itself tonight~”
Her final button fell apart as she stood upright again. With a little flourish, she allowed the garment to slide down behind her as her arms leaned back, causing it to fall to the floor. This made Shining’s friends hollar, clearly enjoying their show. Meanwhile, Shining’s cheeks seemed to grow more red as embarrassment and arousal was taking over. Twilight took this time to do the same with her skirt, allowing it to fall to the ground. He stepped up and out from the skirt, her foot coming to rest next to Shining’s as she moved to straddle his lap. Her weight fell onto his legs as her arms grabbed onto his shoulders. “Sadly, you only get to keep the gift for an hour. But who knows~?” Twilight over emphasized every action, leaning close as she rolled her hips. Then, she lifted off, turning around and pushing her rear against his lap. She knew she didn’t have a Rarity level ass, but she had enough to get room going. And if a roll back onto Shining was anything to go off of, he was certainly enjoying himself.
Twilight jumped a bit feeling a hand fall on her side. She looked back to find Shining flinching away with hands to the side. She grinned and winked back to him. “Go on, handsome~ I’ll let you touch this time. Long as you can keep it in your pants.”
Secretly, though, Twilight really wanted him to not do that, to finally be together with Shining. But they weren’t alone, for one. And for another, she knew she shouldn’t want that. She was sure he didn’t want her. But there was no wrong way to fantasize, I guess.
Shining’s hands slowly returned to her side as she continued her dance. He kept his touch light to allow her to move as she needed to, but strong enough to make her shiver from his touch. His hand would glide across her skin, spurring her onward. It was everything she could hope for here.
Unfortunately, an hour isn’t as long as she’d have liked. Her timer went off and made her jolt up in surprise. As she heard the others let out groans, she turned back to Shining before slowly moving away from him. She deliberately did so in a way that kept her ass on his mind a little longer. “Oh well. You know how it goes.” She picked up her clothes and winked back to Shining, “Maybe next time we can enjoy ourselves longer. Or maybe have some real fun~” She walked back over to the false cake and climbed the sections as she waved back to Shining. “See you around, handsome.” She hopped back inside the cake and called out to Silver, “Wheel me back out while I put these back on, okay?”
She heard Silver confirm and she felt the cae move. All the while, she returned the clothing to her body and the hour’s events played out again in her mind. She could practically feel the blood pooling in her cheeks as her blush formed. With a few deep breaths to keep character she felt the cake stop, and she stood up again. She found her car nearby and Silver dusting off his hands. “Appreciate it.”
“No worries. Maybe I should hire you for another event.”
“You know where to find me.” Except that she plans to scrub that burner phone from records and move on. This was a one off event. And that made her ache in her heart.
Silver smiled, helped her break down the cake, and waved her off. “See you around.”
Twilight watched him go back inside before pulling out from the curb and driving off. She glanced up through the rearview mirror, thinking back and imagining how things could have been different. The road was the only thing keeping her from losing herself to her fantasies.
After a while, she returned to Sunset’s loft and made her way inside. Removing the mask, she set it on the table and walked to change back into her usual style of clothing. Back in her cyan blouse, purple skirt, and short socks, she made her way over to the kitchen. She needed a snack to help her mood and help her focus for when Shining’s party was over so he could visit.
Then she heard the doorbell. She jumped in shock and almost dropped a small container of strawberries, which Sunset apparently enjoyed. Placing it down again, she made her way back to the door, just as another ring played in the loft. “I’m here! Hang on!” She opened it up, expecting some solicitor or something. Not this. “Shining?”
“Hey, Twilight.” Shining was grinning and waving with his free hand. The other had one of those reusable shopping bags from the local market. “Sorry I’m a little early.”
“No kidding.” Twilight stepped away and let him inside, too confused to be worried about that fact. “I figured Silver would try to do a ‘party-all-night’ thing.” It was a fair thought, since he was prone to do just that.
“Yeah…” Shining placed his bag on the kitchen’s table and leaned back onto the surface as he turned back to her. “After… something at the party, he said he was going to leave me alone for a while…”
Twilight could probably guess what her brother’s friend meant by that… And her cheeks turned a little pink at the thought of Shining doing so to a memory of her.
“Point is, party ended early and I figured I’d stop by.” Shining seemed to be unwilling to look her in the eyes.
This got Twilight a little concerned, so she decided to move onto a new subject, hoping it will help him relax a little. “So, what’s in the bag?”
Shining reached into the bag and produced a small pastry container with two slices of cake. “It is my birthday, remember?”
“Uh… Duh. I knew that.” Twilight grinned, happy to be in her brother’s presence again. It was like everything was normal, like she didn’t just grind her ass against his junk mere minutes ago. “I already got you your gift earlier.”
“I know. I appreciate the new O&O books, by the way. It should be interesting getting to play later. But you also didn’t get any cake. So I brought some over.”
“Aw, you do care.” Twilight teased him a bit as she got a couple forks from Sunset’s kitchen drawers. “What are we waiting for?”
Shining chuckled and popped open the item. He placed it between them for them to share as a plate. “Nothing I can think of.” Sitting down, the two cut into their respective cakes and enjoy the flavor. After a while, though, Shining glanced to Twilight before staring down at his half-eaten cake slice. “Hey, Twily, can I ask you something?”
Twilight turned to him, having basically finished her cake already. Swallowing the final bite, she placed her fork down on the container's plate. “What’s up?”
“What’s up with that mask over there?” He pointed to the Masque of the Shadow Walker resting nearby.
Twilight glanced at the mask, considering her next move. He’ll be suspicious if I say it isn’t anything. He’ll think I’m hiding something. Better to just explain what it is. “It’s a magic item I picked up a while back. As far as I can tell, it can hide your identity using magic. No one would know you or even recognize your voice. No one would even think you're wearing a mask." Twilight spoke with an enthusiasm that only really came up when she talked about magic. It was all so fascinating to her, not to mention the possible applications.
"I'm guessing you tested it already."
"Here and there. I also found out that if you know about the mask itself, not necessarily what it does, than it doesn't work. It's kind of odd, honestly."
"Well, it would explain why Silver and Banner didn't recognize you."
"You would still need to consider any kind speech patterns, since if you give who you are, the mask…" Twilight took a moment to actually hear what her brother just said. Then another to comprehend it. She slowly, agonizingly turned back to face him. "What did you just say?"
Shining knew he'd opened the cursed box, and it was better to deal with the contents now. "I saw you with that mask a week ago. I didn't think anything of it, at first. Figured it was a souvenir or something to do with your friend Rarity. So… yeah. I wasn't affected by the mask."
Twilight was stunned silent as the night's events played out in her head. Everything she'd done now knowing he'd seen through her.
But she didn't get far before Shining spoke up again. "I'd just like to know why you did that. Was it a money thing? A prank?"
Twilight swung her arms around in a panic, as if to swat away the suggestion. After a moment of stammering, she eventually took a breath and calmed down enough to return to the conversation. “It’s… just that I…” She had difficulty saying it out loud. Some part in the back of her mind was practically demanding that she at least tell him on the slimmest chance that he would reciprocate. And even if he didn’t, it would at least get it off her chest. But rationality was holding her emotional core back, reminding her that would wouldn’t make anything better.
Oh, yeah, because being the stripper at your brother’s party and being found out means ANY of this can be salvaged otherwise! Her internal voice of harsh reason, which often sounded similar to her alter ego Midnight Sparkle, berated her. Now, you can either tell the truth, or bury yourself further in your own emotional grave. Your call.
Twilight took a deep breath to calm her nerves before staring back down at the table. "I did it because it was for you." Before Shining could respond, she continued, "I love you, Shining. As in being in love with you. I have for a few years now. I know that siblings aren't supposed to feel like that, but I can't help it. But it's because I'm your sister that I had to go through all this. I wanted just one moment where I wasn't your sister Twilight. Where I didn't have to hold back how I feel. But I guess I still couldn't really do anything. Honestly, I don't regret it. I just wish things could have gone better…"
There was silence over the room for a moment after that. It was impossible to tell what either was thinking once that was out there. Neither could find the strength of will to break the silence either. At least for a while.
Twilight could feel tears forming in her eyes, but she was able to hold them off for now. "Shining… I-"
She was cut off as a finger lightly pressed against her lips. Shining had turned on his chair to face her properly. "You said your side. Let me say mine."
Twilight nodded. She wasn't sure what to make of the situation, so any opportunity to not talk was welcome.
Shining removed his finger from her lips and moved himself closer on his chair. "I'll admit, it was an odd thing to see. I hadn't expected it and just thought I was seeing things at first. But as I saw you, really saw you, it was impossible not to see it was you. Even with that mask and how differently you acted."
Twilight had trouble meeting his eyes, but also found herself unable to look away. It was a contradiction she didn't fully understand in that moment. Like some fleeting hope was forcing her to look into his eyes. Those beautiful ice blue eyes… She shook her head slightly to get herself back to reality.
Shining continued, unaware of her inner thoughts. "I just had to confirm why. Why you'd do that at all. Now that I have the answer…" He trailed off. There was clearly more to say, but he quieted down before she could hear it. With a shake of his own head, he looked her square in the eyes. "Twilight. What you did has consequences. Opening a Pandora's Box of feelings that we tried to ignore."
Twilight might not be the most socially observant person, but even she could catch that when spoken out loud. "We?"
Shining nodded, leaning forward and placing his hand on top of hers, causing her to squeak a bit in surprise. "Twily, I always said you were the most amazing sister a guy could ask for. But I also thought you were the most amazing person someone could ever want. And I'll admit that I've dreamed about what could have been. If we weren't related. At one point I even asked myself, 'does it really matter?' And now, I know that it doesn't."
Twilight was quiet, unable to truly believe what was happening. "Do… you mean that?"
"Every word. Did you?"
Twilight didn't answer with words. Rather she jumped to her feet, closed the distance between them, and practically slammed her lips against his. It wasn't practiced or experienced. What it was, however, was passionate, carnal, loving, and hopeful. But above it all, it was undeniable. As Shining’s arms wrapped around her, he began to follow suit, wrestling for control of the kiss. And of course, he was winning, but Twilight was okay with that. Sweet lord, she was okay with that. Twilight never wanted this to end.
But she also knew it would have to. After all, if this was happening, this only the beginning. As they pulled away, their breathing was heavy as their lust built up within them. But something else had been building as well. Twilight leaned closer, her head resting on his chest as she sat on his lap. "Shining, do you think we could… you know…" Despite everything she'd done to this point, she was still embarrassed to say it out right.
Shining couldn't help but chuckle a little. "Not even a first date?"
Twilight playfully smacked his shoulder, "I've known you all my life. And I've waited enough for this. Please?"
Shining gave an exaggerated, but obviously joking sigh. "Fine." He pulled her back up to kiss her again before continuing. "But only because you're so cute when you get like that."
"Are you insinuating that I’m not cute otherwise?" Twilight shot back with a playful smirk.
But Shining didn't budge or stammer. "I don't know. Maybe you are. Maybe you aren't." He was clearly good natured about it, though. "But do you really care enough about that right now?"
"No. I suppose I don't." Twilight gave him another quick kiss before standing up and taking his hand. "Come on."
Shining couldn't help but chuckle a little. "Your place or mine?"
Twilight rolled her eyes at his line. "Actually, I got permission from Sunset. She might not know who I was thinking of at the time, but we're allowed to have our fun here."
"If you say so." Shining followed her through the loft to the area designated as Sunset’s bedroom. Most of the floor plan was open, so it wasn't hard to figure out what was where.
The two made their way to the bed, Shining plopping down onto the edge of the mattress as Twilight straddled his lap again. The two shared another prolonged kiss as Twilight’s hands traced along his chest. She reached down and pulled his t-shirt over his head, with his help to make sure it came off easily. Her core shook seeing him like that. She felt Shining’s hands caress her side, as though to do the same to her, but then he stopped.
He seemed to think for a moment before smiling to her again, “Memory serves, my present was going to unwrap herself tonight.”
Twilight blinked before letting out a giggle. “I did say that, didn’t I?”
Twilight stood back up as Shining adjusted himself to sit closer to the edge. Twilight kept her eyes on her brother as she unbuttoned her blouse. Unlike last time, she did so quickly. However, rather than throw it away in the throws of passion, she moved her arms underneath from the back as she made sure the front stayed obscured somewhat. As she shuffled a bit, she smirked to Shining. With a quick move, her bra dropped down, revealing it was a strapless style, and fell to the floor. She kept her blouse on, teasing at its removal but refusing to do so at this time. First, she unzipped the side of her skirt and let it fall to the floor. She propped herself up, straddling his lap again as she reached back and dropped the socks. Keeping eye contact with him, she finally pushed the blouse over her shoulders and down her back to the floor. She remained only in a pair of blue panties.
Shining’s hands returned to her body almost immediately. Her whole body shivered the minute his hands touched her skin again. She never thought she’d feel this again, yet here she was. Shining leaned up to meet her lips with his own again. Their hands met for a moment, sharing contact, before slinking down to Shining’s jeans. This time, it was Twilight’s turn to stop. She grinned as an idea formed in her head. She hopped off and onto her knees in front of him on the floor. She winked up toward him and leaned close to his crotch. She popped open the button before grabbing the zipper with her teeth. She pulled the metal tab down and put his cock one step closer to freedom. She took a deep breath, moment of truth, Twilight. Here we go.
She slunk her fingers beneath his boxers and pulled them and his jeans down enough to free him. She couldn't help but stare for a moment before moving closer. She gave the tip a tentative kiss, gauging Shining's reactions for any hint for her to stop. When none came, she moved down and continued to kiss his shaft. Twilight didn't have the most experience with this, just videos and sneaking some practice with certain foods when no one else was around. She never got any real feedback about this. Until now. Speaking of now…
She gave a slow lick up the length of his cock before reaching the tip once more. With a simple move, she pushed the tip against her lips and took him into her mouth. She soon found her body moving ahead using more instinct than technique. But from the moans coming from Shining, she was doing a pretty good job.
"Fuck, Twily, where did you learn to do this?"
Twilight popped her lips from him a moment, her hand covering for her as she spoke, "I may have done a little research. Best to be prepared, right?" With her piece said, she returned her lips to his cock with an increased pace.
Shining took in a sharp breath as his sister took in more of his cock. "Well, your research is paying off."
Twilight let out a happy moan before pushing herself to take in the rest of his cock. While she knew she had to temper her expectations when compared to her research subjects (read: porn stars), it was still something entirely different to do it. Shining wasn't porn star level in terms of his size, but Twilight still found herself gagging a little as she bottomed out. And yet, it wasn't an overly bad feeling either. It was just right for her.
Shining shivered as everything was happening. "T-Twiliy, I'm going to…"
He was interrupted as Twilight pulled back just enough and moved in her rhythm again. It was only a matter of time until…
Shining gripped her head and held her in place, unable to bring himself to remove her anymore. Now he took control of the pace, bucking his hips up into her. He let out a lust filled moan as he unloaded his seed into her mouth.
Twilight was caught off guard by his actions at first, but recovered quickly. As he came into her mouth, she found herself moaning along with him. She'd found conflicting accounts about the taste of semen, but the usual consensus is that it's an acquired taste. And she'd be damned if she didn't acquire this taste.
As things were winding down, Twilight found herself with a mouth full of her brother’s cum. And a choice needed to be made. But not really, though. She swallowed the cum without a second thought. Once she was done, she looked up to him, opening her mouth and sticking out her tongue like she'd seen in her research. After this, she winked saying, "Thanks for the meal~"
This got Shining to chuckle a little. "You're such a dork."
"Like you're one to talk."
"I made peace with my situation a long time ago."
As Twilight laughed, she couldn't help but feel happy. A part of her was scared she'd lose these kinds of interactions. But it seems she didn't have to worry so much. Even when they're baring their hearts and bodies to each other, they were still Shining Armor and Twilight Sparkle.
As she stood up to meet him again, however, he surprised her by grabbing her wrist and spinning them both around to switch places. When they landed, Twilight was on her back as Shining leaned over her. Twilight wasn't sure what he was up to, but she wasn't about to stop him either. As Shining held himself up with one hand, the other glided along her side, to her thigh, and then back up to her panties. As his fingers pushed against the fabric, Twilight found herself unable to control any of her moans. She was already wet from the anticipation, but the way he handled her only made her more so.
Shining kept his eyes on her face, smiling as she moaned in delight. "Seems like you were prepared. Classic Twily." A bit of a joke, but also rather in character for her to be ready ahead of time, even here.
"S-shut up!" Twilight squirmed under his touch. "Sh-Shining…" her tone made him stop for a moment. "Just to let you know, I'm on the pill and have day afters juts in case. So don't pull out. Okay?" Twilight lost her usual confidence she had when interacting with her brother. "Please."
Shining was surprised at first, but soon he smiled and kissed her before answering. "Okay, Twily. Just for you."
As both took a deep breath, they began to guide one another. Twilight pulled her panties down and away as Shining finally removed the rest of his clothing. They were finally, truly bare to one another. Shining was only one small motion away from the point of no return. They both knew this was what they wanted. As stared into one another's eyes, they knew beyond a doubt what had to happen next. They moved together, and there was no going back.
Twilight flinched at first. Her virginity had been taken by her brother, at last. She'd heard it would hurt at first and gradually get more pleasant. There was the initial sting from her hymen tearing, but it faded faster than she'd expected. Soon, the two began to gyrate into each other's movements. Everything they did was filled by their passion. Every caress, every thrust, every kiss… It all came back to one thing. Love.
Twilight knew some girls liked it rough, and, if her subconscious reaction to Shining’s actions at the end of the blowjob was anything to go by, she might be one of them. But that was an experiment to have another day. Right here, right now, she was in bliss. She knew Shining was on cloud nine right next to her. She reached up and grabbed his cheeks before pulling him down into a passionate kiss.
Neither knew how long they'd been going to this point. Neither cared. But Shining was able to speak through ragged breaths, "Twily, I'm…"
He didn't get to finish as Twilight cried out, "Me too! Let's cum together, Shiny~"
And that was the last straw. Shining, true to his word, remained inside her as he came. Twilight’s convulsing form reached up and hugged him against her chest as she rode out her own climax. She felt so full, both physically and mentally. For the first time in a long time, she felt whole.
As both began to descend from their high, Twilight gave her brother another kiss and smiled up toward him. "I love you, Shining."
Shining armor smiled back, whispering tenderly into her ear, "I love you, Twily. No matter what."
Twilight grinned to him, “Think we can go again?”
Shining let out a quick chuckle. “Sure.”
“But this time, I’ll let you rest a bit.” She moved him to the side and rolled them both to place herself on top of him.
Both of the sibling lovers were too enraptured by each other that they failed to notice when the door to the apartment opened, only to close again after a few seconds.
Outside, Sunset’s hand hung on the handle to her door. She was early and tried to get ahold of Twilight, figuring the nerdy girl had just gone to sleep. Then she walked in on that. Sunset slowly started to nod before turning away. She pulled out her phone and dialed a number. As she walked off, she spoke to the receiver, “Hey, AJ. You owe me ten bucks.”
