The sequel to Anon-A-Miss: New Student. It's winter break and Logan and Sunset decide to spend it together but that's not all. Logan's childhood friends are also coming to visit during the holidays. Sunset is excited to spend the holiday with two more people and especially Logan. She's just happy to finally have better friends to spend time with during the holidays.

However, it's not all good news. Abigail hears about a restaurant being filed against a lawsuit. Not just any restaurant, but the one she had founded many years before! Apparently, some costumer had claimed that his food was poisoned by one of the staff members. Abigail's friend is in desperate need of help so she decides to go back to Manehattan and prove her friends' and the restaurant's innocence. She can't help but feel like Gilda's mother had something to do with it.