Breaking Up Is Fun to Do

“She is,” shrugged Starlight. She sounded disappointed, though that might have just been a further insult to Trixie. “Well I guess she’ll live for now. I do miss having slaves, and she’d make a pretty fun one if I keep a tighter leash on her uptight ass.”

“So uh, should I go now?” While Keith was all up for staying for more fun, Starlight was clearly enjoying the release of some inner sociopathy and he didn’t want to be on the menu since she wasn’t going to off the rape-bait.

“Rape her up the asshole first,” Starlight smirked down at Trixie. “And you, little bitch, are going to turn around and raise that ass for him like a good piss-covered fuck sleeve, and suck my cock in apology for being an annoying little shit for this whole trip.”

“Starlight, my hind legs are broken…” Trixie soaked on a sob.

“You mean these legs?” Starlight narrowed her eyes, twisting Trixie’s knees further, eliciting a surprised scream. “I hope that wasn’t a ‘no’ to my order, because you don’t have permission to say no anymore, to any creature, got it? I don’t care if it’s a friend or a complete stranger wanting to plow you in a public park.”

“I’ll do it, I’m sorry!” Trixie gave in quickly. As Starlight released her legs, she rolled herself weakly over. It took her several attempts as she tried to prop her bottom half to push her rump into the air, her swollen legs shaking as she whined in pain.

“What a whore,” said Starlight. “A conniving slut that constantly cheats on her faithful marefriend or talks her into three-or-more-somes that she doesn’t really want to participate in but can’t risk losing you. That’s the reputation you’ll have for the rest of your life, drawing the well-deserved hatred of anyone worth being friends with, not that anyone worth it would be friends with you.”

Trixie tensed again when Keith grabbed her behind, clenching her teeth but flagging her tail upwards. His cock still slick from her foal-loaded snatch, he pushed it into her behind without hesitation. At first she tried to relax the pressure on her legs in hopes that he’d hold up her behind at least, but he only put more pressure on them. She nearly collapsed several times, but growls from Starlight made her renew her effort and stay up despite the increasing torment in her legs.

Starlight tugged the ropes from Trixie’s front legs, then lifted her front half up, forcing her to put more strain on her hind legs. She gave Trixie a mocking kiss, and a thick shaft dropped down from between Starlight’s hind legs as she cast a spell. When moved the pulsing meat forward, a few inches longer than Keith’s natural equipment, Trixie opened her muzzle, her only complaint was another whimper as Keith intentionally jarred one of her injured knees.

“Starlight this is making my knees worse, what if they have to take off my legs…” Trixie muttered before Starlight stuffed her throat. Starlight didn’t pause any more than Keith would have, forcing the magical meat back to her throat. Trixie’s eyes widened as if Starlight wasn’t usually this forceful with their futa fun, her throat swelling as Starlight pushed it right down her neck, not stopping until her balls slapped on Trixie’s chin.

“If that happens,” Starlight smirked. “Then you’d be the sluttiest cripple in Equestria. Doubly cripple, since you’re already one with magic.”

Keith moved a hoof to feel of Trixie’s throat, chuckling at the thickness sliding in and out. He and Starlight rammed her back and forth, letting her move farther than needed to punish her kneecaps even more. Trixie had stopped crying, her eyes glazed over at this point, clearly broken from the treatment from someone she had trusted. Fuck that was so hot.

“You’re not trying Trixie,” Starlight warned, and Trixie began to rotate her ass and head more, working the cocks in either end, even tensing her ass to put actual effort into getting the stallion inside off.

“I think this arrangement will work better for your uh… relationship,” chuckled Keith. “Damn she can squeeze that ass though.”

“And you,” smirked Starlight, leaning forward. She shared a deep kiss, but then whispered. “You can say what you want to this slut to torment her, but I trust that you don’t really think some of that, right? You realize that the only thing that stallions are good for is loading us with foals, and not even that when magic is available. I’m only letting you do this because it’s more humiliating to her. Do you agree, you filthy mudpony whose balls I could crush like rotten grapes and choke you on them?”

“Uh, yeah, of course,” Keith nodded, not daring to disagree when Starlight might still be aching to murder somepony. Her words weren’t quite as damaging to his ego as they might have otherwise been, since he’d been pinned down out here during his trips too. Racism was a favorite dirty-talk for a lot of unicorns, and females never missed an opportunity to talk down to males when they finally managed to pin one down.

“That’s a good dirt horse,” Starlight smirked. “Never forget that you’re inferior in race and gender.”

Starlight doubled her efforts and their two bodies moved gradually faster. He was able to last a lot longer now that he’d gone off twice in two hot bodies, so just casually enjoyed the misery of the broken mare beneath him. It was always delicious when a well-raped victim reached the point of accepting their status as a sex toy, and this one had earned a traumatizing future as a sex slave instead of just a single event.

He really felt like he’d done a good deed.

Even after his previous orgasms, the whole situation and knowing what would happen to Trixie now was too arousing for him to hold for long. He shoved down on her hard enough for her to collapse again, then drilled hard into her to expel spurt after spurt of rich cum into her posterior. It was a much less useful load, but all the same it was intense to use the broken mare in every way.

“Fucking hair-trigger,” Starlight rolled her eyes as she continued to ram Trixie’s throat. “I’ll never understand that. Mares do fine with magic cocks, yet ponies born with them can’t hold it in long enough for proper fun.”

“Sorry,” Keith said as he slowly withdrew. “You fillies are just… really hot.”

“Well I know that,” smirked Starlight. “If for different reasons. How about you move here to choke her on your shitty dick while I take her pussy. After that, you can leave her to me. I want to take a nice relaxing day tormenting her on my own here.

“S-sure thing,” Keith said, both happy to do so and a bit relieved that it looked like Starlight wasn’t going to murder him. Mares were so unreasonable anytime rape was involved, regardless of if they were giving or receiving.

Trixie tried to turn herself around, but was forced around by Starlight’s magic when she took too long. She stared at Keith’s brown-tinted shaft cross-eyed as he waited a moment to smell herself on it, then pushed it forward to her lips. With a new look of disgust, she opened her muzzle obediently.

Starlight leaned forward to watch her slurp the organ with an evil grin, grasping her bottom and pounding her filled pussy from behind. She didn’t make Trixie stand all the way up, but forced pressure on her hind legs all the same, one of which was now bent the wrong way at her swollen knee.

“That’s it, you deserve this, don’t you,” Starlight purred down at Trixie, then purred again as Trixie nodded in agreement with no hesitation. “You’re more broken than anyone in my village was. It’s so liberating to do this in such a violent manner instead of taking time to get into someone’s head the hard way. Right, random rapist I just let knock us up?”

“Wouldn’t know,” chuckled Keith. “Never tried the hard way… she’s pretty good at sucking the taste of her shit off my dick though.”

“She should be as much shit comes out of her muzzle,” grunted Starlight.

Keith had to admit, he was getting more nervous the longer he spent with Starlight, so at this point was keen on getting done and getting out of there. He pulled Trixie’s head closer to his gut, shoving deeper into her throat and enjoying the familiar fear of a pony choking on his dick. He panted, moving a hoof to feel the shape of his shaft through her neck, shivering as he slid towards one last orgasm.

“You know, I’ll have to knock you up next,” panted Starlight as she grasped Trixie’s rear-end harder. “But I thought it was important to teach you a lesson by letting some random loser do it first. He’s lucky I want him to get away scot-free as part of that humiliation too, or he’d be taking your place on the snuff menu. Still tempted...”

That was his cue to leave, but luckily the situation was still incredibly arousing, so he blasted off in her throat quickly still. He gave several powerful pumps directly into her gut, then yanked back, pulling her eyes open and letting the rest splatter over them to let them burn just a bit more.

As Keith backed away, Starlight renewed her efforts on Trixie’s puss. She slammed Trixie’s head onto the floor hair, eliciting a yelp as she yanked her plot up and nailed it with such force that it was surprising to not hear bones breaking. Starlight groaned soon as well, but kept ramming her dick even as she orgasmed, not even slowing down as she pumped another load inside.

As Keith exited, her could hear Trixie’s sobbing renewed, now not wanting to be left alone with the one she’d been in love with earlier that day.

“We’re not even half done, slut,” Starlight told her, still not having slowed down her movements, merely switching it up to ram her tailhole instead. “Once I’m done with you, you’ll never sit comfortably again.”

What a beautiful relationship.