Equestria Girls: Halloween Sex Night

“I feel so much better now.” You said finish peeing and readjust your pants.

You got out of the bathroom which you guys passed by earlier that is near the stairs, until you are greeted by your girlfriend who was waiting outside and wraps herself next to you. You notice that her legs are showing with the upper part of the tail itself still attached to the back of her waist. You are impressed since she did some modifications with her costume. But this didn't change the fact that she is standing next to you like she is wearing a swimsuit all this time with her full body exposed to you after removing the jacket you borrowed since she is half naked on top.

“Don’t tell me you purposely want to accompany me just for us to be by ourselves?”

“Yes?” Rarity playfully replies positioning in front and presses her body on yours. You feel her soft bosom touching your chest as you are pushed back to the wall.

“The others might get worried about why we’re taking too long.”

“They won’t mind, we’ll just be quick if you cooperate.”

Arguing back won’t help since she wants to do it with you right now. After having second thoughts you dropped your prop sword and wrapped your arms around her body as she did the same on wrapping her arms around your neck. Rarity took the next move and pressed her lips on yours. After a few soft kisses, the next one is when she firmly presses them on yours as you begin to lower your body which she follows without both of you breaking your kiss and the hug. She then removed her other arm and undo your pants revealing your member as she readjust to sit on top of you. She moved the lower part of her thong showing her white flower and began to grind making you feel her lips rubbing on your dick. While Rarity was busy, you inserted your right hand into her bra and cupped one of her breasts as you massage it in a circular motion earning more moans from her while still not breaking the kiss. You also felt her nipple being hard on your palm since her body was exposed to the coldness of night and of how horny she is right now.

The sound of thunder can be heard from outside but both of you didn't care since the two of you are in paradise and the only sounds both of you hear are moans and your tongues dancing inside. Rarity then breaks the kiss leaving a string of saliva as she continues with her grinding.

“Your moans feel like you are singing instead.”

“I’m not Twilight, but I did my research that mermaids use their singing voice to lure their victims to death.” Rarity said between her moans and her grinding. But then stopped as she placed her hand on your cheek and moved her face closer to your with her nose touching yours. “Though this mermaid only uses her singing to please the one she loves, which he already is.”

“Gyaaaaaaaaaahhh!”

The moment was interrupted and Rarity got scared clinging on to you but then recognized that scream belongs to Rainbow Dash. After fixing both of yourself up, you carried your girlfriend and retraced yourselves back to the second floor to the hallway where you two and Pinkie where.

"The sound is coming from down this hallway." Rarity pointed to the direction where the two of you last saw Pinkie which led to an intersection. "My goodness, now which way?"

Due to the thunder rumbling and lightning flashes, things became scarier as Rarity grips on to your top a little harder. You then hear the sound of their voices and you follow the sound. Rarity points to see moonlight coming from that room and the sound of her friends' voices coming there.

You approached the room while still carrying your girlfriend. Upon looking inside both of you stood there with your mouths open, both flabbergasted and disgusted somehow because all of her friends are heavily breathing, groping their own bodies and you see their drinks spilled on the floor including the water jug which contained the juice.

“R-rarity help.” Fluttershy said laying on the bed while massaging her breasts.

“Oh my stars! Girls, what on earth are you doing?” Rarity asked.

“There ya’ll are, what took both of yer so long?” Applejack asked while massaging parts of her body with hand covered paws.

“That question can follow, but why on earth are you doing this to yourselves?” Rarity followed when her friends looked at Rainbow Dash who is tied up with the prop whip of her costume squirming to either break free or to satisfy herself for face is slightly red while breathing heavily. “Does Rainbow have to do something with this?”

Sunset narrated after reading her mind earlier that Rainbow planned to get revenge on Rarity after that one day when she jokingly got Rainbow dressed in that poofy dress she disliked before the Fall Formal. That is when Rainbow Dash’s boyfriend walks into the store and finds his girlfriend in that funny getup while maintaining his poker face and turns around that he will come back later, but not after giving Rainbow a thumbs up and says she looks cute in that much to his girlfriend’s embarrassment.

Now that you guys are here at the haunted house, Rainbow waited at the corner when you took the water jug and cup from Pinkie. Just as you hand the drink to your girlfriend is when she used her superspeed to freeze time and rushed over and added the drug to the drink then rushed back to the others like nothing happened. Then Pinkie added when you excused yourself to go to the bathroom is when Rarity poured the juice back into the jug contaminating the rest of the content. When Pinkie came back and that is when all of them took a break and this happened.

“That was supposed to be for Rarity only. I can’t believe all of this got backfired!” Rainbow yells while still trying to break herself free.

“Serves you right because I didn’t expect your boyfriend would come and see you like that which became unintentional, humph!” Rarity replied giving a huff but then got back to the topic. “So how can we fix this mess?”

“There is only one way, if we get satisfied enough with pleasure then it will go away.” Twilight suggested the solution.

“Good, I’ll give your boyfriends a call-”

“Wait.” Twilight cuts you off. “Since you are here, maybe you can be the one to help us.”

It took for you moments to process what the egghead said. You quickly shook your head and still can’t believe Twilight suggested that you have sex with them. The worst part is that Rarity also heard what she said and it could be uncomfortable for your girlfriend to do this to her friends.

“No way! If I end up doing that to all of you, then I would end up cheating on Rarity.”

“Ok, I know you would say that. But Twilight is right, calling our boyfriends just for this would be troublesome to them since it's now raining outside and they might get into an accident. It will not be considered cheating if we do it not in a loving way.” Sunset states. “Don’t worry, we assure you that you will not get beaten up after this. Right girls?”

The others agreed to Sunset. You looked at Rarity who still has second thoughts about this. You then looked back at the window with rain pouring down until you felt your girlfriend tugging onto your shirt as she nodded, giving her approval for you to do it. Before you begin you placed Rarity as she sat on a nearby chair next to a dusty desk table. You asked first if they have any protection with them; Sunset is an exemption since she cannot get pregnant for she is a pony, Fluttershy and Applejack have their pills, Pinkie has two condoms who will share the other to Rainbow Dash for she didn't bring any, Twilight who didn't say anything which made you worry and for Rarity which you will do later has her pills.

“So who is first?”

“Ma murrmurrr!”

While your eyes aren’t facing in front, you feel someone but recognize the color pink meaning it’s Pinkie Pie. She leapt onto you from the front as you catch her in your arms as she held her arms around your neck and her legs around your waist. When she makes eye contact, you see that she is completely naked that a moment ago she was still in her costume but the only thing she forgot to remove was the gas mask.

“Really?” You sarcastically said and took the mask off her face.

“Sorry. Because when you said who’s first I was in the middle of taking my costume off which I really need your help. So enough of the talking and let’s get this fucking started!”

“Note to self, never make Pinkie dress up and portray a character who is weird because Pinkie already is and we don’t want her to get even weirder.” You thought and slowly shook your head while looking upwards. Then you look downwards to see the condom was already placed on your dick and your pants was lowered already. "Wait a minute, since when did I undo my pants and how did Pinkie placed the condom on my dick without me- Never mind, I do not wish to know."

Without another word Pinkie aligned your head with her dripping sex while you still carry her. You now slowly inserted your shaft into the party girl and due to how horny she is, her insides were wet enough that you easily pushed it in until it hit her cervix. Pinkie gasped as you patiently waited for her go signal and with a simple nod while giving you her bedroom eyes you started to pump inside of her.

“Oh yeeaah… that feels good.” Pinkie said while resting her head on your shoulder.

Her insides then begin to tighten making you grunt as you begin to go a little faster but still not to go overboard. You can smell the aroma coming from her hair as you nuzzle on it which Pinkie felt you smelling it. You see from Pinkie’s shoulder that Rarity is starting to get jealous as she begins to pleasure herself while watching you do this to her friend. You can feel her breath through your ear as her head is resting on your shoulder.

"You know what will be more fun than just having sex?" Pinkie asked which you just shake your head. "Eating at the same time!"

Pinkie pulls out from her hair which looks like a cylinder like cookie that was dipped in chocolate as she placed half of it between her teeth. She moves her head a bit forward gesturing you to take it form her. As you got the other end of the cookie between your teeth, Pinkie grabbed your head and pulled you in until your lips are firmly pressed to hers as the two of you tasted the cookie which is also a wafer. Funny on how Pinkie prefer to do food play with her boyfriend as you separate your mouth from hers. Then you feel your nether regions tingling meaning only one thing.

“Pinkie!” You get her attention.

“Are you going to cum?” Pinkie asked. “Well go on big boy, LET ME HAVE IT!”

With one thrust you came inside of Pinkie as she arch her back and screamed at the same time when lightning struck outside and thunder rumbling, startling all of you. After staying there like that for a while as she savors the moment, you pull out of her and lay Pinkie on the bed as you remove the condom and checked if there are any tears and lucky you there weren't.

“Uh, why are you eating Pinkie’s hair?” Sunset asked.

Out of curiosity you realize that you are biting Pinkie’s hair as you immediately spat it out and apologize since her hair smelled like cotton candy.

“I feel so much better now. As a thanks I’ll give you this.” Pinkie reached into her hair and pulled out a pack which looked like…”Ta-da! Rainbow colored marshmallows. Just a thing for you to enjoy with your little marshmallow, get it huh?”

“Oh Pinkie.” You and Rarity said inside your heads after that pun of hers.

You then feel someone tugging at your shirt and you see it’s Fluttershy who wants to go next. She said she already took a pill wanted to be on top as you got onto the bed as she positioned herself on top of your lap.

“If it feels uncomfortable just tell me, you don’t have to force yourself.”

“I-Its alright we all know that you are the gentle type when you do it with Rarity.” Fluttershy stutter as she removed her panties. “Besides, the only way to finish a vampire is...with a wooden stick.”

Its either you are dumb that she is dressed up and pretending to be a vampire and taking it literally or its a sex joke. Fluttershy giggled as she pointed downwards to your member which you know that its the sex joke she is referring to.

“Well, here goes…” Fluttershy begins to take you inside of her. Her eyes were shut tight as you were finally inside of her. Since she is the most sensitive one of all the girls, you just remained in your position.

“Are you sure you’re okay?” You asked now concerned that she is still trying to endure it. After opening her eyes, tears started to form.

“I-It’s fine. This happened when it was my first time and my boyfriend was kind enough to wait until I got used to it.”

After one deep breath, Fluttershy slowly lifts herself then lowers back down and slowly repeats the process. You just remain there and let her do the moving. The strap supporting her black dress comes undone as her chest becomes exposed to you. Fluttershy did have the largest chest size of the group as you looked away. To your surprise the shy girl grabbed your head and pulled you in as your face is now smothered between them.

“Could you also play with them, also to s-suck on my nipples? I-I’ll easily cum if you do that at the same time.”

You thought that she normally does this routine with her boyfriend as you are being smothered between her chest. You reached out and grabbed one of her melons and started massaging it. You looked up and she seemed okay with it as you placed your mouth on the other on her areola as you began sucking it. You can feel how hard her nipple is in your mouth as you swirl your tongue around it while still sucking at the same time. You then switch to the other and alternately doing both, even sucking both at the same time.

"Oh my! Yes, y-yes just like that."

Fluttershy then tugs to your hair a little harder and her moans start to grow louder on the amount of pleasure she is receiving. After removing your mouth now that her nipple is all wet, you feel yourself twitching inside of her.

“Fluttershy.”

“Go on, please do it. I-I’m almost there, I-” Before she could finish she ended up biting your neck.

"Ooowwwwww!"

You end up screaming and arching your back and release your load inside as Fluttershy squeals in the process as she sprays all over your crotch. When afterglow hits, the one riding fell on top of you with your face buried again on her tits.

“I’m so sorry, I forgot that I was wearing these.” Fluttershy apologizes as she reaches inside her mouth and pulls out a set of teeth with vampire fangs. She slowly got up as you support her... “Oh no, there is a little blood coming out. Wait a moment.”

Fluttershy went to get her bag at the corner of the room with the others. You placed your hand on the part where she bit you and you see droplets of blood on your hand. She then came back and after cleaning the excess blood, she covered the bite mark with a band aid.

“A-Again I am so sorry for biting you. I-It just felt so good that I had to suppress my moans because it's very embarrassing.”

“‘It’s fine, don’t worry. Are you feeling better though?”

“Yes, and it’s all thanks to you.”

Fluttershy yawned as she lay down on the bed to rest for a while. That is two girls down and the next one should be…

“HELP!”

You quickly looked to your girlfriend on why she needs help only for you to stare with your mouth open. Rarity and Applejack have been best friends since childhood. Right now, you see the farm girl who lowered the hood of her costume showing her blonde hair is on top straddling your girlfriend with her hands pinned and Rarity can’t even escape and her flailing was only minimal because her lower half is covered with her tail costume.

“Darling, don’t just stand and help me please!” Rarity calls out to you, snapping you out from whatever you are thinking. “Applejack, stop that!”

“Ah’m sorry Rares.” Applejack said as she sucked on her friend’s neck.

She then lowers herself and nuzzles herself on Rarity’s chest. Then using her teeth, she pulls down Rarity’s bra leaving her breasts exposed to the cold of the night. The cowgirl begins to suck on one of her friend’s nipples.

“Applejack.” Rarity begs her friend to stop as she still struggles to break free but still proven useless for her friend's grip. Applejack then moves her head back up to Rarity’s face again…“Wait do-mmmmmph.” Rarity could finish as AJ pressed her lips on her friend, starting to make out with your girlfriend.

While Applejack is occupied with Rarity, what she didn’t realize is that you are standing next to them and with one swing you slapped (more like a pat) her ass. This cowgirl shot her head up, separating her kiss from your girlfriend and looking at you with a surprise and angry look.

“Did ya’ll just slap mah ass?” Applejack asked.

“Uhh...bad kitty?” You said.

While Applejack is focused on you and busy processing what you said, her grip loosens which gives Rarity a chance for payback. She quickly snagged her friend’s geode which became unnoticed at the farm girl as she tried to get it back only for hands to be shackled by diamond like handcuffs.

“Rarity, get this darn thing off me!” Applejack demands. "And hand over mah geode back."

“Uh uh uh.” Rarity said as she sat up, moving her right index finger back and forth while holding her friend’s geode in the other hand. “I will return this to you later. Now, you have been a very bad kitty and bad kitties need to be disciplined.”

Applejack couldn't believe what she just heard. She thought about this thoroughly but after what she did, AJ sighs and played along as you carried your girlfriend back to her seat again.

You went back to Applejack who is still sitting on her knees, not after Rarity whispering something in your ear.

“Don’t worry even though Rarity said to punish you, I will still be gentle.”

“No wonder why mah best friend fell for you, you’re a gentleman.”

You instructed the cowgirl to lay on her stomach as she rested her head on her arms. Before you could start, Rarity called out to both of you first and snapped her fingers, releasing her friend from her diamond cuffs then gave you the signal to proceed. You then placed your left hand on her back preventing her from getting up and gave her ass cheek a pat but a little harder.

“Yer call that a slap. Ah know ya’ll can do better than, do it harder.” Applejack commanded.

You comply and instead of your palm only, you can feel parts of her rear with your fingers upon slapping it. She groans but enjoys this as you take moments then slap her ass again. All of this didn’t feel right, so you’ve thought of something better. You raised both hands and when AJ expected a double slap, you grabbed both of her ass cheeks making her gasp and looked back at where your hands were. You begin to grope her rear making it into a massage as the farm girl begins to relax and groan in pleasure as she moves her bottom back and forth synchronizing with your hand movements.

“Oh yes, that’s the stuff.” Applejack closes her eyes, enjoying the moment. She then slams her paw covered hands, getting your attention. “Ah, can’t take it any longer. Sugarcube hurry up and put it in!” She raised her bottom where the crutch point is already damp.

"I have this funny idea." You said getting Applejack's attention as you removed your hands from her buns. "Since we have Rainbow Dash here dress up as Daring Do, how about we do lion tamer." Rainbow raised her head hearing this as a smile grew on her face what your suggesting. " So how about we unite Rainbow over here then let her borrow the chair my girlfriend is sitting on-"

Applejack cut you off as she moved her face now inches near yours giving you an angry face with her eyes squinted. You can easily tell that expression says 'don't even think about it finishing your sentence' as you puck your lips to avoid saying anything else.

"Yeah, she did that to me last time after I helped her out with finishing the set for the play," Rainbow said.

"Because you read my damn diary ya idiot!" Applejack yelled. "Don't yer know that is private property?!"

"Really?" You and Rarity said in unison.

Rainbow Dash just rolled her eyes as she lay there on the floor for a moment then resume with untangling the whip wrapped around her. You and Applejack resumed with where you left off. Before starting you first look at Rarity to see she is busy with her fingernails using a nail file. You doubt that she got used to this because earlier she felt left out as you positioned yourself behind her best friend. You moved part of her costume as you aligned your member at her entrance and you slowly pushed your way inside of her. After a few more pushes you are now completely in as the farm girl shudders.

“A-Alright sugarcube, ya’ll can start now.” Applejack gives you the go signal.

You start to move inside of her as she continues to lay there. To make her enjoy this more, you moved your hand to the spot where her clit is but it's covered due to the costume and rubbed it which actually worked. Applejack started to moan a little louder with her eyes rolled upwards. You moved your hand again and started feeling her sides then moved it to her chest as you massaged it a little. Even though the fabric is in the way, you can feel her hard nipples underneath her costume.

"Ah'm sorry if Ah have to do this." Applejack then pushes herself back. Every time you pushed forward, she pushes herself back wanting for you to go deeper into her.

Granting her wish and wanting to disciple her a little more for the roleplay, you grabbed both of her wrists as you continue to pump inside of her with her cannot escaping for the ecstasy she is getting.

“Keep goin, Ah’m very close!” Applejack said making you go a little faster.

“Not for long.” You warned releasing your grip on her wrists and now hugging her from behind with her chest pinned between your arms.

After a few more thrusts and without holding it in much longer, you came inside of her as her head shot up. You pulled out of her and saw a small amount of your cum leaking from her as she rolled onto her back heavily breathing still with her eyes rolled up.

Another lightning has struck again and the sound of thunder is louder than last time scaring all of you.

“That was scarier than before.” You said then looked back at AJ who is now sitting up. “Hope I didn’t go too rough on you with the disciplining, feeling better?”

“Don’t yer worry partner, I do deserve that after what Ah did to Rarity.” Applejack turns her attention to Rarity who nods giving her a warm smile meaning everything is good between them. “Feelin a lot better now, much obliged partner.”

With three down, three more to go.