Sprout quivered as Hitch stared at him expectantly.

"You're... Serious..." The red stallion said, not able to hide the shock from his voice, and Hitch took a single step towards him.

"I'm not going to make you do anything against your will, Deputy. But if you really don't want to do this, then I'm afraid I'll have to send you packing, with a very detailed report on what the final straw was," Hitch warned, causing Sprout to wince. "But with what I've been able to gather, at least a part of your mind wants this. Thanks to you and your thinking that you'd actually get away with what you were doing, part of me is curious, as you can plainly see."

Sprout felt a wave of heat flush through his face as his gaze shot between Hitch's hind legs for barely a moment, and it was enough for Hitch to notice, who smirked.

"So, what is it going to be? Don't make me tell you a third time," Hitch told him.

Sprout shuddered again as he felt his shaft stiffen up again. He took a deep, quiet breath, as he turned around to face the bed, and slowly stepped toward it, putting his front hooves up on the mattress. He heard Hitch leave the cell for a moment, going over to the front door, and sliding the deadbolt into place, before returning to the cell, and popped the lid open on the bottle of lube. He resisted the urge to jump as he felt his tail get pulled up, and felt the cold goop get gently pushed against his sphincter by the tip of Hitch's hoof. His ears folded back, but his erection got harder still between his belly and the mattress.

Sprout heard the sheriff apply more to himself, before he tossed the bottle next to his deputy on the bed. He heard the bed frame creak as Hitch's weight was partially added to the bed. He took a breath as he felt Hitch's tip press against his hole.

"Alright, I've never done this before, but do your best to relax. I'm sure it'll go in easier that way, and trust me, at this point, it's going in," Hitch told him.

Sprout took another deep breath, and did his best to relax as many muscles as he could. He felt Hitch's tip slowly push into him, and by reflex he tensed up and took in a gasping breath. Hitch was gracious enough to pause, and let his deputy get used to the new intrusion. When his breathing slowed, and he felt him relax again, he resumed pushing, and another inch went in. That was as far as he got as the smaller pony tensed up again, but this time, he made a sound, as Hitch's tip brushed against his prostate.

"Ahhh..." Sprout let out a moan after his initial gasp, as he felt his own erection twitch at his prostate was stimulated.

Hitch, however, hadn't given any kind of reaction yet. He merely waited for Sprout to relax again, then continued forward. This continued for about a minute and a half, then the final inch slid in a little easier than the rest of it, and Sprout felt his stomach bulge forward to make room, as well as Hitch's medial ring sliding against his prostate, and his brain was nearly overwhelmed.

Now, Hitch couldn't help but react as he felt his balls come to a rest against Sprout's.

"Wow... You're certainly tight... And warm, Deputy," Hitch complimented. "Keep breathing, because here I go."

He felt Hitch pull back, and it felt like he was relieving himself, but then he gently thrust back in, and his prostate was assaulted again, and he let out a cry of pleasure.

"Try your best to keep quiet, it's getting late, you know," Hitch told him, pulling out again.

As Hitch slowly got into a gentle rhythm, Sprout fought through the pleasure induced stupor, and reached forward to grab the pillow that was at the head of the mattress. Because if Hitch thought he'd be able to be quiet, he had another thing coming. But he would do what he could to muffle himself, pulling the pillow towards him, and sunk his face into it as his superior continued to take him from behind.

Hearing Sprout pleasurably moan and cry into the pillow was just... So hot, and in response, Hitch's pace got faster.

His prostate being continually stimulated, Sprout risked lifting his head up from the pillow to take a breath as he felt himself begin to spurt out onto his belly and sheets.

"Ahhh... Hiiitch...!"

Hearing his name called like that was almost too much, but the sheriff held on for one more go.

"Alright, hope you're ready for one serious rutting...!" Hitch warned on the next pullout, before slamming back in, and doubling his pace as he began to fervently fuck his deputy.

Sprout had to shove his face into the pillow once again, his cries crescendoing every time Hitch slammed into him.

It's not like Hitch had never clopped off before, but this sensation was something different, and he could only guess it was because of how tight Sprout's hindquarters were gripping his shaft.

"Ahh! Here it comes, Sprout!" Hitch cried, before slamming in one last time and holding himself there, before feeling himself erupt into the red stallion. Sprout let out an elongated cry, his eyes rolling up into his head. The assault on his prostate had emptied himself out, only to be filled up with Hitch's hot seed. He felt nearly ready to burst as the sheriff's shots finally began to die down to short spurts, and he heard him give out a long, sighing breath.

Once he was confident he would be able to stand on his own power, Hitch slowly pulled out, and admired his work, as Sprout was slumped over the bed. He decided to help out, shoving his back half up onto the mattress before he started to leak out the back.

"Alright, I think you can spend the night here to avoid any embarrassment walking home. I'm pretty sure I've figured out how you'll be useful if I keep you on, deputy. I expect this bedding to be down in the laundry room by the time I get in tomorrow morning, clear?" Hitch asked.

Still gasping and breathless, Sprout merely nodded as he slowly curled up into the sheets that were becoming more wet and sticky as Hitch's deposit began to seep out of him.

Hitch grabbed the bottle of lube from the mattress and left the cell, nearly closing it all the way but leaving it unlocked. After tossing the lube into his bottom desk drawer, he headed for the front door when he made sure he was completely sheathed. Unlatching the front door, he opened it and stepped out onto the street, where all the street lamps were on and the sun was now completely over the horizon. After turning to lock up, he turned to the street and saw Phyllis come up.

"Good evening, Sheriff Hitch. I was wondering where Sprout was," she greeted.

"Evening, Mrs. Cloverleaf. Sprout is taking the overnight shift tonight. Part of the deal he made to stay on the force," Hitch replied.

"Oh, so you're actually considering keeping him on? How kind of you, Sheriff."

"I won't mince words, Phyllis. I'm gonna be riding his ass to mold him into a better deputy, but if he has it in him, he'll come through it."

Phyllis gave him a gentle smile.

"Well, I'll pardon your Fancy, Sheriff. But feel free to ride it all you need to, if you feel that's what he needs."

"Rest assured, ma'am, I'll be doing just that."

Author's Note

Well, that's that. I hope you all enjoyed.

As always, thanks for reading!