Author's Note

So, so, SO sorry I posted this late. But it was supposed to be on Halloween, but my drive has been less active lately and I'm trying to get back on track, so I hope you'll forgive me. Anyways, Happy Birthday to Carlosesunbrony, his birthday is on March 24th, you guys.

And as always, thank you to all my fans for all of your patience and support. Be sure to stay tuned for more chapters and stories to come in the future and remember to keep on bronying on.

A Spooktacular Night Part 1

3 and a half years. 3 and a half glorious years was all it took to turn your life into a happy beginning from a lone human being stuck in Equestria to a happily married man with 3 mare wives and 3 healthy children, 2 daughters and 1 son. The years have been good to you and your family and things were only getting better as Nightmare Night was coming around the corner and you couldn't wait. Especially since Rarity went and designed all kinds of costumes for herself, the rest of your wives for the holiday.

She even took the liberty of making some outfits for the kids. You dressed up as Connor Kenway from Assassin's Creed, the same costume you wore when you visited Bronycon.

Rarity designed herself a sexy vampire empress outfit, with a stylish purple cape and matching colored corset underneath that would most likely show off serious boobage. But having her cape on covers up most of her upper body, perfect for whenever the kids are with her. She also had leggings and boots that were almost up to her knees, making her even more sexy for you. And for the icing on the cake, she even had fake vampire teeth and cute bat wings attached to the back of her costume with Sweetie's help.

Starlight's costume, thanks to Rarity's help, was a witch. Her outfit was black and lavender, with a hint of blue in it to bring out her natural colors beautifully. Atop her head, her hat was black and it had a purple stripe at the base of it, cape that's black on the outside and dark purple on the inside. Her coreset was purple with a vertical blue strips down the middle. Her leggings were striped purple and black. And like any good witch, she carries around a broom, which she can use to fly around with.

Octavia's costume was a surprise to everyone, including you. Her costume of choice... was a punk rockstar with the freaky black masquera, lipstick and even her hairstyle was freaky. All wild and feathered out, really showing off the authenticity. Rarity had also stitched up a black shirt with broken white sleeves that left Tavi nearly sleeveless and matching skinny jeans with tears in them. And for more authenticity, she carries around a guitar that Vinyl let her borrow, just to make her costume more believeable.

As for your little boy, Silver Shine, Rarity thought it'd be cute if he was dressed as an assassin similar to your Connor Kenway outfit from back home. While the basic design was similar to your costume, the color was the only thing that was different, with his being silver-ish grey.

Amber Melody was dressed up as a baby version of Countess Colouratura. Well, at least without all the fancy clothes and make-up like when she sang Razzle Dazzle. No, she dressed moreso as Rara when she sang The Magic Inside and Amber looked so cute in her little outfit, it melted your heart. Perhaps in a few years from now, when Amber's fluent in speaking, she'll develope a beautiful voice or a love for music like her mother.

Now, as for Starshine Glimmer, you asked Rarity to design a Rey Skywalker costume for Starshine, which Rarity was kind of confused at first. Luckily, you told her how she looked like and what she wore. The basic design was pretty much easy, so Rarity got it done in just a short amount of time. With a white robe and matching sweats and gold trims, Starshine looked ready to take on the First Order.

At the moment, Nightmare Night was about to begin later on tonight and all of your kids were dressed up and ready for a stroll around Ponyville. You had your costume hanging in the closet while your wives were downstairs, chatting with each other about... something. But you weren't sure what they were talking about because whenever you asked about it, they'd either reply with "Oh, just simple lady talk," or even "nothing important, no need to trouble yourself." They were up to something, but you just didn't have any idea of what it was they were talking about, so you merely focused on other things.

For now, with the babies resting up, you took this opportunity to help decorate the town with the other ponies in Ponyville, as well as setting up games for the young fillies and colts. In the past, you always enjoyed Nightmare Night, especially offering up your share of candy to the mare in the moon. Yes, it was all pretend, but still, even the moon princess needs something to know she's appreciated. In the past, you even openly admitted to her that you enjoyed her night. Luna returned your kindness with a big hug and a great big "HUZZAH," which you found so adorable.

Since then, you've been on good terms with Princess Luna and she would come visit you in your dreams just so she could wind down and relax after dealing with so many ponies' nightmares. One day, Rarity found out about your chats with Luna and asked about it.

You told her how it was just conversations about her dealing with the hardships of countless ponies having nightmares and the stress of raising and lowering the moon. Rarity believed you, understanding how hard it was for the princess of the night every night. It was no surprise that this info eventually reached your other wives, Starlight and Octavia. They were just as understanding as Rarity. It's nice to have wives like them who actually take the time to listen to what you have to say and actually believe you. It was never like this back home where you used to live, but that's all buried in the past now.

And so, night falls and it's time for you to give your kids the best Nightmare Night experience, even if they still can speak or walk yet. You're at the house, getting your kids all straddled in the 3-seat stroller, all of them having their costumes on. You also had your costume on, as did your wives.

"Okay, ladies. Shall we head off?" you asked.

"But of course, although... Anon, would it be alright if you went along without us?" Rarity asked. "It's just that... there's a few things the ladies and I have to do before anything else." And there she goes, being as vague as possible, piquing your curiosity like always.

"Uh... I don't get it, Rares. Why now, of all times? This is supposed to be a special time for all of us to take our kids out, are you sure you want me to go without you?"

"Think of it this way, honey. You can tell stories to the kids while taking them to get some candy. We might run a little late with our last-minute preparations, but don't let it get in the way of you having fun. We'll join you eventually, don't you worry about that." Starlight assured.

"Well, if you say so, I guess," you replied, hesitantly.

"Don't worry, dear. We'll still have plenty of fun before the night is finished. Now go on and show our children a wonderful time tonight." Octavia added. Well, with no other choice and with your wives assuring you they'd show up later on, you took your kids out into town for their very first halloween. Rarity closed the door to the house while you kept walking. You let out a sigh, thinking about nearly everything changed tonight, how this was supposed to be a family thing between you AND your wives and kids.

Then again... there's no point in sulking about it. As long as you and your kids get to have fun, then that's all that matters, so you kept on going and stopped in the middle of town. Every pony in town dressed as something either silly, majestic, or even scary.

You can see all of the games you helped set up, like the bean bag toss games, dunk tank, bobbing for apples, one of AJ's personal favorites and many, many more. To start things off, you walked around town, pushing the stroller while waving to a few of your pony neighbors, wishing them a happy Nightmare Night. Then, along the way, you stopped by a house and knocked on the door. This particular house belonged to Creamy Heart, a good friend of yours and the mother of a young Button Mash.

One look at your kids and instantly, "Awww, aren't they just so cute?" Creamy asked, overcome by how adorable your babies were.

"They sure are. This is their first Nightmare Night." you replied. "I planned on bringing my wives along with me, but for some reason they couldn't come. So, as their only daddy, I'm strolling them along solo, not that I don't mind, my precious little bundles of joy," you cooed, smothering each of your kids. Baby Silver Shine cooed in his little baby voice, smiling happily. Starshine giggle adorably while Amber Melody reached out and grabbed onto your face while sucking on her pacifier.

"Well, I think it's sweet the kids get to spend quality time with daddy." Creamy replied. Soon, she grabs a bowl full of candy and gives a few pieces to each of your kids. "There you go."

Your kids all cooed happily, wiggling their cute little arms and legs around. "Heheh, looks like they like their first treats, thanks a lot, Creamy. And have a Happy Nightmare Night," you said.

"You too, Anon," she replied.

And so, the night continues on as you hit up more houses, getting candy for your kids and saying high to some of your neighbors, striking up chats on how they're doing. Of course, you had a few run-ins with some of the Mane 6, mainly Pinkie Pie, dressed up in her chicken costume, running around and screaming randomly at anything that looks scary. Then there's Rainbow Dash all dressed up in her Shadowbolt costume, pulling pranks on unsuspecting ponies as usual.

She almost pulled a lightning strike prank on you, but when she saw you a baby stroller, she immediately backed off and let you be. She even told you she almost made a bad call. You thanked her for not startling your kids and gave her a fist bump before moving on.

The rest of the night, you kept getting more and more candy for your three bundles of joy, then when the bags were just about filled up past the top, it was time to make a detour. "That's my babies, now... Amber, Silver, Starshine... we're about to head off towards the statue of Nightmare Moon. But don't be scared, because you three are about to save Ponyville," you said to the three babies. Your kids didn't understand what you were saying, they just looked at you with their big eyes and cooing like all babies do.

As you pushed the stroller, you continued on with the story. "Legend has it that Nightmare Moon is supposed to come once a year to accept the offerings of candy as tribute to not gobble up anypony here and that means with your candy, you can save Ponyville!"

The babies still didn't understand you, but you didn't care. Soon, you all made it to the Nightmare Moon statue where a few other fillies and colts were paying tributes to Nightmare Moon. And as an even bigger surprise, Princess Luna was there as well, playing along with the kids. One look at you and she waved you over to her before turning to the young foals. "GO NOW, FOR YOUR OFFERINGS ARE NOW COMPLETE!!!" Luna boomed, but made sure not to be too loud in front of your kids.

The other kids ran off while you walked over to Luna and gave her a hug. "Good to see you, Luna, Happy Nightmare Night, things going alright?" you asked.

"Yes, all is well. And my, what precious little foals you have. I take it they're here to save Ponyville as well from the clutches of Nightmare Moon?" she chuckled with a wink. "They are far braver than I thought if they're paying tributes at such an early age, dear Anon. How old are they?"

"About 6 months." you confirmed.

"Aww, how adorable. And again, my sincerest congratulations on becoming a father. I wish you a long, happy life with your loving family. OH! One more thing," Luna then gestured you to come closer to her. You did so and heard her whisper. "Your wives said for you to come back to the house. They said something about having some sort of... special surprise for you."

"My wives?" you asked before realizing, "Hmm... now that you mention it, they have been missing for nearly 2 hours, so I'll go and see what's up. Thanks for letting me know, princess."

"Please, thou may call me by Luna," the precious moonbutt corrected with a slight blush. And so, after giving some candy offerings to "Nightmare Moon," you took the kids with you back down the path towards the house to meet up with your three, loving wives. You had to find out just exactly what is going on and why they nearly missed out on Nightmare Night of all times, especially with their own kids.

"Don't lose your head over this, Anon. I'm sure they've got some sort of reason for not wanting to join us, so just take the kids home... put them in their rooms... and sit down and talk things out," you told yourself as your house was coming quickly coming into view.

Once you arrive, you open the door and see Rarity, Starlight and Octavia all sitting comfortably on the couch, still dressed up in their beautiful costumes. "Darling, you're home! So glad you could make it, did you and the kids have lots of fun?" Rarity asked, turning her attention to the kids with buckets full of candy, their eyes looking heavy like they're ready to head off to bed.

"Yeah, but still... it would've been great if you three were with us," you replied calmly.

"I know, darling and I'm sorry. Look, how about I put our children to bed and then we'll explain why we had to miss out on the holiday as a whole family," Rarity replied.

You nodded. "I'd like that."

Rarity then took the babies out of the strollers using her magic and wrapped her arms around all three before heading upstairs into the babies' bedroom. She comes out five minutes later. "Apologies, I had to get the kids into their pajamas and change their diapers." she said.

"That's fine. Now, what's the reason you ladies chose to sit out on such a special holiday? You're all dressed up, yet the kids are already wiped out." you pointed out.

"And for a good reason. You see, honey..." Starlight paused before clapping her hands twice above her head, confusing you for a second. Next thing that happens is the sound of multiple hoof steps coming from the kitchen and making their way into the living room. You turn quickly and notice some other guests you recognized immediately, feeling a smile form on your face.

From the kitchen entrance, you saw Sweetie Belle, dressed up as a sexy she-devil. Her costume was red with black leggings and elbow-length gloves. Next was Trixie, who dressed up as a witch, just like Starlight, looking like they're witch sisters. Then there was Luna, who dressed up as Nightmare Moon.

"You see, darling... the girls and I have gotten to talking and lately, they've heard about how happy you've made nearly everypony here in Equestria. While, they are aware you already have 3 wives as it is, but nothing would make them happier than to be a part of your big family. If you agree, we'll have to expand the house or even get an even bigger one, which could take time." Rarity explained.

"And if you decline... well, we fully understand and allow you to carry on," Luna added. But all too quickly, you rushed at the girls and hugged Luna, making her gasp in surprise.

You gave a soft laugh and looked into the eyes of the lunar princess. "I've always did like you girls in a romantic way, though I wasn't sure if you felt the same way about me. But now that I know... you bet your cutie marks that I'd be MORE than happy to welcome you girls into the family!" you confessed. The others stared at you with glee and sparkling eyes of joy.

"Hooray! Trixie's gonna be a bride!" Trixie cheered in third person.

"Woo-hoo! This'll be fun! I'm sharing a husband with my sister!" Sweetie cheered adorably. You turned to the younger marshmallow sister and hugged her, making her giggle. She surprises you with a flurry of kisses on your cheeks and then a long one on your lips. You smooched her back and then turned to Trixie, who threw herself into your arms. You hugged her and planted a smooch on her soft lips. Then, you went back to Luna whom you embraced in a big hug and a long, passionate kiss. It felt so good, her beautiful wings stiffened and spreaded out like a pair of wing boners.

"Wonderful, now that our husband has given the approval, I believe it's time we got down to what is truly important now... and I believe you all know what I mean," Rarity winked.

Right away, all the girls gathered you in the middle of the living room and soon, you feel each of these lovely mares press their sexy costumed bodies against you. Rarity, like the hot vampiress, began sucking on your neck, making you shiver in pure pleasure. Trixie and Starlight went down on their knees and undid your pants and boxers, revealing your stiffening cock to them. Starlight's eyes went half-lidded as she recalls the times when you destroyed her pussy numerous times and giving you two a daughter.

Trixie was astonished by how big your thing was. She even felt a tad nervous about whether or not you can fit inside her tight little pussy later on. But for now, her biggest concern... is whether or not her bosom is big enough to please you.

Speaking of which, Starlight undid part of her costume, exposing her big bosom, along with Trixie, earning a thirsty look from your glimmering wife. "Wow, Trixie. I had no idea your boobs were as big as mine, they sure do look really lovely." Starlight called out. Trixie blushed at hearing her comment. "I'll bet you're wanting to take her big girls for a spin. Isn't that right, honey?" she asks you.

"If you only knew," you replied, wanting to motorboat your face into her big bosom. Both naughty witch cosplayers humored you by trapping your hardened cock into their double boobie trap and teasing your cock with licks and flicks.

You felt your body shivering from how good it felt. Sweetie Belle clinged to your vacant arm and pointed her little toy trident right up against your chin. She leaned against you with a sultry stare you found both cute and sexy, it'd drive you nuts. "You have been such a bad boy, Anon. All these mares wrapped around your finger without a care in all of Equestria. Someone needs to punish you," Sweetie teased before sucking on the other side of your neck, making you moan a big louder.

But the fun doesn't stop there. Tavi surprises you by pressing her exposed boobs against your back and wraps her arms around your neck from behind, leaving a trail of kisses on your cheek.

AND for the icing on the cake, Luna approaches you from the front and... BOO-YAH, she's got your face trapped in her soft boobie trap and is smothering you with some serious boobage. Her breasts look like they're a pair of small moons you can barely hold in the palm of your hands. Your mind lit up like the 4th of July, having 6 hot mares service you and 3 of them wanting to be part of your herd.

You got some soft melons around your hot dog, a she-devil and a vampiress sucking on each side of your neck, a mammary attack from the front and you're moon-boob motorboating in the front. You hear the girls giggles and moaning softly from your reactions.

The girls continue to service you the same way for another 5 minutes until finally. "Ladies..." Tavi addressed, making all the mares stop what they're doing. "...What do you say we go... au natural, strip our man down and lay him on the floor and get a better feel of him?" she suggested. The other ladies seemed to like the idea a lot and so, with a little help from Luna's magic, you were stripped out of your entire costume, displaying your butt-naked body along with your future waifu 6.

Now that you're all butt-naked, you're then laid on the ground by your wives and now... the real fun begins as Starlight and Trixie move up to your pecs and begin playing with them, flicking their tongues against your manly nipples, sucking on them so tenderly.

Goosebumps formed all over your body. 'I take it back! THIS is true heaven!' you thought. Next, Rarity and Sweetie Belle both went down to where your cock was. You could see Rarity working her tongue on the tip of your manly sausage while Sweetie's getting a good taste of your meatballs. You could see and feel the younger marshmallow cutie sucking on your massive ballsack hard. 'FREAKING HELL, THIS FEEL SO GOOD!' you screamed inside your head with joy.

It gets even better as Tavi gives your neck some tongue action while Luna gets cute with you, nuzzling her cheek against yours before smooching you lovingly.

Her warm, soft lips pressed against yours, her big bosom resting against your shoulder, it all felt like a dream... except it was no dream. This... this was really happening. THIS is your reality. You love it so much, you wrapped one arm around the moon princess, caressing her beautiful wings. Luna moans beautifully as she kept her lips locked with yours, not minding your soft, tender touch. Your other arm wraps around Tavi and now she's lubing up your neck way more with her skilled, talented tongue.

Starlight and Trixie kept on licking your nipples while circling their fingers around your well-toned chest and impressive 6 pack like you're a big man candy.

Back with the two marshmallow mares down below, Rarity removed her mouth from your beefy sausage and gave your grapefruit-sized balls some extra love. Sweetie Belle took her chance to finally stake her claim on your hard meat pole. She sucks on it hard and bobs her head up and down. Her eyes shoot into the back of her head from how tasty you were. Her tongue swirled around your dick like it were some thick lolipop, add that with some sultry, thirsty growls and hums and you're tingling all over.

Because of the two sisters giving your cock some attention, it got the others a little jealous. Especially Luna, since she never got to taste you yet.

Eventually, you felt most of the girls stop, save for the two servicing your dick. You look up and can tell all these other girls want a taste of your yummy meatsicle. "Hey, what's wrong, girls? Let me guess, do you wanna have a shot at it yourselves?" you asked. Asking them made them turn to you for a second.

"Was it that obvious?" Luna asked, blushing and avoiding eye contact. The other girls reacted in a similar way with Tavi avoiding eye contact and nodding, Starlight blushing and licking her lips and Trixie blushed while winking right at you.

"Hey, no worries, I think I got a solution. Of course, it may require you girls having to take turns, so... here's how it should go down for you girls; Luna, why don't you lay down right in front of the couch and, uh... Rarity, Starlight, Trixie, you three sit on the couch... with your cute flanks facing towards me. Sweetie, Octavia, I would like you two give praise to de Moonbutt and I really mean... show Luna some much-needed love." you instructed in a sultry tone that got pretty much all the mares in the room... wet.

They all did as instructed and now Sweetie was sucking on some moon boobs while Tavi was making sweet music with Luna by tasting her majestic alicorn nethers. You position your still-hardened cock above Luna and sink it down onto her.

She opens her mouth and takes in nearly all of your cock. Her mouth felt so warm around your cock that you immediately begin humping downwards, fucking Luna's royal throat. At the same time, you leaned forwards and licked and slurped Rarity's tasty unicorn cooch. You also got in some finger action with the two naked witch cosplayers, Starlight and Trixie. Your fingers pumped in and out, making the two moan together, clenching the couch like their lives depended on it.

The sheer pleasure you felt right now was completely out of this world. Your hips moved on their own, Luna gagging on your hot, stiff meat pillar, but didn't have a care in the world. You could feel your balls slapping against her chin repeatedly.

You then plunge your face into Rarity's cooch and eat up her womanhood. She jolted with a pretty yelp and let out a small climax on your face just because it felt so good. Then afterwards, your two fingers plunged deep inside the naked witches love caverns, exploring every nook and cranny. Starlight and Trixie's juices leaked like crazy and neither cutie could get enough of your skilled hands. Sadly, the fun couldn't last long with your balls tensing up and ready to shoot your first massive load of the night.

"C...Cumming! I'm... I'm cumming!!!" you warned. Just then, Luna stopped you with her magic and then used it again to teleport you sitting on the couch and all the girls sitting at your feet while the moon princess jerks you off with her magic.

"Cum for us, oh handsome groom-to-be! Spread thy sticky love juice all over your additional sex slaves, for we crave your tasty seed!" Luna urged in a sultry growl. Suddenly, Trixie, Starlight, Rarity and Sweetie Belle all jerked your stick with their magic, coating your dick in multiple aura until suddenly, you let out a satisfied grunt, shooting all your hot, manly milk all over your lovers' faces and bodies. Their mouths all opened wide and let your cum fall onto their tongues and into their mouths, drinking it up.

You leaned back against the couch, panting and trying to catch your breath. 'Jeez! It was only a little foreplay and already, these girls have wiped me out! I must be outta shape in the sex category!' you thought, staring up at the ceiling, your breath becoming steady again.

Looking down, you see the girls cleaning themselves up by licking your hot seed off of their own bodies and each others, getting you all nice and hard. It's gonna take a while before all the girls are cleaned up nicely and ready to continue, so you laid back against the couch with a sigh of relief. You close your eyes to the sound of the sweet, sexy moans these mares give off as they're cleaning up so good. And while they're licking themselves clean, you start to reminisce about how you wound up in Equestria.

At first, you were shocked to find out that you wound up in your dream place and wound up in a relationship with the most beautiful unicorn mare in Ponyville.

To think that you came here by chance and it was all thanks to Queen Galaxia. If only you could tell her in person, or even in your dreams how grateful you are to her for giving you this second chance at life and all because you risked your life to save some cosplayers back at Bronycon in your previous homeland. Sure, you miss your family, but you hope they're pulling through okay without you.

By the time a minute rolls by, you open up your eyes to look away from the ceiling and find the girls all looking at you, some with sultry smiles and others with cutesy smiles. "Yes girls?" you grinned.

"Anon, deary," Octavia started. "How do you feel about... a private dance show? This way, you'll be more than riled up and ready to take us all no problem. I'm sure I speak for all of us that you'd love a good dance from your soon-to-be six wives." she explained. Just then, your heart skipped a beat and you gave a chuckle and sat up, still keeping that grin on your face.

"Who am I to decline such a sexy offer?" you winked.

"Yay! Naked dance party!" Sweetie cheered adorably. You felt your heart melt and just for the hell of it, you hugged Sweetie Belle and nuzzled her cheek to cheek, making her giggle cutely. For a 21 year old mare, she still knows how to pull off the cuteness so well.

"Now that Sweetie's almost killed Anon with her cuteness, let's get this party started," Starlight Glimmer said as she went towards the record player and put a record before starting the song.

As soon as it began, you sat back and watched as these six lovely mares danced beautifully. Their manes flipping while flaunting their flawless, magical curves.

This was far better than those typical strip clubs back in the real world. Their booties shook to the beat of the music and they even extended out their long, sexy legs. Such flexibility has never turned you on this much since... ever, actually. Sweetie Belle and Rarity made it even more sexy for you by mashing their soft marshmallow boobs together and moving them in parrallel directions against each other left and right, allowing their nipples to graze against each other.

Luna twirled on one hoof while hoisting Octavia in the air like they were in an ice skating competition, Luna's wings spreaded out wide and everything.

Starlight and Trixie made such an AMAZING team. These two mares got up close and personal with you, grinding their naked pussies against your legs while swaying their massive ta-tas against your face, getting you thirsty for some milk. You couldn't resist the urge to touch them, but... Starlight restrained you and waved her finger while grinning at you.

"Naughty boy, you can give it to me good once we finish." Starlight said seductively.

You nodded and felt her let go of your arm and soon all six mares gathered in one circle as they spun around, twerking their big-ass flanks in circular motions. To say you died and gone to heaven is an understatement in itself because this is a living heaven. Oh, how lucky you felt to be in this wonderful world.

Eventually, their dance finished and all of them finished with all of them gathering around you with Rarity, Starlight and Tavi behind the couch.

Rarity was in the middle, Tavi on your left and Starlight on your right. Sweetie and Trixie sat on each side of the couch with you, Sweetie on the left, Trixie on the right. Finally... Luna sat herself down right on your very lap, her beautiful face just inches away from yours, almost about to kiss you. Staring into her half-lidded eyes felt so mesmerizing, you couldn't look away from her.

"Best... dance... ever," you uttered softly.

But the party was far from over... not by a longshot even. And the night was young and these girls were gonna use every waking moment of it to get what they want. And you, too.