Once upon a time, Fluttershy loved Nightmare Night. But then, one year, she got separated from her friends in the crowded rush of Cloudsdale’s trick or treating. That was the last time she went out for Nightmare Night.

So… just what did happen, that year?

She’s never told a soul. But once a year, it all comes flooding back to her.

Cover art by CartoonLion and Tommy Mocacci

CW: NC-17, Foalcon, Musk, Physical violence, Interspecies sex (griffon-on-pegasus), Age difference (grown-griffon-on-filly-pegasus), Hard Core Non-Con, Asphyxiation