A Cozy Nightmare Night

You hesitantly walk by door after shiny, metal door. A very dim light shines against the blue benches, and as you keep going, you remark with a shaky voice, "Th-this seems... pretty s-scary enough..."

The floor is still cold, and slightly damp from the showers, and there's a constant dripping noise that's coming from just around the corner. You breathe through your mouth quietly, and whisper, "Nopony should interrupt us here. The school's closed, and even if somepony came in, we'd definitely hear them coming."

You're inside of the locker rooms that connects to your school's gymnasium. It's dark, and quiet, and as you keep on going, you keep looking all around. "This place looks so different without any lights on," you remark. You're soon right beside your very own locker, and as you open it, your forehead starts to sweat. You can't wait to see Cozy Glow again, and yet, this'll be the last time.

After tonight, you might not ever see her again.

You hold onto it steadily with your aura, and you ask, "Am I really ready to do this...?"

It unwraps, and the glossy ball of enchanted sugar drops loftily onto the soft frog of your hoof. It rolls left, and then it rolls right, but as you bring it up to your lips, you stop momentarily. You quietly gulp, and you feel tense while standing all alone. It's now inches away from your lips, and you say, "It'll be... the last time..."

It goes in, and while it breaks apart almost too easily, you try to fight back a teardrop.

You're perfectly still, and you sense the all too familiar tingling sensation coursing through your entire being. It's an experience unlike any other, and you'll never forget it. You inhale, and exhale slowly, and you look around one more time while patiently awaiting for Cozy Glow to reappear, but for a while, she doesn't.

You glance, and double check the area again, and you even make a circle going around the tinier island of lockers, but she's nowhere to be found.

You're soon trembling because you have no idea what could've gone wrong. For about a minute or so, you just stare at your locker which still remained open, and eventually, you sigh sadly.

"Oh, no... Cozy Glow... Where are you? I thought... you'd be here by now."

"Freeze, Mister!" A familiar and sweet yet authoritative voice echoes from behind. You slowly turn, and you then hear Cozy Glow commanding you to, "Stay where you are, you criminal degenerate!"

You're light as a feather whenever you're in her presence. For now, all you can see are those scarlet eyes of hers. You can also spot her nice smile, and as she comes closer towards you so that you can see her outfit, you release a breath of sheer relief. "I was... really worried you wouldn't show up."

She's wearing a police officer's cap as well as a cute and petite cop uniform minus the trousers. The badge that's found right next to her heart twinkles with her every movement, and she asks you, "Miss me?"

The air around you and Cozy Glow becomes heavy, and dense. You merely nod.

Again, she's asking you, "Mister...? Do you... D-do you like me?"

Your mouth drops after hearing this. All you're able to do for a long time is stare, and slightly tremble. "I..." You feel confused by this question. "Of course I do," you tell her. "I wish... that I could see you more often... I wish... that you didn't have to go..."

She smirks at that, and assures you, "I wish that I didn't have to leave you either, but... unfortunately, that's just how the spell works." She lightly giggles into your ear as she embraces you with a long hug. When it ends, she says, "At least for now, we have this time together, so let's enjoy it. Alright, Mister?"

You're nodding your head once more, and you're caught within her innocent yet guilty vision. Everything about her tonight is far too alluring, and you kiss her slowly.

You kiss her very, very slowly.

It'll perhaps be the last.

The police officer's hat drops to the floor, and the two of you wander lovingly towards a shiny, nearby bench. Cozy Glow bends over to present you with her swishing tail. You've never really noticed this up until just now, but she's even got a few, tiny, white freckles dotting both of her round openings.

"Go ahead," she says. "I'm completely legal."

You chuckle, and say, "You... are hardly legal."

"I'm legal enough," she counters, and following this, you feel your dick pressing up against her right cheek.

It's warm to the touch.

"Are you... really alright with this?" You ask this filly kindly, "We could do anything you wanted... I'd love to... be with you, of course, Cozy Glow, but... if this isn't what you actually had in mind for tonight..."

She locks her eyes with yours yet again, and somewhat scowls. "I..." The insulted expression melts into concern, and she openly admits something to you.

She lovingly admits this to you.

She forwardly admits, "I want... nothing else but to be with you... just one more time, Mister... I never even want to leave your side ever again." Her left hoof spreads her young cheeks for you. "P-please... Be gentle, though. This is... still very new for me, but I wouldn't give up this feeling for the world."

You're shaking, but still, you press more and more against her until at last, you sink, dip, and slide your way through. Her thighs are thoroughly wrapping around your member, and as you back up only to go sinking further in, you ask Cozy Glow, "I'm going to miss you... so much, Cozy..."

She pants with every thrust.

"Oh, just sh-shut up already... and enjoy yourself... for as long, and as much as you can tonight. I'm... n-not worth crying over, you stupid..." She sniffles, and tries to hold her muzzle. You see a tear escape. "You stupid..."

You're buried completely within her core, and you whisper into her ear, "I know... I'm just a stupid pony that's fallen in love with you... I should've had better judgement with the candy, but curiosity got the better of me... and now, I... I love you, Cozy."

You're once again making perfect eye contact with her now while satiably plowing away. You sigh, and pant with every movement that you make, and you're unable to stop. It just keeps going and going like this for minutes at a time, but Cozy seems to have gone to her happy place. Her tears have stopped for the time being.

You nearly feel out of breath even as you huff a couple of times, and your voice audibly lets Cozy Glow know that you're actually enjoying this just as much as she seems to be. That's when the filly copper pulls you closer with the help of her cosmic magic, and your cock is squeezed vigorously against her lewd walls.

She's moaning along with you, and as you listen to her young, and serene voice, she huffs non-stop against your ear. You keep slamming yourself into her and against her well plowed rump that much more. Your vision blackens slightly, and as the white cream seeps through, it makes a beautiful noise while hitting the metal bench below.

Everything becomes hazy for you, and it's mostly because you've never known of this level of joy, and bliss. This amazing, and yet seemingly unending burst of amusement has forced you to ejaculate, and you toss your head back while the ecstatic feeling washes over your whole, equine body.

She sadly looks back at you from her bench, and says, "I wish I could stay, too, Mister... Please... don't be sad." She flickers momentarily. "I'll never forget you..."

You stare at her with a fairly tired expression, and using your magic, you bring her closer for one final hug.

"Stay with me... just a little bit longer, Cozy... Please..."

She replies, "Golly, Mister... I'll try..."