Late at night, within a huge ass oak tree/library concoction of a building, you, the human lay upon a warm, and soft couch on your left side. You were dressed in nothing but a pair of black underpants. You could hear a nearby fireplace crackling, giving heat into the room. You didn't need much to keep you warm on this slightly cold night, for you were spooning a cute, fluffy purple creature.
Your hands rested upon her upper back, and your head was buried into the silky softness of her mane. Down below, your legs lay against her own, warm and furry legs to keep you warm. The softness of her lavender fur against your bare skin felt incredible. She was a unicorn no less, who had a substantially large backside pressed against your crotch. She was after all, basically a horse. However, her species was more affectionately known as a pony. Her rump was shapely and plump, you didn’t find ponies attractive before coming here in Equestria, but that was quickly changing. Her lovely ass was doing a real number on you.
If you were standing up, she would meet you at near eye level when face to face. She was a few inches shorter than you. You could not help but poke her with your erect cock against her lovely backside. It felt wrong, yet so right. Your penis was awfully confused while it had an erection poking her butt. Or perhaps your mind was confused? Not your penis.
The mare’s tail wagged excitedly back and forth at the feel of your cock poking her rump through your underpants. As a result, her tail came to gently brush against your lower torso, and upper legs during her wagging. The mare happily read a brown, leather-bound book as you spooned her from behind.
You were somewhat disturbed from the sight of her tail wagging back and forth. You were reminded of a feral equine back home from Earth. They were unclean and ugly-looking. But nonetheless, you continued to spoon this nice mare. She wore glasses to make you at ease whilst she read to show her intelligence. You were spooning an intellectual creature with a sapient mind like your own. A tool-building species. Unlike the equines back home, she did not shit on the floor. In fact, she was cleaner in you than in some ways. She used magic to clean her body in addition to using a bathroom. She smelled of wonderful lavender perfume to put you even further at ease.
This mare was known as Twilight Sparkle. A cute nerd horse you could not help but fall in love with. If you were going to cross the species barrier, you were going to cross it with a high-class intellectual pony. Not some dirty peasant farmer Earth Pony. You were going to fuck the upper-class unicorn elite.
Granted, Applejack was a nice mare, but she stung to the high heavens sometimes. You once had the displeasure of visiting her while she was at work. You got a terrible whiff of sweat from the hard-working farmer. You were thankful that she was civilized like other ponies. She too, like other ponies here cleaned herself and didn’t just shit on the ground.
“Anon, are you ready to move on to the next stage of our friendship lesson?” she asked in a wonderful, sweet voice.
“Can we… just cuddle and… err… maybe kiss for a little first?” you asked in a low nervous tone.
Twilight scooted herself away from you, bringing her wonderful backside away from your member poking it. Before she subsequently rolled herself over to face you. You were face to face with a pair of big purple eyes looking at you. Her beautiful eyes glowed in the dark like that of a cat’s.
Those big eyes of hers were far more expressive and intelligent looking than the equines back home on Earth. Those glasses she wore made her seem even more intelligent. They were forward-facing predator eyes rather than sideways facing like prey eyes. However, they were somewhat comically large, nearly on par with basketballs. Her face in general was far more expressive than that of a horse. It was almost as if she was crossed with a human and equine in some ways. Her snout was far smaller, and cuter looking than a horse’s one.
Shortly after she turned to face you, the mare placed her soft, spongy feeling hooves on your shoulders, and then leaned her head into your neck and began to affectionately nuzzle you. The mare uttered happy low whinnies, and other feral horsey sounds. Your body trembled at the feeling, both from the pleasure and the creepiness of hearing neighs, and other horsey sounds from her. It felt as if you were not in the presence of an intelligent equine any longer.
Twilight soon came to an abrupt stop and pulled her head back to look at you in concern. You were in a state of shock, the intelligent mare you fell in love with was gone, replaced with a dumb, ugly pony from Earth with horrid small eyes, and an unexpressive horsey face with a protruding snout.
“Anon, are you okay? It’s me, Twilight Sparkle. I’m not a pony from your world in what you describe in your own words as, ‘a dumb dirty horse that does not wash and shits on the ground’”. As she spoke, her big horsey lips flopped about vigorously. You said nothing in response. You could not find anything to say back.
You sighed in relief when the horrid vision of Twilight being a dumb horse from Earth vanished away. She was back to being the mare you loved, Twilight Sparkle. The mare stared at you with a look of concern on her face, her big purple eyes stared into your own, far smaller human eyes.
“Twilight… can we just cuddle tonight? I’m not sure about having sex. I just saw you as a horse from back home. I know that’s not you. I hate that I saw such a thing.”
“Oh… you don’t think I’m ugly, do you?” she said in a worried tone, her ears drooping sadly.
“No! God no! Twilight… I-I--” the sight of seeing Twilight’s eyes beginning to tear up broke you.
So, with that, you immediately stopped being a hesitant pussy, and brought your lips to hers, and kissed her. Twilight made low, muffled horsey sounds as you kissed her, but you didn’t care. To top it all off, you brought both of your hands and lay them on her backside, and took a tight grip. Your hands sank into the plush softness of her plump rump like that of memory foam, before meeting her strong and firm muscles underneath.
Twilight’s long and thick equine tongue came into your mouth and began to swirl about, joining alongside yours in a tender dance of intimacy between a human and a pony. Your kiss felt like it went on for an eternity before it finally ended. When you pulled apart, there was a bridge of saliva connecting your departing lips. The mare looked at you with a big happy smile on her face. You looked at her with a smile of your own.
“Anon, I hope you won’t be creeped out. But I whinny like a banshee during sex. Is that okay? You won’t be disturbed by my horsey sounds, will you?” she said in a worried tone, her ears drooping sadly.
“Twilight, you can make all the horsey sounds you want. For I know, those sounds are coming from you. A sexy and intelligent pony,” you said softly, reaching to gently stroke the back of her ear with your right hand.
“Neeiiigghh!” she whinnied happily. You weren't disturbed by it. You're going to quit being a pussy and fuck a pony. Besides, big fat pony butts are great.
