Submit to Starlight

by PegPony

Rating: mature
Tags: Fetish, Rarity, Starlight Glimmer, Fluttershy, Porn, Sex, Profanity, Alternate Universe, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 3292

futa Starlight fucks Rarity

After discovering that Fluttershy has chosen to accept a new life in Starlight's town where everyone is equal, the rest of the gang decide to send out Rarity to find out what Starlight did to get Fluttershy to convert, the final step turns out to be rather different than she initially expected.

This story was written for: Tailsic

Published 2021-11-21 22:40:00 UTC
Last updated 2021-11-21 22:40:00 UTC

Prologue

When they had arrived in Starlight's town of equality, Fluttershy seemed to be the only one who actually liked it that way, so when they were all locked in a room and forced to listen to Starlight's propaganda looping over and over again, she seemed like the best candidate to send out into town so that she could pretend she had accepted their philosophy. What they hadn't expected however was that Fluttershy would never come back to the room because, somehow, Starlight had gotten Fluttershy to actually become part of the town's equality culture for real.

Fluttershy seemed so happy to no longer have a talent for talking to animals and just accept that she was now as average as anyone else, she had her own house, she adopted the accepted hairstyle and clothing for mares and had even begun urging her friends to join her and the rest of the townspeople every time they were brought out of the room to see if they had changed their minds. Her friends were all very concerned, whatever Starlight had done to truly make Fluttershy convert must have been powerful to say the least and, after a lengthy discussion, they decided that the best person to send out next to see if she could get the big scoop was Rarity. The plan was that Rarity would say that she'd gladly become a member of the equality populace just so she could be with her friend Fluttershy and at least talk about their shared passion for sewing and she would, hopefully, discover what it was that Starlight had done and report back to the rest of the group and help put a stop to it without succumbing to it herself.

Yet another day came where the droning of Starlight's voice over the speakers was continually drilled into their minds to a point where they remembered the messages down to the very inflections in the sentences themselves. As the door opened so that Starlight could inspect them and see if they were ready to accept the town's ways, Rarity prepared herself for what would certainly be her toughest challenge to date, reconnaissance.

Equal and Erect

As per usual, the gang all stepped out of the room to see Starlight stood there with the entire population of the town behind her, including Fluttershy. Starlight smirked and said "So... any of you ready to join us yet?"

All of them gave the same silent response as before, except for Rarity, who played her part beautifully as she tentatively went "Um... I h-have a question actually..."

Starlight perked up and said "Yes Rarity?"

Rarity went "If I join the town... can I still talk to Fluttershy about things we like, the past and that kind of stuff?"

Starlight went "Well... so long as you don't intend to try and corrupt her with thoughts of getting her talent back, then sure!"

Rarity took a deep breath and went "Then...I am willing to accept your ways". The rest of them played their part by adopting looks of shock and utter betrayal while the rest of the town cheered in celebration of yet another element of harmony accepting that their way was the right way.

As Rarity walked forward and joined the crowd, Starlight smiled and said "Anyone else?" They stayed silent, the result of which was that, like every other time, they were sent back into the room be treated to more and more hours of propaganda being repeated over and over again, eventually they would succumb and accept the messages as their new truth. Now that they had fell for Rarity's apparent change of heart, it was time for Rarity to talk to Fluttershy, fully intending to figure out through what devious means Starlight had managed to get her to convert and become the newest member of the town. While people were busy building Rarity's new home, the same as every other house, Rarity and Fluttershy chowed down on some disgustingly average muffins and had a chat.

Fluttershy kicked off the conversation by saying "So Rarity... did you really convert just because you missed having me as a friend? I always felt like you were closer to the others, you and Twilight bonded over magic, I always figured you and Applejack would end up becoming an item because opposites tend to attract and Rainbow... well actually you didn't have much in common with Rainbow, same goes for Pinkie as well actually... but my point is I didn't think you and I had much rapport as friends"

Rarity said "Oh nonsense dear! I always tried to get you to be more confident, plus you and I both shared a passion and a knowledge for sewing and the fashion scene, I'm sorry that I didn't make more of an effort to indulge in your company more often"

Fluttershy said "Oh don't worry Rarity, besides, now that you've accepted Starlight's way, we can make up for lost time!"

This seemed like a natural segway in the conversation that would allow Rarity to do some digging as she said "Yes indeed, though come to think of it you were originally sent into town to do some scouting and see if we could put a stop to this whole thing... what changed?"

Fluttershy's tone changed slightly as she recalled her original mission, she looked at Rarity sternly and said "You haven't been sent by the others to do what I failed to do have you?"

Rarity shook her head and said "No no! Not at all! Once I learned that you had become part of the culture I just accepted the inevitable! I swear!"

Fluttershy stared at her intensely, seeing the sweat rolling down her friend's temples as she said "So... you wouldn't object to going to Starlight's home to complete the process, would you?"

Rarity said "Certainly not dear... what is the final step if I may ask?"

Fluttershy smirked, she figured Rarity would want her to spill the beans... but where was the fun in that? Fluttershy walked Rarity to Starlight's home and knocked on the door, Rarity was nervous, if this "final step" was able to get Fluttershy to betray her friends then would the same happen to her? If she could get through it without succumbing and report back to her friends, then it seemed worth the gamble. After a few seconds Starlight opened the door and said "Fluttershy! Good to see you! I see you've brought our new friend Rarity along, is there a problem?"

Fluttershy simply smiled and said "Oh no, not really a problem per se, it's just Rarity here is having doubts about her decision the same way me and all the other girls in town had before you showed us the joy of living here"

Starlight said "Ah I see, well thank you for bringing her here Fluttershy, you are excused". Fluttershy left while Starlight gently ushered Rarity into her home and closed the door and said "So Rarity, what seems to be your issue with the town?"

Rarity cleared her throat as she tried to come up with a reason before she went "Oh I just... you know, what with the town being so small and there only really being one item of clothing that covers the... sensitive... areas of our bodies, I just feel I have no purpose"

Starlight went "Thought as much, you know your friend Fluttershy came to me with the same reason, so did almost every other mare in our community. While you may not have a talent Rarity, you most certainly do have a purpose, a purpose that every mare in our town shares. If I may, I'd like to show you the "final step" that will solidify your acceptance and purge all thoughts of doubt and talent from your mind", Rarity gulped and nodded, she didn't see that she had much choice if she was going to discover what the "final step" was and tell her friends so that they could formulate a way to combat the effects of it and free everyone. Starlight took Rarity to her bedroom and said "Now then Rarity, disrobe please"

Rarity blushed and went "You mean... be n-n-naked?"

Starlight nodded and said "Yes, it makes the process much easier without clothing getting in the way, don't worry, if it makes you feel more comfortable I shall be disrobing as well"

Rarity relaxed, she was actually rather relieved to get the itchy, scratchy sack-like cloth off of her body, even though it meant she had to reveal her body. As soon as the clothing hit the floor she felt really vulnerable with herself on show and instantly moved to cover herself, Starlight giggled a little and said "Please Rarity, don't hide your beauty, you have a very lithe and stunning body, not to mention a bust that would be a handful for any man or woman". Rarity smiled and though reluctant, she slowly moved her hands to her side and allowed Starlight an unobstructed view of her ample breasts and her, somewhat, moistening pussy. The process was feeling rather thrilling and erotic at the moment, but Rarity remained still and unwavering, if embarrassment was part of the final step then she had to resist, if Fluttershy did this then so could she. Starlight smiled and said "Good, now sit on the bed if you please, then once I disrobe we can begin"

Rarity sat down, she was curious to see what Starlight's body was like because while she considered herself strictly heterosexual, she had never been opposed to the notion of experiencing what she imagined was the more elegant touch of a woman. Rarity shook those thoughts from her mind however, she doubted that what was about to transpire was a sexual experience, it was most likely something magical that made it necessary for them both to be completely nude. Starlight faced Rarity and without a seconds hesitation allow her clothes to drop to the floor, Rarity noticed that she too had a decent rack, though in contrast to Rarity's thick round buttocks, Starlight had a slightly smaller and even muscular set of cheeks, however the thing that caught Rarity by surprise was what was laying in between Starlight's legs. Starlight didn't have a tucked away and delicate pussy, in fact Rarity couldn't tell if she even had a pussy at all, her focus and attention were drawn by what was clearly a set of swollen pendulous balls hanging underneath a throbbing and hardening cock.

The Final Step

Rarity was speechless, the air was still and silent until Starlight smirked and said "What's the matter Rarity? see something you like?" Starlight swayed her hips, making her almost fully erect dick sway from side to side as if trying to entice Rarity in dropping to her knees ready to give the stiff member a good polishing with her mouth.

Rarity, at a loss for words just went "Um... I uh... have you... h-have you always had... er... that?"

Starlight went "Well no, I wasn't born with it. It's a little something I added when I founded the town in order to help the mares realize that, without their talents, they still had one singular thing that all mares are good at without even trying......"

Before Rarity could even register what was about to happen, Starlight had pushed her onto her back, forcibly opened her legs and taken her place in between them with her cock poised and ready to penetrate her. Rarity's eyes widened in shock and went "You mean... b-but wait! What about... you know... lesbians?"

Starlight chuckled and said "Rarity, I find it funny that you're willing to believe I have magic powerful enough to remove talent and fashion a working cock in place of my pussy but you don't believe I have magic powerful enough to make sure that everyone in the village is heterosexual. Though what I find even funnier is that you even asked that question rather than begging me to stop or trying to flee, you know what I'm about to do, right?" Starlight had a point, Rarity didn't know why but she couldn't bring herself to resist or attempt to stop what was about to happen, why wasn't she trying to escape? She knew what the final step was now... then again, it would give the game away if she didn't allow it to happen, better to wait it out and pretend to convert so that she wouldn't blow her cover, that way she wouldn't have to engage in some kind of confrontation when she tried to report back to her friends.

Rarity feigned innocence and said "Well... if this is r-r-really the final step in being accepted in the village...... then I wouldn't really have converted if I didn't let you do what you m-m-must..." Starlight smiled wickedly and moved forward, pressing the tip of her fat cock against Rarity's quivering entrance. Both of them were breathing heavily, ready and waiting with anticipation for when there was enough force for Starlight to penetrate Rarity's cunt. Starlight shuddered as the head of her cock popped inside, Rarity's tight, convulsing, positively drenched and moist pussy lips parted to make way for her member, stretching over the tip of her cock and already clamping down and clenching around her before she had even properly entered her. Starlight gritted her teeth, sweat already beginning to run down her forehead as she gripped onto Rarity's thighs and continued to sink herself further in, it was certainly a very snug fit but neither of them were willing to accept that it might have been just a bit too snug.

After a minute of arduous pushing, refusing to stop and groaning from the sheer heat and tightness of such an unused dick milker, Starlight finally bottomed out in Rarity and let out a big sigh of satisfaction as she simply held herself there, allowing the both of them to adjust and acclimatize to the feeling of their union. Rarity had remained defiantly silent throughout, though her bright red cheeks and sweat on her skin betrayed how she was feeling, if this was what she had to go through in order to free the town and her friend... then she didn't particularly mind.

Once Starlight had calmed down, she said in a breathy voice "Damn Rarity... you're hugging my cock so tightly... you're gonna be an interesting one...", before Rarity could even ask what she meant, Starlight began pulling backwards, dragging her cock until she was halfway out and then immediately plunging herself all the way back in with a pleasured moan. After her first thrust, Starlight picked up a consistent and steady rhythm, applying the right amount of pressure to apply in order to easily pound Rarity's pussy and, hopefully, fuck her so good that she'd realize that Starlight's philosophy was correct. As Rarity bit her lip and scrunched up her eyes, Starlight smirked to see her futile attempts at resisting the shots of ecstasy coursing through her body, she increased her tempo and leaned down to whisper in Rarity's ear "Let go Rarity... it will feel so much better if you do... Fluttershy made such delicious squeals when I screwed her... come on, you might as ell enjoy it... enjoy the way I'm fucking you!" Starlight punctuated the end of her sentence with a particularly hard thrust, causing Rarity to finally allow herself to express her pleasure vocally, she could feel the way her pussy walls were rippling across the skin of Starlight's cock as she pistoned her hips at a dizzying pace, so deep that her swinging and churning balls slapped against her thighs.

The second Starlight's ears were graced with the pleased coo's of Rarity's voice she giggled and said "That's it Rarity, see how much easier and pleasant things are when you listen to me? Don't doubt the choice you made, you belong in this town, I've created the truest form of friendship anyone can have, I've created true harmony... embrace equality!!!" Rarity was beginning to falter, the sensations she was experiencing had corrupting her thoughts and made her mind struggle to concentrate on anything other than how good this the constant sex felt. Starlight decided it was time to, quite literally, hammer home the point and began pumping away at Rarity's cunt, eager to rail her as hard and as fast as she was able. Unfortunately she was a tad too eager, as on one of her backwards movements she got the angle slightly wrong, making her cock spring out into the cold air rather than being back in the warmth of Rarity's confines.

Starlight grunted and said "Shit, fucking gotta get back in, I need to be back inside you..." Starlight had to grin when she gripped her shaft and aimed it back to Rarity's entrance, when she noticed that Rarity had reached down to spread her pussy lips for her, rather than using the opportunity to stop the sex. Starlight hilted herself in Rarity and got back into her fuck pattern, being sure not to repeat her mistake, she spoke up once more and said "Come on Rarity, I can't stop and I can't cum until you fully and truly submit... do it..."

Rarity's moans of delight became more frequent as they increased in pitch, the undeniable feeling of an orgasm building in her groin, she held herself back, she couldn't let this happen...

Starlight was already pent up and in need of an ejaculation since before she had even penetrated Rarity, she groaned and raised her voice "Rarity, just do it.. please do it..."

No, Rarity could feel her orgasm coming and she had to stop it so that she could... so that she... Rarity felt a twinge of confusion, she couldn't remember why she was even doing this anymore. Once that realization hit her, she figured why hold back? That question was never answered as Starlight re-styled Rarity's hair into the accepted hairstyle mid-thrust before screaming at her "FUCKING DO IT!!"

Rarity cried out "I ACCEPT EQUALITY! I ACCEPT YOUR WAY! Please... please make...fuck, oh fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck fuck FUCK!" Rarity failed to finish her sentence as she wrapped her legs around Starlight's waist and came hard, absolutely creaming on Starlight's dick, enough that her fuck fluids leaked out around the enormity of stiff mare meat stuffed in her cunt. Starlight cried out in a similar fashion as a deluge of thick warm spunk rocketed out from he tip of her cock, crashing against Rarity's cervix, her balls tensing with each shot.

Eventually the two of them relaxed and got their breath back, finishing the sex in much the way they had started it. Starlight said "Fuck Rarity... you really drained my nuts, I don't think I've ever felt my balls this empty... you put up a good fight I must admit, I might consider taking you on as my personal bitch if you're able to milk my dick like that... holy shit...", Starlight withdrew, humming in contentment as she felt Rarity's velvety insides clinging onto her as if to try and stop her from exiting. Starlight stood up and said "Now, go rejoin the others, they've probably finished your new home by now". With a new mindset, Rarity stood up, put her clothes back on and went back out into the town, desperately hoping that her friends would see the light, realize the error of their ways and take their place in the town just like she and Fluttershy had, adopting a wide grin at the thought.

The End.

Author's Note

Thank you Tailsic for this story idea! I hope you enjoyed it :)