A Fluttering Hearth's Warming Eve

by StormLuna

Rating: mature
Tags: Porn, Fetish, Self Insert, Fluttershy, Sex, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Human, Anthro, Romance
Length: 3817

Hearth's Warming Eve has arrived and the time has come and I got the strangest letter in the mail, it was from Fluttershy. We were good friends but I certainly didn't expect to get a letter from her, one that demanded I go see her immediately.

Hearth's Warming Eve has arrived and the time has come and I got the strangest letter in the mail, it was from Fluttershy. We were good friends but I certainly didn't expect to get a letter from her, one that demanded I go see her immediately.

Story includes: M/F, Panty fetish, foot fetish, cum ingestion, boobie sucking and commitment.

All characters are age 18+.

Source for cover art: https://www.deviantart.com/hendro107/art/Fluttershy-Sexy-Anthro-596465943

Published 2021-12-17 22:10:02 UTC
Last updated 2021-12-17 22:10:02 UTC

Fluttering Love

It was Hearth's Warming Eve in Ponyville and the overall mood was happy and festive. There were decorations all over town, ponies were out singing and the shops were very busy. Last year I was really unnerved with everything being so busy but this year I had the day off so I was able to just avoid the crowds, well for the most part. There was one thing I had to do, I had to go to the post office and get my mail.

When I first arrived in Ponyville, everypony always gave me strange looks given none of them had ever seen a human before but now they greet me the same way they do their fellow ponies, in a friendly manner. Once I got to the post office, I was happy that all I had to do was get my mail because the line of ponies at the counter was very long. It made me wonder why though because many had packages and there was no way the items they were mailing would get to their destinations in time for the holiday.

When I got my mail, I saw that I had a letter from Fluttershy. That was kind of strange because we were friends and normally if she wants to visit, she comes to see me instead of sending me a letter in the mail. I was very curious about what she had to say so I opened it right there in the post office and in it was your normal card wishing me a Happy Hearth's Warming but she had also wrote her own message in there,

"Luke,

First I want to wish you a Happy Hearth's Warming but I would love it if you would come to my cottage as soon as you get this letter. Normally I would spend today with my friends but I told them we were going to spend some time together today and I have a very special present for you, something especially for you! If you don't come I will understand but I will be very sad. I hope to see you soon.

Love,

Fluttershy"

This was something very strange, how she signed her letter. She was most likely the best friend I had in Ponyville because of my introverted nature but for her to sign it love, that was odd. Now I needed to go to one of the stores and get her something. I felt kind of bad though because I didn't know exactly what to get her. I knew she loved animals but getting her food for them wouldn't really be something for her.

Something then hit me, I'd go visit one of her friends. Rarity would certainly be able to give me advice on what to give her. Rarity was likely my second best friend because of her closeness with Fluttershy so she probably wouldn't think anything bad about me asking her for advice. When I got to the boutique and entered I heard, "Welcome to The Carousel Boutique, where everything is chic, unique and magnifique!"

When she saw me she added, "Luke darling, I certainly didn't expect to see you today!"

I replied, "Well I got a letter from Fluttershy wanting me to come over and I have absolutely no idea what to get her."

Rarity gave me a smile and said, "Follow me, I think there is something that you can get her that she will love."

Alright, I knew that Fluttershy did like fashion some and figured that Rarity likely knew exactly what she would want. Rarity led me to a rack of dresses that were out of season, ones that looked more like they were for spring. She showed me one that was in a flower print, primarily tulips and marigolds. She suggested, "If you want to get her something she'll like, I'd go with this one."

She levitated it to me and given that I wasn't hurting financially, I decided to get it for her without even looking at the price tag. I gave Rarity a smile, "Well if you think she'll like it, I know she will."

She was blushing a bit as she replied, "And I know what she has for you and I know you're going to love it!"

That kind of surprised me because Rarity pretty much had no idea what kinds of things I liked. To be honest, even Fluttershy didn't know the things I liked most, but then again getting the things I liked the most would be impossible unless she found a portal to the world I came from, a world that she probably wouldn't like.

As I headed over towards her cottage, I was very curious as to what she would have for me. Did she maybe know more about me than I thought or was Rarity simply saying that to get me excited to go to my best friend's cottage. I would soon find out.

When I got to her cottage I knocked on the door and I heard her yell, "Come in and lock the door." She paused for a moment before adding, "And don't let any of the animals in, I want this to be just us!"

I did notice that there were a few more animals outside of her cottage than normal. That did kind of surprise me given that it wasn't exactly what you'd call temperate outside. Well I'm sure Fluttershy had her plans and whatever they were, I knew they'd be good. I opened the door and headed in before looking around. What surprised me though was that Fluttershy was nowhere to be seen.

I called out, "Fluttershy, where are you?"

I heard a yell, "I'm up in my bedroom. Just come on up!"

I knew that by saying to come on up it meant her bedroom was upstairs. I initially felt a bit odd to be going up her stairs but since she told me to do so, I told myself that it would be perfectly ok. Once I got up there I saw that there was only one door that was closed most of the way. I knocked on it and asked, "Fluttershy, are you in there?"

She seductively replied, "I am. Close your eyes and come in!"

The way she responded sounded very seductive. For a brief moment I was wondering if she was going to want something more than friendship but then I reprimanded myself knowing that Fluttershy wouldn't just go inviting me into her bedroom to seduce me. Perhaps that was simply where she was storing the gift she had for me.

I headed in and immediately I felt a soft hand grab mine, the soft hand of Fluttershy. Her voice remained seductive as she said, "Ok, on the count of three I want you to open your eyes. One, two, three!"

When I opened my eyes I was stunned. Standing in front of me was Fluttershy in the type of outfit I would never expect. She was wearing a revealing green top that was having trouble holding her breasts in. She was wearing matching leggings and a pair of blue-green panties. The moment I saw her I became hard and she immediately noticed this.

"Wow, you must really find me hot!"

I blushed deeply, "Maybe!"

She giggled, "Oh I think it is more than just a maybe!" She saw that I had a bag with me and added, "Is this for me?"

I replied, "It is, Rarity told me that you'd probably like it."

She pulled the dress out of the bag and had a huge smile on her face. She exclaimed, "Oh thank you Luke, I love it! It is exactly what I've been wanting for so long!"

She embraced me tightly and began to grind herself up against my fully erect member. She let out a gentle hum before suggesting, "Now how about you undress because you can't have your gift if you don't."

I nodded and as I was undressing, I knew exactly what my gift was going to be. My gift was going to be Fluttershy herself. It was no wonder that she signed the letter to me love instead of your friend. I felt a surge of warmth flowing through my body as I began to imagine giving Fluttershy the love that she was obviously wanting. Once I was fully undressed she noticed that I already had some pre-semenal fluid at the very tip of my member. She shook her head and sighed, "Tsk, tsk. What am I going to do with you?"

I blushed deeply, "I'm sorry Fluttershy, it is just that you're so incredibly sexy."

She gave me a smile, "Mhmm....now come and unwrap your present. She is getting very impatient!"

I immediately began to undress her, starting with the leggings first. I wanted to save the garments that were hiding the sexiest parts of her for a minute later. I then was torn between removing her top or her panties. Ultimately I removed her top and stood there in a daze, gazing at those lovely tits of hers. She gave me a smile and giggled, "You can hold them if you like."

I reached out, cupped them and began to massage them. I'm not overly familiar with breast sizes but my guess is that those babies had to be F cups as she had the largest breasts out of her friends. She was moaning gently as I was massaging them and then I decided to remove her panties. I wasn't going to remove them any old way though, I got on my hands and knees and began to remove them with my teeth.

When I did this she giggled, "Oh my, you must have a panties fetish....I like that. Now you can just suck them clean instead of me having to wash them!"

This was going to be sweet, she was going to let me suck her underwear clean? That meant one thing, I would get to taste her whenever she chose to wash her panties. Once I got her underwear down to her knees and she stepped out of them, I immediately began to suck on the part that right under her pussy. She gave me a smile and giggled, "Good boy, now be sure to suck them clean, suck them until you can't taste me anymore!"

I continued to suck on her underwear, relishing in the fact that I was doing something that no woman ever allowed me to do, suck her panties clean. After sucking on them for nearly ten minutes, I could not taste anything else and quit sucking. She gave me a smile and added, "Thank you Luke, I'll be sure and let you know when I need my panties cleaned but now" she plopped down on the bed and ordered, "Come and get your present!"

I approached her bed and wondered where I should start. All of her was so sexy but then I decided I'd start at the bottom and work my way up so I immediately took to her big toe. She kicked lightly and giggled, "Luke, that tickles!"

I stopped sucking and commented, "And it tastes so good!"

She again giggled, "A foot fetish huh? What other kinds of fetishes do you have that I will like?"

I gave her a smile before taking back to her toe. She continued to giggle as I began to run my tongue between her toes and her giggles were so cute. I could keep on doing that for hours but I'm sure that she wants a whole lot more than me simply satisfying what seemed to be her like of my foot fetish. I then began to move my sucking up and I noticed something about her. Her coat was incredibly soft and it seemed to be thin, making it have more of a silky feel to it than how it likely is with most of the ponies.

Her breathing became slowly but surely heavier as I moved up her legs but once I reached her inner thighs, she gasped loudly, "Oh Luke, you're so close!"

I gave her a smile, "I know and I'm going to let you in on a secret, I love sucking on a girl's inner thighs. They are so tasty and the smell of your marehood is so sweet!"

She pouted, "You're teasing me Luke, you're teasing me!"

I could tell by the tone in her voice that she secretly liked it and wouldn't mind if I sucked for a while. I then moved far up enough that her wet pussy was rubbing up against the side of my face, coating it in girlcum. I stopped sucking for a moment and asked, "Somepony's really turned on, isn't she?"

Fluttershy giggled, "Mhmm!"

I then decided to dive right in. I began to suck and the moment I began to probe her she squealed, "Oh Luke, yes baby yes!"

I gave her a thumbs up before continuing to suck and probe her. Her moaning continued to get louder and her breathing became heavier the longer I gave her the pleasure that she so desperately wanted. I then placed my hands on her flanks and began to massage her cutie marks, causing her moans to become almost ear splitting and her squeals to become more intense.

After a few minutes of massaging them she squealed, "Oh Luke baby, I'm gonna, I'm gonna!"

I formed an air tight seal when I heard this because I wanted to make sure and get every single drop of the sweet treat she was about to provide for me. She then let out an even louder squeal as she began to flood my mouth full of her cum. That mare must have a ton of cum stored up in her because it felt like she continued to flood my mouth with so much of it. Once she had gave me every last drop, I got up and licked my cum covered lips. "Oh my Fluttershy, you are so tasty! I could drink this every day forever!"

She gave me a cute giggle, "You never know, you might be able to!"

That was a statement that I certainly was not expecting. Was Fluttershy wanting to be more than just friends and that was her way of saying it? I wasn't going to go counting my chickens before they hatched though because this might simply be her Hearth's Warming gift to me, not an indication that she wanted something more.

She then nodded her head which I knew was her way of saying that she wanted me to get back to work. I then moved up to her belly and the second I began to suck on her, she began to squirm and giggle, "No Luke no, that tickles so much! Please, it tickles so much!"

She may have said no but giving the nature of her giggling, I knew she liked it and her squirming was so hot and cute! How could I not continue to suck on her belly? After another minute I decided to continue moving up until I got to a part of her I have long dreamed of sucking on, her tits. The moment I began to suck on them she moaned, "Oh Luke, yes baby yes!"

She grabbed my hair and began to pull on it as I was sucking on her. She began to squeal as I began to run my tongue on her rock hard nipples. With my mouth I was sucking on one tit and with my hand I was massaging the other. Her breathing was becoming heavier, her moaning was becoming louder and I could feel her heart beginning to beat faster. It was not long until she moaned, "Oh Luke, I'm gonna cum again!"

When she said this, I put my kneecap right in front of her pussy so she would soak it. I didn't want it to go to waste and I figured my knee would be a much better place for it than her sheets. When she finally climaxed, she let out an ear splitting squeal as my kneecap was covered in her warm nectar. After her climax she moaned, "Oh Luke, please take me now, please take me! I can't take it anymore, I need your cock and I need it so bad!"

I gave her a smile, "And I need you so bad too. My cock needs your pussy so badly!"

She stroked my face and demanded, "Then fuck me and kiss me!"

Right as she felt my member make contact with her lips she became nervous, "But please be gentle, I've never done this before."

I figured that she would be a virgin given her introverted nature but I always love it when I'm able to take a girl's, or in her case, a mare's virginity. As I slowly began to enter her, we both let out gasps of pleasure. I could tell though that she was very nervous the further I went in and then I hit a barrier, a barrier that finally gave way. She sank her fingernails into my back and let out a scream of pain.

I was very concerned and asked, "Fluttershy, are you ok? Do you want me to stop?"

She yelled, "No, just lay still for a minute but once you start again, take it slow! I want our moment to last!"

That was something I was really hoping for. I wanted our moment to be more intimate and once she gave me a nod, I knew it would be ok to get to work on her. I began to gently thrust her as she wrapped her legs around me, tightening her vaginal walls. Her tighter walls felt like a slice of heaven! They were so hot, wet and tight. It felt like they were lovingly embracing my cock, just as it felt like Fluttershy was lovingly embracing me.

We then began to kiss passionately and she quickly forced her tongue into my mouth, fighting my own for dominance and hers was easily dominating mine. Her kiss was a feeling of pure bliss but still, the hot, wet and tight blanket that was wrapped around my cock continued to feel like the slice of heaven I had never felt before.

Giving it to Fluttershy slow and steady was so much better than drilling her. Eventually we both began to moan loudly as our climaxes were coming. It was such a wonderful feeling as her walls contracted around me tighter the closer to her climax she got. Finally the two of us released together, a loving simultaneous climax. Feeling her cum soaking me was so wonderful as I continued to release rope after rope of semen straight into her womb.

After our climaxes were complete, we laid there in our afterglow, giving one another loving smiles. Once I began to lose my erection, I pulled out and exclaimed, "Oh Fluttershy, I have never felt such pleasure before in my life!"

She gave me a kiss before lovingly stating, "Luke, I have wanted this from you for so long and it was perfect! I never knew such pleasure existed!"

She then turned us onto our sides and we began to kiss passionately. She again forced her tongue into my mouth and I felt a flood of saliva flowing into my mouth, saliva that I greedily swallowed. We continued to kiss for what had to be hours until she finally broke the kiss. I had always had a soft spot for Fluttershy but during our moment I felt so much more develop for her, I felt pure love for her. I knew it would probably seem quick but I wanted to tell her how I truly felt.

"Fluttershy, I am going to admit that I have been fond of you from the moment I met you. That beautiful smile of yours, your kind and sweet nature, your empathy, how you don't put yourself ahead of others and how you'll be there if I need to talk." My voice began to break as I asked her, "Fluttershy, I love you with all my heart and I'm wondering if you'd be my marefriend?"

She gave me a wet sloppy kiss before exclaiming, "Yes Luke yes, yes I'll be your marefriend!"

The two of us gave one another a huge smile before engaging in another long, passionate kiss. We began to rub our bodies together, heating ourselves up and working up a good sweat. If there was one thing I loved it was having a hot and sweaty body wrapped around mine. Once we finally broke our kiss Fluttershy asked, "Luke, what would you think about moving in with me?"

I could hardly believe it. Here was Fluttershy, not that long after us becoming a couple asking me to move in with her. Now her cottage was very small and there would be very little room for both of us, well that along with having Angel being in there all the time and maybe not liking me but how could I possibly say no? "Of course I'll move in with you Fluttershy, oh I love you so much!"

She gave me a smile and giggled, "Now you'll be able to drink my cum anytime you want, and we can have sex anytime we want!"

I gave her a kiss before replying, "I know Fluttershy and now I feel like my life is perfect....oh I love you so much."

She returned the kiss before giggling, "Oh I love you too Luke. I can only imagine what will come next, maybe marriage before too long!"

Wow, just wow. Fluttershy was already bringing up marriage and I'll admit, I would love to marry her. I replied, "Oh Fluttershy sweetie, whenever you're ready, we'll get married and have an eternity together, an eternity filled full of love."

She gave me a smile before yawning, "You know Luke, everything we've done today has wore me out so much. I was wondering if we could lay here, hold each other close and fall asleep."

I too was tired and yawned, "I'd love that Fluttershy. I can't wait until we do this every single night, forever."

She let out another yawn before laying her head under mine, "I love you Luke, you sleep tight."

I yawned again, "I love you too Fluttershy, sweet dreams."

She was the first one to fall asleep and as I laid there listening to her rhythmic breathing, I truly felt happy. Rarity had told me that I would really like what Fluttershy had to give to me but I never knew that gift would be her. What she gave me truly was a gift I loved and to make things better, we were a committed couple and were already talking about marriage.