A Fabulous Hearth's Warming Eve

by StormLuna

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Human, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Rarity, Self Insert, Porn
Length: 2609

Hearth's Warming Eve had arrived and after getting off of work, I headed home. I had no plans for the night except getting some sleep until a certain fashonista came to visit. Her visit would be anything but ordinary.

Hearth's Warming Eve had arrived and after getting off of work, I headed home. I had no plans for the night except getting some sleep until a certain fashonista came to visit. Her visit would be anything but ordinary as she wound up making it the best night ever!

A special thanks to Bronycommander for the idea of doing one involving Rarity

Published 2021-12-18 19:10:01 UTC
Last updated 2021-12-18 19:10:01 UTC

A Fabulous Night

Hearth's Warming Eve had arrived and the amount of activity in Ponyville had increased significantly. Despite the less than pleasant weather, many ponies were out mingling, carolers were out singing and all the stores were busier than normal. Barnyard Bargains was no exception as ponies were coming in to buy last minute gifts for their family and friends. One good thing about that was that the day seemed to be going by much faster than it normally would. The other positive was that Mr. Rich was keeping the store open until seven instead of closing at five. Most ponies would consider that bad but with me being a human with no family to have to get home to, he left me in charge of things until it was closing time. The best thing though, from five to seven he was giving me double pay. Now that is what makes for a great boss.

Once seven had arrived, the store was empty so there would be nopony around to keep me there late. Once I locked up and headed home, it was dark and there was nopony out and about. One thing I had learned from last year was that most ponies give their gifts on Hearth's Warming Eve instead of the holiday itself. That was nothing like it was back in my world when my family would exchange gifts after breakfast on Christmas morning. It really didn't affect me though since I lived alone.

Once I got home I headed straight to the kitchen to cook some supper. I figured that just because I lived alone and had no reason to celebrate the holiday, I wasn't going to do something special for it. I had bought some hamburger a couple days ago, a very rare item to find in Ponyville, and made myself a cheeseburger pie. I would have some for that night and then some for the following day. As I was cooking, I put on some of the heavy metal that I loved so much back in my world. Despite me having no one to celebrate the holiday with, I was perfectly content.

Once I had finished cooking and sat down to eat, I heard a knock on my door. I'll admit, I was less than thrilled that somepony would interrupt me during my meal but I answered the door and surprisingly, it was Rarity. I couldn't help but wonder why she would be visiting me on Hearth's Warming Eve given that she has a little sister to celebrate with, that along with parents who were likely visiting as well.

She gave me a smile, "May I come in?"

I replied, "Yeah sure. If you're hungry I just got finished making a cheeseburger pie."

Rarity gave me a smile, "Thanks for the offer darling but I think I will pass. I don't like meat."

I replied, "Very well. So what brings you over tonight?"

Rarity gave me a seductive look, "Well you see darling, I know that you are all alone on Hearth's Warming and you really should have somepony with you."

I replied, "Well I'm used to it, it has been......"

She then pulled me into a deep kiss and wrapped her arms around me, pulling me closer to her. I then wrapped my arms around her and our kiss deepened. Normally when I cooked a cheeseburger pie that was the only thing I was focused on but Rarity kissing me caused that to fall down on my priority list. My number one thought was her and what else she had planned for me besides a deep kiss.

When she finally broke the kiss she remembered that I had fixed myself some supper. She said, "I'm so sorry darling, I forgot you were eating supper." She gave me a smile and added, "Maybe I'll try some of that cheeseburger pie. It might be good."

I exclaimed, "That's wonderful, I haven't hand anypony to share a meal with in ages."

I got her a slice on a plate and we went into the living room, sat down on the couch and began to eat. She was using her magic to hold her fork so while I was eating like a human, she had one hand on my leg and was stroking it. I gasped, "Ra-Rarity, that feels so good!"

She winked at me and gave me a smile before getting back to her meal. While she didn't say anything, I could tell that she liked it. This relieved me because it meant that I would have somepony around for longer than just long enough for a passionate kiss. I tended to eat this dish much quicker than I should given how good it was. Once the two of us finished our meal I said, "Let me take your plate and get it rinsed off before I put it in the dishwasher."

Rarity grasped me in her magic and objected, "Luke darling, that can wait. I have something I need to discuss with you, well that and I have a present for you."

This was something that surprised me. Rarity and I do know one another because of my friendship with Twilight and Fluttershy but I don't know if we exactly see one another as friends. I asked, "Really, you have a present for me?"

Rarity gave me a smile, "I do but can I use your restroom?"

I replied, "Yes. Go down the hall and it will be the second door on the left."

She headed to the restroom and as she was walking, I noticed that she was carrying a bag with her. I didn't notice that at first but then again my first concern was eating and then I was so lost in her kiss that nothing else crossed my mind. I did however go and get my leftovers covered and put in the fridge so that it wouldn't dry out before the following day. I got that taken care of and as I was returning to the living room, Rarity returned but something was different about her, the way she was dressed.

When she arrived, she was wearing an overcoat and was dressed rather modestly but now she was revealing a very revealing outfit. It resembled the women's Santa outfits back in my world but with hers, her top fit so snug it was barely holding in her massive breasts. I always knew that Rarity was well endowed but I didn't know she was that big. I then began to wonder what they looked like when they were free and not constrained.

Imaging what they looked like caused me to get hard very quickly. Rarity saw this and gave me a smile, "I take it you like what you see?"

I returned the smile, "I, I do....you are incredibly sexy."

Rarity approached me, stroked me and began, "Luke darling, I need to admit something to you. While I do have a family to celebrate Hearth's Warming Eve with, I am a lonely mare and I am a needy mare and I know you are a lonely man. I know you likely haven't had anyone special since you've been in Equestria" she then stroked my bulge and added, "and I know you must get needy."

I gasped as she stroked my member, "Y-yeah, I do get needy like everyone else."

Rarity gave me a kiss before continuing, "Alright Luke, I'm very needy and you're needy. What do you say we satisfy our needs. I need your cock in my pussy and I know your cock wants to be in my pussy."

I was in a state of shock at this point. Here was Rarity, easily the sexiest mare in all of Ponyville, maybe even Equestria, wanting to have sex with me. Both of us were needy and I wanted to satisfy her needs. I grabbed her hand and suggested, "How about we go to my bedroom so we can release all this pent up need for sex."

She gave me a kiss before I led her into my bedroom. Once we arrived she pointed to herself and suggested, "Luke, think of my body as a gift from me to you. How about you come and unwrap your gift?"

I pointed to myself and added, "And my body is my gift to you so how about you unwrap your gift?"

I decided to start unwrapping her first and the more I revealed, the hotter I was getting for her. Once she was fully nude I gasped, "Rarity, never before have I seen such beauty. You are more beautiful and sexier than the sexiest goddess that could ever exist."

Rarity approached me and said, "Now I'm going to unwrap my present and I have a good feeling it will be so sexy."

She started to undress me and I saw her smile getting bigger and bigger. I was surprised to be honest because I don't think I'm anything to write home about. I've always classified myself as average at best. Once she removed my boxers and saw my fully erect cock she licked her lips, "And this, it is perfect. It will be perfect to please me with."

I was beyond happy that she liked what she saw. I thought that once she undressed me, that she would think I was sub-par and would just head home. She then plopped down on my bed and suggested, "How about you come and claim your present darling? I can tell that you want me so badly."

I gave her a smile and I began to wonder where I should start. Rarity was a lady after all and while I would have loved to start sucking on her toes, I figured that I had best not. She spread her legs wider and arched her back, making her vagina much more accessible. I then knew what it was she wanted. I crawled on the bed and immediately dove in her pussy.

"Oh my! Luke, that feels absolutely divine!"

I gave her a thumbs up and began to suck harder and shoved my tongue up inside of her. I could tell that she was enjoying the pleasure I was giving her as her breathing got heavier and her moans got louder. I then wondered about one thing, what happened when a mare had her cutie marks massaged? I placed my hands on her flanks and began to massage those diamonds.

The moment I began to massage her marks she began to call out, "Oh Luke darling, yes baby yes! Keep sucking baby, keep sucking!"

I continued to suck and probe her and her moaning continued to get louder and louder. Ultimately her moans became louder, "Oh Luke darling, I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonnaaaa!

I knew to prepare my mouth for a tasty treat when she said this. Finally she let out a loud squeal as she flooded my mouth full of her cum. Her cum was so tasty so I made sure to swallow every last drop of it. I wanted it all in my stomach, not on my comforter. Once I had drank all of it I gave her a smile, "Oh Rarity, I have never tasted anything more sweet in my life!"

She motioned for me to come up and replied, "Oh I have more for you dear, my girls really need your attention."

I gave her a smile, "Oh I'm more than ready to give your girls the attention they need!"

I got up further on the bed and took straight to her left tit. The moment I began to suck she started to moan loudly and call out my name. I then saw her flare her horn up and suddenly she had begun to lactate and I was drinking her milk! That was something I never imagined would happen and it seemed like the more I drank, the more I was wanting her. I don't know what kind of magic her milk had but it was working like an aphrodisiac, all I could think about was when I would finally get to give her my member.

After I finished that tit, I took to the other one. After all, it would not be very nice to drink one dry and leave the other one full. Once I finished off all of her milk I gave her a smile, "Oh Rarity, your milk is so sweet! I could drink it everyday for the rest of my life!"

Rarity giggled, "If you want to drink it everyday darling, you can drink it as much as you want."

Sweet! This meant that Rarity was wanting us to become friends or probably friends with benefits. I don't know if anything beyond that would ever develop but friends with benefits would be perfect! I then decided the time had come for us to finally release all that pent up sexual need we had.

I lined my cock up with her pussy and asked, "Are you ready for this?"

Rarity screamed, "I never thought you'd ask! We are both needy, lets satisfy those needs!"

I gave her a smile and then I shoved my cock into her, causing her to squeal in ecstasy, "Oh Luke, pound me, drill me!"

I then got to it and immediately both of us were moaning in ecstasy. Her pussy was so hot, wet and tight. As I was giving it to her, she wrapped her legs around me tightening her vaginal walls. It was such a wonderful feeling. It felt like my member was lovingly embraced in a hot, wet and tight cell. I had never felt anything more pleasurable in my life.

As I continued to give it to her, we began to kiss passionately with her shoving her tongue into my mouth, fighting with my own for dominance. Given that I'm a human, her tongue was easily winning the battle. Our kiss felt truly wonderful, it felt like we were bonding in a way that no human and mare would but her loving walls embracing my member felt even better.

Ultimately though we both felt our climaxes coming and our moans became louder and our breathing became heavier. As her climax was coming, her walls began to tighten around my member tighter and tighter. I was thrusting harder and harder as my member was slamming up against her cervix and then finally it happened, we climaxed simultaneously. She unleashed a flood of cum that soaked my member and I released a flood of semen that shot straight into her womb.

After our climaxes were complete, we turned on our sides and Rarity asked, "So Luke, did you like your present?"

I gave her a kiss and exclaimed, "Oh I more than liked it Rarity, I loved it!"

She returned the kiss and asked, "What would you think about us doing this more often, maybe even every day if I can get away with it?"

I gave her a smile, "Seriously, every day?"

"Yes darling, every day. I know I can make time for us to do this."

I replied, "Oh I'd love that Rarity!"

She gave me a smile before wrapping herself around me and pulling me into another deep passionate kiss. As we were laying there kissing, I was happy and content. Both of us were able to release a lot of pent up sexual desire and it seemed like Rarity and I doing this was going to be a regular basis. Rarity and I may not be an item but having sex like this quite often is exactly what I need, what she needs, what both of us need!