two of a kind

by Bestfluttercordfan

Rating: everyone
Tags: Romance, Fluttershy, Random, Discord, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Alternate Universe, Main 6
Length: 4316

When hearts and hooves day comes along and When hearts and hooves day comes along and fluttershy still hasn't told her crush she loves him what will happen

this story takes place during season 5 and this is a different universe where rarspike is a thing and pinkdash is a thing and where scootaloo and rainbow are sisters When hearts and hooves day comes along and When hearts and hooves day comes along and fluttershy still hasn't told her crush she loves him what will happen

Published 2022-02-15 03:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2022-02-21 01:18:12 UTC

Chapter 2

The next day at sugar cube corner.

Applejack " Hi pinkie.

Applejack said as she walked in.

Pinkie pie " Hiya applejack.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped to her friend.

Applejack " So why did you want me to be here?

Applejack said confused.

Pinkie pie " Well it's about fluttershy.

Pinkie pie said.

Applejack " Let me guess she said no to the hearts and hooves day party again.

Applejack said.

Pinkie pie " Yes she always says no why won't she come.

Pinkie pie said as she pouted.

Applejack " Well fluttershy doesn't celebrate hearts and hooves day pinkie you have to understand this every year this happens fluttershy says no and you want me to go reason with her.

Applejack said.

Pinkie pie " I don't understand why fluttershy doses not celebrate hearts and hooves day I can understand nightmare night because fluttershy gets scared really easily.

Pinkie pie said as she pouted even more.

Applejack " Listen pinkie hearts and hooves day is about spending the whole day with the one you love now I don't mean friend or brother or sister mom or dad I mean your special some pony the pony you want to spend the rest of your life with the one you want to start a family with but fluttershy well she doesn't have a special some pony I don't even think she has a crush on any pony.

Applejack said as she hugged pinkie.

Pinkie pie " Your right applejack but if I can find fluttershy a special some pony she will come to the party oh your the best applejack.

Pinkie pie said as she bounced out of sugar cube corner.

Applejack " You can't force some pony to love another pony it won't work.

Applejack shouted at pinkie pie.

At fluttershys house.

Pinkie pie " Hiya fluttershy.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped inside.

Fluttershy " Oh hello pinkie pie.

Fluttershy said.

Pinkie pie " Have you met bulk biseps he's really strong almost every mare in ponyville Is drooling over him I bet you think he's really hot don't you.

Pinkie pie said as bulk biseps walked in.

Fluttershy " Muscles are over rated.

Fluttershy said as she took a bite from her pancake.

Pinkie pie " Ok so your not into muscles but he can provide you safety he can keep you safe from anything.

Pinkie pie said.

Fluttershy " I honestly doubt that.

Said as she thought about discord.

Bulk biseps " Hey cutie wanna go on a date.

Bulk biseps said as he sat next to fluttershy.

Pinkie pie " He likes you fluttershy.

Pinkie pie said.

Fluttershy " I'm sorry bulk biseps your a good friend but no I don't like you in that way.

Fluttershy said.

Pinkie pie " Fluttershy this might be your only chance to have a special some pony.

Pinkie pie said.

Bulk biseps " Well I'm going to go I did what you asked pinkie.

Bulk biseps said as he went out the door.

Fluttershy " What the fuck pinkie you thought if a stallion came up here and asked me out I would say yes then I would have a reason to come to your party on hearts and hooves day well let me tell you this it isn't going to happen I don't celebrate hearts and hooves day get the fuck out of my house now.

Fluttershy said angerily.

Pinkie pie " I'm sorry flutters I just thought.

Pinkie pie said sadly.

Fluttershy " Don't fucking talk to me you can talk to me when I know your sorry.

Fluttershy said as she slammed the door in front of pinkie pie.

At surgar cube corner.

Pinkie pie " dashie I don't know what I'm going to do fluttershy is really mad at me she won't even talk to me.

Pinkie pie said sadly as she was hugging her mare friend.

Rainbow dash " I go hang out with my little sister scootaloo for a few hours and you go piss fluttershy off what did you ever do.

Rainbow dash said as she hugged pinkie.

Pinkie pie" Well I thought if I got fluttershy a special some pony she would come to my party that's on hearts and hooves day she never comes I just want her to come.

Pinkie pie said sadly.

Rainbow dash " Pinkie you can't force some pony to love another pony they don't love and you know fluttershy doses not celebrate hearts and hooves day she never has even when me and fluttershy were fillies she never celebrated hearts and hooves day.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie " Your right dashie.

Pinkie pie said.

At discords house.

Spike " So this is where you live.

Spike said as he walked into discords house.

Discord" Yes this is where I live.

Discord said as he was hiding a picture of fluttershy that had hearts on the picture frame.

Spike " so What do you want to do.

Spike said.

Discord " I don't know.

Spike " Ok.

Spike said.

Discord " Spike how do you make it look so easy.

Discord said as he looked at spike.

Spike " What do you mean discord?

Spike asked a little confused.

Discord " I mean how were you able to confess your feelings to rarity weren't you afraid that she might not of feel the same way about you.

Discord asked.

Spike " Yeah I was afraid that rarity wouldn't feel the same way that's why I kept my feelings a secret for so long.

Spike said.

Discord " Well ok then.

Discord said.

Spike " Why did you want to know?

Spike asked curiously.

Discord " Uh no reason.

Discord said.

Spike " Ok.

Spike said.

Chapter 3

The next day at fluttershys house.

Twilight " Pinkie are you sure about this fluttershy could be back any minute and she is mad at you and this isn't proofing your sorry about what you did yesterday.

Twilight said nervously as pinkie picked locked the door.

Pinkie pie "Everything is going to be fine twilight I just need to look for something.

Pinkie pie said as she walked into the dark house.

Twilight"Look for what?

Twilight asked a little confused.

Pinkie pie" Welllllllllllll there has to be a reasonable explanation why fluttershy got so mad at me yesterday.

Pinkie pie said as she was looking through a pile of papers that was on a table.

Twilight" There is a reason you tried to force love.

Twilight said.

Pinkie pie"Yeah I know that but I don't understand why fluttershy got so mad.

Pinkie pie said.

Twilight " Well ok then.

Twilight said as pinkie pie went Upstairs.

Pinkie pie " Haha I found it.

Pinkie pie said as twilight came running up to stairs.

Twilight "That's just a picture of discord by her bed like fluttershy and discord are friends.

Twilight said.

Pinkie pie" Your right let's just go before fluttershy comes back.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped out the door.

Twilight "Ok.

Twilight said as she locked the door with her magic.

At surgar cube corner in the party planing cave.

Rainbow dash"Pinkie are you down here.

Rainbow asked as she was flying down to the party planing cave.

Pinkie pie" Yes dashie I'm down here.

Pinkie pie said as she looked at her board that had a picture of fluttershy pinned in the middle and a lot of other pictures surrounding it.

Rainbow dash "Pinkie what are you doing.

Rainbow dash said nervously when she saw the board.

Pinkie pie" Oh nothing I'm just gathering clues to why fluttershy is mad at me for trying to help her and I think I have it.

Pinkie pie said as she was walking next to rainbow dash.

Rainbow dash " Ok pinkie you clearly need sleep it's 1:00 in the morning and fluttershy is mad at you because you tried to force her to be with someone she doesn't like you need to prove to her you are sorry and fluttershy is perfectly happy without a special some pony.

Rainbow dash said as she was grabbing the pink earth pony.

Pinkie pie "No I don't need sleep look at these clues I gathered.

Pinkie pie said as she wiggled her way through rainbows grip.

Rainbow dash" All of your so called clues is picture of a tea shop a picture of a grocery store a picture of discord walking out of the bathroom I don't even know why you have that.

Rainbow dash said as she looked at the board.

Pinkie pie "Don't worry dashie soon you will understand.

Pinkie pie said as she put another picture on the board.

Rainbow dash" What the fuck pinkie why do you have a picture of fluttershy going into the bathroom.

Rainbow dash said as she watched her marefriend put more pictures on the board.

Pinkie pie " Because look it's the same bathroom discord used.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash " Ok.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie "Look I saw fluttershy go to the tea shop earlier today and the pony at the register knew exactly what to bring her.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash"Fluttershy likes tea.

Rainbow dash said as she was getting sleepy.

Pinkie pie"I gathered all of these clues but I still don't have a clue what any of this means.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" It means go your ass to bed.

Rainbow dash said sleeply.

Pinkie pie "Excuse me have you forgotten who your fucking talking to.

Pinkie pie shouted as she turned around and looked at rainbow dash.

Rainbow dash" I'm sorry pinkie ok I didn't mean to say that I'm just so fucking ass tired ok and your so called clues don't fucking mean anything ok so can we just go to fucking sleep.

Rainbow dash said as she was walking next to pinkie.

Pinkie pie "Ugh my clues do mean something dashie and stop fucking swearing you know how I feel about ponies fucking swearing at me.

Pinkie pie said angerly.

Rainbow dash" Yes I know pinkie but you also know how fucking cranky I am when I don't get fucking sleep.

Rainbow dash shouted at pinkie.

Pinkie pie "Shut up just shut up.

Pinkie pie said as she ran past rainbow dash and out of the party planing cave.

Rainbow dash" Pinkie listen I'm sorry I yelled at you and I know how you hate it when ponies swear at you especially when I swear at you I didn't mean to loose my temper I'm just tired ok it's now 2:00 in the morning and I'm tired maybe your so called clues mean something or maybe they don't but you can figure that out once we get some sleep and I could probably even help you.

Rainbow dash said as she walked into pinkies bedroom.

Pinkie pie " Dashie I'm sorry if I made you mad I just don't know how I'm going to prove to fluttershy that I'm really sorry for what I did the other day.

Pinkie pie said as she cried into the pillow.

Rainbow dash " No no I wouldn't ever ever be mad at my awesome marefriend especially since it's this close to hearts and hooves day.

Rainbow dash said as she wrapped her hooves around pinkie.

Pinkie pie " I love you dashie I love you more than cupcakes

Pinkie pie said as she looked at rainbow.

Rainbow dash "Well that's a lot you love cupcakes more than anything.

Rainbow dash said with a laugh.

Pinkie pie" That is true I do like cupcakes but every since I fell in love with you dashie I love you more than cupcakes.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash "Well to tell you the truth before I fell In love with you I used to love being awesome more than anything but I love you more than I like being awesome.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie" Wow.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash "Yeah and I'm glad I fell in love with you.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie" I'm glad I fell in love with you dashie.

Pinkie pie said as she smiled.

Rainbow dash "So now what?

Rainbow dash asked.

A flash back in pinkies mind.

Pinkie pie" Hm that pony over there looks really grumpy I'm going to go make him feel better.

Pinkie pie said.

Rarity "Don't you dare do that.

Rarity said stomping on pinkies tail.

Pinkie pie" Why can't I he looks angry and I like making ponies smile.

Pinkie whined in pain as she felt rarity stomp on her tail.

Rarity"You will just make him even more mad.

Rarity said will a Huff.

Pinkie pie " How?

Pinkie asked.

Rarity "Well I have been watching that stallion over there and every Mare is asking him out but I also have noticed him starring at a mare over there with hearts in her eyes but anytime he trys to go over there a punch of mares start swarming him and asking him if he will be his very special some pony.

Rarity said.

Pinkie pie" But he already has some pony in mind to be his very special some pony.

Pinkie said.

Rarity "That's right.

Rarity said.

Back in the present.

Pinkie pie" I understand it now.

Pinkie pie shouted as she rushed down the stairs.

Rainbow dash"Wait what understand what I'm so confused what are you talking about.

Rainbow dash shouted as she was flying after pinkie.

Pinkie pie "I understand why fluttershy got so mad at me.

Pinkie pie said as she went into the party planing cave.

Rainbow dash" Oh you have.

Rainbow dash said as she was catching up with pinkie.

Pinkie pie "Yes I have you see I tried getting fluttershy a special some pony so she would come to my party but of course you can't force some pony to love another pony they don't even love then I remember what rarity told me last year and then it came to me fluttershy already has a special some pony.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" She doses?

Rainbow asked confused.

Pinkie pie " Yeah she has a crush on discord.

Pinkie pie said as she added the last picture she had on the board.

Rainbow dash "Is that a picture of a picture of discord bye fluttershys bed?

Rainbow dash asked.

Pinkie pie" Yup.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash "No no no fluttershy can't be in love with that monster.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie" Dashie we talked about this you can't call discord a monster anymore he isn't evil anymore so knock it off.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash "I know I'm sorry so what are we going to do.

Rainbow dash asked.

Pinkie pie" Well since fluttershy hasn't even told discord how she feels about him I will get them together then that will prove to fluttershy that I'm sorry.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" But we don't even know if discord feels the same way.

Rainbow dash" said.

Pinkie pie " Phht oh please have you not seen the way discord look's at fluttershy.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" No not really.

Rainbow dash admitted.

Pinkie pie "Well I have and it clearly shows that discord has feels for fluttershy.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" Well ok then I'm going to bed wake me up when you need my help.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie "Ok dashie I will.

Pinkie pie said

Chapter 4

The next day at sugar cube corner.

Pinkie pie "dashie wake up.

Pinkie pie shouted in rainbows ear.

Rainbow dash"what what I'm up.

Rainbow said sleeply.

Pinkie pie" have you forgotten about the plan.

Pinkie pie said as she poked rainbows snout.

Rainbow dash "no no I didn't forget the plan.

Rainbow said.

Pinkie pie" good because it's going to be a long day I need you to keep fluttershy busy.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped off the bed.

Rainbow dash "I'm confused you want me to keep fluttershy busy I thought the plan was to get fluttershy and discord to confess their feelings for each other.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie" that is the plan but there needs to be a romantic setting so I need to set that up without them knowing.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash " I don't know I confessed my feelings for you in front of cheese sandwich when you were going to leave ponyville.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie "yes I know but do you have any other ideas.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" yes I do have another idea we lock fluttershy and discord in a room for 9 hours and we have puzzles for them to do and they have to find a way out and while they are doing they will realize that they make a pretty good team and they will feel so comfortable with each other they will start spreading secrets with each other and then one of them will say I have a crush on you and then they both blush and kiss.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie "that doses seem like a good plan.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash" so you wanna do it?

Rainbow dash asked.

Pinkie pie "yes I will set the puzzles up they will have to work together to find the key.

Pinkie pie said as she zoomed out of the room.

In the mysterious room.

Fluttershy" huh where am I why is it so dark?

Fluttershy asked as she looked around.

Discord " ow my head.

Discord said as he was getting up.

Fluttershy "discord is that you?

Fluttershy asked as she was walking in the darkness.

Discord" fluttershy?

Discord asked as he was looking around.

Fluttershy "yes.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" where are we?

Discord asked.

Fluttershy "I don't know I can't even see you it's too dark.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" don't worry your not alone I'm here too even if I can't see you how about you come to me by following my voice.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "oh ok.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" Marco.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "polo.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" Marco.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "polo.

Fluttershy said then she bumped into something.

Discord" hi fluttershy.

Discord said as he was reaching his paw down trying to locate where fluttershy was.

Suddenly the lights flashed on and 2 ponies came in.

Fluttershy "pinkie rainbow.

Fluttershy said as her eyes adjusted.

Pinkie pie" Hiya fluttershy.

Pinkie pie said.

Rainbow dash "you both must be confused to why your here.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie" your here to do a puzzle.

Pinkie pie said.

Discord "a puzzle.

Discord said.

Rainbow dash" yes a puzzle.

Rainbow dash said.

Pinkie pie "you only have 9 hours to complete all of the puzzles and find the key to get out and you have to work together.

Pinkie pie said as rainbow dash and her left the room.

Fluttershy" so I guess we are spending the day together doing a puzzle trapped in a room.

Fluttershy said.

Discord "yeah.

Discord said.

Fluttershy" let's just get the puzzles done and get out of here like there is only a few more days until hearts and hooves day and I have to make sure angel bunny has enough of food because I'm not leaving my house on hearts and hooves day.

Fluttershy said.

Discord "yeah your right like hearts and hooves day is all about love it's the worst holiday of the year.

Discord said.

Fluttershy" hearts and hooves day isn't all bad I used to like hearts and hooves day until I found out it was only for ponies who has a special some pony.

Fluttershy said.

Discord "what would you do if I asked you to be my special some pony.

Discord said nervously.

Fluttershy" what I..I.

Fluttershy said she was too shocked to say anything else.

Discord "it was just question relax I know you hate hearts and hooves day so relax.

Discord said as he regretted what he said.

Fluttershy" I am relaxed I just didn't know what to say because well um um you are special to me.

Fluttershy said as she blushed.

Discord "oh well you are really special to me.

Discord said.

4 hours later.

Fluttershy" there's only one puzzle left.

Fluttershy said.

Discord"yeah.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "we make a good team with these puzzles.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" yeah we do.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "so um I was thinking maybe we should hang out some more.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" yeah we should.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "I can't keep it a secret anymore.

Fluttershy said as she looked at discord.

Discord" what are you talking about fluttershy are you ok?

Discord asked.

Fluttershy "no I'm not ok I love you discord I love you every day I want to kiss you and I want to see you but I can't I can't because well I'm just afraid of what you would think I love you discord I want to be with you.

Fluttershy said.

Discord" I love you too I love you more than chaos.

Discord said.

Fluttershy "discord will you be my special some pony?

Fluttershy asked.

Discord" yes.

Discord said.

Then fluttershy spreaded out her wings and started flapping them she then she playfully tackled discord knocking him to the ground with a long kisses.

9 hours later.

Pinkie pie opens the door and she sees fluttershy and discord on the ground and they kissing deeply.

Pinkie pie"Hiya guys.

Pinkie pie said as she hops in.

Fluttershy "oh hi pinkie pie.

Fluttershy said as she was scrambling up to her hooves.

Pinkie pie" so ugh flutters are you still mad at me for trying to force you to love some pony doses this prove that I'm sorry because I'm really sorry.

Pinkie pie said.

Fluttershy "yes this proves that you are sorry.

Fluttershy said.

Pinkie pie" I know you said no to this but now you have a special some pony so would you please come to my hearts and hooves day party please it will be fun.

Pinkie pie said.

Fluttershy "of course I will come me and discord will be there.

Fluttershy said.

Chapter 1

It was a sunny day in ponyville and fluttershy was hanging out with her good friend discord they were having Tuesday tea.

Fluttershy " Are you enjoying your tea discord?

Fluttershy asked as she picked up her tea cup.

Discord " Yes I am.

Discord said as he looked into fluttershys sparking blue eyes.

Fluttershy" Well I'm glad you could make it.

Fluttershy said as she siped her tea.

Discord " I wouldn't miss this for the world.

Discord said as he picked up a sandwich.

Fluttershy " Well I mean hearts and hooves day is coming up in a few weeks.

Fluttershy said as she put a sugar cube in her tea.

Discord " Oh well that holiday really isn't important to me because what's point being lovey dovey ew gag.

Discord said nervously.

Fluttershy " Oh well your right I never seen the point either since I never was in love before.

Fluttershy said.

Discord " Well I best be going now today was fun fluttershy I can't wait until next week.

Discord said as he was scooping up the sandwiches.

Fluttershy" Ok bye.

Fluttershy said.

Discord teleported to his house.

Discord " Why did I say that you stupid idiot.

Discord said as he slammed his head against the wall.

Discord " You stupid idiot why did you say that to the mare you have a crush on maybe I used to think hearts and hooves day was stupid and I thought love was stupid but I don't anymore ever since I feel in love with her I want to be with her I want her to be my special some pony but after that I doubt that she has a crush on me besides why would a beautiful mare like her love a monster like me.

Discord said as he sat on the couch.

At fluttershys house.

Pinkie pie " Hiya flutters.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped in.

Fluttershy " Oh hello pinkie pie.

Fluttershy said as she was putting the tea set in the sink to be washed.

Pinkie pie " Watcha doing.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped to fluttershy.

Fluttershy " Ofh nothing just cleaning up.

Fluttershy said as she thought about discord.

Pinkie pie " Flutters I know you don't really celebrate hearts and hooves day because you don't have a special some pony but I thought maybe this year instead of staying here at your house you could at least come to my hearts and hooves day party I plan every year you never come and it's really fun.

Pinkie pie said as she pulled a invitation out of her saddle bag.

Fluttershy " Pinkie every year you try to get me to come and I always say no and my answer is still no there's no point of me going to that party I will be the only pony there without a special some pony and there's no point in celebrating hearts and hooves day without a some pony.

Fluttershy said as she put the invitation on the table.

Pinkie pie " Come on flutters it'll be fun I know hearts and hooves day is about spending the day with your special some pony but I really want you to come.

Pinkie pie said as she watched fluttershy.

Fluttershy " I'm sorry pinkie the answer is no.

Fluttershy said as she thought about what discord said.

Pinkie " Well ok then bye.

Pinkie pie said as she hoped out the door.

Fluttershy" If only you knew how much you mean to me.

Fluttershy said sadly as she looked at a picture of discord.