Just This Once

Big Mac couldn’t believe what he was hearing. His beautiful wife was telling him that she found a really nice couple and wanted to…have an orgy. He shook his head but stopped himself from asking her to say it again for the fourth time. Her cute eyes softened him up all the time but he tried resisting on this one. He was a one-mare stallion even if his wife wanted him to…experiment. He turned away and walked out of the barn with a “Nope!”

*********
A week later, Sugar Belle scooted just a little bit closer to Big Mac in bed and started talking. “I was talking with Pinkie Pie the other day and she told me about an adult party she had a few months ago. There were a few different stallions and mares from around Ponyville there doing all sorts of fun adult things.” Sugar Belle giggled. “Pinkie said she was glad she thought about renting out the spa. It made clean up a lot easier.”

Big Mac sighed. “Why are you telling me this, Sugar Belle?”

She draped a hoof over him and started tracing little circles on his chest. “I don’t know. It just sounds like fun, doesn’t it? Cutting loose with friends. Letting them touch you as something other than friends for a night. Doesn’t that sound fun?”

“Nope.” Mac rolled on his side away from Sugar Belle, hunching slightly out of her reach. He didn’t like that idea one bit.

***********

Another week later, she was on top of him in their bed. She was so beautiful and she knew just how to rile him up. She leaned her muzzle down to his cheek and gave him a soft kiss. Then she lifted her muzzle to his ear. “Wouldn’t you love to feel another pussy while you watch your wife get pleasured by another pony?”

“Nope!”

Big Mac sat up in bed, causing Sugar Belle to slip off his barrel to the floor. He stomped to the door and opened it to a stunned Applejack. She wasn’t expecting her brother’s door to be ripped open like that. Big Mac stammered and shifted to hide his boner as he slammed the door, but in his embarrassment, he slammed it too hard, causing it to fall off the hinges.

Panicked, he shoved past his sister and ran for the bathroom down the hall, cock slapping his belly all the way. He barely made it to the bathroom before his cock exploded all over the floor. He slumped to the floor unable to enjoy any sort of afterglow from his impromptu public masturbation. He stared at his spunk all over the floor and let his mind wander.

His wife was asking for something that she really wanted. He knew this. He had committed to her and wanted to give everything to her, but the concept of an orgy was so foreign to him. He knew that plenty of other ponies did it and they all seemed okay. Heck, the Cake twins were from one such gathering. It was a bit controversial when that was revealed to the town, but everypony seemed to forgive and forget in a matter of minutes. And the main upset wasn’t even that they had the orgy. Ponies were just mad that they tried to lie about it.

But the other issue was…He had never felt this way about anypony except Sugar Belle. Even as a young colt, Applejack going through her heat never really bothered him. He knew that some siblings had no control over themselves and ended up rutting each other through the season, but it had never been an issue for him. He actually wondered if he was gay for a while because he just wasn’t attracted to any of the mares in town.

But then he met Sugar Belle.

She made him feel everything. He felt love. Real love, and not that horrible obsession that came from the love poison. He felt passion and desire in his pursuit of her. He felt attraction to a mare, both physical and emotional. And last, but certainly not least, he felt horny when she was around. She awoke so much in him and he loved her so much for it.

And now she wanted to have him share all of that with somepony else. It just felt so wrong.

He got up and cleaned up the floor. After one last look in the mirror to pump himself up, he opened the door and walked back to his room. The door was leaning against the wall and AJ was talking quietly with Sugar Belle while they both sat on his bed. The briefest thought that his sister was probably sitting on a cum stain crossed his mind before he shushed it away and spoke.

“Sugar Belle, can we talk in private?”

Applejack stood and patted Mac’s shoulder on her way out of the door. “I’ll keep Apple Bloom downstairs while you guys talk.”

Mac nodded and turned back to face his wife. She looked a little scared and Big Mac felt really bad about that. He plodded over and sat on the floor next to her so they could be eye to eye.

“I did some thinkin’ down the hall. I realized that I want to give this to you, but at the same time, it feels like you’re asking me to give away this wonderful gift that you finally woke up inside me. I don’t fully feel proper doin’ somethin’ like that.”

Sugar Belle placed a hoof on his shoulder. “I should apologize, Big Mac. I shouldn’t have asked you that way. I just…I was thinking if you were riled up, maybe you would agree. Applejack told me that was “downright dirty” of me.” The side eye from Big Mac forced elaboration. “I didn’t tell her details about what we were doing or what I asked. But she’s smart enough to know a few things.” She pressed her head up to his. “We are married you know.”

Mac couldn’t help but smile at that. She was his wife. And she was an amazing wife. He knew she loved him with all her heart. He pulled her into a hug squeezing her right to the point where she loved it. He put his muzzle to her ear.

“Let’s do it.”

Sugar Belle pushed out of the hug and stared at Mac with eyes like saucers. “No! Big Mac if you don’t want to, I’m not going to force you. You are far more important to me than any fantasy.”

He raised a hoof to calm her reaction. “I know what I said. But you’re important to me, too, Sugar Belle. I love you with my whole heart and I know you love me the same.” She grabbed his hoof at that and nodded while Mac continued. “This is something you really want to try and pushing myself to be a bit more adventurous is a good thing. Celestia knows I like to push myself in O&O.”

Sugar Belle giggled. “Did you finish making your Lancer yet?”

Mac chuckled. “No. Soon, though. But what I’m sayin’ is that I want to do this. I want to do this for you and with you. Because I love you.”

He smiled and watched the sparkles grow in his wife’s eyes. She pounced on top of him and gave him everything he liked.

They forgot the door was open.