It was currently nighttime as Pinkie Pie was sleeping in her bed, laughing and giggling. Inside of the party pony’s dream, she was currently having a picnic with all of her friends in the middle of a grassy field as they were laughing and chatting with each other, not a care in the world.

“Pinkie darling, how’s it been with G.A. lately? You two seem close,” said the fashion pony. “Have you two kissed?”

The party pony’s friends started giggling, except for the rainbow pony, who gagged, and a chuckling Spike.

Pinkie Pie blushed while expressing a cross between angry and embarrassed. “What about you, huh?! Have you asked Twilight out on a date, or even kissed her yet, hmm?” she countered.

Rarity had a blush on her face. “W-Well, I-I…” said the fashion pony.

As for the smart pony herself, she was blushing too. The party pony then looked at the fashion pony with a victorious smile. Suddenly there was the sound of dark laughter near them, surprising the group. They all turned their heads towards the direction of the laugh and were shocked. The laugh had belonged to a mare who looked exactly like Pinkie Pie herself, except the pink colorings were dulled, mane and tail were straight, and the look in the mare’s eyes did not hold any friendliness at all like the party pony’s eyes, but instead it was something else, something scary.

Even though Pinkie Pie was afraid, she decided to greet her mysterious look-alike since the party pony does love making friends, even in her own dreams too. Pinkie Pie went and approached the mysterious mare. “Hello there, my name’s Pinkie Pie! What’s yours?” greeted the party pony.

The look-alike gave them a smile. “Nice to meet you too. As for a name, call me ‘Pinkamena’,” the pink pony informed.

Pinkie Pie gasped. “That’s my name! Except mine’s Pinkie!” she exclaimed.

Pinkamena gave the party pony a smirk. “Yeah. Weird coincidence, huh?” asked the mare. She then turned towards Twilight Sparkle and started to trot over to the smart pony. “Especially since we are the same pony, except for one slight difference. Want to know what it is, Twilight?”

Twilight Sparkle nodded, interested. After all, she’d be able to learn about a new pony that she could become friends with.

Warning: Death

Suddenly, Pinkamena took out a sharp-looking knife from out of her own mane. The mare then grabbed Twilight Sparkle by the horn and forcefully brought the smart pony’s head down. After that, Pinkamena drove the knife into her throat and sliced it across in a fast motion, then the mare then let go of Twilight Sparkle’s horn. Blood started to spurt out of the smart pony’s neck wound. She began gasping for air for a few seconds before falling to the ground, dead. Everyone was shocked to see what had just happened.

Pinkamena was grinning. “I’m more interested in having fun in a different way,” the mare informed.

Before anyone knew what happened next, she then threw her knife at Fluttershy, fast. It was too fast for the shy pony to even dodge and it had taken her by surprise. As a result, the blade of the knife ended up impacting Fluttershy in the chest, stabbing the shy mare where her lungs were. Blood ended up leaking out of the wound and onto her chest. Everyone looked at the shy pony, shocked. As for Fluttershy, she looked down at where the knife was, including the blood. The shy pony then looked back up with tears in her eyes and blood coming out of her mouth.

“...Help,” uttered Fluttershy.

The shy pony fell to her side, completely still. Pinkamena trotted over to her and pulled out her blood-coated knife from Fluttershy's body.

“Nothing personal, Fluttershy, but you would've gone for help, and I can't have that,” said Pinkamena.

Rainbow Dash and the apple pony both became angry.

“I’m gonna bucking kill you!” shouted the rainbow pony.

“Save some fer me, Dash!” shouted Applejack.

The mare was calm as the two ponies rushed at her. She then dodged out of the way, making the two miss Pinkamena completely. The mare smirked at them.

That only made Rainbow Dash even more mad. “Get her!” she shouted.

The two then started going after her. But every time they tried to restrain or hit Pinkamena, the mare would dodge around both of them with acrobatics like how Pinkie Pie herself moved. Speaking of the party pony, she was still sitting down, staring at the scene. As for the dragon kid, he was pulling at Pinkie Pie’s hoof, trying to get her to come along, but it was no use as the party pony was rooted firmly in place.

“Pinkie, we have to run! Quick!” shouted Spike. “If we don’t, we’ll be next! And we’ll only be in Applejack and Rainbow Dash’s way.”

Rarity was right next to the dragon kid. “Spike-wikey’s right. If we’re in their way, we might end up next,” agreed the fashion pony. “Besides, they should be able to handle that-that vile, monstrous, friend-killer who killed two of our friends.”

Unfortunately, she didn’t notice that the mare was standing behind her.

Pinkamena was grinning. “Aww, I didn’t know that you felt that way about me, Rarity. Just for that, you die next,” she said.

The fashion pony turned around, gasping loudly. The moment Rarity turned her head, the mare had stabbed the tip of the knife straight through and into the fashion pony’s head. She then crumpled to the ground, instantly dead. Pinkamena then, with a strong pull, removed the knife from Rarity's head, causing blood to pour out of the wound soon after.

The mare smirked. “At least you died beautifully. Too bad Twilight’s not alive to see you die,” she said. Pinkamena then looked at Spike. “You’re next.”

“Aaah!” he screamed, scared.

Before her hoof could even grab the dragon kid, a voice sounded off.

“You leave him alone!” shouted Rainbow Dash.

Pinkamena trotted backwards as a rainbow-colored blur suddenly flew past where the mare was.

“Nice try,” said the mare.

Spike only ran a few steps before he was grabbed, and then picked up from the ground by the back of his neck by Pinkamena. She placed the blade of the knife against the dragon kid’s throat.

Pinkie Pie snapped out of it and saw that he was captured by her look-alike.

“W-Wait-” said the party pony.

She was too late as the mare had then sliced the blade across Spike’s neck, causing blood to come out the wound. Pinkamena then tossed the dragon kid’s body to the ground as he gasped for air while clutching at the wound.

“Well, only three left,” she said.

Pinkamena jumped out of the way as the apple pony’s hoof had just missed her. The mare backed away as Applejack was approaching.

“End of the line,” said the apple pony.

“Hold on, Applejack,” said Rainbow Dash. She landed next to Applejack. “I want to go first. She killed our friends.”

“Now hold on there a second. I should go first,” argued the apple pony. “They were my friends too.”

The rainbow pony got in her face. “No, me,” argued Rainbow Dash.

“No, me,” argued Applejack.

The two then started arguing over who was going to fight Pinkamena first. They didn’t notice that she was continuing to back away, but only a little more until the mare was standing right next to Pinkie Pie. Pinkamena then wrapped a leg around the party pony’s neck while the other was holding the knife, pointing it right at Pinkie Pie’s face.

“You two come any closer, and I’ll force Pinkie Pie here to die,” she said, serious. “You don’t want that to happen now, do you?”

The apple pony and rainbow pony stopped arguing and noticed that the party pony was being held hostage.

“Hey! You let her go!” shouted Rainbow Dash. “Right now!”

“Nope. Not gonna happen,” said the mare, smiling. “Instead, I think I’ll be taking her with me, and if I see any of you two try to rescue her or even follow us, she’s dead. Understand?”

The rainbow pony growled. She couldn’t let the pony who killed four of her friends escape, but she also can’t let Pinkie Pie die. Meanwhile, Applejack was thinking the same thing. In the end, the two only stood there in place.

Pinkamena knew that they would choose to save their friend's life by not letting the party pony die. “Glad you two decided to listen to me and spare your friend from dying. I’ll be on my way now,” she said. “Bye.”

The mare trotted away backwards while dragging Pinkie Pie along with her, heading towards the forest.

The party pony was really worried. “I really hope something or somepony wakes me up from this nightmare soon,” she thought.

Few Minutes Later

Once she was sure that neither one of the two was around, Pinkamena pulled the knife away from Pinkie Pie. Then, the mare threw the party pony away from her.

“Finally. Now it's just you and me,” said Pinkamena. “Also, don’t get any ideas on running away. I don’t want to hurt you anyway.”

Pinkie Pie got up off of the ground and turned around to face the mare. “W-Who are you?” she asked, scared.

“Like I said, I am you. Actually, I am the part of you that loves to kill,” Pinkamena informed.

The party pony was shocked. “W-What?” said Pinkie Pie. “No, it just can’t be.”

Pinkie Pie backed away, while the mare started to approach the party pony.

A creepy grin appeared on Pinkamena’s face. “I came into your dream to have a little chat with you, but I needed your friends out of the way first so that we can be alone. Had to improvise and take you hostage since fighting against those two whether they fight separately or together might be a little hard for me,” she informed. “We've gotten off-topic. So, like I said before, let’s talk.”

Author's Note

This chapter happens on the same day as Chapter 12, but a few hours later.

For those of you who are wondering what's happening, the bleed from the Pinkamena universe is behind this. The stuff that was absorbed into Pinkie Pie could only change part of her mind because she was fighting it inwardly as the party pony did not want to become a killer. Then, the part of the mind that was changed became a split personality and took the form of Pinkamena herself.

Originally Applejack and Rainbow Dash were supposed to die as well, but I then decided to let them live instead. Also, if it was outside the dream world, then Pinkamena might not have been lucky enough to kill some of them and get away with it.

The Psychopath proofread this chapter. It was also their idea for a split personality Pinkamena.

Comments are welcome.