Pinkamena Meets Mystic Skies

by MysticSkies115

Rating: teen
Tags: Drama, Gore, Original Character, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Comedy, Romance, Scootaloo, Pinkie Pie, Profanity, Violence
Length: 2109

Pinkamena Diane Pie meets an unexpecting stallion just minding his own business. What will happen to the stallion in her hands?

Pinkamena Diane Pie is at her place on Sugar-Cube Corner when A blue stallion with a spikey brown mane and a 115 number cutie mark on his flank walks into her place. The hunt was on! This fanfic is a Grimdark Story. So it is pretty bloody and gory. But its got a hint of romance in it. So enjoy!

Published 2022-04-11 21:30:00 UTC
Last updated 2022-04-15 21:23:39 UTC

Chapter 1-The First Encounter

It was just another day for Pinkamena Diane Pie, making Cupcakes as usual with her secret ingredient.
Pinkamena saw her work of art and was pleased with it.

"There, thats the last Pony meat cupcake!", She said as she looked at the fourth wall.
"I told you the secret ingredient, now you must die!", she continued

She started to put the cupcakes in the oven, until the service bell rung.

"I wonder who that could be?", Pinkamena thought to herself.

She walked from the kitchen to the service counter and saw her next possible victim.

"Hiya stranger! What brings you here to Sugar Cube Corner?", Pinkamena asked the blue stallion in a greeting tone of voice as the stallion flipped his spikey brown mane back to get his hair out of his face.

"I'm just here to pick up my cupcakes I ordered this morning", the blue stallion told her.

Pinkamena shook her head and went back to the kitchen and started making the cupcakes and a special punch for him to drink. A few minutes later, the strange blue pony's order and drink was finished!
Before Pinkamena carried his order to him, she placed some sleeping pills in his punch and started to walk out the kitchen door to give him the order and the drink.
She placed the box of cupcakes on the countertop and rung him up on the cash register.

"That'll be 12 bits sir", Pinkamena told the stranger as the cash register's bell dinged.

The blue stallion handed her the money and was about to head out the door, when Pinkamena stopped him.

"What's your name anyway mister 115 pony?", Pinkamena asked him.

"Mystic Skies", the blue pony answered with a horrified look on his face.

Mystic saw his cupcake box covered in blood and entrails remains. He started to scream but held it in to avoid suspicion.

"Well its nice to meet you Mr. Skies", Pinkamena said in a twisted cheerful voice.

She grabbed the drink and handed it to Mystic.
Mystic looked at the drink and back at her creepy smile while trying to find a way out of this situation.

"Fuck it!", Mystic said as he took the punch and drunk it.

He looked up at Pinkamena as his vision was getting blurry.

"Motherfucker!", Mystic said to her.

He collapsed onto the floor and closed his eyes and went to sleep. Pinkamena laughed at Mystic while he was asleep.

"He never saw it coming.", Pinkamena said to herself

Pinkamena dragged Mystic's body down to her dungeon and put his body on a hospital surgical table and tied his body down to the table, then she tied his hooves to a couple of wooden posts.
The first set of two posts was at the head of the table, while the other set of two posts was at the foot of the table. Pinkamena tied his hooves to the posts and went upstairs to get her killing tools.

A few minutes later, Mystic started to wake up from the sedative that Pinkamena placed in his drink, he started babbling nonsense before his vision and the sedative hangover adjusted. He woke up completely and found himself tied up! His body was tied down to a surgical type table, his legs and hooves tied to wooden log posts and his mouth taped shut! Mystic tried to move and cry for help but to no avail.
His muffled screams and crying couldn't be heard from the underground dungeon he was trapped in.
Suddenly, the dungeon doors opened slowly and the squeaking of a hospital cart could be heard entering the dungeon room while Pinkamena was humming a song as she began to enter the cell that Mystic was in! The cell door opened and Pinkamena entered the room still humming her song as she walked towards Mystic and stopped her cart and her humming.

"Hiya Mysty, or should i call you dinner", she asked Mystic jokingly.

Mystic tried to answer her but his mouth was still taped shut. Pinkamena saw the tape around his muzzle and ripped it off like a bandaid. Mystic yelled out in pain and anger.

"What the fuck!", Mystic yelled out at Pinkamena

Pinkamena raised an eyebrow and walked slowly towards him.

"You didn't need to yell Mysty", she said to him

Mystic watched her walk over to the cart and pulled out a machete and walked back over to him.

"Mystic, i've been watching you ever since you came to Ponyville and placed your number in my bowl of other ponies that I have to kill, and your number came up", she explained to Mystic Skies.

Mystic lifted his head up and looked at her stroking the knife to see if it was sharp.

"But why did you kill all of those ponies in the first goddamn place and why choose me?", he questioned her.

She got pissed and slammed the knife blade on the table, completely missing Mystic's groin area.

"The reason that i chose you was because you're very special to me", Pinkamena said to Mystic while untying him. "But from now on, you work for me and Scootaloo", she continued.

When she untied him, he got up and shook the dust off of his coat. Pinkamena started to exit the dungeon cell, when Mystic grabbed her hoof. She looked at Mystic, and noticed that he had tears streaming down his face.
He pulled her into his embrace and hugged her! Though Pinkamena didn't know what the hell to do, because she never had a stallion to hug her and cry on her shoulder before. She started to feel happy again, her straight pink mane and tail tried it's damndest to turn back to normal but failed to do so. Pinkamena shoved Mystic away from her, releasing herself from the hug.

"Don't do that again or I will end you Mystic", she said to him while raising her hoof at him.

Mystic nodded in agreement and followed Pinkamena upstairs.
It took them a few minutes to reach the main building which was Sugar Cube Corner.
Pinkamena opened the door and led Mystic to his room.

"If you need anything just call Scootaloo", she told Mystic.

Mystic grunted in agreement of what she said.
Pinkamena looked behind her as Mystic laid down in his bed to go to sleep.
She closed the door behind her and sat down in the hallway corridor looking down at her hooves.

"What is this feeling that i feel inside of me? Is this love? No it can't be! Pinkamena snap the hell out of it!", Pinkamena argued with herself in her head.

Pinkamena finally snapped out of it and came back to reality. She walked down the hall to her room and went to bed.
This is only the beginning,and Hell hath no fury for Pinkamena Diane Pie and Mystic Skies!

Pinkamena will return.

Chapter 3- Mystic's Revival and Revenge.

After Mystic Skies was brutally murdered by the love of his life,
Pinkamena had terrible flashbacks of when she murdered her friends in the most gruesome ways that nopony in Equestria couldn't survive from! Meanwhile,Scootaloo was dragging a deceased and decapitated Mystic Skies to the incinerator to burn the body and reduce it to ashes.

"Even for a dead pony, you're pretty heavy Mystic", Scootaloo said to the dead and decapitated Mystic Skies

In just under a few minutes of saying that, Mystic's body started to come back to life, moving and almost talking on its own! Scootaloo felt the movement vibrations through her left wing and looked down at the body very slowly! When her eyes met Mystic's now moving body, she dropped him and backed away from it and watched in horror as Mystic got up on all fours apparently looking at Scootaloo! Mystic looked at Scootaloo and slowly approached her, still bleeding from his former head area.

"What the fuck? But you're dead", Scootaloo said to Mystic.

"Do you know what my cutie mark is?", Mystic said to her in a ghostly tone of voice.

Scootaloo looked at Mystic wth a frightened but confused look, approached his flank very cautiously and saw his Cutie mark.

"Its just three numbers, 115.",she replied to Mystic.

Mystic stomped his hooves twice to let her know that she was correct! They both sat down on their rumps while Mystic started to tell Scootaloo his whole life story.

"I was injected with an unknown revival serum before I was born, the memories of that day are very distorted. Then one day, a colt had punched me in the nose during recess at school. I was so furious that my alter ego RageFire came out. I actually killed that kid that day in front of the whole school and thats when that 115 number appeared on my flank",he said to a very attentive Scootaloo.
"That day, I knew my talent was killing bad guy ponies and reviving myself if I got killed or decapitated", Mystic continued

Mystic turned around and looked in front of him, facing away from Scootaloo.

"Now if you will excuse me, I have to go Kill somepony", he said

He started walking away from Scootaloo, while he was
still leaking blood from his wounds, while Scootaloo fainted from the whole situation!

Chapter 2- Mystic meets his demise.

After a very long night of chaos and confusion, Mystic woke up to the sound of pots and pans banging against the kitchen wall, So Mystic went to investigate the noise and who was causing it.
He walked down the stairs and walked into the kitchen, and saw Scootaloo trying to cook breakfast. Mystic let out a sigh of relief. Scootaloo heard him sigh, and turned around to face him.

"Hello Mystic!", Scootaloo said to him with a greeting tone of voice.

Mystic looked at the orange pegasus filly and noticed the blood on her face. Mystic raised his hoof and pointed at the blood stain on her face.

"Why is there blood on your face?", Mystic asked Scootaloo

Scootaloo looked at the stove and looked down in shame. She looked back up at Mystic with a smile on her face.

"I killed Twilight a few years back, before you came along", she told Mystic while wiping the blood from her face

Mystic sighed and hugged Scootaloo. He looked around but didn't see Pinkamena anywhere in the bakery,he grew concerned.

"Where's Pinkamena at?", Mystic asked Scootaloo.

Scootaloo looked up at him and pointed at Pinkamena standing behind him with a Carving knife. Mystic turned around quickly and Pinkamena swung the knife and sliced his throat open!
Mystic grabbed his throat and tried to stop the bleeding as he fell backwards onto the floor, bleeding profusely.
Mystic laid there choking and coughing up blood, while his conciousness was fading and coming back again.
Pinkamena urged Scootaloo to get a jar and collect his blood from the floor.

Pinkamena raised the knife high above her head and stabbed Mystic multiple times in the chest area, revealing his heart and ribcage. Scootaloo collected the blood and sealed the jar up and handed it to Pinkamena.
Pinkamena looked at Scootaloo and took the jar of blood from her and sat on top of Mystic.
Mystic coughed up a lot of blood! Mystic coughed up so much blood that a bathtub could be filled up with it!
He looked up at Pinkamena with tears in the blue stallion's eyes,still clutching his bleeding throat as he slowly fades.

"Why did you do that Pinkamena? You said I was special.", Mystic said to her while choking on his own blood.

Pinkamena looked at him and picked his head up and licked the blood from his throat and took her hooves and snapped his neck and ripped his head off of his shoulders!
Pinkamena raised his decapitated head and leaned underneath his revealing spine bones and rinsed herself with his blood while his body was twitching due to his nerves and blood squirting from where his head was. Pinkamena ordered Scootaloo to get rid of his body and mounted his head on her wall. She looked at the mounted head and was pleased.

"You were special Mystic, but I can't fall in love with you! Though you are special enough to be my new addition to my home decor! As my new trophy on my wall!", she said to Mystic's head on the wall.

She slowly smiled a devilish smile. But the medicine she gave him, what was it and what did it do? The world won't know for sure what it does. But only Pinkamena knows.