You take a closer look at the pendant. It has a butterfly. More specifically, it is a butterfly, a pink one with wings stretched wide. For as intimidating as Pauline is, the amulet looks harmless, even childish. Why not put it on? You slip its chain over your head and let it rest with the force of gravity down over your neck. The butterfly rests on the center of your chest.

You're not paying that much mind. Something's happening and your attention is there. Two great, ghostly, wings have erupted from your back, stretching out as wide as the butterfly's wings. A horn glitters on your head where none had been a moment before. "What?" is all you can think of to ask.

But it's gone a moment later, leaving you back as a perfectly normal human.

"Hm." Pauline reaches for a shoulder, her long nails grabbing you like the talons of a predatory bird. "Interesting. You've passed another test... Enough that we can get serious."

"Stop." You push her back, not that she goes far. She's stronger than she looks. "Enough games. I've been honest and straight forward with you."

"Which is concerning, truth told." She walks past you, chuckling. "There are a thousand reasons some strange new person might come to me, asking that, with an honest face. Many of them aren't good. Keep the amulet, it's only useful to ponies anyway."

Wait... "Didn't you say it was used for generations for magic?"

"I lied." Pauline returns to the livingroom. "It was dropped by a pony, long ago enough that I'm not sure there's a year for it. It passed through countless hands before reaching mine, and I had nothing to do with it." She sinks into her chair and leans back, looking awfully relaxed. "I offered it to our mutual friend, and he wanted nothing to do with it."

You take a moment to digest this new information. The amulet is a relic connected to ponies, not Pauline's secret order as she first implied. Perhaps this offers a purer conduit to the power you seek.

You consider the vision you glimpsed when first donning the pendant. Could its magic have revealed your true nature, if only for an instant? The wings and horn fading away hints at talents waiting to be awakened.

Turning back to Pauline, you choose your next words carefully. "This amulet belongs to my people. I can feel it resonates with me in a way your teachings do not. I mean no offense, but our paths diverge here."

She nods, unsurprised. "As I suspected they might. Very well. Our deal is concluded - I've given you what I can. What you do now is up to you alone."

Her sharp gaze bores into you. "I will give you one last piece of advice, freely given. Magic is power, neither good nor evil in itself. But it will change you, as surely as you change the world with it. Stay grounded in who you are, or you will lose yourself."

With those grave words lingering in the air, she shows you out. Returning to your car, you grip the amulet thoughtfully. Though not what you expected, it feels significant somehow. A key that now rests in your hands. Where it leads remains to be seen. But you know one thing - it is time to bring the ponies together again. There is much to discuss.

You slide the amulet into your pocket for the drive home, mulling over the intense encounter with Pauline. She was clearly dangerous, but ultimately gifted you an artifact that could unlock pony magic. Her advice to stay grounded lingers as you consider the perilous path ahead.

Seeking power is risky, but focused properly, perhaps it can be harnessed for good. Arriving home, you resume organizing another pony gathering - not for crisis this time, but prosperity and purpose. There are virtues to embody, gifts to share, and magic to rediscover. Overcoming complacency and fear will be difficult, but step by step, your people must shine again.

You explain everything to Nick - the meeting with Pauline, the amulet you now possess. He is troubled you put yourself at risk, but supportive as always. Together you send out invites for local ponies to meet in one week. That week you spend in contemplation, centering yourself and preparing for the test ahead. You feel ready.

The day arrives. Donning the amulet beneath your shirt, you make your way to the meeting, ready to take the next step and lead others to join you if they so choose. With humility but conviction, you move to embrace destiny. There's just one thing still tugging at you.

You weren't much closer to understanding Magic with a capital M. For all that scary meeting with Pauline, you hadn't learned how to do magic her way. All you'd gotten was that amulet. Was that enough? You sure hoped it was... Worse case, you still knew where she lived... Even if visiting her again feels like a risky venture.

The pendant had to mean something... But is it a direct thing? You're pretty sure it's not just... a button to press and everything works. It was, at best, a stepping stone. But what to?

You walk from your car with Nick at your side. You're headed for the next pony meeting. Would more get done than the last one? Sure, you'd made a friend or two, but the ponies, as a whole, hadn't gotten a lot done. You knock on the door.

You take a deep breath as the door opens, determined to make progress at this gathering. The amulet is a puzzle piece, but not the whole picture. Rediscovering magic will take work and commitment from all ponies.

Stepping inside with Nick, you scan the room as more arrive. There's tension and uncertainty in the air. Many seem surprised you called this meeting. But you also see curiosity and cautious optimism in a few faces.

Once it seems all who will attend are present, you call the group to order. "Friends, I know gathering like this is unusual outside of crises. But there are virtues we must reclaim, gifts to be shared, and magic to uncover. Our world needs those lights rekindled."

You explain your encounter with Pauline and the amulet, though you skip certain disturbing details. "This is connected to our past, our potential. But it alone is not enough. Each of us must look within and live our purpose."

You see some nodding, considering your words. Others seem skeptical or afraid. But none have left yet. "I don't know exactly where this path leads. But I must walk it. If you will join me, together we may go further than any could alone. Will you help light the way forward?"

The question hangs in the air. This is a pivotal moment. Some seem ready to take that step, to embrace hope and purpose again after so long adrift. Others waver, the comfort of old habits holding them back. But the choice must be theirs to make. The future rests on their answer.

The large man you had met the first time, at the door, raises a hand. "That is a lot of horseshit you're tossing our way." A few voices raise in agreement. "What proof do you have that any of this means anything to any of us?"

Nick thrust a finger at him. "She already shared a gift with me. Pony gifts can be shared. If nothing else at all, she was right about that."

The tide of the conversation shifts, though still quite turbulent. The inertia of the ponies would not be so easily swayed. "What are you scared of?" You fix the larger man with a stare, focusing your honest energy at him. "Tell us the truth. Nothing but it."

His teeth set, struggling against the sudden magic being tossed his way. "Dirty... pool. Bloody hell." He slams a fist against the ground. "There are a thousand things to be scared of. We lost the lotto. Coulda been blenders, like the werewolves, or seen the answer to the universe like the mages. Nope! Not even gothic bloodsucking. Just a bunch of friendship ponies." He batted his lashes overly dramatically. "Like that matches. Why aren't you scared is the better question."

You consider his words carefully. There is truth in them - being a pony in this world is difficult and dangerous. But fear cannot rule you.

"You're right, there is much darkness surrounding us," you reply. "I would be a fool not to feel that weight. But living in fear accomplishes nothing. We must have courage to seek the light, even glimpses of it, and let them guide our hooves."

You turn your gaze to encompass all present. "The magic we once wielded is nearly forgotten. Our gifts, our purpose - lost to time. Yes, that loss haunts us still. But though the road is hard, I believe these virtues can be ours again if we commit to walking it."

Gesturing to the amulet, you continue passionately. "This relic of our past proves that magic is not gone forever. Its return is possible, if we strive together to earn it. We are 'just' ponies, yes - but that does not make us powerless. Our hearts and hooves can yet make a difference, if we let them."

Looking around the room, you see your words having an impact. There is still uncertainty, but also growing resolve. "I don't know exactly where this path leads either. But I see now it's one we must walk, not flee. Will you join me? The first steps are the hardest - but imagine what heights we might reach together."

You extend a hand in invitation. The big man hesitates, then firmly grasps it in his own. "You drive a hard bargain. But... you're right. Sitting on my hands solves nothing." Others move to join hands too, connecting in shared purpose. The energy in the room is shifting, fear giving way to anticipation. "Learning how to fight still isn't a bad idea though..."

You burst into a little laugh. It isn't a cruel one, just legitimately amused. "You're not wrong. Knowing how to defend ourselves is a good idea, and sharing these gifts is a part of it." You fall to all four hooves, tail lashing with eager energy. "There are a thousand little tricks we've been hoarding to ourselves. And by ourselves, I mean each of us seperately. You want to know how to do that honesty trick? I'll show you. But, there is a catch."

The ponies groaned. There was always a catch. "Don't look like that." You step forward with a light clip-clop. "Each gift is part of a virtue. If you don't feel that virtue, the gift isn't coming. So, if you want to do honesty tricks, you have to feel honesty. I bet some of you already know some gifts, a lot of them I don't know. I want to see and learn them. I want to show you mine. This should be an open and eager exchange between us all."

An older pony that had been silent sits up and half the room looks towards her. "You are a kindness."

"Yes?" you admit. It hadn't been a secret. "Why?"

"But you just did what you called an honesty." She brought her hooves together slowly. "How many virtues have you put your hooves into?"

"Five?" You can't help that your voice sounds a bit nervous. "Is that bad?"

The elder pony considers your words thoughtfully. "Pursuing multiple virtues is unusual. Most focus only on their primary purpose."

You nod in understanding. "Perhaps we've become too narrow in our thinking. The virtues can support each other - honesty aids kindness, laughter lightens loyalty's burdens. If sharing gifts means exploring multiple virtues, so be it."

The elder ponders this, then responds, "Or you're seeking the top?" She nods at your amulet. "A new ruler of us all, do you imagine a crown in your future?"

Author's Note

More questions than usual, but the general consensus is pretty strong in taking and putting it on. What's the worst that could happen?

Wait, where'd our magical montage go? Well, this is interesting too...

Time to vote! Change, now they note, where applicable, what traits, if any, are sure to come up. Click here 👉https://forms.gle/afw1tAqchKxtZZR58

Join the special community of folks who like my stories, see the updates early, and/or get your own written here at atreon!

Join my discord to chat!