The Twins

by bakersong

Rating: mature
Tags: Sex, Zebra, Anthro, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Second Person, Alternate Universe, Romance, Original Character, Porn, Fetish, Profanity
Length: 6960

After two years of dating Zelra, a Zebra you met when you went to Zebrica on a trip to study the plants their, you finally get to meet her sister. What she failed to mention is that they are identical twins, and to top it off it's Nightmare Night.

After two years of dating Zelra you finally get to meet her sister, Zelia, who was coming in for a costume party for Nightmare Night. Though you knew they were twins, you didn't know that they were identical twins. While you didn't think this would be a problem at first but after having a few drinks, it may lead to some confusion and accidents. But is it really an accident?

Published 2022-06-04 04:30:01 UTC
Last updated 2022-06-04 04:30:01 UTC

Meeting the Sister

"So, you excited bout picking up Zelia?" You ask with a knowing smile as your girlfriend of two years was practically skipping down the road. Not that you could blame her since they hadn't seen each other since, but they did exchange letters often.

"Sure am! I mean this is the longest we've gone without seeing each other, and it's been kind of weird. I mean we heard about twins having a special connection with each other, but actually feeling it is a whole other world!" Zelra said as she stopped to look back at you with a big smile. "She's almost here, I can feel it."

"I bet, and it's something I've always believed myself. Just can't wait to see what she's like," You say as you catch up, which as you did you gave her a little peck on the nose. This made her roll her eyes but her smile seemed to grow.

"You remember how we first met?" Zelra asked, which you of course did.

You were on a research trip to study the plant life in Zebrica, which you were glad you did as not only were you apart of the team that discovered a new flower but also found Zelra along the way. Which she was staying at the same village as you were as part of the Zebra team that also helped with guidance and of course translations in case our normal translator wasn't around. You two became very close in the six months you were both there, and she ultamitly decided to come to Equestria with you.

But in those first six months you found out that her sister was studying to become a Potion Master and was even participating in the completion to become an apprentice to Zecora. Zecora was said to be the best of the best in her skills, and since she lives in the Everfree she had access to all kinds of rare plants there to use. It something the two profession had in common, as you did have to have an understanding of the plants you are using in potions.

You knew all this because you were constantly asked by different potion brewers about what plants they would most likely need for a particular potion. Which you did pick up a lot of tips and tricks and did potion brewing as a hobby. While you weren't great at it you were definitely better than most hobbist, so you were hoping that would be a good way to make a connection to Zelia.

"That look means you're going down memory lane!" Zelra said in a chiper tone making you look at her.

Today she was wearing a nice shirt with a lilly printed on the front, with a mid-calf length light blue skirt with of course flip-flops on. Her hair was down to her shoulder blades and was very wavy naturally, and to top it off was her beautiful emerald green eyes. Every time you met her eyes you couldn't help the smile that spread across your face, which you knew she had that effect on others as well but it seemed to really work with you.

"Well, can you blame me?" You ask as you not so sneakly grabbed her ass.

"Sttooopp, we're in public!" Zelra said her cheeks going red, though she now had a flirty smile of her own to match the one you know had.

"Wouldn't be the first time," You say trying to hold in a laugh at how red she was going.

"We only did that once, in an empty building. Now can you stop laughing at me?" Zelra asked with a little pout.

"Fine, fine but I will say that its been a few days since the last time we did anything," You reply making her laugh a bit.

"I know, but we've both been busy the past couple of days. Besides I do have something planned for tomorrow," Zelra said giving you a little wink as she traced a finger down your chest before stopping just above your waist. You could feel yourself getting hard as she did this.

"Can't wait, but since it's gonna be tomorrow, and I'll hold you to that, why don't we go pick up your sister?" You ask as she laughed as you awkwardly suffle around trying to hide your hard on as best as you could. But Zelra nodded before you both continue just enjoying each other's company.

Though you couldn't help the idea's that came to your mind about tomorrow which considering it was Nightmare Night, and all of you were going to a costume party a certain idea kept coming into your idea. But then you had no idea what she was going to dress up as which only made you imagine her in different costumes, though that didn't help with your hard on. Taking a deep breath to clear your mind, though that only worked for a bout two seconds.

"I know that look, and knew you would get a few ideas. Bet you're picturing me in different sexy costumes, like maybe am I gonna be a nurse? Or maybe even a maid?" Zelra teased making you roll your eyes.

"Maybe, but here's the thing, you don't know what I'm dressing as either," You teased making her give a slightly defeated look. "So, to changed the topic why don't you tell me a bit about your sister while we wait?"

"Sure can!" Zelra replied as you two sat at a bench at the train station to wait. She told a few stories you've heard quite a bit over the past couple of years, and even some small tibits that you hadn't known before.

"Attention, the train from Ponyville will be arriving in two minutes. Once again, two minute warning," An announcer said over the intercom making Zelra stop in midsentence as a huge smile came across her face.

"I'm so excited! I wonder what she's been doing, and how her exams went!" Zelra stated in her excitement, which in her defense since Zleia went to ponyville for the apprenticeship for Zecora they hadn't been exchanging as many letters. Especially when she was entered into the finals.

"Yeah, heard no one has manged to pass her test though. But from what I've heard bout your sister, I think she has a pretty good chance," You say as both of you got up to go stand by the loading and unloading area.

"Care to explain what you mean?" Zelra asked as you gave her a knowing smile.

"I know what test Zecora uses to really determine who has the chance to be her apprentice. Before you ask, no I can't tell you as Zecora herself made me swear not to, and besides it's not really something you can really prepare for. You either know it through experience or you don't, and since Zecora lives in the Everfree then it's something you have to know, you know?" You ask trying to hold back your laugh as she looked lost and confused a bit.

"So... you've met Zecora before?" Zelra asked quizzically.

"I could have sweorn I told you, she taught me a lot of the tricks I use now for my hobby," You reply.

"Wait, that was Zecora? I know for a fact she hasn't tooken anyone as an apprentice," Zelra said with a raised eyebrow.

"It wasn't for an apprenticeship, and she does like to teach the basics to anyone who has an interest in it. Like for example, when I was there she was also teaching a little filly by the the name of Applebloom," You explain.

"Huh, didn't know that, and I think you told me that when we first met. But still, that is so awesome you got to meet Zecora! My sister will love that!" Zelra said as the train was coming in.

Which after few seconds the trained slowed to a crawl and then to a stop, it was another thirty seconds before they had the doors open. As both of you stood there waiting for Zelia you could feel Zelra reach out and grab you hand again. Soon enough you saw a Zelia stepping out, but you were a little confused as she looked almost exactly like Zelra.

Sure, most people when they hear of twins they automatically assume they are identical but you have worked with plenty of twins before. Identical twins were very rare, and not to mention Zelra had never mentioned that they were identical. Granted you didn't never asked, and you couldn't blame her since it's what she was used to. But as you looked you could see some minor differences, for one she seemed maybe three to four pounds heavier than Zelra, and she had saphire blue eyes. Other than that, they looked exactly alike.

Getting Ready

After you got over your initial shock you quickly pointed her out to Zelra who instantly started making her way through the crowd. You managed to keep up and soon the three of you met up with the two sisters wrapping each other's arms in a big hug and releasing a loud squeal. This of course made all those around them create a large circle around them.

"It's sooo good to see you after so long!" Zelra squealed as they started to calm down from their squealing.

"I know, and this must be your boyfriend," Zelia said as they broke from their hug and finally noticed you.

"Yup, nice to meet you, Zelia," you awkwardly said and held out a hand. As you did you noticed her scanning you.

"Not bad looking at all," Zelia said with a little smile as she took your hand. "Nice to finally meet you in person!"

"Uh, thanks, and looking forward to getting to know you more," You said making her smile grow.

"Yup, especially since I know you are quite a Botanist," Zelia said as Zelra took a few bags off of her to carry.

"So, how did the exams go?" Zelra asked making Zelia's shoulders shag a bit. Seeing this you could tell Zelra was already trying to bite her own tongue off.

"It was... rough to say the least, but I did pass!" Zelia squealed out as she jumped up and down making it very clear she wasn't wearing a bra at the moment.

"I'm so happy to hear that, but would you stop jumping like that? Especialy since you're not wearing..." Zelra started before Zelia finished.

"A bra, I know I know! But it was so hot on the way here and you know how the girls get," Zelia said making Zelra turn red and making you laugh. You knew what they were talking about since Zelra moved in with you.

"So, you ladies ready?" You ask as you helped carry Zelira's luggage. "By the way, good job on the apprentiship. Zecora is not only an excellent potion maker, she is the best teacher as well. But anyway, how did you like that last test?"

"Oh, that was a sinch! I mean I get it's not something a lot of people would know, and even fewer who would actually understand it, but was very easy! At least for me," Zelia stated making you smile and nod.

"I understand what you mean," You say making Zelia whistle.

"So, you know what it was about?" Zelia asked making you nod.

"Yeah, I helped Zecora out a little while back and the subject happen to come up. She even tried to get me to sign up for her test. But outside of it being a hobby, I have no plan on becoming a Potion Brewer, let alone a master of it," You explain making Zelia's jaw drop a bit.

"Why didn't you tell me your boyfriend was this cool?" Zelia asked turning to Zelra.

"Well, most people wouldn't think its cool," You muttered under your breath.

"Hey, I more or less found out myself before you came in. I mean, he did tell me something about it when we first met but that kind of slipped my mind," Zelra said rubbing the back of her head as she gave a little embarrassed grin.

"Man, I can't wait to pick your brain then!" Zelia said as she turned her attention back to you.

"Could that wait until we get to the house? Maybe over some tea?" You asked making Zelias eyes light up.

"Sure, come on Zelra, let's race!" Zelai said, and before Zelra could reply she took off.

"Wait, you don't know the way!" Zelra shouted as she ran after her sister making you laugh.

You decided to take your time, and thinking about what you thought of Zelia which wasn't hard since she did remind you a lot of Zelra, both physically and mentally. But as you thought about her the only real way to tell them apart was their eyes, and sure you noticed she might weigh a little more unless you paid attention you wouldn't be able to tell. Not to mention the outfit she was wearing.

She was wearing short jean shorts where the pockets stuck out the bottoms, and showed off her ass pretty well. Which she was also wearing a tight Metallic bacn t-shirt, which should have gave you the first clue she wasn't wearing a bra since you didn't see the outline. The image of her jumping up and down with her boobs going with the motion was hard to get out of your head, especially since them being identical you could even envision her naked. But you quickly shook those thoughts out of your head, even if it was too late as you could feel yourself stiffen up.

After a night of questioning and talking with both of them they finally went to bed around midnight, and woke up the next day to the smell of cooking breakfast. Zelia had decided to make you three breakfast as a thank you for letting her stay until she got a message from Zecora. It wasn't bad, and you might be a bit biased, but you liked Zelras eggs a lot better.

"So, you two ready for tonight?" You ask as you took a drink of orange juice. Though you could see both of them look at each other first and gave each other big smiles.

"Oh, we're more than ready for tonight," Zelra stated making you wonder since she had a tone you couldn't quite place.

"Don't you worry your little head off, but you know this will be my first Nightmare Night. So heck yeah I'm excited!" Zelia said as she got up, which you had to look away since all she was wearing was the t-shirt from yesterday and a purple pair of panties. Which you caught Zelra looking at you as if she was watching how you were reacting.

"Do I get a hint at what you two are dressing up as?" You asked as you took another drink.

"Hm, we're going as the same thing if that helps!" Zelia answered making Zelra laugh as you shook your head.

"Fair enough, but can you be a little more descriptive?" You asked making Zelia get a big smile.

"It's made out of fabric," Zelia said and this time both girls busted out laughing as you gave the official 'ugh' of defeat.

"So, what you going as?" Zelra ask and this time you gave a smile.

"I'm going as something," You simply stated making Zelra roll her eyes with a smile.

"Well, anyway the part starts at four which means we gotta start getting ready by noon at the latest," Zelia said as she turned and gave a wink to Zelia who returned the gesture.

"Fine by me," Zelia said, though it did make you even more curious about what they were going as. But you knew you wouldn't get anything else from them so you finished off your oj and rinsed the glass.

The three of you hung out for a little while just talking a bit about what has happen and changed over the past two years, which included the fact that their village just recently got a new Chiefton before Zelia left. Unfortuanatly the old one had a few health issues and could no longer perform his duty. Which as you talked the girls looked up at the clock and realized it was almost noon now.

"Well, it's time for us to start getting ready. Now, don't you come in and peek on us oaky?" Zelra asked making you smile.

"Cross my heart," You reply making Zelra give a big smile.

"Aww, is that one your y'alls things? Cause that's kind of sweet!" Zelia said as both of them got up. "I know you just promised and everything, but you really better not peek in while we get all naked and...OWW!"

"Don't be teasing my man like that," Zelra said as she hit her sister's arm, though there was something about it that seemed off. "Anyway, when you gonna get ready?"

"Oh, probably bout two. Won't take me long at all," You say giving a little sly smile as you couldn't get the image out of your head now.

"Alright, well let's get going then!" Zelia said as she took her sister's hand and running up the stairs. You shook your head but you couldn't blame Zelia for excitement, but you knew you had some time to waste so you picked up the book you've been reading.

After a little while you looked up as you heard them shuffling around and giggling, but you looked at the clock and it wasn't time to get ready. Which after that and about another hour you put your book down and went to where you put your own costume. It really only took about twenty minutes to get it on just right, but as you looked at yourself now dressed as Zemulus, the ancient Pegasus warrior who won his freedom through battle.

"Will you stop grabbing me there? You know I'm sensitive there," You heard Zelra say as you walked by the their door. This made you stop for a second and debated to stay and listen, but you shook your head and went back down the stairs.

You picked up your book again and continued ready, though you had to repostion yourself sine you weren't used to waring a toga. But you managed to get used to it fast enough, and not to long after you heard their door open making you look up and saw it was now three thirty. Your attention shifter when you heard them coming down the stairs, and your jaw nearly hit the floor.

As you looked you saw that they were wrapped up in what looked like old bandages, but they were wrapped up skin tight in them. The only thing that showed was their eyes, which as you looked at them over and over again you had to shift your legs a bit as there was a problem rising. The fact that they were wrapped up tightly like they were freshly mummified it showed off everything.

"Um... uh..." You couldn't get anything out and as the two sisters looked at each other they couldn't help but laugh.

"Well, thanks for the complement," Zelra said as she came up to you pushing the bandage that was covering her mouth out of the way to give you a little kiss. "You look very handsome."

"T-thanks," You say trying to keep your attention on only Zelra which only made her giggle.

"You know you can look at Zelia, not gonna bite your head off for it," Zelra said making you nod. "But, you ready to make our way there? Gonna take us a good ten minutes to walk there!"

"Yup, sure am!" Zelia said as she wrapped an arm around Zelras shoulder and you could only nod, not trusting your own tongue at this point. But at least it made sense now why it took them so long since they were carefully wrapped up.

All three of you walked out of the house and started your way to the party, and as you three walked it did become easier to look at Zelia since she was hidden behind her costume. You held Zelras hand the whole way there, even managing to make a couple of grabs at her ass, which she swatted your hand away. Soon enough the three of you arrived at the party.

A few hours later and the three of you were having a blast dancing and even doing some karaoke, which you find Zelia has a better voice than either you or Zelra. After awhile you saw Zelia messing around with your drink but didn't put too much thought into it, even if afterwards it tasted a bit different. Once you took a few sips you did managed to figure out what it was and you were confused for a bit, but then you remembered the promise Zelra made you yesterday. But you had to wonder if she would really ask her sister for that kind of help, but then again from what you'ver heard and seen they were very close.

"Man, you two ready to go?" You asked as you noticed that party was starting to slow down. That and you very well started to struggle hiding something due to your costume.

"Sure am! How bout you Zelia?" Zelra asked as she looked you over reaffirming what you were thinking. This made you give inward laugh since you didn't want to ruin whatever she was planning, just had to act like you didn't have a clue.

The three of you started to go on your way back to your house, the two girls walking in front of you giving you a great view of both of them. Though you tried to focus more on Zelra but it was difficult since they both had a similar shape. It was getting a bit frustrating with how stiff you were and the view was only making it more difficult but at least by then you were only a block away.

"Man, really need to go!" One of them said as they got to the front, you realized it was Zelia since she didn't have a key. As soon as Zelra got to the door and unlocked it Zelia instantly ran into the bathroom.

"Guess she did need to go, but hope she has fun with those bandages," You said as you finally caught up. This made Zelra snicker a bit.

"We had to help each other during the party if that helps," Zelra said making you raise an eyebrow.

"Well, after you," You said making a gesture with your hands, which Zelra quickly grabbed one pulling you along with her. She was giving you a little look that made you shiver, especially as she slowly lowered them to look at the tent you had put up.

"You know, I'm really looking forward to a little later," Zelra said as she sat down on the couch making you give a little disappointed look. This got her to give a little laugh. "Don't worry, I promise the wait will be worth it! I just got to go to the bathroom myself."

Which as she said that you both heard the toilet flush and not long after Zelia was out, though her costume now seemed really loose. You shifted a bit, which Zelra noticed and quickly placed her hand on your lap making you shiver again as she gently helped you. She gave you a little wink before getting up to go to the bathroom which you then took a quick drink as Zelia gave you a bit of a look, which when you looked you saw that somehow she had covered her mouth.

"Ah, that feels so much better!" Zelra said as she came out of the bathroom. Some of her bandages around her breast seemed loose letting you get a little peek.

The three of you sat around the living room for a little while longer and while you weren't paying much attention they both got up, one going to the bathroom again and the other upstairs. This made you smile as you started your own way up the stairs, and as you did you heard the familiar squeak of your bedroom door open. Sure enough as you got there, the door was open a decent amount with who you knew for sure was Zelra undoing her bandages and as she did so you couldn't take it anymore.

Though you managed to restrain yourself as you started to sneak up to her watching as she unwrapped herself which made it difficult to control yourself. By the time you were right behind her she had most of her torse unwrapped including her ass and more importantly her lower entrance. A smile spread across your face as you wrapped one of your arms around to play with her now exposed breast and the other went in between her legs making her gasp in surprise.

Accidents Happen?

She let out a surprised gasp that quickly turned into a moan as you inserted a finger inside her, making you realize how wet she already was. You began to kiss and nip her neck and collar bone while playing with her tit in your other hand. She tried to speak as you did this, but only a moan came out as you pressed against her clit.

"I have been looking forward to this," You whisper in her ear as you freed your very hardened member and lined it up to her entrance.

"N-no, w-wai... Nnnggaaahh!" Zelra moaned out as you pressed into her getting a good fourth of your member inside in one thrust.

"Fuck yes! It's been too long if you ask me," You said as you pushed in more making the only response you got was another moan. "Your acting just like how you did when we first..nnggaahh... time we did it..."

You now had about eighty percent in her now and she was practically puddy in your hands even before the real fun began as she lowered the top half of herself onto the bed as she moaned out. As she did you could feel her start to relax enough that it became a bit easier to move, so you withdrew until only your tip was left inside and she tried to take the opportunity to speak. Though once again before even a single word came out of her mouth she practically screamed as you shoved your entire length back into her, but with the force that you did, it made her face go into the mattress muffling her. Though you felt her clench you pretty tightly as her womanly juices shoot out and splatter on your thighs.

"G-guess you r-really needed this... fffuuck! You're so tight," You said as even as she loosened up from her orgasm she still had an almost vice-like grip.

"I-I'm n-not..." Zelra tried though as you shifted it caused you to pull out a bit making her moan again. Hearing her moan like that spurred you on as you began a rhythmic pace, one which you knew she loved.

Sure enough, she was acting just like you expected as she grabbed onto the blankets as moan after moan came out which was making it difficult to keep going as you were already close. But you were going to make sure she had another climax herself, so standing straight up while continuing your thrusting you took a hand and moved it over her ass. She always said she didn't like any anal stuff, but you learned that she was sensitive in that hole so you take advantage of it every now and again.

"W-wha...nngash..." Zelra moaned out as she felt your hand on her ass causing you to smirk as you place your thumb in your mouth before placing it against her backdoor. "N-noo..."

It was already too late as you pushed your thumb into her tight ass making her give a moan that had a little mix of pain in it but sure enough, you felt the telling signs she was about to open the flood gates. As she started to clench you again you let out a groan as you were so close, and with one last thrust, you unleashed squirt after squirt into her making her this time give a silent scream. You were breathing heavily as you started to calm down from your orgasm, and as you looked down you smiled as it seemed she had blacked out due to the pleasure.

You slowly pulled your still fully erect member out of her and looked at your handy work as a mix of both of your cums leaked out of her partially opened lips. Though the smile you had started to fade as you started to notice something wasn't right, the Zebra in front of you seemed a little heavier, though not by much. The realization especially hit you when she opened her blue eyes and they locked with yours.

"I-I..." Fear started to swell in you as you realized what you just did and with who.

"Gee, you couldn't wait could you?" The fear completely solidified as you turned around to see Zelra. "My goodness, you fucked her pretty hard didn't you?"

"W-what..." You started being confused by her tone since it wasn't one you were expecting.

"If you're wanting to know why I'm not angry, well I am but not for the reason you're thinking. You see, what I am angry about is you ruined my plan," Zelra said as she came up to you taking your member into one of her hands and began to stroke it making you moan.

"I-I don..." You started before Zelra cut in.

"Well, you see we were planning on surprising you later with a little threesome. But no, you couldn't wait and decided to take things into your own hands," As she said that she began stroking harder making you fling your head back. "So, Zelia, what did I tell you?"

"Hhmm, it was incredible. I-I mean, you told me he has a t-thick head but I-I didn't think you meant that head," Zelia said as she had adjusted her position on the bed.

"T-then let me make it up to you," You managed as you grabbed her hand that was stroking you before locking lips with her. While you didn't completely understand it at the moment you knew you weren't going to let the opportunity slip through your fingers.

"Gee, get a room you two!" Zelia called out with a little laugh.

"Hey, do you mind moving a bit?" You asked as you broke the kiss never looking away from Zelra who now had a slight look of fear in her eyes. Though she also had some mischief in there as well.

"No problem," Zelia replied as she moved a bit as you locked lips with Zelra once more, this time pushing her back at the same time. When the back of Zelras legs hit the bed she was forced to sit down before laying down with you on top.

"You think the both of you are so smart when I at least know about the potion Zelia used," You say as you quickly give the Zebra a little wink. "Though I just thought it would be just for you and me, your idea sounds pretty damn hot."

"W-what are you gonna do?" Zelra asked making you smile as you lined up against her entrance.

"You feel pretty wet, you were probably watching, maybe even touching yourself as I fucked your sister weren't you?" You asked as you started to tease her making her whimper a bit.

"Y-yes..." Zelra answered making you stop your teasing. "P-please, I-I want it..."

"Then have it you shall," You whispered in her ear, before giving one powerful thrust getting over half of your member in. Zelras eyes went wide with a bit of pain but that was quickly taken over by the pleasure as she moaned out.

But you weren't going to let her off easy, so you pulled out a bit before thrusting back this time getting all of your member inside making you groan out as you felt your tip kiss her cervix. As you began thrusting in the same rhythm you used before you realized she was completely naked herself. Which made you look down to see her breast bouncing up and down as you thrust in and out, you quickly managed to pop one in your mouth nipping and sucking her nipple.

"Aahh.. I-I want..." Zelra couldn't finish her sentence as you continued your relentless assault on her.

"Me, oh my, you two are going at it pretty hard. I think he's even fucking you harder than he did me if that's possible," Zelia said as she came over making you let go of her sister's breast, though you weren't quite expecting her to grab the breast with one hand. She moved her other hand down between you and Zelra and managed to wrap the very base of your member in a couple of fingers.

"Sshhit! This feels amazing!" You say as you thrust not only into the woman of your dream tight pussy, but with Zelra wrapping her fingers as she did, it only added to the pleasure. You were getting very close to finishing.

"I-inside!" Zelra called out though you knew you didn't have much choice since at that moment you knew even if you did try to pull out, it wouldn't do any good.

"This really is hot to watch," Zelia said which you hadn't even realized she had stopped playing with Zelra's breast and was now fingering herself, which she eventually removed her hand from around your shaft. Once she did you once again gave a final thrust releasing inside of Zelra, and this time you knew you had the right mare.

"Nnggaaaahhhh!" Zelra screamed her nails digging into your back as her own orgasm took over, her eyes rolled to the back of her head for a few seconds. While your vision turned white from the intense pleasure.

"Ffuuckk, d-do you two always fuck this hard?" Zelia asked, though your only reply was to quickly pull out of Zelra and hop onto her locking lips. "Hhmmpph!"

"On your stomach again," You ordered which she followed moving her ass in the air making you give an evil smile.

"Show me what you've... wait not there! Aaauuggh!" Zelia exclaimed as you lined up and pressed into her ass.

"Fuck yes!" You called out as you pushed your way into her tight hole.

"I-I'm gonna...." Zelia moaned out as you pushed in even further and then you felt her squirt a large amount of her cum onto you.

"You came just from that little bit going in, then can't wait to see how you react with the whole length in you," You said as you gave a hard thrust pushing over half of you into her tight hole making you moan and groan yourself, and you were almost already about to cum again. Her response to this was squealing out in a mix of pain and pleasure.

"S-she has taken anal far b-better than I have," Zelra spoke up as you started to pull out a bit before thrusting back in. "He's getting ready to cum, get ready this one looks pretty big!"

Sure enough, as you thrust back in which only got about three-fourths of the way in before you unloaded into Zelia's ass making her squeal out in pure pleasure. As she came she fell forward making you pop out of her making you unload all over her ass and lower back, when you came down you saw that she had truly and fully passed out now. But you still needed more and turned your attention back to Zelra who was already come close to you.

Before you could do anything she grabbed your shaft and began stroking it, and while she locked eyes with you she leaned forward inserting your tip into her mouth. You let out a moan as she did so, grabbing the back of her head you guided her forward until you felt your member hit the back of her throat. To your surprise, she continued onward making you enter her throat.

"Ffuucckk, I-I thought you didn't like d-deep... Ngah!" You groaned, and to top it off as you looked down she was playing the innocent girl card making you moan even more. Obviously, her only response was to hum around your member which only sent shivers up your back, she then began going back and forth though with how sensitive you were you weren't gonna last much longer. Sure enough, you grabbed the back of her head again as you held her there as you came into her throat.

"T-tasty..." Zelra said in between her coughing after you let her go.

"S-sorry..." You say, but you weren't done as you looked over her body hungrily, which after she calmed her coughing she took notice.

"What are you waiting for? Fuck us as much as you want," You didn't need to be told twice.

Morning After

You were having the greatest dream of your life as you, Zelra, and her sister Zelia were having an amazing threesome that you couldn't believe was happening. Though this dream was getting interrupted as you felt something begin to stroke you, and as you opened your eyes you were met by both of them smiling down at you while Zelra stroked you. As soon as she saw you open your eyes fully she leaned in for a kiss while Zelia moved out of sight and below the covers where you felt her wrap her lips around your tip.

"I-It... fuck!... wasn't a dream?" You managed to ask.

"Nope, now would you like me to help you a bit more?" Zelra replied with a little smile that said she was gonna do some mischief. You nodded making her smile grow more as she moved her hand to the outside of the blanket and placed it on top of Zelia's head. Before you could process what she was gonna do Zelra pushed down on Zelias head hard enough where the Zebra took most of your length into her mouth where she moaned out and groan around your dick.

"Shit!" You scream out as you couldn't help but buck your hips pushing the rest in and unloading in her mouth. Zelra released her sister who immediately came up for air as she coughed and gagged.

"W-why'd you do that?" Zelia asked as she managed to get herself under control.

"We needed to remove the last of it right? The only way to negate the effect of the potion is through cumming right?" Zelra asked making Zelia roll her eyes.

"Yes, but it's not the only way nor did it require you to nearly choke me out of his dick!" Zelia said though she had a little smile as she shook her head.

"A-alright girls, d-do you want to tell me what your plans were?" You asked before raising a finger to silence them. "Let me take a shoot in the dark, alright? Your plan was for Zelia to slip me a potion that let me last a lot longer, which would have been fine if it didn't have a certain taste to it..."

"Told you, I mean he did work with Zecora..." Zelia said with a smirk.

"So, what else were we planning?" Zelra asked.

"Well, as far as I can tell you obviously wanted to have a threesome, which what guy doesn't, especially with identical twins. But it seems I may have slightly thrown a small wrench in the plan when I mistook Zelia for you Zelra," You answer.

"That you did, which you most certainly didn't through anything small around at all," Zelia said as she looked at your now half-massed member.

"So, uh, what about you know..." You said making the two mares look at each other.

"Well, I used protection myself, always have used it. But hey, I'm gonna go take a shower okay?" Zelia said as she quickly got out of the bed making you look at her and her exposed body again. You noticed she was walking much slower and with a limp.

"You fucked her pretty good last night, but to answer your question..." Zelra started but was becoming more and more nervous. You had a feeling where this was going.

"Zelra..." You started before she cut in.

"I'm pregnant! I've been pregnant since we last, you know..." Zelra said making you give her a huge smile as you wrapped her in a tight hug.

"I'm gonna be a dad! Oh man, wait until my mom finds out!" You say excitedly, but then an odd thought crossed your mind. "Is this why you wanted to have a threesome?"

"M-maybe? I don't know, but it was so much fun!" Zelra said making you place a hand on her cheek and another on her stomach.

"Yes, but any time with you is always fun. I love the both of you dearly," You say making her roll her eyes.

"So, not to ruin the announcement but do you want to continue this fun in the shower with Zelia? It's obvious that the potion hasn't completely worn off yet, so you probably have a few more loads left," Zelra said making you laugh.

"Yeah, that sounds good to me," You say as you leaned in to kiss her.