Sunny watches as Hitch rolls on his chair from his desk to the file cabinet and back to his desk with a file. "Are you sure, Hitch? Come on, you could use a break." Sunny asked, trying to convince him.
"I'm sorry Sunny, but with Sprout fired I'm practically working overtime just to make ends meet." Hitch replied as he frantically combed through the file.
"All of our friends will be there, it won't be complete without you." Sunny said in a singsong voice trying to convince him.
"Sunny, I'm sorry, but until I hire a new deputy most of my time will be spent here." Hitch sternly, but still politely declined as he put the file back in the cabinet.
"What if I become your deputy?" Sunny asked with a smile.
Hitch chuckled. "I appreciate the offer, Sunny, but I have to decline that too. If you became my deputy you would barely have time for personal affairs. Also, it'd keep you away from your smoothie stand, and there's nopony who makes them like you do." Hitch replied, causing Sunny to blush.
"T-thank you, Hitch. I didn't know you liked them that much. Sunny replied, trying to hide her blush.
"That's why I get one everyday, it really brightens my day, well that and seeing you." Hitch said, causing Sunny to blush more.
Hitch retrieved another file and brought it to his desk. "You girls go on and have fun, maybe I can join the next one." Hitch said as he started writing.
"Ok, see you around, good luck finding a new deputy." Sunny said as she headed out of the station.
Arriving at her Lighthouse she smiled at her home. It had been two months since the incident had occurred, after the whole fiasco everypony in town came together to help repair the lighthouse, even Sprout.
Entering her house she shut the door and straightened the picture of her and her dad before heading into the kitchen. She then started preparing for her friends' arrival as she started setting out various chips and drinks.
After Sunny had finished setting up the party, a knock came on her door. Sunny gleefully rushed to the door and opened it to see Izzy, Zipp, and Pipp all waiting.
"Hey guys, please come on In and make yourself at home." Sunny said as she ushered them in.
"Huh, I thought the sheriff would be the first to arrive." Zipp said as she entered.
"Oh, Hitch is busy at the station. Though I can't blame him, he is diligent in his work." Sunny replied as she gingerly shut the door to keep the picture straight.
"Ohhhh, Sunny, the other ponies did a great job with the fixup." Izzy said as she looked at the repairs.
"Yeah, they did, even Sprout helped out." Sunny replied.
"So what do you want to do first, Sunny?" Pipp asked, setting her phone down where she could find it.
"Well, I figured we can start with a movie." Sunny replied as she went to the DVD cabinet.
"That sounds fun, which movie?" Zipp asked.
"Wellll, I was thinking maybe a romantic comedy." Sunny replied as Zipp grew a little nervous,
"Those really aren't my style, but I'll give it a shot." Zipp said, kind of hesitating a bit
While they watched the movie, near the end they heard sniffling. Looking over to the side, they all saw Zipp tearing up as the unlikely couple got together.
Sunny turned on the lights as the credits rolled. "Zip? Are you ok?" She asked only to receive a nod.
"Ok, so what now?" Sunny asked as Izzy got an idea.
"Oh oh oh, how about truth or dare?" She suggested that Pipp agreed they should play.
As they gathered around in a circle, the ponies spun an empty soda bottle clockwise to see who would go first. The bottle slowly landed on Pipp who smiled devilishly.
"Looks like it's your turn, Pipp." Izzy said as Pipp glanced around.
Stopping at Zipp, Pipp smiled. "Zipp, truth or dare?" She asked her sister.
Thinking she could outsmart her tech-obsessed sister, Zipp smugly smiled. "Dare." She replied as she awaited Pipp's response.
"I dare you to tell the truth, Do you like romantic comedy movies?" Pipp asked, shocking her older sister.
Groaning in defeat, Zipp let out a sigh. "Fine. Yes, I love that genre, they already make me tear up." Zipp said, causing Pipp to snicker.
They continued to play until it was Izzy's turn, looking at Sunny Izzy asked the question. "Sunny, truth or dare?"
"Truth." Sunny said confidently thinking it won't be bad as she took a drink.
"Do you love Hitch?" Izzy asked, causing her earth pony friend to do a spit take in shock at the question.
"What, no. Come on he's a foalhood friend of mine, besides I think Zipp likes him." Sunny said, blushing brightly.
"Only as a friend, besides he's not my type, I prefer stallions who are shy and smart." Zipp replied.
"Ah come on, Sunny, we all have seen your face when he's around. Your cheeks go all red and there's an increase in your sparkle." Izzy said as she nudged her friend.
"It's obvious that he likes you, Sunny. Why else would he accompany you on the journey?" Pipp asked.
"Well, he was going to arrest me and Izzy." Sunny replied.
"I mean besides that, you obviously struck a chord with him, and you have told us he was always a buffer between you and Sprout. It's obvious he likes you to give things a shot." Pipp argued, causing Sunny to blush.
"Ugggh, fine. I do like him, but I don't know if he wants a relationship." Sunny said as she admitted her feelings.
"Sunny, why don't you ask him out, mares are just as capable of asking out stallions." Zipp said.
"But what if it changes things between us, it could ruin our friendship." Sunny argued.
Izzy just put a gentle hoof on her friend's shoulder. "Sunny, it'll only ruin your friendship if you let it." Izzy said as she hugged her friend.
After a few more encouraging words from her friends, Sunny grew a smile on her face. "Ok, you're right girls, I'll ask him tomorrow." Sunny said before she looked around the room, looking for her truth or dare victim.
The next day, Sunny woke up bright and early and made her way to the sheriff's office, Hitch was hunched over his desk, snoring up a storm as a finished file had been left out.
Sunny chuckled to herself as she gingerly picked up the file and placed it in the file cabinet. Sunny tried her best to shut the file cabinet's drawer quietly, but Hitch somehow heard it and woke up with a jolt.
"Who goes there? Stop in the name of the law." He uttered still half asleep, causing Sunny to laugh at his outburst.
"Stand down, sheriff, there's nothing wrong." Sunny said as she made her way to his desk. "Looks like you're all caught up." Sunny said as Hitch got up and got him a cup of coffee.
"Yeah, it was a hard shift." Hitch stopped and took a sip of his coffee. "But I did find out my new deputy should be here later today." Hitch said smiling.
"That's great, do you know who it is? Sunny asked.
"No, but with them on their way I can now have personal time." Hitch replied as he downed his cup of joe.
"That's great, because. I was wondering, would you like to um, date me?" Sunny asked, causing Hitch to immediately look at her shocked and blushing.
"Well, I did always think we'd make a great couple, but I thought it would make our friendship weird," Hitch said while rubbing the back of his head.
"I did too, but Izzy told me it'll only ruin our friendship if we let it." Sunny replied.
"Hmm, Izzy seems to be really insightful. She really is a good friend." Hitch replied, thinking it over.
"Yeah she is." Sunny answered back as both of them turned to each other.
"I want to date you and buck you." Both of them said in unison, causing them both to blush.
A few minutes of silence passed until Sunny spoke up. "I know it isn't conventional, but I can think of no other pony I want to lose my virginity to than you." She said as Hitch blushes.
"I feel the same way, Sunny." Hitch replied as he set down his mug.
Sunny did smile mischievously. "Well you did say you're all caught up and a new deputy is on their way." Sunny walked to the doors and locked them. "Why don't we have a little fun now?"
Hitch blushed as he felt his cock start to peek out. "A-are you sure, Sunny? I'm still technically on duty." Hitch said as Sunny kissed him on his cheek.
"Who says you can't have pleasure while on duty?" She asked as she stroked his chin with her tail.
"I g-guess we can." Hitch replied as he looked back to Sunny, her vulva beginning to wink at him.
"But let's make it fun, after all I did break the law." Sunny said as she grabbed the hoofcuffs and cuffed herself to the holding cell. "I still need to face punishment." She said as she bent over, exposing her marehood to Hitch who had a full on erection right now.
Hitch gulped as he approached Sunny. Her legs spread, ready to accept him as her mate. "Are you really sure, Sunny?" Hitch asked one more time. As he approached Sunny.
"Yes, punish me with your nightstick, shove it deep in my pussy and punish me like the criminal I am." Sunny said as Hitch mounted her and shoved his cock deep inside her.
Both he and Sunny moaned in pleasure as the warmth of their genitalia combined and embraced each other.
"Ohhhh Hitch, this feels so good." Sunny cried out as Hitch continued to thrust, pulling in and out as fast as he could.
As they bucked each other, the movements of their bodies caused Sunny's cuffs to bang and clang against the iron bars of the cell.
After a solid five minutes of Hitch and Sunny bucking each other, Hitch gave one more powerful thrust as his balls slid into Sunny's marehood, as he climaxed and shot his seed deep into her.
Sunny moaned in pleasure as her vaginal muscles squeeze Hitch's cock as he nutted inside her.
Sunny panted as Hitch slowly pulled out, his dick long and limp, dripping in a mix of his semen and Sunny's vaginal fluids. from the pleasure the two had shared.
"I think you served your time, you are free to go." Hitch said as he uncuffed Sunny, letting her go, playing the part.
Sunny smiled and gave her arrester a kiss on the cheek. "Maybe we can do this again, say at my house next time?" Sunny said as Hitch smiled.
"Of course, I'll like that. You were really good, Sunny." Hitch complimented her before she turned to leave.
"So were you, you really know how to use your nightstick, maybe I'll play with it some next time." Sunny said as she left.
A week has passed since Sunny and Hitch bucked. Sunny goes about her day when she starts feeling nauseous and sick. While out for groceries she picks up a pregnancy test and returns home to promptly take it.
Two hours passed after Sunny urinated on the small stick, as she took a deep breath she looked at the stick only to see a bright red plus sign on the item.